User login
International medical graduates (IMGs) constitute more than 24% of the total percentage of active physicians, 30% of active psychiatrists, and 33% of psychiatry residents in the United States.1 IMGs serve in various medical specialties and provide medical care to socioeconomically disadvantaged patients in underserved communities.2 Evidence suggests that patient outcomes among elderly patients admitted in U.S. hospitals for those treated by IMGs were on par with outcomes of U.S. graduates. Moreover, patients who were treated by IMGs had a lower mortality rates.3
IMGs trained in the United States make considerable contributions to psychiatry and have been very successful as educators, researchers, and leaders. Over the last 3 decades, for example, three American Psychiatric Association (APA) presidents and one past president of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry were IMGs. Many of them also hold department chair positions at many academic institutions.4,5
In short, IMGs are an important part of the U.S. health care system – particularly in psychiatry.
In addition to participating in psychiatry residency programs, IMG physicians are heavily represented in subspecialties, including geriatric psychiatry (45%), addiction psychiatry (42%), child and adolescent psychiatry (36%), psychosomatic medicine (32%), and forensic psychiatry (25%).6 IMG trainees face multiple challenges that begin as they transition to psychiatry residency in the United States, including understanding the American health care system, electronic medical records and documentation, and evidence-based medicine. In addition, they need to adapt to cultural changes, and work on language barriers, communication skills, and social isolation.7,8 Training programs account for these challenges and proactively take essential steps to facilitate the transition of IMGs into the U.S. system.9,10
As training programs prepare for the new academic year starting from July 2020 and continue to provide educational experiences to current trainees, the COVID-19 pandemic has brought additional challenges for the training programs. The gravity of the novel coronavirus pandemic continues to deepen, causing immense fear and uncertainty globally. An APA poll of more than 1,000 adults conducted early in the pandemic showed that about 40% of Americans were anxious about becoming seriously ill or dying with COVID-19. Nearly half of the respondents (48%) were anxious about the possibility of getting COVID-19, and even more (62%) were anxious about the possibility of their loved ones getting infected by this virus. Also, one-third of Americans reported a serious impact on their mental health.
Furthermore, the ailing economy and increasing unemployment are raising financial concerns for individuals and families. This pandemic also has had an impact on our patients’ sleep hygiene, relationships with their loved ones, and consumption of alcohol or other drugs/substances.11 Deteriorating mental health raises concerns about increased suicide risk as a secondary consequence.12
Physicians and other frontline teams who are taking care of these patients and their families continue to provide unexcelled, compassionate care in these unprecedented times. Selfless care continues despite awareness of the high probability of getting exposed to the virus and spreading it further to family members. Physicians involved in direct patient care for COVID-19 patients are at high risk for demoralization, burnout, depression, and anxiety.13
Struggles experienced by IMGs
On the personal front, IMGs often struggle with multiple stressors, such as lack of social support, ethnic-minority prejudice, and the need to understand financial structures such as mortgages in the new countries even after extended periods of residence.14 This virus has killed many health care professionals, including physicians around the world. There was a report of suicide by an emergency medicine physician who was treating patients with COVID-19 and ended up contracting the virus. That news was devastating and overwhelming for everyone, especially health care clinicians. It also adds to the stress and worries of IMGs who are still on nonimmigrant visas.
Bigger concerns exist if there is a demise of a nonimmigrant IMG and the implications of that loss for dependent families – who might face deportation. Even for those who were recently granted permanent residency status, worries about limited support systems and financial hardships to their families can be stressors.
Also, a large number of IMGs represent the geographical area where the pandemic began. Fortunately, the World Health Organization has taken a firm stance against possible discrimination by calling for global solidarity in these times. Furthermore, the WHO has emphasized the importance of referring to the disease caused by SARS-CoV-2 as “COVID-19” only – and not by the name of a particular country or city.15 Despite those official positions, people continue to express racially discriminatory opinions related to the virus, and those comments are not only disturbing to IMGs, they also are demoralizing.
Travel restrictions
In addition to the worries that IMGs might have about their own health and that of their families residing with them, the well-being of their extended families, including their aging parents back in their countries of origin, is unsettling as well. It is even more unnerving during the pandemic because the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the State Department advised avoiding all international travel at this time. Under these circumstances, IMGs are concerned about travel to their countries of origin in the event of a family emergency and the quarantine protocols in place, at both the country of origin and at residences.
Immigration issues
The U.S. administration temporarily suspended all immigration for 60 days, starting from April 2020. Recently, an executive order was signed suspending entry in the country on several visas, including the J-1 and the H1-B. Those are two categories that allow physicians to train and work in the United States.
