Anne-Gaëlle Moulun

A significant quantity of dysfunctional monocytes appears to indicate poor cardiovascular prognosis in patients with type 2 diabetes, according to a new publication. Nicolas Venteclef, PhD, director of an Inserm institute for diabetes research at Necker Enfants Malades Hospital in Paris, France, led the research.

Quantifying Inflammation

Patients with type 2 diabetes have about twice the risk for a cardiovascular event associated with atherosclerosis, such as a heart attack or stroke, during their lifetimes. “Predicting these complications in diabetic patients is usually very difficult,” Dr. Venteclef told this news organization.

“They are strongly associated with inflammation in these patients. Therefore, we sought to quantify this inflammation in the blood.” To do this, his team focused on monocytes, a category of white blood cells circulating in the blood. They measured the blood concentration of monocytes and the subtypes present in patients with type 2 diabetes.

The results were published in Circulation Research.
 

Dysfunctional Monocytes

The team worked with three cohorts of patients. The first, named AngioSafe-2, consisting of 672 patients with type 2 diabetes, was recruited from the diabetology departments of Lariboisière and Bichat Claude Bernard hospitals in France. This cohort allowed researchers to demonstrate that the higher the number of circulating monocytes, the greater the risk for cardiovascular events, independent of age and duration of diabetes. This observation was confirmed through a second cohort, GLUTADIAB, that comprised 279 patients with type 2 diabetes. Scientists complemented their work with molecular analysis of circulating monocytes in these two cohorts, which revealed certain predominant monocyte subtypes in patients with type 2 diabetes at high cardiovascular risk. “These monocytes are dysfunctional because they have a mitochondrial problem,” Dr. Venteclef explained.

To better understand how these results could be used to predict cardiovascular risk, the team collaborated with colleagues from the University Hospital of Nantes on a cohort called SURDIAGENE, which included 757 patients with type 2 diabetes. “We conducted a longitudinal study by following these patients for 10 years and quantifying cardiovascular events and deaths,” said Dr. Venteclef. Circulating monocyte levels were correlated with the occurrence of heart attacks or strokes. The researchers observed that patients with type 2 diabetes with a monocyte count above a certain threshold (0.5 × 109/L) had a five- to seven-times higher risk for cardiovascular events over 10 years than those with a monocyte count below this threshold.

A patent was filed at the end of 2023 to protect this discovery. “Our next step is to develop a sensor to quantify monocytes more easily and avoid blood draws,” said Dr. Venteclef. “As part of a European project, we will also launch a trial with an anti-inflammatory drug in diabetics, with the hope of interrupting the inflammatory trajectory and preventing complications.”
 

This story was translated from the Medscape French edition using several editorial tools, including AI, as part of the process. Human editors reviewed this content before publication. A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

A significant quantity of dysfunctional monocytes appears to indicate poor cardiovascular prognosis in patients with type 2 diabetes, according to a new publication. Nicolas Venteclef, PhD, director of an Inserm institute for diabetes research at Necker Enfants Malades Hospital in Paris, France, led the research.

Quantifying Inflammation

Patients with type 2 diabetes have about twice the risk for a cardiovascular event associated with atherosclerosis, such as a heart attack or stroke, during their lifetimes. “Predicting these complications in diabetic patients is usually very difficult,” Dr. Venteclef told this news organization.

“They are strongly associated with inflammation in these patients. Therefore, we sought to quantify this inflammation in the blood.” To do this, his team focused on monocytes, a category of white blood cells circulating in the blood. They measured the blood concentration of monocytes and the subtypes present in patients with type 2 diabetes.

The results were published in Circulation Research.
 

Dysfunctional Monocytes

The team worked with three cohorts of patients. The first, named AngioSafe-2, consisting of 672 patients with type 2 diabetes, was recruited from the diabetology departments of Lariboisière and Bichat Claude Bernard hospitals in France. This cohort allowed researchers to demonstrate that the higher the number of circulating monocytes, the greater the risk for cardiovascular events, independent of age and duration of diabetes. This observation was confirmed through a second cohort, GLUTADIAB, that comprised 279 patients with type 2 diabetes. Scientists complemented their work with molecular analysis of circulating monocytes in these two cohorts, which revealed certain predominant monocyte subtypes in patients with type 2 diabetes at high cardiovascular risk. “These monocytes are dysfunctional because they have a mitochondrial problem,” Dr. Venteclef explained.

