Case Reports

One Hundred Case Series of Vocal Cord Dysfunction in a Military Treatment Facility

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

Patient Descriptions

Study patients were referred for a variety of reasons, often from primary care clinics for concerns for asthma, episodic dyspnea, wheezing, or decreased exercise tolerance thought to be related to pulmonary or allergy causes. Pulmonology worked closely with Speech Therapy and referred VCD cases for speech evaluation, including video stroboscopy. Notably, of the patients in this cohort, although some were suspected to have asthma, those patients were ruled out during part of the pulmonology evaluation, both with PFT testing and methacholine challenges. An asthma diagnosis is important in a military treatment facility, as asthma is often grounds for discharge.

Patients ranged in age from 13 to 68 years, with a median age at 31 years diagnosis. Thirty-nine females and 61 males comprised the total case series. Speech Therapy diagnosed 97 patients, 96 were diagnosed at Eglin AFB hospital via stroboscopy. One patient was diagnosed off-base by Speech Therapy via direct visualization, 1 patient was diagnosed by Pulmonology on-base via direct visualization, and 2 patients were diagnosed by ENT on-base via direct visualization. These patients had direct laryngoscopy completed, often to rule out other organic causes for upper airway disease processes, and were found to have visual paradoxical vocal cord movement. Ninety-eight patients completed PFTs. Several patients were lost to follow-up, as can be common in a military population with frequent moves or members leaving service.

On record review, patient symptoms were present in the range of 2 months to 20 years, with a median duration of symptomatic reports lasting 2 years prior to diagnosis. Common diagnoses prior to visual VCD diagnosis included asthma, exercise-induced asthma, anxiety, and episodic wheezing. Risk factors that were evaluated in this case series included age, sex, body mass index (BMI), GERD, allergic rhinitis, postnasal drip, active smoker, previous smoker, and mental health diagnoses (Figure 4).

Pulmonary function test results were analyzed on 98 patients, including forced expiratory volume in 1 second (FEV1); forced vital capacity (FVC), FEV1/FVC ratio; peak inspiratory flow (PIF) and peak expiratory flow (PEF)—available in 97 studies; forced expiratory flow (FEF) at 25% to 75% of FVC (FEF 25%-75%)—available in 96 studies; and maximum voluntary ventilation (MVV) and MVV/FEV1 ratio—available in 60 of 98 PFTs.

Interventions

All patients diagnosed by Speech Therapy on-base were provided with laryngeal relaxation techniques, diaphragmatic breathing techniques, and controlled inhale/exhale techniques at time of diagnosis, with frequent follow-up scheduled with Speech Therapy and Pulmonology. All diagnoses potentially contributing to laryngeal irritation were treated, including GERD, allergic rhinitis, smoking cessation, weight loss, and exercise recommendations as needed.

Patients reported improvement on follow-up appointments with Speech Therapy in overall control of symptoms, subjectively categorized as poor improvement, partial improvement, and complete improvement. This was a subjective measurement of improvement and fully dependent on follow-up care and patient reporting for improvement. No predefined number of follow-ups was determined; patients were followed monthly until they declined further care, fully improved, moved out of the military treatment system, or were lost to follow-up.

Treatment included structured Speech Therapy sessions. Response to treatment was subjectively qualified by patient report. Fifteen patients reported complete resolution of symptoms, 57 reported partial improvement, 24 reported poor improvement, and 4 patients were lost to follow-up.

Results

Risk factors for the diagnosis of VCD included possible associations with GERD, allergic rhinitis, smoking, prior smoking, BMI, and mental health diagnoses. Body mass index ranged from 17 to 36 in the case series, with median BMI of 27. Mental health diagnoses were present in 35 patients and included diagnoses of anxiety, depression, and adjustment disorders. Gastroesophageal reflux disease diagnosis was present in 59 of the case series patients, 80 had the diagnosis of allergic rhinitis, 63 were diagnosed with postnasal drip. Sixteen case series patients were current smokers. An additional 26 were previous smokers (at least 100 cigarettes in lifetime) for a total of 42 patients that were current or prior smokers.

The chart review was completed to evaluate for the presence of these diagnoses, which included previous treatments; for example, proton pump inhibitors for GERD, antidepressants for depression, or intranasal steroids for allergic rhinitis. The diagnosis was counted as present if the patient was currently being treated for the particular diagnosis in question.

PFT Data

Data from PFTs were available for 98 of 100 cases diagnosed. Review of data across all 98 patients is noted for median FEV1 of 3.6, a median FVC of 4.5, with ratio of 0.80.

The median PIF was 5.1, and median PEF was 8.2, with a PIF/PEF ratio of 0.62. Mid-flow volumes also were analyzed, and FEF 25% to 75% median was 3.3. For the 60 patients that had minute ventilator volumes calculated, the median MVV was 118.5 L/min and median MVV/FEV1 was 32.0 (Table).

Pages

Recommended Reading

Allergic Reaction to Phenylephrine
Federal Practitioner
The Rural-Urban Gap in Mortality
Federal Practitioner
Ginseng Derivatives May Protect Against Flu
Federal Practitioner
HHS Funds More Health Centers
Federal Practitioner
Paid Sick Days Help Reduce Flu Exposure (For Some)
Federal Practitioner
Medication Adherence and Operating Room Efficiency for a Surgical Subspecialty
Federal Practitioner
Odontogenic Sinusitis
Federal Practitioner
A Faster Way to Diagnose Cushing Syndrome
Federal Practitioner
Hearing Loss in People With Good Hearing
Federal Practitioner
March 2017 Digital Edition
Federal Practitioner