IMGs in the United States reside and practice here under different types of immigrant and nonimmigrant visas (J-1, H1-B). This year, the Match results coincided with the timeline of those new immigration restrictions. Many IMGs are currently in the process of renewing their H1-B visas. They are worried because their visas will expire in the coming months. During the pandemic, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services suspended routine visa services and premium processing for visa renewals. This halt led to a delay in visa processing for graduating residents in June and practicing physicians seeking visa renewal. Those delays add to personal stress, and furthermore, distract these immigrant physicians from fighting this pandemic.
Another complication is that rules for J-1 visa holders have changed so that trainees must return to their countries of origin for at least 2 years after completing their training. If they decide to continue practicing medicine in the United States, they need a specific type of J-1 waiver and must gain a pathway to be a lawful permanent resident (Green Card). Many IMGs who are on waiver positions might not be able to treat patients ailing from COVID-19 to the full extent because waivers restrict them to practicing only in certain identified health systems.
IMGs who are coming from a country such India have to wait for more than 11 years after completing their accredited training to get permanent residency because of backlog for the permanent residency process.16 While waiting for a Green Card, they must continue to work on an H1-B visa, which requires periodic renewal.
Potential impact on training
Non-U.S. citizen IMGs accounted for 13% of the total of first-year positions in the 2020 Match. They will start medical training in residency programs in the United States in the coming months. The numbers for psychiatry residency matches are higher; about 16% of total first-year positions are filled by non-U.S. IMGs.17 At this time, when they should be celebrating their successful Match after many years of hard work and persistence, there is increased anxiety. They wonder whether they will be able to enter the United States to begin their training program on time. Their concerns are multifold, but the main concern is related to uncertainties around getting visas on time. With the recent executive order in place, physicians only working actively with COVID-19 patients will be able to enter the country on visas. As mental health concerns continue to rise during these times, incoming residents might not be able to start training if they are out of the country.
Furthermore, because of travel/air restrictions, there are worries about whether physicians will be able to get flights to the United States, given the lockdown in many countries around the world. Conversely, IMGs who will be graduating from residency and fellowship programs this summer and have accepted new positions also are dealing with similar uncertainty. Their new jobs will require visa processing, and the current scenario provides limited insight, so far, about whether they will be able to start their respective jobs or whether they will have to return to their home countries until their visa processing is completed.
The American Medical Association has advised the Secretary of State and acting Secretary of Homeland Security to expedite physician workforce expansion in an effort to meet the growing need for health care services during this pandemic.18 It is encouraging that, recently, the State Department declared that visa processing will continue for medical professionals and that cases would be expedited for those who meet the criteria. However, the requirement for in-person interviews remains for individuals who are seeking a U.S. visa outside the country.
As residency programs are trying their best to continue to provide educational experiences to trainees during this phase, if psychiatry residents are placed on quarantine because of either getting exposed or contracting the illness, there is a possibility that they might need to extend their training. This would bring another challenge for IMGs, requiring them to extend their visas to complete their training. Future J-1 waiver jobs could be compromised.
Investment in physician wellness critical
Psychiatrists, along with other health care workers, are front-line soldiers in the fight against COVID-19. All physicians are at high risk for demoralization, burnout, depression, anxiety, and suicide. It is of utmost importance that we invest immediately in physicians’ wellness. As noted, significant numbers of psychiatrists are IMGs who are dealing with additional challenges while responding to the pandemic. There are certain challenges for IMGs, such as the well-being of their extended families in other countries, and travel bans put in place because of the pandemic. Those issues are not easy to resolve. However, addressing visa issues and providing support to their families in the event that something happens to physicians during the pandemic would be reassuring and would help alleviate additional stress. Those kinds of actions also would allow immigrant physicians to focus on clinical work and to improve their overall well-being. Given the health risks and numerous other insecurities that go along with living amid a pandemic, IMGs should not have the additional pressure of visa uncertainty.
Public health crises such as COVID-19 are associated with increased rates of anxiety,19 depression,20 illicit substance use,21 and an increased rate of suicide.22 Patients with serious mental illness might be among the hardest hit both physically and mentally during the pandemic.23 Even in the absence of a pandemic, there is already a shortage of psychiatrists at the national level, and it is expected that this shortage will grow in the future. Rural and underserved areas are expected to experience the physician deficit more acutely.24
The pandemic is likely to resolve gradually and unpredictably – and might recur along the way over the next 1-2 years. However, the psychiatrist shortage will escalate more, as the mental health needs in the United States increase further in coming months. We need psychiatrists now more than ever, and it will be crucial that prospective residents, graduating residents, and fellows are able to come on board to join the American health care system promptly. In addition to national-level interventions, residency programs, potential employers, and communities must be aware of and do whatever they can to address the challenges faced by IMGs during these times.