To better understand how these results could be used to predict cardiovascular risk, the team collaborated with colleagues from the University Hospital of Nantes on a cohort called SURDIAGENE, which included 757 patients with type 2 diabetes. “We conducted a longitudinal study by following these patients for 10 years and quantifying cardiovascular events and deaths,” said Dr. Venteclef. Circulating monocyte levels were correlated with the occurrence of heart attacks or strokes. The researchers observed that patients with type 2 diabetes with a monocyte count above a certain threshold (0.5 × 109/L) had a five- to seven-times higher risk for cardiovascular events over 10 years than those with a monocyte count below this threshold.

A patent was filed at the end of 2023 to protect this discovery. “Our next step is to develop a sensor to quantify monocytes more easily and avoid blood draws,” said Dr. Venteclef. “As part of a European project, we will also launch a trial with an anti-inflammatory drug in diabetics, with the hope of interrupting the inflammatory trajectory and preventing complications.”
 

This story was translated from the Medscape French edition using several editorial tools, including AI, as part of the process. Human editors reviewed this content before publication. A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

A significant quantity of dysfunctional monocytes appears to indicate poor cardiovascular prognosis in patients with type 2 diabetes, according to a new publication. Nicolas Venteclef, PhD, director of an Inserm institute for diabetes research at Necker Enfants Malades Hospital in Paris, France, led the research.

Quantifying Inflammation

Patients with type 2 diabetes have about twice the risk for a cardiovascular event associated with atherosclerosis, such as a heart attack or stroke, during their lifetimes. “Predicting these complications in diabetic patients is usually very difficult,” Dr. Venteclef told this news organization.

“They are strongly associated with inflammation in these patients. Therefore, we sought to quantify this inflammation in the blood.” To do this, his team focused on monocytes, a category of white blood cells circulating in the blood. They measured the blood concentration of monocytes and the subtypes present in patients with type 2 diabetes.

The results were published in Circulation Research.
 

Dysfunctional Monocytes

The team worked with three cohorts of patients. The first, named AngioSafe-2, consisting of 672 patients with type 2 diabetes, was recruited from the diabetology departments of Lariboisière and Bichat Claude Bernard hospitals in France. This cohort allowed researchers to demonstrate that the higher the number of circulating monocytes, the greater the risk for cardiovascular events, independent of age and duration of diabetes. This observation was confirmed through a second cohort, GLUTADIAB, that comprised 279 patients with type 2 diabetes. Scientists complemented their work with molecular analysis of circulating monocytes in these two cohorts, which revealed certain predominant monocyte subtypes in patients with type 2 diabetes at high cardiovascular risk. “These monocytes are dysfunctional because they have a mitochondrial problem,” Dr. Venteclef explained.

To better understand how these results could be used to predict cardiovascular risk, the team collaborated with colleagues from the University Hospital of Nantes on a cohort called SURDIAGENE, which included 757 patients with type 2 diabetes. “We conducted a longitudinal study by following these patients for 10 years and quantifying cardiovascular events and deaths,” said Dr. Venteclef. Circulating monocyte levels were correlated with the occurrence of heart attacks or strokes. The researchers observed that patients with type 2 diabetes with a monocyte count above a certain threshold (0.5 × 109/L) had a five- to seven-times higher risk for cardiovascular events over 10 years than those with a monocyte count below this threshold.

A patent was filed at the end of 2023 to protect this discovery. “Our next step is to develop a sensor to quantify monocytes more easily and avoid blood draws,” said Dr. Venteclef. “As part of a European project, we will also launch a trial with an anti-inflammatory drug in diabetics, with the hope of interrupting the inflammatory trajectory and preventing complications.”
 

