Evidence lacking in treatments for pain in MS

SEATTLE – When it comes to pain in patients with multiple sclerosis, two pain specialists offered this advice: Mind the gap. While pain is a major burden in MS, there’s a huge hole in research about the best treatments. That means medical professionals and patients can only rely on a few signposts for navigation.

But the medical literature does offer glimmers of insight into drug treatments, said Brett R. Stacey, MD, and Pamela Stitzlein Davies, MS, ARNP, FAANP, both of the University of Washington, Seattle, in presentations at the annual meeting of the Consortium of Multiple Sclerosis Centers.

An estimated 44%-66% of patients with MS report pain. Their experiences are similar to those of other patients with pain, Dr. Stacey said, although there are some exceptions. Trigeminal neuralgia is not uncommon in patients with MS, and level of pain fluctuates markedly in MS patients.

“There are no [Food and Drug Administration]–approved drugs specifically for painful MS. There are few clinical trials and no first-line evidence about first-choice medicine,” Dr. Stacey said. As a result, he said, all drug options are off-label.

Based on his experience, the best first-line options for pain in MS appear to be the antidepressants duloxetine (Cymbalta), venlafaxine (Effexor), nortriptyline (Pamelor), desipramine (Norpramin), and amitriptyline, as well as the nerve pain drugs pregabalin (Lyrica) and gabapentin.

In regard to antidepressants, “most patients you give these medications to are not going to have a meaningful response. None of them are typically a home run” for pain in MS, Dr. Stacey said.

Duloxetine, he added, is expensive even as a generic, and nausea is possible within the first few days. It’s time to try something else if nausea sticks around for 5 days, he said.

However, there is a special benefit for duloxetine, he said: “For lower back pain, nothing is better. But that doesn’t mean the evidence is fantastic.”

Gabapentin, he said, “is relatively benign in terms of serious adverse effects,” although significant weight gain is possible. “It does not work for pain that doesn’t have a sensitization element. A lot of people throw gabapentin at things for which it will never work.”

Pregabalin, on the other hand, “can be potentially effective when other things like gabapentin and tricyclics have failed,” he said.

Second-line treatments include the lidocaine patch, tramadol, and the capsaicin 8% patch (Qutenza). And third-line treatments include botulinum toxin A and opioids.

Ms. Davies, who focused her presentation on opioids and pain in MS, agreed about the appropriate role of opioids. “They should be considered third-line, fourth-line, fifth-line, further down,” she said. “There’s a limited role for them in pain related to MS,” she said, specifically in regard to neuropathic pain.

There’s very little research into opioids in MS, she added, and their role is limited by side effects and the possibility of overdose.

Another option is low-dose naltrexone (Revia, Vivitrol), a drug used to treat alcohol and drug dependence. “Here in our clinic, patient after patient asks about naltrexone for everything,” Dr. Stacey said.

The treatment requires the use of a compounding pharmacy, he said, and evidence in MS consists of small studies with mixed results.

Dr. Stacey also addressed trigeminal neuralgia, which affects an estimated 5%-10% of patients with MS. For this condition, he said, “everything works less well in MS patients than non-MS patients.” Drug treatments include the seizure/nerve pain medication carbamazepine (Equetro, Carbatrol, Tegretol) and the seizure medication oxcarbazepine (Oxtellar, Trileptal), he said. Surgery is also an option.

SEATTLE – When it comes to pain in patients with multiple sclerosis, two pain specialists offered this advice: Mind the gap. While pain is a major burden in MS, there’s a huge hole in research about the best treatments. That means medical professionals and patients can only rely on a few signposts for navigation.

But the medical literature does offer glimmers of insight into drug treatments, said Brett R. Stacey, MD, and Pamela Stitzlein Davies, MS, ARNP, FAANP, both of the University of Washington, Seattle, in presentations at the annual meeting of the Consortium of Multiple Sclerosis Centers.

An estimated 44%-66% of patients with MS report pain. Their experiences are similar to those of other patients with pain, Dr. Stacey said, although there are some exceptions. Trigeminal neuralgia is not uncommon in patients with MS, and level of pain fluctuates markedly in MS patients.

“There are no [Food and Drug Administration]–approved drugs specifically for painful MS. There are few clinical trials and no first-line evidence about first-choice medicine,” Dr. Stacey said. As a result, he said, all drug options are off-label.

Based on his experience, the best first-line options for pain in MS appear to be the antidepressants duloxetine (Cymbalta), venlafaxine (Effexor), nortriptyline (Pamelor), desipramine (Norpramin), and amitriptyline, as well as the nerve pain drugs pregabalin (Lyrica) and gabapentin.

In regard to antidepressants, “most patients you give these medications to are not going to have a meaningful response. None of them are typically a home run” for pain in MS, Dr. Stacey said.

Duloxetine, he added, is expensive even as a generic, and nausea is possible within the first few days. It’s time to try something else if nausea sticks around for 5 days, he said.