Dr. Raman Baweja is affiliated with the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Penn State University, Hershey. He has no conflicts of interest. Dr. Verma is affiliated with Rogers Behavioral Health in Kenosha County, Wis., and the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science in North Chicago. She has no conflicts of interest. Dr. Ritika Baweja is affiliated with the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Penn State. Dr. Ritika Baweja is the spouse of Dr. Raman Baweja. Dr. Adam is affiliated with the department of psychiatry at the University of Missouri, Columbia.
References
1. American Psychiatric Association. Navigating psychiatry residency in the United States. A Guide for IMG Physicians.
2. Berg S. 5 IMG physicians who speak up for patients and fellow doctors. American Medical Association. 2019 Oct 22.
3. Tsugawa Y et al. BMJ. 2017 Feb 3;256. doi: 10.1136/bmj.j273.
4. Gogineni RR et al. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am. 2010 Oct 1;19(4):833-53.
5. Majeed MH et al. Academic Psychiatry. 2017 Dec 1;41(6):849-51.
6. Brotherton SE and Etzel SI. JAMA. 2018 Sep 11;320(10):1051-70.
7. Sockalingam S et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2012 Jul 1;36(4):277-81.
8. Singareddy R et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2008 Jul-Aug;32(4):343-4.
9. Kramer MN. Acad Psychiatry. 2005 Jul-Aug;29(3):322-4.
10. Rao NR and Kotapati VP. Pathways for success in academic medicine for an international medical graduate: Challenges and opportunities. In “Roberts Academic Medicine Handbook” 2020. Springer:163-70.
11. American Psychiatric Association. New poll: COVID-19 impacting mental well-being: Americans feeling anxious, especially for loved ones; older adults are less anxious. 2020 Mar 25.
12. Reger MA et al. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 10. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.1060.
13. Lai J et al. JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Mar 23;3(3):e203976-e203976. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.3976.
14. Kalra G et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2012 Jul;36(4):323-9.
15. WHO best practices for the naming of new human infectious diseases. World Health Organization. 2015.
16. U.S. Department of State. Bureau of Consular Affairs. Visa Bulletin for March 2020.
17. National Resident Matching Program® (NRMP®). Thousands of medical students and graduates celebrate NRMP Match results.
18. American Medical Association. AMA: U.S. should open visas to international physicians amid COVID-19. AMA press release. 2020 Mar 25.
19. McKay D et al. J Anxiety Disord. 2020 Jun;73:02233. doi: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2020.102233.
20. Tang W et al. J Affect Disord. 2020 May 13;274:1-7.
21. Collins F et al. NIH Director’s Blog. NIH.gov. 2020 Apr 21.
22. Reger M et al. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 10. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.1060.
23. Druss BG. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 3. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.0894.
24. American Association of Medical Colleges. “The complexities of physician supply and demand: Projections from 2018-2033.” 2020 Jun.
International medical graduates (IMGs) constitute more than 24% of the total percentage of active physicians, 30% of active psychiatrists, and 33% of psychiatry residents in the United States.1 IMGs serve in various medical specialties and provide medical care to socioeconomically disadvantaged patients in underserved communities.2 Evidence suggests that patient outcomes among elderly patients admitted in U.S. hospitals for those treated by IMGs were on par with outcomes of U.S. graduates. Moreover, patients who were treated by IMGs had a lower mortality rates.3
IMGs trained in the United States make considerable contributions to psychiatry and have been very successful as educators, researchers, and leaders. Over the last 3 decades, for example, three American Psychiatric Association (APA) presidents and one past president of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry were IMGs. Many of them also hold department chair positions at many academic institutions.4,5
In short, IMGs are an important part of the U.S. health care system – particularly in psychiatry.
In addition to participating in psychiatry residency programs, IMG physicians are heavily represented in subspecialties, including geriatric psychiatry (45%), addiction psychiatry (42%), child and adolescent psychiatry (36%), psychosomatic medicine (32%), and forensic psychiatry (25%).6 IMG trainees face multiple challenges that begin as they transition to psychiatry residency in the United States, including understanding the American health care system, electronic medical records and documentation, and evidence-based medicine. In addition, they need to adapt to cultural changes, and work on language barriers, communication skills, and social isolation.7,8 Training programs account for these challenges and proactively take essential steps to facilitate the transition of IMGs into the U.S. system.9,10
As training programs prepare for the new academic year starting from July 2020 and continue to provide educational experiences to current trainees, the COVID-19 pandemic has brought additional challenges for the training programs. The gravity of the novel coronavirus pandemic continues to deepen, causing immense fear and uncertainty globally. An APA poll of more than 1,000 adults conducted early in the pandemic showed that about 40% of Americans were anxious about becoming seriously ill or dying with COVID-19. Nearly half of the respondents (48%) were anxious about the possibility of getting COVID-19, and even more (62%) were anxious about the possibility of their loved ones getting infected by this virus. Also, one-third of Americans reported a serious impact on their mental health.
