User login
Tread carefully, but do not eliminate them as an option, two experts advise.
SAN DIEGO – Not long before his presentation at Psych Congress 2019, psychiatrist Rakesh Jain, MD, MPH, chatted with a fellow attendee, a nurse practitioner from Tyler, Tex. As Dr. Jain recalled later, his fellow Texan told him that “it’s not unusual to see patients on three benzodiazepines.”
The nurse practitioner “talks to them about how they need to do things differently, and they forget,” Dr. Jain said. “He’s very worried about them.”
Dr. Jain is familiar with the feeling. Like many mental health professionals, he worries about the role of benzodiazepines, which seem to be both widely used and misused. Figuring out their proper place in psychiatry “may require us to raise our game,” said Dr. Jain, of Texas Tech University in Midland.
What to do? Dr. Jain and a colleague offered the same answer – tread carefully, but do not eliminate them as an option – in two separate sessions at the annual Psych Congress.
As Dr. Jain noted, benzodiazepines are popular, and for good reason. “There are many patients, perhaps hundreds of thousands, who are using benzodiazepines chronically, and they’re doing it right. There’s not a CVS in America where benzodiazepines aren’t well stocked. They’re very inexpensive, and the most costly benzodiazepine is still cheaper than Motrin.”
On the other hand, he said, the medications are linked to addiction and physical dependence. “Thirty percent of those who die of opioid overdoses may not have died if they didn’t have benzodiazepines [in their systems].”
In another presentation, psychiatrist Murray B. Stein, MD, MPH, of the University of California at San Diego and VA San Diego Healthcare System, offered these tips about prescribing benzodiazepines for patients with anxiety.
Be very cautious about prescribing as needed
“It’s rarely indicated to prescribe benzodiazepine [as needed] when you’re treating people with anxiety,” he said. “The main reason is patients don’t know when they need it. They take their pills either when they’re so anxious that they’ve already been freaking out for a long time, or they take it when they’re first starting to feel at least a bit anxious. That leads to taking it to prevent being anxious.”
Allow an as-needed approach in certain situations
However, he said, advise patients to try the medication beforehand so they understand its effects. “I’ve had one occasion where I thought we had a dose worked out well. Somebody had to do a work presentation, and he took the medicine and got up in front of the group. He wasn’t anxious at all. But he couldn’t remember a single thing.”
Don’t use them as patients start SSRIs
Patients can get anxious as they start SSRIs, especially for panic disorders, Dr. Stein said. So it might seem reasonable, as some psychiatrists believe, to add benzodiazepines on a short-term basis.
But Dr. Stein said he is not a fan of this approach. As he noted, benzodiazepines are hard to stop. He prefers to help patients understand possible side effects of SSRIs instead, and he emphasized the importance of being available to help patients get through them.
Dr. Jain and Dr. Stein each reported multiple relationships with industry.
Tread carefully, but do not eliminate them as an option, two experts advise.
Tread carefully, but do not eliminate them as an option, two experts advise.
SAN DIEGO – Not long before his presentation at Psych Congress 2019, psychiatrist Rakesh Jain, MD, MPH, chatted with a fellow attendee, a nurse practitioner from Tyler, Tex. As Dr. Jain recalled later, his fellow Texan told him that “it’s not unusual to see patients on three benzodiazepines.”
The nurse practitioner “talks to them about how they need to do things differently, and they forget,” Dr. Jain said. “He’s very worried about them.”
Dr. Jain is familiar with the feeling. Like many mental health professionals, he worries about the role of benzodiazepines, which seem to be both widely used and misused. Figuring out their proper place in psychiatry “may require us to raise our game,” said Dr. Jain, of Texas Tech University in Midland.
What to do? Dr. Jain and a colleague offered the same answer – tread carefully, but do not eliminate them as an option – in two separate sessions at the annual Psych Congress.
As Dr. Jain noted, benzodiazepines are popular, and for good reason. “There are many patients, perhaps hundreds of thousands, who are using benzodiazepines chronically, and they’re doing it right. There’s not a CVS in America where benzodiazepines aren’t well stocked. They’re very inexpensive, and the most costly benzodiazepine is still cheaper than Motrin.”
On the other hand, he said, the medications are linked to addiction and physical dependence. “Thirty percent of those who die of opioid overdoses may not have died if they didn’t have benzodiazepines [in their systems].”
