Earlier this year,
If enacted, the EDUCATE Act would cut off federal funding to medical schools that force students or faculty to adopt specific beliefs; discriminate based on race or ethnicity; or have diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) offices or any functional equivalent. The bill would also require accreditation agencies to check that their standards do not push these practices, while still allowing instruction about health issues tied to race or collecting data for research.
In response to the introduction of this act, CHEST published a statement in support of DEI practices and their necessary role within the practice of health care and medical training programs.
It is our belief that health care requires a solid patient-provider therapeutic alliance to achieve successful outcomes, and decades of scientific research have shown that a lack of clinician diversity worsens health disparities. For patients from historically underserved communities, having clinicians who share similar lived experiences almost always leads to significant improvements in patient outcomes. If identity concordance is not feasible, clinicians with considerable exposure to diverse patient populations, equitable approaches to care, and inclusive perspectives on health gained through continuing, comprehensive medical education and professional training can also positively impact outcomes.
Research indicates that a diverse medical workforce improves cultural competence and can help clinicians better meet the needs of patients from diverse backgrounds and ethnicities and that the benefits of diverse learning environments enhance the educational experience of all participants. Racial and ethnic health inequities illuminate the greatest gaps and worst patient outcomes, especially when compounded by disparities related to gender identity, ability, language, immigration status, sexual orientation, age, socioeconomics, and other social drivers of health. Research also shows that nearly one-fifth of Latine Americans avoid medical care due to concern about experiencing discrimination, Black Americans have significantly lower life expectancies, and Asian Americans are the only racial group to experience cancer as a leading cause of death. It is also well documented that communities experiencing disproportionately high rates of COVID-19 infection, hospitalization, and mortality when compared with White Americans include Black, Latine, Asian, Native Hawaiian, and Native Americans.
“In 2023, the CHEST organization shared its organizational values: community, inclusivity, innovation, advocacy, and integrity,” said CHEST President, Jack D. Buckley, MD, MPH, FCCP. “In strong accordance with these values and with our mission to champion the prevention, diagnosis, and treatment of chest diseases and advance the best patient outcomes, CHEST is firmly committed to the necessity of diversity, equity, and inclusion in health care research, education, and delivery.”
Guided by our core values, CHEST is relentlessly committed to improving the professional’s experience and patient outcomes equally. This commitment compels us to work toward eliminating disparities in the medical field. According to the most recent US Census projections, by 2045, White Americans will no longer be considered a racial majority, with Black, Latine, and Asian Americans continuing to rise. It is incumbent upon us to ensure that our clinician workforce reflects the diversity of its local and national communities.
The underrepresentation of physicians from racially diverse backgrounds is factually clear. Black physicians comprise 5% of the current physician workforce despite Black Americans representing 13% of the population.1 Similarly, while Native Americans comprise 3% of the United States population, Native American physicians account for less than 1% of the physician workforce, with less than 10% of medical schools reporting total enrollment of more than four Native American students.2 Where gender is concerned, women make up about 36% of the physician workforce, a professional disparity that is further exacerbated given the intersections of race and gender, resulting in a significant impact on the current workforce.3 Allowing disinformation to influence the future of medical education and patient care directly contradicts our mission as clinicians dedicated to improving the health of all people.
If physician representation and patient outcomes are linked, as research shows, the lack of diverse medical school representation has dire consequences for matriculation, job recruitment, retention, and promotion. Without supportive policies, programs, and equity-focused curriculums in medical education, we will never close the gap on professional disparities, which means we will similarly never close the gap on health disparities.
Our commitment to our members, all health care professionals, and the field of medicine means that we will stand firm in our defense of DEI today and every day until we have achieved optimal, equitable health for all people in all places. CHEST is committed to an intersectional approach to equitable health care education and delivery. We strive to design solutions that center the most impacted and radiate support outward, ensuring our interventions benefit all others experiencing discrimination.
Read more about CHEST’s commitment to diversity and other advocacy work on the CHEST website.
References
1. AAMC. Figure 18. Percentage of all active physicians by race/ethnicity, 2018. AAMC; 2019. https://www.aamc.org/data-reports/workforce/data/figure-18-percentage-all-active-physicians-race/ethnicity-2018#:~:text=Diversity%20in%20Medicine%3A%20Facts%20and%20Figures%202019,-Diversity%20in%20Medicine&text=Among%20active%20physicians%2C%2056.2%25%20identified,as%20Black%20or%20African%20American
2. Murphy B. New effort to help Native American pre-meds pursue physician dreams. AMA. January 13, 2022. https://www.ama-assn.org/education/medical-school-diversity/new-effort-help-native-american-pre-meds-pursue-physician-dreams
3. AAMC. U.S. Physician Workforce Data Dashboard. AAMC; 2023. https://www.aamc.org/data-reports/report/us-physician-workforce-data-dashboard