How Often Are Staring Spells Seizures?

CHICAGO—About half of staring spells referred to a new-onset seizure (NOS) clinic turn out to be epileptic seizures, according to a retrospective chart review presented at the 47th Annual Meeting of the Child Neurology Society.

Children with nonepileptic staring were younger and more likely to have developmental delay, compared with children with epileptic staring, said Seunghyo Kim, MD, Visiting Associate Professor of Pediatrics at Emory University School of Medicine in Atlanta, and his colleagues. In addition, children with nonepileptic staring were more likely to have been referred by a primary care physician than by an emergency department.

A Common Reason for Referral

Staring spells are common in children and a frequent reason for referral to NOS clinics, the investigators said. Staring spells may be generalized absence seizures, focal seizures, or nonepileptic events. Few studies, however, have examined patients who newly present to a neurology clinic with the chief complaint of staring spells.

To evaluate the clinical and demographic features of children who present with staring spells to a regional NOS clinic, the researchers reviewed charts from 2,818 patients who visited a children’s hospital between September 22, 2015, and March 19, 2018. The investigators identified 189 patients with staring spells.

They excluded 48 cases where staring was accompanied by or followed by generalized tonic-clonic seizures or other motor seizures. In addition, they excluded 16 cases of established epilepsy and four cases of provoked seizures, including febrile seizures.

The final study population included 121 cases. About 48% of these patients with staring spells were African American, and 38% were white. Patients’ mean age at first visit to the NOS clinic was 6, and mean age at staring spell onset was 5.2.

Fifty-nine patients (49%) had epileptic staring episodes, and 62 patients (51%) had nonepileptic events.

Continue to: Approximately 50% were referred by an emergency department...

 

Approximately 50% were referred by an emergency department, 48% by a primary care physician, and 2% by an urgent care clinic. Of the 62 cases that turned out to be nonepileptic events, about 61% were referred by primary care physicians.

MRI Findings in Patients With Focal Seizures

On average, patients with nonepileptic staring were younger at the initial clinic presentation and at staring spell onset. Patients with nonepileptic staring had an average age of 4.8 at their initial visit, whereas patients with focal seizures had an average age of 6.3. Patients with absence seizures had an average age of 8.3.

Patients with nonepileptic events were more likely to have developmental delay (approximately 35%) versus patients with focal seizures (23%) or absence seizures (8%).

Absence epilepsy was diagnosed in 24 patients (20%), and focal epilepsy in 35 patients (29%).

Of the 59 cases of epileptic staring, 46% (n = 27) were classified as syndromic; 36% (n = 21) had childhood absence epilepsy, and 5% (n = 3) had juvenile absence epilepsy. In addition, there was one case each of mesial temporal lobe epilepsy with hippocampal sclerosis, Panayiotopoulos syndrome, and generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures.

About one-third of patients received MRI, and seven patients had etiologically relevant findings (eg, brain tumor, malformation of cortical development, and periventricular leukomalacia). All of the patients with abnormal MRIs had focal seizures.

“An NOS clinic ... can provide rapid, accurate diagnoses for staring spells,” said Dr. Kim. “This is important, as children with nonepileptic events should not be given the diagnosis of epilepsy, and their events should not be treated with seizure medications. Similarly, children who have epileptic seizures require accurate diagnosis, as the treatment depends on the seizure type.”

CHICAGO—About half of staring spells referred to a new-onset seizure (NOS) clinic turn out to be epileptic seizures, according to a retrospective chart review presented at the 47th Annual Meeting of the Child Neurology Society.

Children with nonepileptic staring were younger and more likely to have developmental delay, compared with children with epileptic staring, said Seunghyo Kim, MD, Visiting Associate Professor of Pediatrics at Emory University School of Medicine in Atlanta, and his colleagues. In addition, children with nonepileptic staring were more likely to have been referred by a primary care physician than by an emergency department.

A Common Reason for Referral

Staring spells are common in children and a frequent reason for referral to NOS clinics, the investigators said. Staring spells may be generalized absence seizures, focal seizures, or nonepileptic events. Few studies, however, have examined patients who newly present to a neurology clinic with the chief complaint of staring spells.

To evaluate the clinical and demographic features of children who present with staring spells to a regional NOS clinic, the researchers reviewed charts from 2,818 patients who visited a children’s hospital between September 22, 2015, and March 19, 2018. The investigators identified 189 patients with staring spells.

They excluded 48 cases where staring was accompanied by or followed by generalized tonic-clonic seizures or other motor seizures. In addition, they excluded 16 cases of established epilepsy and four cases of provoked seizures, including febrile seizures.

The final study population included 121 cases. About 48% of these patients with staring spells were African American, and 38% were white. Patients’ mean age at first visit to the NOS clinic was 6, and mean age at staring spell onset was 5.2.

Fifty-nine patients (49%) had epileptic staring episodes, and 62 patients (51%) had nonepileptic events.

Continue to: Approximately 50% were referred by an emergency department...