In another presentation, psychiatrist Murray B. Stein, MD, MPH, of the University of California at San Diego and VA San Diego Healthcare System, offered these tips about prescribing benzodiazepines for patients with anxiety.
Be very cautious about prescribing as needed
“It’s rarely indicated to prescribe benzodiazepine [as needed] when you’re treating people with anxiety,” he said. “The main reason is patients don’t know when they need it. They take their pills either when they’re so anxious that they’ve already been freaking out for a long time, or they take it when they’re first starting to feel at least a bit anxious. That leads to taking it to prevent being anxious.”
Allow an as-needed approach in certain situations
However, he said, advise patients to try the medication beforehand so they understand its effects. “I’ve had one occasion where I thought we had a dose worked out well. Somebody had to do a work presentation, and he took the medicine and got up in front of the group. He wasn’t anxious at all. But he couldn’t remember a single thing.”
Don’t use them as patients start SSRIs
Patients can get anxious as they start SSRIs, especially for panic disorders, Dr. Stein said. So it might seem reasonable, as some psychiatrists believe, to add benzodiazepines on a short-term basis.
But Dr. Stein said he is not a fan of this approach. As he noted, benzodiazepines are hard to stop. He prefers to help patients understand possible side effects of SSRIs instead, and he emphasized the importance of being available to help patients get through them.
Dr. Jain and Dr. Stein each reported multiple relationships with industry.
SAN DIEGO – Not long before his presentation at Psych Congress 2019, psychiatrist Rakesh Jain, MD, MPH, chatted with a fellow attendee, a nurse practitioner from Tyler, Tex. As Dr. Jain recalled later, his fellow Texan told him that “it’s not unusual to see patients on three benzodiazepines.”
The nurse practitioner “talks to them about how they need to do things differently, and they forget,” Dr. Jain said. “He’s very worried about them.”
Dr. Jain is familiar with the feeling. Like many mental health professionals, he worries about the role of benzodiazepines, which seem to be both widely used and misused. Figuring out their proper place in psychiatry “may require us to raise our game,” said Dr. Jain, of Texas Tech University in Midland.
What to do? Dr. Jain and a colleague offered the same answer – tread carefully, but do not eliminate them as an option – in two separate sessions at the annual Psych Congress.
As Dr. Jain noted, benzodiazepines are popular, and for good reason. “There are many patients, perhaps hundreds of thousands, who are using benzodiazepines chronically, and they’re doing it right. There’s not a CVS in America where benzodiazepines aren’t well stocked. They’re very inexpensive, and the most costly benzodiazepine is still cheaper than Motrin.”
On the other hand, he said, the medications are linked to addiction and physical dependence. “Thirty percent of those who die of opioid overdoses may not have died if they didn’t have benzodiazepines [in their systems].”
In another presentation, psychiatrist Murray B. Stein, MD, MPH, of the University of California at San Diego and VA San Diego Healthcare System, offered these tips about prescribing benzodiazepines for patients with anxiety.
Be very cautious about prescribing as needed
“It’s rarely indicated to prescribe benzodiazepine [as needed] when you’re treating people with anxiety,” he said. “The main reason is patients don’t know when they need it. They take their pills either when they’re so anxious that they’ve already been freaking out for a long time, or they take it when they’re first starting to feel at least a bit anxious. That leads to taking it to prevent being anxious.”
Allow an as-needed approach in certain situations
However, he said, advise patients to try the medication beforehand so they understand its effects. “I’ve had one occasion where I thought we had a dose worked out well. Somebody had to do a work presentation, and he took the medicine and got up in front of the group. He wasn’t anxious at all. But he couldn’t remember a single thing.”
Don’t use them as patients start SSRIs
Patients can get anxious as they start SSRIs, especially for panic disorders, Dr. Stein said. So it might seem reasonable, as some psychiatrists believe, to add benzodiazepines on a short-term basis.
But Dr. Stein said he is not a fan of this approach. As he noted, benzodiazepines are hard to stop. He prefers to help patients understand possible side effects of SSRIs instead, and he emphasized the importance of being available to help patients get through them.
Dr. Jain and Dr. Stein each reported multiple relationships with industry.
REPORTING FROM PSYCH CONGRESS 2019