Racial Disparities in Treatment and Survival for Early-Stage Non-Small Cell Lung Cancer: Is Equal Access Health Care System the Answer?

Article Type
Changed
Thu, 12/15/2022 - 14:37

Background

Survival for early-stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) has dramatically improved with advancement in surgical and radiation techniques over last two decades but there exists a disparity for African Americans (AA) having worse overall survival (OS) in recent studies on the general US population. We studied this racial disparity in Veteran population.

Methods

Data for 2589 AA and 14184 Caucasian Veterans diagnosed with early-stage (I, II) NSCLC between 2011-2017 was obtained from the Cancer Cube Registry (VACCR). IRB approval was obtained.

Results

The distribution of newly diagnosed cases of Stage I (73.92% AA vs 74.71% Caucasians) and Stage II (26.07% vs 25.29%) between the two races was comparable (p = .41). More Caucasians were diagnosed above the age of 60 compared to AA (92.22% vs 84.51%, p < .05). More AA were diagnosed with adenocarcinoma at diagnosis (56.01% vs 45.88% Caucasians, p < .05) for both Stage I and II disease. For the limited number of Veterans with reported performance status (PS), similar proportion of patients had a good PS defined as ECOG 0-2 among the two races (93.70% AA vs 93.97% Caucasians, p = .73). There was no statistically significant difference between 5-year OS for AA and Caucasians (69.81% vs 70.78%, p = .33) for both Stage I and II NSCLC. Both groups had similar rate of receipt of surgery as first line treatment or in combination with other treatments (58.90% AA vs 59.07% Caucasians, p = .90). Similarly, the rate of receiving radiation therapy was comparable between AA and Caucasians (42.4% vs 42.3%, p = .96). Although both races showed improved 5-year OS after surgery, there was no statistical difference in survival benefit between AA and Caucasians (69.8% vs 70.8%, p = .33).

 

Conclusion

In contrast to the studies assessing general US population trends, there was no racial disparity for 5-year OS in early-stage NSCLC for the Veteran population. This points to the inequities in access to treatment and preventive healthcare services as a possible contributing cause to the increased mortality in AA in general US population and a more equitable healthcare delivery within the VHA system.

Author and Disclosure Information

Albany Medical Center, Stratton VA Medical Center

Issue
Federal Practitioner - 38(4)s
Publications
Topics
Page Number
S4
Sections
Author and Disclosure Information

Albany Medical Center, Stratton VA Medical Center

Author and Disclosure Information

Albany Medical Center, Stratton VA Medical Center

Background

Survival for early-stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) has dramatically improved with advancement in surgical and radiation techniques over last two decades but there exists a disparity for African Americans (AA) having worse overall survival (OS) in recent studies on the general US population. We studied this racial disparity in Veteran population.

Methods

Data for 2589 AA and 14184 Caucasian Veterans diagnosed with early-stage (I, II) NSCLC between 2011-2017 was obtained from the Cancer Cube Registry (VACCR). IRB approval was obtained.

Results

The distribution of newly diagnosed cases of Stage I (73.92% AA vs 74.71% Caucasians) and Stage II (26.07% vs 25.29%) between the two races was comparable (p = .41). More Caucasians were diagnosed above the age of 60 compared to AA (92.22% vs 84.51%, p < .05). More AA were diagnosed with adenocarcinoma at diagnosis (56.01% vs 45.88% Caucasians, p < .05) for both Stage I and II disease. For the limited number of Veterans with reported performance status (PS), similar proportion of patients had a good PS defined as ECOG 0-2 among the two races (93.70% AA vs 93.97% Caucasians, p = .73). There was no statistically significant difference between 5-year OS for AA and Caucasians (69.81% vs 70.78%, p = .33) for both Stage I and II NSCLC. Both groups had similar rate of receipt of surgery as first line treatment or in combination with other treatments (58.90% AA vs 59.07% Caucasians, p = .90). Similarly, the rate of receiving radiation therapy was comparable between AA and Caucasians (42.4% vs 42.3%, p = .96). Although both races showed improved 5-year OS after surgery, there was no statistical difference in survival benefit between AA and Caucasians (69.8% vs 70.8%, p = .33).

 

Conclusion

In contrast to the studies assessing general US population trends, there was no racial disparity for 5-year OS in early-stage NSCLC for the Veteran population. This points to the inequities in access to treatment and preventive healthcare services as a possible contributing cause to the increased mortality in AA in general US population and a more equitable healthcare delivery within the VHA system.

Background

Survival for early-stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) has dramatically improved with advancement in surgical and radiation techniques over last two decades but there exists a disparity for African Americans (AA) having worse overall survival (OS) in recent studies on the general US population. We studied this racial disparity in Veteran population.

Methods

Data for 2589 AA and 14184 Caucasian Veterans diagnosed with early-stage (I, II) NSCLC between 2011-2017 was obtained from the Cancer Cube Registry (VACCR). IRB approval was obtained.

Results

The distribution of newly diagnosed cases of Stage I (73.92% AA vs 74.71% Caucasians) and Stage II (26.07% vs 25.29%) between the two races was comparable (p = .41). More Caucasians were diagnosed above the age of 60 compared to AA (92.22% vs 84.51%, p < .05). More AA were diagnosed with adenocarcinoma at diagnosis (56.01% vs 45.88% Caucasians, p < .05) for both Stage I and II disease. For the limited number of Veterans with reported performance status (PS), similar proportion of patients had a good PS defined as ECOG 0-2 among the two races (93.70% AA vs 93.97% Caucasians, p = .73). There was no statistically significant difference between 5-year OS for AA and Caucasians (69.81% vs 70.78%, p = .33) for both Stage I and II NSCLC. Both groups had similar rate of receipt of surgery as first line treatment or in combination with other treatments (58.90% AA vs 59.07% Caucasians, p = .90). Similarly, the rate of receiving radiation therapy was comparable between AA and Caucasians (42.4% vs 42.3%, p = .96). Although both races showed improved 5-year OS after surgery, there was no statistical difference in survival benefit between AA and Caucasians (69.8% vs 70.8%, p = .33).

 

Conclusion

In contrast to the studies assessing general US population trends, there was no racial disparity for 5-year OS in early-stage NSCLC for the Veteran population. This points to the inequities in access to treatment and preventive healthcare services as a possible contributing cause to the increased mortality in AA in general US population and a more equitable healthcare delivery within the VHA system.

Issue
Federal Practitioner - 38(4)s
Issue
Federal Practitioner - 38(4)s
Page Number
S4
Page Number
S4
Publications
Publications
Topics
Article Type
Sections
Disallow All Ads
Content Gating
No Gating (article Unlocked/Free)
Alternative CME
Disqus Comments
Default
Gate On Date
Thu, 09/09/2021 - 14:00
Un-Gate On Date
Thu, 09/09/2021 - 14:00
Use ProPublica
CFC Schedule Remove Status
Thu, 09/09/2021 - 14:00
Hide sidebar & use full width
render the right sidebar.
Conference Recap Checkbox
Not Conference Recap
Clinical Edge
Display the Slideshow in this Article
Medscape Article
Display survey writer
Reuters content
Disable Inline Native ads
WebMD Article