This story was translated from the Medscape French edition using several editorial tools, including AI, as part of the process. Human editors reviewed this content before publication. A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Investigators from the French Health and Medical Research Institute (INSERM), University of Bordeaux, and Charles Perrens Hospital, alongside their Canadian, British, and Swedish counterparts, have shown that attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) or attention-deficit disorder without hyperactivity is linked with physical health problems. Cédric Galéra, MD, PhD, child and adolescent psychiatrist and epidemiologist at the Bordeaux Population Health Research Center (INSERM/University of Bordeaux) and the Charles Perrens Hospital, explained these findings to this news organization.
 

A Bilateral Association 

ADHD is a neurodevelopmental condition that develops in childhood and is characterized by high levels of inattention or agitation and impulsiveness. Some studies have revealed a link between ADHD and medical comorbidities, but these studies were carried out on small patient samples and were cross-sectional.

A new longitudinal study published in Lancet Child and Adolescent Health has shown a reciprocal link between ADHD and physical health problems. The researchers conducted statistical analyses to measure the links between ADHD symptoms and subsequent development of certain physical conditions and, conversely, between physical problems during childhood and subsequent development of ADHD symptoms.
 

Children From Quebec

The study was conducted by a team headed by Dr. Galéra in collaboration with teams from Britain, Sweden, and Canada. “We studied a Quebec-based cohort of 2000 children aged between 5 months and 17 years,” said Dr. Galéra.

“The researchers in Quebec sent interviewers to question parents at home. And once the children were able to answer for themselves, from adolescence, they were asked to answer the questions directly,” he added.

The children were assessed on the severity of their ADHD symptoms as well as their physical condition (general well-being, any conditions diagnosed, etc.).
 

Dental Caries, Excess Weight

“We were able to show links between ADHD in childhood and physical health problems in adolescence. There is a greater risk for dental caries, infections, injuries, wounds, sleep disorders, and excess weight.

“Accounting for socioeconomic status and mental health problems such as anxiety and depression or medical treatments, we observed that dental caries, wounds, excess weight, and restless legs syndrome were the conditions that cropped up time and time again,” said Dr. Galéra.

On the other hand, the researchers noted that certain physical health issues in childhood were linked with the onset of ADHD at a later stage. “We discovered that asthma in early childhood, injuries, sleep disturbances, epilepsy, and excess weight were associated with ADHD. Taking all above-referenced features into account, we were left with just wounds and injuries as well as restless legs syndrome as being linked to ADHD,” Dr. Galéra concluded.

For Dr. Galéra, the study illustrates the direction and timing of the links between physical problems and ADHD. “This reflects the link between physical and mental health. It’s important that all healthcare professionals be alert to this. Psychiatrists and mental health professionals must be vigilant about the physical health risks, and pediatricians and family physicians must be aware of the fact that children can present with physical conditions that will later be linked with ADHD. Each of them must be able to refer their young patients to their medical colleagues to ensure that these people receive the best care,” he emphasized.

The team will continue to study this cohort to see which problems emerge in adulthood. They also wish to study the Elfe cohort, a French longitudinal study of children.

This article was translated from the Medscape French edition. A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Investigators from the French Health and Medical Research Institute (INSERM), University of Bordeaux, and Charles Perrens Hospital, alongside their Canadian, British, and Swedish counterparts, have shown that attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) or attention-deficit disorder without hyperactivity is linked with physical health problems. Cédric Galéra, MD, PhD, child and adolescent psychiatrist and epidemiologist at the Bordeaux Population Health Research Center (INSERM/University of Bordeaux) and the Charles Perrens Hospital, explained these findings to this news organization.
 

A Bilateral Association 

ADHD is a neurodevelopmental condition that develops in childhood and is characterized by high levels of inattention or agitation and impulsiveness. Some studies have revealed a link between ADHD and medical comorbidities, but these studies were carried out on small patient samples and were cross-sectional.

A new longitudinal study published in Lancet Child and Adolescent Health has shown a reciprocal link between ADHD and physical health problems. The researchers conducted statistical analyses to measure the links between ADHD symptoms and subsequent development of certain physical conditions and, conversely, between physical problems during childhood and subsequent development of ADHD symptoms.
 

