CHICAGO—The VA could save nearly $10,000 annually per patient in the Mountain West region referral area by administering lower-level hematology/oncology care within the system instead of in the community, according to a new analysis.
The findings reflect that the community care encouraged by the MISSION Act is more expensive than US Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) care, said report lead author Alyson Clough, PharmD, a clinical pharmacy specialist with the George E. Wahlen Veterans Affairs Medical Center (VAMC) in Salt Lake City, Utah, in an interview. Clough and colleagues presented the poster at the 2023 annual meeting of the Association of VA Hematology/Oncology.
The 2018 MISSION Act expanded the eligibility for non-VA community services within the VA. “If a veteran requires care that a VA cannot provide in-house, lives in a state/territory without a full-service VAMC, and/or lives further than a certain distance/time from a VA Medical Center, then the veteran may be eligible to receive care in the community,” Clough said.
For the new analysis, the researchers focused on the Salt Lake City VAMC referral area, which spans about 125,000 square miles in Utah, Idaho, and Nevada. “While the MISSION Act helped give those veterans more options for specialty care—including hematology/oncology—many veterans are still driving several hours on a routine basis for chemotherapy treatment and injection therapies, even in the community setting,” Clough explained.
The researchers looked at the costs of “low-risk cancer care,” which Clough said consists of “chemotherapy or immunotherapy that is less likely to cause significant side effects during the infusion, is typically nonhazardous, and/or can be administered via a short infusion [30 minutes or less] or an injection.”
In fiscal year 2022, the VA paid more than $5.7 million for community care services for 380 veterans in the referral area, about $15,060 each, according to the analysis. In contrast, the average cost for 1774 veterans within the VA system was $5424. “By retaining or re-establishing hematology/oncology veteran care within VA, we estimate cost savings of approximately $9636 per unique veteran.”
Specifically, the researchers wrote that the average care costs were $5297 per veteran in the community vs $1143 at the VA, and average drug costs were $9763 per veteran in the community vs $4281 in the VA. These amount to total costs of $15,060 per veteran in the community vs $5424 in the VA.
Low-risk services “are ideal to bring to more isolated regions,” Clough noted. “Traveling and/or finding accommodations for pets can be very difficult for veterans during chemotherapy treatments. Bringing care to the veteran increases veteran convenience, reduces need for transportation, reduces out-of-pocket cost to the veteran, and can improve care coordination.”
It’s not clear why VA care is cheaper than community care, she said, “but it may be related to the [higher] patient volumes we see in our VA facilities.” Lower overhead costs and government pricing contracts for chemotherapies/injectables could also be factors, Clough explained. In an interview, Todd Wagner, PhD, Stanford University Professor in the Department of Surgery and Director of the Health Economics Research Center at the VA, said the analysis needs risk adjustment for cancer severity and other illnesses and comorbidities that could affect cancer treatment. “In our work, sicker veterans get care in VA, and healthier veterans are choosing VA-purchased care [in the community].”