User login
Much has been written about how we clinicians should respond when one of these patients presents in our office. Obviously, we start with a good history and physical exam and then progress to whatever laboratory or imaging tests we believe will yield the most accurate diagnosis in the shortest amount of time and with the minimum risk to the patient.
However, the number of children complaining of abdominal pain who arrive at clinicians’ offices is but a mere fraction of the youngsters who have shared the complaint with their parents or caregivers. Little has been written about what is going on beneath the surface of this monstrous iceberg of pediatric abdominal pain.
A recent poll commissioned by C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital at the University of Michigan attempts to determine how Doctor Moms and Dads are handling their children’s belly pain complaints on what is truly the frontline of health care. Using a national panel of more than 2,000 parents, the investigators reviewed the responses of more than 1,000 individuals who had at least one child age 3-10.
Seventeen percent of the parents reported that their children complained of abdominal pain at least once a month. Only a bit more than 50% of these parents say they have discussed this frequent pain with their children’s providers. Less than a third of parents reported their children complain of abdominal pain only a few times a year and half the parents responded that their children rarely or never complained of a bellyache.
The survey drilled a little deeper and discovered that for the most part, parents took a thoughtful history and did a reasonably focused physical exam. More than a third of respondents felt “very confident” in their ability to recognize a serious problem. A third of parents reported that they would treat the symptoms with an over-the-counter product.
About a quarter of the parents attributed their children’s complaints to anxiety or to gain attention. In these situations, more than half of the parents said they would talk to the child about his/her concerns and/or suggest relaxation techniques or employ distraction. Only a few would allow the child to stay home from school or miss other activities. In general, it feels like Dr. Moms and Dads in the trenches are doing a pretty good job evaluating, triaging, and managing most children with abdominal pain. At least in my experience, unfortunate outcomes of pediatric abdominal pain as the result of home mismanagement are rare.
This is a nice little survey, but I don’t think it tells us much we haven’t already suspected. What we really want to know more about are those exceedingly rare but avoidable situations when parents have not managed their children’s belly pain well and the results have been tragic. Why did they wait so long to call the physician? What signs did they miss? What symptoms did they ignore or discount? Are there patterns we can better address with education?
Just as in cases of Sudden Unexplained Infant Death, investigating with sensitivity can be extremely difficult. Interviewing parents who are still processing the unexpected death of their child is something that must be done without the slightest hint of assessing blame. Sometimes that is just plain impossible. Fortunately, these cases are rare.
If we are considering launching the study that I have proposed, we must also embark on a parallel study that asks what are the systemic conditions that may have led to the tragic mismanagement of pediatric abdominal pain? When parents have been alert to children’s complaints and appearance and attempted to seek medical care, what impediments did they encounter? Was there a triage nurse or on call physician who didn’t listen, or failed to ask the right questions? Was the emergency room just too busy to allow a proper evaluation? Was there a communication problem? And, of course, there is always the money. Did the parents’ concern about paying for the evaluation blind them to their instinct to call? These are not easy questions to ask ourselves but they must be asked if we wish to bring our failure rate closer to zero and retain the trust of our patients.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at pdnews@mdedge.com.
Much has been written about how we clinicians should respond when one of these patients presents in our office. Obviously, we start with a good history and physical exam and then progress to whatever laboratory or imaging tests we believe will yield the most accurate diagnosis in the shortest amount of time and with the minimum risk to the patient.
However, the number of children complaining of abdominal pain who arrive at clinicians’ offices is but a mere fraction of the youngsters who have shared the complaint with their parents or caregivers. Little has been written about what is going on beneath the surface of this monstrous iceberg of pediatric abdominal pain.
A recent poll commissioned by C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital at the University of Michigan attempts to determine how Doctor Moms and Dads are handling their children’s belly pain complaints on what is truly the frontline of health care. Using a national panel of more than 2,000 parents, the investigators reviewed the responses of more than 1,000 individuals who had at least one child age 3-10.
Seventeen percent of the parents reported that their children complained of abdominal pain at least once a month. Only a bit more than 50% of these parents say they have discussed this frequent pain with their children’s providers. Less than a third of parents reported their children complain of abdominal pain only a few times a year and half the parents responded that their children rarely or never complained of a bellyache.
The survey drilled a little deeper and discovered that for the most part, parents took a thoughtful history and did a reasonably focused physical exam. More than a third of respondents felt “very confident” in their ability to recognize a serious problem. A third of parents reported that they would treat the symptoms with an over-the-counter product.
About a quarter of the parents attributed their children’s complaints to anxiety or to gain attention. In these situations, more than half of the parents said they would talk to the child about his/her concerns and/or suggest relaxation techniques or employ distraction. Only a few would allow the child to stay home from school or miss other activities. In general, it feels like Dr. Moms and Dads in the trenches are doing a pretty good job evaluating, triaging, and managing most children with abdominal pain. At least in my experience, unfortunate outcomes of pediatric abdominal pain as the result of home mismanagement are rare.