Children From Quebec

The study was conducted by a team headed by Dr. Galéra in collaboration with teams from Britain, Sweden, and Canada. “We studied a Quebec-based cohort of 2000 children aged between 5 months and 17 years,” said Dr. Galéra.

“The researchers in Quebec sent interviewers to question parents at home. And once the children were able to answer for themselves, from adolescence, they were asked to answer the questions directly,” he added.

The children were assessed on the severity of their ADHD symptoms as well as their physical condition (general well-being, any conditions diagnosed, etc.).
 

Dental Caries, Excess Weight

“We were able to show links between ADHD in childhood and physical health problems in adolescence. There is a greater risk for dental caries, infections, injuries, wounds, sleep disorders, and excess weight.

“Accounting for socioeconomic status and mental health problems such as anxiety and depression or medical treatments, we observed that dental caries, wounds, excess weight, and restless legs syndrome were the conditions that cropped up time and time again,” said Dr. Galéra.

On the other hand, the researchers noted that certain physical health issues in childhood were linked with the onset of ADHD at a later stage. “We discovered that asthma in early childhood, injuries, sleep disturbances, epilepsy, and excess weight were associated with ADHD. Taking all above-referenced features into account, we were left with just wounds and injuries as well as restless legs syndrome as being linked to ADHD,” Dr. Galéra concluded.

For Dr. Galéra, the study illustrates the direction and timing of the links between physical problems and ADHD. “This reflects the link between physical and mental health. It’s important that all healthcare professionals be alert to this. Psychiatrists and mental health professionals must be vigilant about the physical health risks, and pediatricians and family physicians must be aware of the fact that children can present with physical conditions that will later be linked with ADHD. Each of them must be able to refer their young patients to their medical colleagues to ensure that these people receive the best care,” he emphasized.

The team will continue to study this cohort to see which problems emerge in adulthood. They also wish to study the Elfe cohort, a French longitudinal study of children.

This article was translated from the Medscape French edition. A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Investigators from the French Health and Medical Research Institute (INSERM), University of Bordeaux, and Charles Perrens Hospital, alongside their Canadian, British, and Swedish counterparts, have shown that attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) or attention-deficit disorder without hyperactivity is linked with physical health problems. Cédric Galéra, MD, PhD, child and adolescent psychiatrist and epidemiologist at the Bordeaux Population Health Research Center (INSERM/University of Bordeaux) and the Charles Perrens Hospital, explained these findings to this news organization.
 

A Bilateral Association 

ADHD is a neurodevelopmental condition that develops in childhood and is characterized by high levels of inattention or agitation and impulsiveness. Some studies have revealed a link between ADHD and medical comorbidities, but these studies were carried out on small patient samples and were cross-sectional.

A new longitudinal study published in Lancet Child and Adolescent Health has shown a reciprocal link between ADHD and physical health problems. The researchers conducted statistical analyses to measure the links between ADHD symptoms and subsequent development of certain physical conditions and, conversely, between physical problems during childhood and subsequent development of ADHD symptoms.
 

Children From Quebec

The study was conducted by a team headed by Dr. Galéra in collaboration with teams from Britain, Sweden, and Canada. “We studied a Quebec-based cohort of 2000 children aged between 5 months and 17 years,” said Dr. Galéra.

“The researchers in Quebec sent interviewers to question parents at home. And once the children were able to answer for themselves, from adolescence, they were asked to answer the questions directly,” he added.

The children were assessed on the severity of their ADHD symptoms as well as their physical condition (general well-being, any conditions diagnosed, etc.).
 

Dental Caries, Excess Weight

“We were able to show links between ADHD in childhood and physical health problems in adolescence. There is a greater risk for dental caries, infections, injuries, wounds, sleep disorders, and excess weight.

“Accounting for socioeconomic status and mental health problems such as anxiety and depression or medical treatments, we observed that dental caries, wounds, excess weight, and restless legs syndrome were the conditions that cropped up time and time again,” said Dr. Galéra.