However, there is a special benefit for duloxetine, he said: “For lower back pain, nothing is better. But that doesn’t mean the evidence is fantastic.”

Gabapentin, he said, “is relatively benign in terms of serious adverse effects,” although significant weight gain is possible. “It does not work for pain that doesn’t have a sensitization element. A lot of people throw gabapentin at things for which it will never work.”

Pregabalin, on the other hand, “can be potentially effective when other things like gabapentin and tricyclics have failed,” he said.

Second-line treatments include the lidocaine patch, tramadol, and the capsaicin 8% patch (Qutenza). And third-line treatments include botulinum toxin A and opioids.

Ms. Davies, who focused her presentation on opioids and pain in MS, agreed about the appropriate role of opioids. “They should be considered third-line, fourth-line, fifth-line, further down,” she said. “There’s a limited role for them in pain related to MS,” she said, specifically in regard to neuropathic pain.

There’s very little research into opioids in MS, she added, and their role is limited by side effects and the possibility of overdose.

Another option is low-dose naltrexone (Revia, Vivitrol), a drug used to treat alcohol and drug dependence. “Here in our clinic, patient after patient asks about naltrexone for everything,” Dr. Stacey said.

The treatment requires the use of a compounding pharmacy, he said, and evidence in MS consists of small studies with mixed results.

Dr. Stacey also addressed trigeminal neuralgia, which affects an estimated 5%-10% of patients with MS. For this condition, he said, “everything works less well in MS patients than non-MS patients.” Drug treatments include the seizure/nerve pain medication carbamazepine (Equetro, Carbatrol, Tegretol) and the seizure medication oxcarbazepine (Oxtellar, Trileptal), he said. Surgery is also an option.

SEATTLE – When it comes to pain in patients with multiple sclerosis, two pain specialists offered this advice: Mind the gap. While pain is a major burden in MS, there’s a huge hole in research about the best treatments. That means medical professionals and patients can only rely on a few signposts for navigation.

But the medical literature does offer glimmers of insight into drug treatments, said Brett R. Stacey, MD, and Pamela Stitzlein Davies, MS, ARNP, FAANP, both of the University of Washington, Seattle, in presentations at the annual meeting of the Consortium of Multiple Sclerosis Centers.

An estimated 44%-66% of patients with MS report pain. Their experiences are similar to those of other patients with pain, Dr. Stacey said, although there are some exceptions. Trigeminal neuralgia is not uncommon in patients with MS, and level of pain fluctuates markedly in MS patients.

“There are no [Food and Drug Administration]–approved drugs specifically for painful MS. There are few clinical trials and no first-line evidence about first-choice medicine,” Dr. Stacey said. As a result, he said, all drug options are off-label.

Based on his experience, the best first-line options for pain in MS appear to be the antidepressants duloxetine (Cymbalta), venlafaxine (Effexor), nortriptyline (Pamelor), desipramine (Norpramin), and amitriptyline, as well as the nerve pain drugs pregabalin (Lyrica) and gabapentin.

In regard to antidepressants, “most patients you give these medications to are not going to have a meaningful response. None of them are typically a home run” for pain in MS, Dr. Stacey said.

Duloxetine, he added, is expensive even as a generic, and nausea is possible within the first few days. It’s time to try something else if nausea sticks around for 5 days, he said.

However, there is a special benefit for duloxetine, he said: “For lower back pain, nothing is better. But that doesn’t mean the evidence is fantastic.”

Gabapentin, he said, “is relatively benign in terms of serious adverse effects,” although significant weight gain is possible. “It does not work for pain that doesn’t have a sensitization element. A lot of people throw gabapentin at things for which it will never work.”

Pregabalin, on the other hand, “can be potentially effective when other things like gabapentin and tricyclics have failed,” he said.

Second-line treatments include the lidocaine patch, tramadol, and the capsaicin 8% patch (Qutenza). And third-line treatments include botulinum toxin A and opioids.

Ms. Davies, who focused her presentation on opioids and pain in MS, agreed about the appropriate role of opioids. “They should be considered third-line, fourth-line, fifth-line, further down,” she said. “There’s a limited role for them in pain related to MS,” she said, specifically in regard to neuropathic pain.

There’s very little research into opioids in MS, she added, and their role is limited by side effects and the possibility of overdose.

Another option is low-dose naltrexone (Revia, Vivitrol), a drug used to treat alcohol and drug dependence. “Here in our clinic, patient after patient asks about naltrexone for everything,” Dr. Stacey said.

The treatment requires the use of a compounding pharmacy, he said, and evidence in MS consists of small studies with mixed results.

Dr. Stacey also addressed trigeminal neuralgia, which affects an estimated 5%-10% of patients with MS. For this condition, he said, “everything works less well in MS patients than non-MS patients.” Drug treatments include the seizure/nerve pain medication carbamazepine (Equetro, Carbatrol, Tegretol) and the seizure medication oxcarbazepine (Oxtellar, Trileptal), he said. Surgery is also an option.