Furthermore, the ailing economy and increasing unemployment are raising financial concerns for individuals and families. This pandemic also has had an impact on our patients’ sleep hygiene, relationships with their loved ones, and consumption of alcohol or other drugs/substances.11 Deteriorating mental health raises concerns about increased suicide risk as a secondary consequence.12
Physicians and other frontline teams who are taking care of these patients and their families continue to provide unexcelled, compassionate care in these unprecedented times. Selfless care continues despite awareness of the high probability of getting exposed to the virus and spreading it further to family members. Physicians involved in direct patient care for COVID-19 patients are at high risk for demoralization, burnout, depression, and anxiety.13
Struggles experienced by IMGs
On the personal front, IMGs often struggle with multiple stressors, such as lack of social support, ethnic-minority prejudice, and the need to understand financial structures such as mortgages in the new countries even after extended periods of residence.14 This virus has killed many health care professionals, including physicians around the world. There was a report of suicide by an emergency medicine physician who was treating patients with COVID-19 and ended up contracting the virus. That news was devastating and overwhelming for everyone, especially health care clinicians. It also adds to the stress and worries of IMGs who are still on nonimmigrant visas.
Bigger concerns exist if there is a demise of a nonimmigrant IMG and the implications of that loss for dependent families – who might face deportation. Even for those who were recently granted permanent residency status, worries about limited support systems and financial hardships to their families can be stressors.
Also, a large number of IMGs represent the geographical area where the pandemic began. Fortunately, the World Health Organization has taken a firm stance against possible discrimination by calling for global solidarity in these times. Furthermore, the WHO has emphasized the importance of referring to the disease caused by SARS-CoV-2 as “COVID-19” only – and not by the name of a particular country or city.15 Despite those official positions, people continue to express racially discriminatory opinions related to the virus, and those comments are not only disturbing to IMGs, they also are demoralizing.
Travel restrictions
In addition to the worries that IMGs might have about their own health and that of their families residing with them, the well-being of their extended families, including their aging parents back in their countries of origin, is unsettling as well. It is even more unnerving during the pandemic because the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the State Department advised avoiding all international travel at this time. Under these circumstances, IMGs are concerned about travel to their countries of origin in the event of a family emergency and the quarantine protocols in place, at both the country of origin and at residences.
Immigration issues
The U.S. administration temporarily suspended all immigration for 60 days, starting from April 2020. Recently, an executive order was signed suspending entry in the country on several visas, including the J-1 and the H1-B. Those are two categories that allow physicians to train and work in the United States.
IMGs in the United States reside and practice here under different types of immigrant and nonimmigrant visas (J-1, H1-B). This year, the Match results coincided with the timeline of those new immigration restrictions. Many IMGs are currently in the process of renewing their H1-B visas. They are worried because their visas will expire in the coming months. During the pandemic, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services suspended routine visa services and premium processing for visa renewals. This halt led to a delay in visa processing for graduating residents in June and practicing physicians seeking visa renewal. Those delays add to personal stress, and furthermore, distract these immigrant physicians from fighting this pandemic.
Another complication is that rules for J-1 visa holders have changed so that trainees must return to their countries of origin for at least 2 years after completing their training. If they decide to continue practicing medicine in the United States, they need a specific type of J-1 waiver and must gain a pathway to be a lawful permanent resident (Green Card). Many IMGs who are on waiver positions might not be able to treat patients ailing from COVID-19 to the full extent because waivers restrict them to practicing only in certain identified health systems.
IMGs who are coming from a country such India have to wait for more than 11 years after completing their accredited training to get permanent residency because of backlog for the permanent residency process.16 While waiting for a Green Card, they must continue to work on an H1-B visa, which requires periodic renewal.
Potential impact on training
Non-U.S. citizen IMGs accounted for 13% of the total of first-year positions in the 2020 Match. They will start medical training in residency programs in the United States in the coming months. The numbers for psychiatry residency matches are higher; about 16% of total first-year positions are filled by non-U.S. IMGs.17 At this time, when they should be celebrating their successful Match after many years of hard work and persistence, there is increased anxiety. They wonder whether they will be able to enter the United States to begin their training program on time. Their concerns are multifold, but the main concern is related to uncertainties around getting visas on time. With the recent executive order in place, physicians only working actively with COVID-19 patients will be able to enter the country on visas. As mental health concerns continue to rise during these times, incoming residents might not be able to start training if they are out of the country.
