User login
LAS VEGAS – Surgical repair of pelvic organ prolapse often may seem like an uncomplicated procedure. But many factors play roles into decisions, and surgeons around the world vary widely in how they handle the operations, Mark D. Walters, MD, told colleagues at the Pelvic Anatomy and Gynecologic Surgery Symposium.
“These prolapse repairs seem relatively simple at first, but they’re not simple at all,” he said.
Questions to ask prior to surgery
It’s important to first answer a number of questions, said Dr. Walters, professor and vice-chair of gynecology at the Cleveland Clinic. “When you see a patient like this, you may not realize how many decisions you’re making.”
These questions include:
- Is the patient sexually active or planning to be?
- Has she had a hysterectomy, and or is one necessary? If so, how should it be done? What does the patient think about a hysterectomy?
- Should the prolapse procedure be performed vaginally, open, laparoscopically, or robotically?
- Is adding a graft advisable? What kind?
- Should there be a sling to prevent stress urinary incontinence?”
Worldwide differences in surgical technique choice
Dr. Walters talked to colleagues from several nations and learned about these variations in surgical techniques.
Chinese surgeons use a variety of techniques with transvaginal mesh (TVM). Their use is more common in more populated cities because of the effect of medical education; native tissue procedures are more common in less-populated regions that are considered “backward.”
TVM with hysteropexy (“apical sling”) also is common in Latin America, while Middle Eastern surgeons have little training in female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery.
In Europe, France embraces mesh surgery and laparoscopy, while the United Kingdom has “completely abandoned” mesh surgery, and the Netherlands rarely uses it in favor of vaginal procedures.
In the United States, he said, TVM is “discouraged” while a variety of other procedures are used.
What procedures should surgeons embrace? There are many topics of debate, Dr. Walters said, including type of transvaginal repair (native tissue or mesh-augmented or sacrocolpopexy?), repair of “defects” in the vagina (even if they’re nonsymptomatic?) and the removal of the uterus (yes or no?).
Dr. Walters pointed to several explanations for this variation, including lack of high-quality research, confirmation bias, economic conflicts – surgeons are in the business of surgery, after all – and lack of insight into what women prefer.
Consider patient choice
In a survey, Dr. Walters polled women in their 50s with this question: “How much do you value your uterus?” Three women, he said, had widely varied opinions on a scale of 1-10, with one at 10 and another at 0.
“A doctor doesn’t know this and doesn’t have a way to ask, and the doctor has [his/her] own opinion about the value of the uterus,” he said. “Shouldn’t we know what patients think?”
How to measure success
He offered these tips about measuring success:
- Focus on symptomatic cure more than clinical cure.
- Remember that perfect anatomic support isn’t linked to health-related quality of life, and some loss of anatomic support is normal.
- Understand that commonly used definitions of anatomic success often aren’t clinically relevant.
Dr. Walters’ disclosures: royalties (Elsevier, UpToDate), website/lecturer (International Academy of Pelvic Surgery), and website editor (Foundation for Female Health Awareness).
This meeting was jointly provided by Global Academy for Medical Education and the University of Cincinnati. Global Academy and this news organization are owned by the same company.
LAS VEGAS – Surgical repair of pelvic organ prolapse often may seem like an uncomplicated procedure. But many factors play roles into decisions, and surgeons around the world vary widely in how they handle the operations, Mark D. Walters, MD, told colleagues at the Pelvic Anatomy and Gynecologic Surgery Symposium.
“These prolapse repairs seem relatively simple at first, but they’re not simple at all,” he said.
Questions to ask prior to surgery
It’s important to first answer a number of questions, said Dr. Walters, professor and vice-chair of gynecology at the Cleveland Clinic. “When you see a patient like this, you may not realize how many decisions you’re making.”
These questions include:
- Is the patient sexually active or planning to be?
- Has she had a hysterectomy, and or is one necessary? If so, how should it be done? What does the patient think about a hysterectomy?
- Should the prolapse procedure be performed vaginally, open, laparoscopically, or robotically?
- Is adding a graft advisable? What kind?
- Should there be a sling to prevent stress urinary incontinence?”
Worldwide differences in surgical technique choice
Dr. Walters talked to colleagues from several nations and learned about these variations in surgical techniques.
Chinese surgeons use a variety of techniques with transvaginal mesh (TVM). Their use is more common in more populated cities because of the effect of medical education; native tissue procedures are more common in less-populated regions that are considered “backward.”
TVM with hysteropexy (“apical sling”) also is common in Latin America, while Middle Eastern surgeons have little training in female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery.
In Europe, France embraces mesh surgery and laparoscopy, while the United Kingdom has “completely abandoned” mesh surgery, and the Netherlands rarely uses it in favor of vaginal procedures.