On the other hand, the researchers noted that certain physical health issues in childhood were linked with the onset of ADHD at a later stage. “We discovered that asthma in early childhood, injuries, sleep disturbances, epilepsy, and excess weight were associated with ADHD. Taking all above-referenced features into account, we were left with just wounds and injuries as well as restless legs syndrome as being linked to ADHD,” Dr. Galéra concluded.

For Dr. Galéra, the study illustrates the direction and timing of the links between physical problems and ADHD. “This reflects the link between physical and mental health. It’s important that all healthcare professionals be alert to this. Psychiatrists and mental health professionals must be vigilant about the physical health risks, and pediatricians and family physicians must be aware of the fact that children can present with physical conditions that will later be linked with ADHD. Each of them must be able to refer their young patients to their medical colleagues to ensure that these people receive the best care,” he emphasized.

The team will continue to study this cohort to see which problems emerge in adulthood. They also wish to study the Elfe cohort, a French longitudinal study of children.

This article was translated from the Medscape French edition. A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com.

Essure implants arrived on the market in 2002 as permanent contraception for women older than age 45 years with children. They were recalled in 2017. Presented as an alternative to laparoscopic tubal ligation, this medical device resulted in rare side effects affecting thousands of women, most notably the nervous system, cardiovascular system, endocrine system, and musculoskeletal system.

Implant analysis protocol

A team from Lyon, France, studied the wear debris from these medical devices and their possible toxic health effects. They discovered that tin could be the cause of the implant’s toxicity. “My research focuses on a variety of medical devices, mostly joint replacements, and more specifically, hip replacements. I look at how these materials behave in humans and how the wear debris affects the body,” explained Ana Maria Trunfio-Sfarghiu, bioengineering expert and research associate with the French National Center for Scientific Research at the Lyon National Institute of Applied Sciences’ Contact and Structure Mechanics Laboratory.

“The problems with Essure implants started with a woman who had been using one for about 10 years and was experiencing side effects such as trouble concentrating and focusing, significant vaginal bleeding, extreme tiredness, hair loss, etc. She had the implant removed, and we retrieved it from her gynecologist and analyzed it alongside other implants,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

“Together with the hospital, we set up an implant analysis protocol. We visited hospital teams to demonstrate how to prepare the biopsies, embedded in paraffin blocks, before sending them to us for analysis. We gave the same specimen preparation instructions for all subjects,” Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu explained.

After a year of clinical analysis, the Journal of Trace Elements in Medicine and Biology published an article about 18 cases.
 

Implant weld corrosion

The Essure implant measures a few centimeters long and resembles a small spring. Once it is released inside the fallopian tube, its goal is to create inflammation and block the tube. It triggers fibrosis, which prevents the sperm from reaching the egg. Premarketing tests had shown that the fibrosis surrounding the implant would keep it from moving. However, the pharmaceutical company hadn’t assessed the mechanical integrity of the spring weld, which was made of silver-tin.

During their analysis in collaboration with the Minapath laboratory, Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu’s team found that the weld had corroded and that tin particles had been released into the subjects’ bodies. “The study included about 40 women, and we found tin in all of them,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

This weld corrosion has several possible consequences. “When the implant degrades, it can travel anywhere in the pelvis, like a needle moving through the body with no apparent destination. The surgeons who operate to remove it describe similar surgeries in military medicine when the patient has been hit by a bullet!”
 

Organotin toxicity

Although tin is not especially toxic for the body when ingested, it can bind to organic compounds if it passes through to the blood. “When tin binds to a carbon atom, it becomes organotin, a neurotoxin,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

She said that this organotin can travel to the brain and trigger symptoms like those found in patients with Essure implants. “For the time being, there is insufficient data to assert that we found organotin in all subjects. Another more in-depth study would be needed to assess migration to the brain. For the past 2 years, we have tried to obtain academic funding to continue our research, so far without success. Academic and political authorities seem to be a bit scared of what we’ve found,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

For her, “it’s how the implant was marketed that is problematic. The implant was designed to create local inflammation, inflammation in itself being difficult to control. Some women need to have their entire uterus and ovaries removed to resolve problems caused by the implant.”
 