Furthermore, because of travel/air restrictions, there are worries about whether physicians will be able to get flights to the United States, given the lockdown in many countries around the world. Conversely, IMGs who will be graduating from residency and fellowship programs this summer and have accepted new positions also are dealing with similar uncertainty. Their new jobs will require visa processing, and the current scenario provides limited insight, so far, about whether they will be able to start their respective jobs or whether they will have to return to their home countries until their visa processing is completed.
The American Medical Association has advised the Secretary of State and acting Secretary of Homeland Security to expedite physician workforce expansion in an effort to meet the growing need for health care services during this pandemic.18 It is encouraging that, recently, the State Department declared that visa processing will continue for medical professionals and that cases would be expedited for those who meet the criteria. However, the requirement for in-person interviews remains for individuals who are seeking a U.S. visa outside the country.
As residency programs are trying their best to continue to provide educational experiences to trainees during this phase, if psychiatry residents are placed on quarantine because of either getting exposed or contracting the illness, there is a possibility that they might need to extend their training. This would bring another challenge for IMGs, requiring them to extend their visas to complete their training. Future J-1 waiver jobs could be compromised.
Investment in physician wellness critical
Psychiatrists, along with other health care workers, are front-line soldiers in the fight against COVID-19. All physicians are at high risk for demoralization, burnout, depression, anxiety, and suicide. It is of utmost importance that we invest immediately in physicians’ wellness. As noted, significant numbers of psychiatrists are IMGs who are dealing with additional challenges while responding to the pandemic. There are certain challenges for IMGs, such as the well-being of their extended families in other countries, and travel bans put in place because of the pandemic. Those issues are not easy to resolve. However, addressing visa issues and providing support to their families in the event that something happens to physicians during the pandemic would be reassuring and would help alleviate additional stress. Those kinds of actions also would allow immigrant physicians to focus on clinical work and to improve their overall well-being. Given the health risks and numerous other insecurities that go along with living amid a pandemic, IMGs should not have the additional pressure of visa uncertainty.
Public health crises such as COVID-19 are associated with increased rates of anxiety,19 depression,20 illicit substance use,21 and an increased rate of suicide.22 Patients with serious mental illness might be among the hardest hit both physically and mentally during the pandemic.23 Even in the absence of a pandemic, there is already a shortage of psychiatrists at the national level, and it is expected that this shortage will grow in the future. Rural and underserved areas are expected to experience the physician deficit more acutely.24
The pandemic is likely to resolve gradually and unpredictably – and might recur along the way over the next 1-2 years. However, the psychiatrist shortage will escalate more, as the mental health needs in the United States increase further in coming months. We need psychiatrists now more than ever, and it will be crucial that prospective residents, graduating residents, and fellows are able to come on board to join the American health care system promptly. In addition to national-level interventions, residency programs, potential employers, and communities must be aware of and do whatever they can to address the challenges faced by IMGs during these times.
Dr. Raman Baweja is affiliated with the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Penn State University, Hershey. He has no conflicts of interest. Dr. Verma is affiliated with Rogers Behavioral Health in Kenosha County, Wis., and the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science in North Chicago. She has no conflicts of interest. Dr. Ritika Baweja is affiliated with the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Penn State. Dr. Ritika Baweja is the spouse of Dr. Raman Baweja. Dr. Adam is affiliated with the department of psychiatry at the University of Missouri, Columbia.
References
1. American Psychiatric Association. Navigating psychiatry residency in the United States. A Guide for IMG Physicians.
2. Berg S. 5 IMG physicians who speak up for patients and fellow doctors. American Medical Association. 2019 Oct 22.
3. Tsugawa Y et al. BMJ. 2017 Feb 3;256. doi: 10.1136/bmj.j273.
4. Gogineni RR et al. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am. 2010 Oct 1;19(4):833-53.
5. Majeed MH et al. Academic Psychiatry. 2017 Dec 1;41(6):849-51.
6. Brotherton SE and Etzel SI. JAMA. 2018 Sep 11;320(10):1051-70.
7. Sockalingam S et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2012 Jul 1;36(4):277-81.
8. Singareddy R et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2008 Jul-Aug;32(4):343-4.
9. Kramer MN. Acad Psychiatry. 2005 Jul-Aug;29(3):322-4.
10. Rao NR and Kotapati VP. Pathways for success in academic medicine for an international medical graduate: Challenges and opportunities. In “Roberts Academic Medicine Handbook” 2020. Springer:163-70.