 

Approximately 50% were referred by an emergency department, 48% by a primary care physician, and 2% by an urgent care clinic. Of the 62 cases that turned out to be nonepileptic events, about 61% were referred by primary care physicians.

MRI Findings in Patients With Focal Seizures

On average, patients with nonepileptic staring were younger at the initial clinic presentation and at staring spell onset. Patients with nonepileptic staring had an average age of 4.8 at their initial visit, whereas patients with focal seizures had an average age of 6.3. Patients with absence seizures had an average age of 8.3.

Patients with nonepileptic events were more likely to have developmental delay (approximately 35%) versus patients with focal seizures (23%) or absence seizures (8%).

Absence epilepsy was diagnosed in 24 patients (20%), and focal epilepsy in 35 patients (29%).

Of the 59 cases of epileptic staring, 46% (n = 27) were classified as syndromic; 36% (n = 21) had childhood absence epilepsy, and 5% (n = 3) had juvenile absence epilepsy. In addition, there was one case each of mesial temporal lobe epilepsy with hippocampal sclerosis, Panayiotopoulos syndrome, and generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures.

About one-third of patients received MRI, and seven patients had etiologically relevant findings (eg, brain tumor, malformation of cortical development, and periventricular leukomalacia). All of the patients with abnormal MRIs had focal seizures.

“An NOS clinic ... can provide rapid, accurate diagnoses for staring spells,” said Dr. Kim. “This is important, as children with nonepileptic events should not be given the diagnosis of epilepsy, and their events should not be treated with seizure medications. Similarly, children who have epileptic seizures require accurate diagnosis, as the treatment depends on the seizure type.”

CHICAGO—About half of staring spells referred to a new-onset seizure (NOS) clinic turn out to be epileptic seizures, according to a retrospective chart review presented at the 47th Annual Meeting of the Child Neurology Society.

Children with nonepileptic staring were younger and more likely to have developmental delay, compared with children with epileptic staring, said Seunghyo Kim, MD, Visiting Associate Professor of Pediatrics at Emory University School of Medicine in Atlanta, and his colleagues. In addition, children with nonepileptic staring were more likely to have been referred by a primary care physician than by an emergency department.

A Common Reason for Referral

Staring spells are common in children and a frequent reason for referral to NOS clinics, the investigators said. Staring spells may be generalized absence seizures, focal seizures, or nonepileptic events. Few studies, however, have examined patients who newly present to a neurology clinic with the chief complaint of staring spells.

To evaluate the clinical and demographic features of children who present with staring spells to a regional NOS clinic, the researchers reviewed charts from 2,818 patients who visited a children’s hospital between September 22, 2015, and March 19, 2018. The investigators identified 189 patients with staring spells.

They excluded 48 cases where staring was accompanied by or followed by generalized tonic-clonic seizures or other motor seizures. In addition, they excluded 16 cases of established epilepsy and four cases of provoked seizures, including febrile seizures.

The final study population included 121 cases. About 48% of these patients with staring spells were African American, and 38% were white. Patients’ mean age at first visit to the NOS clinic was 6, and mean age at staring spell onset was 5.2.

Fifty-nine patients (49%) had epileptic staring episodes, and 62 patients (51%) had nonepileptic events.

Continue to: Approximately 50% were referred by an emergency department...

 

Approximately 50% were referred by an emergency department, 48% by a primary care physician, and 2% by an urgent care clinic. Of the 62 cases that turned out to be nonepileptic events, about 61% were referred by primary care physicians.

MRI Findings in Patients With Focal Seizures

On average, patients with nonepileptic staring were younger at the initial clinic presentation and at staring spell onset. Patients with nonepileptic staring had an average age of 4.8 at their initial visit, whereas patients with focal seizures had an average age of 6.3. Patients with absence seizures had an average age of 8.3.

Patients with nonepileptic events were more likely to have developmental delay (approximately 35%) versus patients with focal seizures (23%) or absence seizures (8%).

Absence epilepsy was diagnosed in 24 patients (20%), and focal epilepsy in 35 patients (29%).

Of the 59 cases of epileptic staring, 46% (n = 27) were classified as syndromic; 36% (n = 21) had childhood absence epilepsy, and 5% (n = 3) had juvenile absence epilepsy. In addition, there was one case each of mesial temporal lobe epilepsy with hippocampal sclerosis, Panayiotopoulos syndrome, and generalized epilepsy with febrile seizures.

About one-third of patients received MRI, and seven patients had etiologically relevant findings (eg, brain tumor, malformation of cortical development, and periventricular leukomalacia). All of the patients with abnormal MRIs had focal seizures.

“An NOS clinic ... can provide rapid, accurate diagnoses for staring spells,” said Dr. Kim. “This is important, as children with nonepileptic events should not be given the diagnosis of epilepsy, and their events should not be treated with seizure medications. Similarly, children who have epileptic seizures require accurate diagnosis, as the treatment depends on the seizure type.”