If these screening strategies are deemed feasible by clinicians and patients, then implementation in routine care is needed, lead author Jan Heijdra Suasnabar, MSc, of Leiden University Medical Centre in the Netherlands, and colleagues reported.
courtesy Leiden University
Jan Heijdra Suasnabar
“Cohort studies have shown that CD likely develops early in life and can be easily diagnosed by detection of CD-specific antibodies against the enzyme tissue transglutaminase type 2 (IgA-TG2),” the investigators wrote in Gastroenterology.
Despite the ease of diagnosis, as few as one in five cases of CD are detected using current clinical strategies, meaning many cases are diagnosed years after symptom onset.
“Such high rates of missed/delayed diagnoses have been attributed to CD’s varied and nonspecific symptoms, lack of awareness, and the resource-intensive process necessary to establish the diagnosis,” Heijdra Suasnabar and colleagues wrote. “From an economic perspective, the burden of CD translates into substantial excess healthcare and societal costs.”
These practice gaps prompted the present study, which explored the long-term cost effectiveness of mass CD screening and active case finding among pediatric patients.
The investigators employed a model-based cost-effectiveness analysis with a hypothetical cohort representing all children with CD in the Netherlands. Iterations of this model evaluated long-term costs as these children moved through the healthcare system along various CD detection strategies.
The first strategy was based on the current Dutch approach, which is the same as that in the United States: Patients are only evaluated for CD if they present with symptoms that prompt suspicion of disease. Based on data from population-based studies, the model assumed that approximately one in three cases would be detected using this strategy.
The second strategy involved mass screening using IgA-TG2 point-of-care testing (sensitivity, 0.94; specificity, 0.944) via youth health care clinics, regardless of symptoms.
The third strategy, called “active case finding,” represented something of an intermediate approach, in which children with at least 1 CD-related symptom underwent point-of-care antibody testing.
For both mass screening and active case finding strategies, a positive antibody test was followed with confirmatory diagnostic testing.
Compared with current clinical approach, mass screening added 7.46 more quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs) per CD patient with an increased cost of €28,635 per CD patient. Active case finding gained 4.33 QALYs per CD patient while incurring an additional cost of €15,585 per CD patient.
Based on a willingness-to-pay threshold of €20,000 per QALY, the investigators deemed both strategies “highly cost effective,” compared with current standard of care. Some of these costs were offset by “substantial” reductions in productivity losses, they noted, including CD-related absences from work and school.
“Our results illustrate how an earlier detection of CD through screening or case finding, although more costly, leads to improved health outcomes and a reduction in disease burden, compared with current care,” Heijdra Suasnabar and colleagues wrote.
Their concluding remarks highlighted the conservative scenarios built into their model, and suggested that their findings offer solid evidence for implementing new CD-testing strategies.
“If found to be feasible and acceptable by clinicians and patients, these strategies should be implemented in the Netherlands,” they wrote.This study was supported by the Netherlands Organization for Health Research and Development. The investigators disclosed no conflicts of interest.