11. American Psychiatric Association. New poll: COVID-19 impacting mental well-being: Americans feeling anxious, especially for loved ones; older adults are less anxious. 2020 Mar 25.
12. Reger MA et al. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 10. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.1060.
13. Lai J et al. JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Mar 23;3(3):e203976-e203976. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.3976.
14. Kalra G et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2012 Jul;36(4):323-9.
15. WHO best practices for the naming of new human infectious diseases. World Health Organization. 2015.
16. U.S. Department of State. Bureau of Consular Affairs. Visa Bulletin for March 2020.
17. National Resident Matching Program® (NRMP®). Thousands of medical students and graduates celebrate NRMP Match results.
18. American Medical Association. AMA: U.S. should open visas to international physicians amid COVID-19. AMA press release. 2020 Mar 25.
19. McKay D et al. J Anxiety Disord. 2020 Jun;73:02233. doi: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2020.102233.
20. Tang W et al. J Affect Disord. 2020 May 13;274:1-7.
21. Collins F et al. NIH Director’s Blog. NIH.gov. 2020 Apr 21.
22. Reger M et al. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 10. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.1060.
23. Druss BG. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 3. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.0894.
24. American Association of Medical Colleges. “The complexities of physician supply and demand: Projections from 2018-2033.” 2020 Jun.
International medical graduates (IMGs) constitute more than 24% of the total percentage of active physicians, 30% of active psychiatrists, and 33% of psychiatry residents in the United States.1 IMGs serve in various medical specialties and provide medical care to socioeconomically disadvantaged patients in underserved communities.2 Evidence suggests that patient outcomes among elderly patients admitted in U.S. hospitals for those treated by IMGs were on par with outcomes of U.S. graduates. Moreover, patients who were treated by IMGs had a lower mortality rates.3
IMGs trained in the United States make considerable contributions to psychiatry and have been very successful as educators, researchers, and leaders. Over the last 3 decades, for example, three American Psychiatric Association (APA) presidents and one past president of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry were IMGs. Many of them also hold department chair positions at many academic institutions.4,5
In short, IMGs are an important part of the U.S. health care system – particularly in psychiatry.
In addition to participating in psychiatry residency programs, IMG physicians are heavily represented in subspecialties, including geriatric psychiatry (45%), addiction psychiatry (42%), child and adolescent psychiatry (36%), psychosomatic medicine (32%), and forensic psychiatry (25%).6 IMG trainees face multiple challenges that begin as they transition to psychiatry residency in the United States, including understanding the American health care system, electronic medical records and documentation, and evidence-based medicine. In addition, they need to adapt to cultural changes, and work on language barriers, communication skills, and social isolation.7,8 Training programs account for these challenges and proactively take essential steps to facilitate the transition of IMGs into the U.S. system.9,10
As training programs prepare for the new academic year starting from July 2020 and continue to provide educational experiences to current trainees, the COVID-19 pandemic has brought additional challenges for the training programs. The gravity of the novel coronavirus pandemic continues to deepen, causing immense fear and uncertainty globally. An APA poll of more than 1,000 adults conducted early in the pandemic showed that about 40% of Americans were anxious about becoming seriously ill or dying with COVID-19. Nearly half of the respondents (48%) were anxious about the possibility of getting COVID-19, and even more (62%) were anxious about the possibility of their loved ones getting infected by this virus. Also, one-third of Americans reported a serious impact on their mental health.
Furthermore, the ailing economy and increasing unemployment are raising financial concerns for individuals and families. This pandemic also has had an impact on our patients’ sleep hygiene, relationships with their loved ones, and consumption of alcohol or other drugs/substances.11 Deteriorating mental health raises concerns about increased suicide risk as a secondary consequence.12
Physicians and other frontline teams who are taking care of these patients and their families continue to provide unexcelled, compassionate care in these unprecedented times. Selfless care continues despite awareness of the high probability of getting exposed to the virus and spreading it further to family members. Physicians involved in direct patient care for COVID-19 patients are at high risk for demoralization, burnout, depression, and anxiety.13
Struggles experienced by IMGs
On the personal front, IMGs often struggle with multiple stressors, such as lack of social support, ethnic-minority prejudice, and the need to understand financial structures such as mortgages in the new countries even after extended periods of residence.14 This virus has killed many health care professionals, including physicians around the world. There was a report of suicide by an emergency medicine physician who was treating patients with COVID-19 and ended up contracting the virus. That news was devastating and overwhelming for everyone, especially health care clinicians. It also adds to the stress and worries of IMGs who are still on nonimmigrant visas.
