Physicians Are Reticent About Taking On Bipolar Depression

MONTREAL — Primary care physicians are not confident when it comes to diagnosing and managing patients with bipolar depression, according to a cross-sectional survey of providers participating in a national electronic health record database.

Among 85 primary care providers in GE Healthcare's Medical Quality Improvement Consortium, self-rated confidence in managing bipolar disorder averaged 1.7 on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being “very confident,” said Dr. Dana King, who presented the findings as a poster at the annual meeting of the North American Primary Care Research Group.

“For other more common disorders such as reflux disease, heart disease, or diabetes, these physicians have more confidence in their ability to sort out complex problems and deal with them. But bipolar disorder is less common and people have less exposure to it during their training,” explained Dr. King, a professor at the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston.

Of the respondents, 86% had been using electronic health records for 3 or more years, and 94% had access to the Internet from their clinical workstations. At the same time, only 8% had recommended Web site information on bipolar disorder to their patients in the last 3 months.

Although 72% of the respondents said they screened depressed patients for bipolar disorder, 38% reported frequently using a standard screening tool, the most common being the Mood Disorder Questionnaire.

Informal screening was more common than was the use of standardized tools and consisted of “a few questions about manic activity in patients with depression,” Dr. King said. Such information screening may involve questions such as, “Do you go on spending sprees? Do you stay up all night? Do you find yourself having ups and downs, including periods of high irritability, anger, or stress?”

As the use of electronic medical records becomes more widespread, they may help prompt physicians to screen patients for bipolar disorder by offering pop-up information, he said. This represents an opportunity for quality improvement.

“Physicians seem to like the idea that we could offer them quick medical information via the electronic medical record that will give them some quick answers,” he said.

The survey did not include formal interviews, but discussions with the participants have revealed that they prefer referring patients with suspected bipolar disorder to mental health specialists if screening comes up positive, Dr. King said. “Many are willing to comanage the patient, but they first want the diagnosis to be confirmed, typed according to bipolar I or II, with an identification of the phase and recommended medications.”

The study was funded by Delaware Valley Outcomes Research and GE Healthcare as part of a quality improvement project dealing with several medical disorders.

MONTREAL — Primary care physicians are not confident when it comes to diagnosing and managing patients with bipolar depression, according to a cross-sectional survey of providers participating in a national electronic health record database.

Among 85 primary care providers in GE Healthcare's Medical Quality Improvement Consortium, self-rated confidence in managing bipolar disorder averaged 1.7 on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being “very confident,” said Dr. Dana King, who presented the findings as a poster at the annual meeting of the North American Primary Care Research Group.

“For other more common disorders such as reflux disease, heart disease, or diabetes, these physicians have more confidence in their ability to sort out complex problems and deal with them. But bipolar disorder is less common and people have less exposure to it during their training,” explained Dr. King, a professor at the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston.

Of the respondents, 86% had been using electronic health records for 3 or more years, and 94% had access to the Internet from their clinical workstations. At the same time, only 8% had recommended Web site information on bipolar disorder to their patients in the last 3 months.

Although 72% of the respondents said they screened depressed patients for bipolar disorder, 38% reported frequently using a standard screening tool, the most common being the Mood Disorder Questionnaire.

Informal screening was more common than was the use of standardized tools and consisted of “a few questions about manic activity in patients with depression,” Dr. King said. Such information screening may involve questions such as, “Do you go on spending sprees? Do you stay up all night? Do you find yourself having ups and downs, including periods of high irritability, anger, or stress?”

As the use of electronic medical records becomes more widespread, they may help prompt physicians to screen patients for bipolar disorder by offering pop-up information, he said. This represents an opportunity for quality improvement.

“Physicians seem to like the idea that we could offer them quick medical information via the electronic medical record that will give them some quick answers,” he said.

The survey did not include formal interviews, but discussions with the participants have revealed that they prefer referring patients with suspected bipolar disorder to mental health specialists if screening comes up positive, Dr. King said. “Many are willing to comanage the patient, but they first want the diagnosis to be confirmed, typed according to bipolar I or II, with an identification of the phase and recommended medications.”

The study was funded by Delaware Valley Outcomes Research and GE Healthcare as part of a quality improvement project dealing with several medical disorders.

MONTREAL — Primary care physicians are not confident when it comes to diagnosing and managing patients with bipolar depression, according to a cross-sectional survey of providers participating in a national electronic health record database.

Among 85 primary care providers in GE Healthcare's Medical Quality Improvement Consortium, self-rated confidence in managing bipolar disorder averaged 1.7 on a scale of 1 to 5, with 5 being “very confident,” said Dr. Dana King, who presented the findings as a poster at the annual meeting of the North American Primary Care Research Group.

“For other more common disorders such as reflux disease, heart disease, or diabetes, these physicians have more confidence in their ability to sort out complex problems and deal with them. But bipolar disorder is less common and people have less exposure to it during their training,” explained Dr. King, a professor at the Medical University of South Carolina, Charleston.

Of the respondents, 86% had been using electronic health records for 3 or more years, and 94% had access to the Internet from their clinical workstations. At the same time, only 8% had recommended Web site information on bipolar disorder to their patients in the last 3 months.

Although 72% of the respondents said they screened depressed patients for bipolar disorder, 38% reported frequently using a standard screening tool, the most common being the Mood Disorder Questionnaire.

Informal screening was more common than was the use of standardized tools and consisted of “a few questions about manic activity in patients with depression,” Dr. King said. Such information screening may involve questions such as, “Do you go on spending sprees? Do you stay up all night? Do you find yourself having ups and downs, including periods of high irritability, anger, or stress?”

As the use of electronic medical records becomes more widespread, they may help prompt physicians to screen patients for bipolar disorder by offering pop-up information, he said. This represents an opportunity for quality improvement.

“Physicians seem to like the idea that we could offer them quick medical information via the electronic medical record that will give them some quick answers,” he said.

The survey did not include formal interviews, but discussions with the participants have revealed that they prefer referring patients with suspected bipolar disorder to mental health specialists if screening comes up positive, Dr. King said. “Many are willing to comanage the patient, but they first want the diagnosis to be confirmed, typed according to bipolar I or II, with an identification of the phase and recommended medications.”

The study was funded by Delaware Valley Outcomes Research and GE Healthcare as part of a quality improvement project dealing with several medical disorders.