This is a nice little survey, but I don’t think it tells us much we haven’t already suspected. What we really want to know more about are those exceedingly rare but avoidable situations when parents have not managed their children’s belly pain well and the results have been tragic. Why did they wait so long to call the physician? What signs did they miss? What symptoms did they ignore or discount? Are there patterns we can better address with education?
Just as in cases of Sudden Unexplained Infant Death, investigating with sensitivity can be extremely difficult. Interviewing parents who are still processing the unexpected death of their child is something that must be done without the slightest hint of assessing blame. Sometimes that is just plain impossible. Fortunately, these cases are rare.
If we are considering launching the study that I have proposed, we must also embark on a parallel study that asks what are the systemic conditions that may have led to the tragic mismanagement of pediatric abdominal pain? When parents have been alert to children’s complaints and appearance and attempted to seek medical care, what impediments did they encounter? Was there a triage nurse or on call physician who didn’t listen, or failed to ask the right questions? Was the emergency room just too busy to allow a proper evaluation? Was there a communication problem? And, of course, there is always the money. Did the parents’ concern about paying for the evaluation blind them to their instinct to call? These are not easy questions to ask ourselves but they must be asked if we wish to bring our failure rate closer to zero and retain the trust of our patients.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at pdnews@mdedge.com.
Much has been written about how we clinicians should respond when one of these patients presents in our office. Obviously, we start with a good history and physical exam and then progress to whatever laboratory or imaging tests we believe will yield the most accurate diagnosis in the shortest amount of time and with the minimum risk to the patient.
However, the number of children complaining of abdominal pain who arrive at clinicians’ offices is but a mere fraction of the youngsters who have shared the complaint with their parents or caregivers. Little has been written about what is going on beneath the surface of this monstrous iceberg of pediatric abdominal pain.
A recent poll commissioned by C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital at the University of Michigan attempts to determine how Doctor Moms and Dads are handling their children’s belly pain complaints on what is truly the frontline of health care. Using a national panel of more than 2,000 parents, the investigators reviewed the responses of more than 1,000 individuals who had at least one child age 3-10.
Seventeen percent of the parents reported that their children complained of abdominal pain at least once a month. Only a bit more than 50% of these parents say they have discussed this frequent pain with their children’s providers. Less than a third of parents reported their children complain of abdominal pain only a few times a year and half the parents responded that their children rarely or never complained of a bellyache.
The survey drilled a little deeper and discovered that for the most part, parents took a thoughtful history and did a reasonably focused physical exam. More than a third of respondents felt “very confident” in their ability to recognize a serious problem. A third of parents reported that they would treat the symptoms with an over-the-counter product.
About a quarter of the parents attributed their children’s complaints to anxiety or to gain attention. In these situations, more than half of the parents said they would talk to the child about his/her concerns and/or suggest relaxation techniques or employ distraction. Only a few would allow the child to stay home from school or miss other activities. In general, it feels like Dr. Moms and Dads in the trenches are doing a pretty good job evaluating, triaging, and managing most children with abdominal pain. At least in my experience, unfortunate outcomes of pediatric abdominal pain as the result of home mismanagement are rare.
This is a nice little survey, but I don’t think it tells us much we haven’t already suspected. What we really want to know more about are those exceedingly rare but avoidable situations when parents have not managed their children’s belly pain well and the results have been tragic. Why did they wait so long to call the physician? What signs did they miss? What symptoms did they ignore or discount? Are there patterns we can better address with education?
Just as in cases of Sudden Unexplained Infant Death, investigating with sensitivity can be extremely difficult. Interviewing parents who are still processing the unexpected death of their child is something that must be done without the slightest hint of assessing blame. Sometimes that is just plain impossible. Fortunately, these cases are rare.
If we are considering launching the study that I have proposed, we must also embark on a parallel study that asks what are the systemic conditions that may have led to the tragic mismanagement of pediatric abdominal pain? When parents have been alert to children’s complaints and appearance and attempted to seek medical care, what impediments did they encounter? Was there a triage nurse or on call physician who didn’t listen, or failed to ask the right questions? Was the emergency room just too busy to allow a proper evaluation? Was there a communication problem? And, of course, there is always the money. Did the parents’ concern about paying for the evaluation blind them to their instinct to call? These are not easy questions to ask ourselves but they must be asked if we wish to bring our failure rate closer to zero and retain the trust of our patients.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics, including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.” Other than a Littman stethoscope he accepted as a first-year medical student in 1966, Dr. Wilkoff reports having nothing to disclose. Email him at pdnews@mdedge.com.