Bigger concerns exist if there is a demise of a nonimmigrant IMG and the implications of that loss for dependent families – who might face deportation. Even for those who were recently granted permanent residency status, worries about limited support systems and financial hardships to their families can be stressors.
Also, a large number of IMGs represent the geographical area where the pandemic began. Fortunately, the World Health Organization has taken a firm stance against possible discrimination by calling for global solidarity in these times. Furthermore, the WHO has emphasized the importance of referring to the disease caused by SARS-CoV-2 as “COVID-19” only – and not by the name of a particular country or city.15 Despite those official positions, people continue to express racially discriminatory opinions related to the virus, and those comments are not only disturbing to IMGs, they also are demoralizing.
Travel restrictions
In addition to the worries that IMGs might have about their own health and that of their families residing with them, the well-being of their extended families, including their aging parents back in their countries of origin, is unsettling as well. It is even more unnerving during the pandemic because the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the State Department advised avoiding all international travel at this time. Under these circumstances, IMGs are concerned about travel to their countries of origin in the event of a family emergency and the quarantine protocols in place, at both the country of origin and at residences.
Immigration issues
The U.S. administration temporarily suspended all immigration for 60 days, starting from April 2020. Recently, an executive order was signed suspending entry in the country on several visas, including the J-1 and the H1-B. Those are two categories that allow physicians to train and work in the United States.
IMGs in the United States reside and practice here under different types of immigrant and nonimmigrant visas (J-1, H1-B). This year, the Match results coincided with the timeline of those new immigration restrictions. Many IMGs are currently in the process of renewing their H1-B visas. They are worried because their visas will expire in the coming months. During the pandemic, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services suspended routine visa services and premium processing for visa renewals. This halt led to a delay in visa processing for graduating residents in June and practicing physicians seeking visa renewal. Those delays add to personal stress, and furthermore, distract these immigrant physicians from fighting this pandemic.
Another complication is that rules for J-1 visa holders have changed so that trainees must return to their countries of origin for at least 2 years after completing their training. If they decide to continue practicing medicine in the United States, they need a specific type of J-1 waiver and must gain a pathway to be a lawful permanent resident (Green Card). Many IMGs who are on waiver positions might not be able to treat patients ailing from COVID-19 to the full extent because waivers restrict them to practicing only in certain identified health systems.
IMGs who are coming from a country such India have to wait for more than 11 years after completing their accredited training to get permanent residency because of backlog for the permanent residency process.16 While waiting for a Green Card, they must continue to work on an H1-B visa, which requires periodic renewal.
Potential impact on training
Non-U.S. citizen IMGs accounted for 13% of the total of first-year positions in the 2020 Match. They will start medical training in residency programs in the United States in the coming months. The numbers for psychiatry residency matches are higher; about 16% of total first-year positions are filled by non-U.S. IMGs.17 At this time, when they should be celebrating their successful Match after many years of hard work and persistence, there is increased anxiety. They wonder whether they will be able to enter the United States to begin their training program on time. Their concerns are multifold, but the main concern is related to uncertainties around getting visas on time. With the recent executive order in place, physicians only working actively with COVID-19 patients will be able to enter the country on visas. As mental health concerns continue to rise during these times, incoming residents might not be able to start training if they are out of the country.
Furthermore, because of travel/air restrictions, there are worries about whether physicians will be able to get flights to the United States, given the lockdown in many countries around the world. Conversely, IMGs who will be graduating from residency and fellowship programs this summer and have accepted new positions also are dealing with similar uncertainty. Their new jobs will require visa processing, and the current scenario provides limited insight, so far, about whether they will be able to start their respective jobs or whether they will have to return to their home countries until their visa processing is completed.
The American Medical Association has advised the Secretary of State and acting Secretary of Homeland Security to expedite physician workforce expansion in an effort to meet the growing need for health care services during this pandemic.18 It is encouraging that, recently, the State Department declared that visa processing will continue for medical professionals and that cases would be expedited for those who meet the criteria. However, the requirement for in-person interviews remains for individuals who are seeking a U.S. visa outside the country.
As residency programs are trying their best to continue to provide educational experiences to trainees during this phase, if psychiatry residents are placed on quarantine because of either getting exposed or contracting the illness, there is a possibility that they might need to extend their training. This would bring another challenge for IMGs, requiring them to extend their visas to complete their training. Future J-1 waiver jobs could be compromised.