In the United States, he said, TVM is “discouraged” while a variety of other procedures are used.
What procedures should surgeons embrace? There are many topics of debate, Dr. Walters said, including type of transvaginal repair (native tissue or mesh-augmented or sacrocolpopexy?), repair of “defects” in the vagina (even if they’re nonsymptomatic?) and the removal of the uterus (yes or no?).
Dr. Walters pointed to several explanations for this variation, including lack of high-quality research, confirmation bias, economic conflicts – surgeons are in the business of surgery, after all – and lack of insight into what women prefer.
Consider patient choice
In a survey, Dr. Walters polled women in their 50s with this question: “How much do you value your uterus?” Three women, he said, had widely varied opinions on a scale of 1-10, with one at 10 and another at 0.
“A doctor doesn’t know this and doesn’t have a way to ask, and the doctor has [his/her] own opinion about the value of the uterus,” he said. “Shouldn’t we know what patients think?”
How to measure success
He offered these tips about measuring success:
- Focus on symptomatic cure more than clinical cure.
- Remember that perfect anatomic support isn’t linked to health-related quality of life, and some loss of anatomic support is normal.
- Understand that commonly used definitions of anatomic success often aren’t clinically relevant.
Dr. Walters’ disclosures: royalties (Elsevier, UpToDate), website/lecturer (International Academy of Pelvic Surgery), and website editor (Foundation for Female Health Awareness).
This meeting was jointly provided by Global Academy for Medical Education and the University of Cincinnati. Global Academy and this news organization are owned by the same company.
LAS VEGAS – Surgical repair of pelvic organ prolapse often may seem like an uncomplicated procedure. But many factors play roles into decisions, and surgeons around the world vary widely in how they handle the operations, Mark D. Walters, MD, told colleagues at the Pelvic Anatomy and Gynecologic Surgery Symposium.
“These prolapse repairs seem relatively simple at first, but they’re not simple at all,” he said.
Questions to ask prior to surgery
It’s important to first answer a number of questions, said Dr. Walters, professor and vice-chair of gynecology at the Cleveland Clinic. “When you see a patient like this, you may not realize how many decisions you’re making.”
These questions include:
- Is the patient sexually active or planning to be?
- Has she had a hysterectomy, and or is one necessary? If so, how should it be done? What does the patient think about a hysterectomy?
- Should the prolapse procedure be performed vaginally, open, laparoscopically, or robotically?
- Is adding a graft advisable? What kind?
- Should there be a sling to prevent stress urinary incontinence?”
Worldwide differences in surgical technique choice
Dr. Walters talked to colleagues from several nations and learned about these variations in surgical techniques.
Chinese surgeons use a variety of techniques with transvaginal mesh (TVM). Their use is more common in more populated cities because of the effect of medical education; native tissue procedures are more common in less-populated regions that are considered “backward.”
TVM with hysteropexy (“apical sling”) also is common in Latin America, while Middle Eastern surgeons have little training in female pelvic medicine and reconstructive surgery.
In Europe, France embraces mesh surgery and laparoscopy, while the United Kingdom has “completely abandoned” mesh surgery, and the Netherlands rarely uses it in favor of vaginal procedures.
In the United States, he said, TVM is “discouraged” while a variety of other procedures are used.
What procedures should surgeons embrace? There are many topics of debate, Dr. Walters said, including type of transvaginal repair (native tissue or mesh-augmented or sacrocolpopexy?), repair of “defects” in the vagina (even if they’re nonsymptomatic?) and the removal of the uterus (yes or no?).
Dr. Walters pointed to several explanations for this variation, including lack of high-quality research, confirmation bias, economic conflicts – surgeons are in the business of surgery, after all – and lack of insight into what women prefer.
Consider patient choice
In a survey, Dr. Walters polled women in their 50s with this question: “How much do you value your uterus?” Three women, he said, had widely varied opinions on a scale of 1-10, with one at 10 and another at 0.
“A doctor doesn’t know this and doesn’t have a way to ask, and the doctor has [his/her] own opinion about the value of the uterus,” he said. “Shouldn’t we know what patients think?”
How to measure success
He offered these tips about measuring success:
- Focus on symptomatic cure more than clinical cure.
- Remember that perfect anatomic support isn’t linked to health-related quality of life, and some loss of anatomic support is normal.
- Understand that commonly used definitions of anatomic success often aren’t clinically relevant.
Dr. Walters’ disclosures: royalties (Elsevier, UpToDate), website/lecturer (International Academy of Pelvic Surgery), and website editor (Foundation for Female Health Awareness).
This meeting was jointly provided by Global Academy for Medical Education and the University of Cincinnati. Global Academy and this news organization are owned by the same company.
EXPERT ANALYSIS FROM PAGS 2019