Investment in physician wellness critical
Psychiatrists, along with other health care workers, are front-line soldiers in the fight against COVID-19. All physicians are at high risk for demoralization, burnout, depression, anxiety, and suicide. It is of utmost importance that we invest immediately in physicians’ wellness. As noted, significant numbers of psychiatrists are IMGs who are dealing with additional challenges while responding to the pandemic. There are certain challenges for IMGs, such as the well-being of their extended families in other countries, and travel bans put in place because of the pandemic. Those issues are not easy to resolve. However, addressing visa issues and providing support to their families in the event that something happens to physicians during the pandemic would be reassuring and would help alleviate additional stress. Those kinds of actions also would allow immigrant physicians to focus on clinical work and to improve their overall well-being. Given the health risks and numerous other insecurities that go along with living amid a pandemic, IMGs should not have the additional pressure of visa uncertainty.
Public health crises such as COVID-19 are associated with increased rates of anxiety,19 depression,20 illicit substance use,21 and an increased rate of suicide.22 Patients with serious mental illness might be among the hardest hit both physically and mentally during the pandemic.23 Even in the absence of a pandemic, there is already a shortage of psychiatrists at the national level, and it is expected that this shortage will grow in the future. Rural and underserved areas are expected to experience the physician deficit more acutely.24
The pandemic is likely to resolve gradually and unpredictably – and might recur along the way over the next 1-2 years. However, the psychiatrist shortage will escalate more, as the mental health needs in the United States increase further in coming months. We need psychiatrists now more than ever, and it will be crucial that prospective residents, graduating residents, and fellows are able to come on board to join the American health care system promptly. In addition to national-level interventions, residency programs, potential employers, and communities must be aware of and do whatever they can to address the challenges faced by IMGs during these times.
Dr. Raman Baweja is affiliated with the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Penn State University, Hershey. He has no conflicts of interest. Dr. Verma is affiliated with Rogers Behavioral Health in Kenosha County, Wis., and the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Rosalind Franklin University of Medicine and Science in North Chicago. She has no conflicts of interest. Dr. Ritika Baweja is affiliated with the department of psychiatry and behavioral health at Penn State. Dr. Ritika Baweja is the spouse of Dr. Raman Baweja. Dr. Adam is affiliated with the department of psychiatry at the University of Missouri, Columbia.
References
1. American Psychiatric Association. Navigating psychiatry residency in the United States. A Guide for IMG Physicians.
2. Berg S. 5 IMG physicians who speak up for patients and fellow doctors. American Medical Association. 2019 Oct 22.
3. Tsugawa Y et al. BMJ. 2017 Feb 3;256. doi: 10.1136/bmj.j273.
4. Gogineni RR et al. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am. 2010 Oct 1;19(4):833-53.
5. Majeed MH et al. Academic Psychiatry. 2017 Dec 1;41(6):849-51.
6. Brotherton SE and Etzel SI. JAMA. 2018 Sep 11;320(10):1051-70.
7. Sockalingam S et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2012 Jul 1;36(4):277-81.
8. Singareddy R et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2008 Jul-Aug;32(4):343-4.
9. Kramer MN. Acad Psychiatry. 2005 Jul-Aug;29(3):322-4.
10. Rao NR and Kotapati VP. Pathways for success in academic medicine for an international medical graduate: Challenges and opportunities. In “Roberts Academic Medicine Handbook” 2020. Springer:163-70.
11. American Psychiatric Association. New poll: COVID-19 impacting mental well-being: Americans feeling anxious, especially for loved ones; older adults are less anxious. 2020 Mar 25.
12. Reger MA et al. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 10. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.1060.
13. Lai J et al. JAMA Netw Open. 2020 Mar 23;3(3):e203976-e203976. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2020.3976.
14. Kalra G et al. Acad Psychiatry. 2012 Jul;36(4):323-9.
15. WHO best practices for the naming of new human infectious diseases. World Health Organization. 2015.
16. U.S. Department of State. Bureau of Consular Affairs. Visa Bulletin for March 2020.
17. National Resident Matching Program® (NRMP®). Thousands of medical students and graduates celebrate NRMP Match results.
18. American Medical Association. AMA: U.S. should open visas to international physicians amid COVID-19. AMA press release. 2020 Mar 25.
19. McKay D et al. J Anxiety Disord. 2020 Jun;73:02233. doi: 10.1016/j.janxdis.2020.102233.
20. Tang W et al. J Affect Disord. 2020 May 13;274:1-7.
21. Collins F et al. NIH Director’s Blog. NIH.gov. 2020 Apr 21.
22. Reger M et al. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 10. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.1060.
23. Druss BG. JAMA Psychiatry. 2020 Apr 3. doi: 10.1001/jamapsychiatry.2020.0894.
24. American Association of Medical Colleges. “The complexities of physician supply and demand: Projections from 2018-2033.” 2020 Jun.