Harm in the United States

Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu’s research has helped American victims obtain acknowledgment of their suffering in the United States. “But the harm caused to women by defective implants has yet to be acknowledged in France,” she added.

She explained that Essure was recalled in 2017 because sales were poor, not because it was deemed dangerous. Her conclusion? “No implant that creates inflammation should be authorized, especially if there is a surgical alternative, which there is here: tubal ligation.”

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape French edition.

Essure implants arrived on the market in 2002 as permanent contraception for women older than age 45 years with children. They were recalled in 2017. Presented as an alternative to laparoscopic tubal ligation, this medical device resulted in rare side effects affecting thousands of women, most notably the nervous system, cardiovascular system, endocrine system, and musculoskeletal system.

Implant analysis protocol

A team from Lyon, France, studied the wear debris from these medical devices and their possible toxic health effects. They discovered that tin could be the cause of the implant’s toxicity. “My research focuses on a variety of medical devices, mostly joint replacements, and more specifically, hip replacements. I look at how these materials behave in humans and how the wear debris affects the body,” explained Ana Maria Trunfio-Sfarghiu, bioengineering expert and research associate with the French National Center for Scientific Research at the Lyon National Institute of Applied Sciences’ Contact and Structure Mechanics Laboratory.

“The problems with Essure implants started with a woman who had been using one for about 10 years and was experiencing side effects such as trouble concentrating and focusing, significant vaginal bleeding, extreme tiredness, hair loss, etc. She had the implant removed, and we retrieved it from her gynecologist and analyzed it alongside other implants,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

“Together with the hospital, we set up an implant analysis protocol. We visited hospital teams to demonstrate how to prepare the biopsies, embedded in paraffin blocks, before sending them to us for analysis. We gave the same specimen preparation instructions for all subjects,” Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu explained.

After a year of clinical analysis, the Journal of Trace Elements in Medicine and Biology published an article about 18 cases.
 

Implant weld corrosion

The Essure implant measures a few centimeters long and resembles a small spring. Once it is released inside the fallopian tube, its goal is to create inflammation and block the tube. It triggers fibrosis, which prevents the sperm from reaching the egg. Premarketing tests had shown that the fibrosis surrounding the implant would keep it from moving. However, the pharmaceutical company hadn’t assessed the mechanical integrity of the spring weld, which was made of silver-tin.

During their analysis in collaboration with the Minapath laboratory, Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu’s team found that the weld had corroded and that tin particles had been released into the subjects’ bodies. “The study included about 40 women, and we found tin in all of them,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

This weld corrosion has several possible consequences. “When the implant degrades, it can travel anywhere in the pelvis, like a needle moving through the body with no apparent destination. The surgeons who operate to remove it describe similar surgeries in military medicine when the patient has been hit by a bullet!”
 

Organotin toxicity

Although tin is not especially toxic for the body when ingested, it can bind to organic compounds if it passes through to the blood. “When tin binds to a carbon atom, it becomes organotin, a neurotoxin,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

She said that this organotin can travel to the brain and trigger symptoms like those found in patients with Essure implants. “For the time being, there is insufficient data to assert that we found organotin in all subjects. Another more in-depth study would be needed to assess migration to the brain. For the past 2 years, we have tried to obtain academic funding to continue our research, so far without success. Academic and political authorities seem to be a bit scared of what we’ve found,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

For her, “it’s how the implant was marketed that is problematic. The implant was designed to create local inflammation, inflammation in itself being difficult to control. Some women need to have their entire uterus and ovaries removed to resolve problems caused by the implant.”
 

Harm in the United States

Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu’s research has helped American victims obtain acknowledgment of their suffering in the United States. “But the harm caused to women by defective implants has yet to be acknowledged in France,” she added.

She explained that Essure was recalled in 2017 because sales were poor, not because it was deemed dangerous. Her conclusion? “No implant that creates inflammation should be authorized, especially if there is a surgical alternative, which there is here: tubal ligation.”

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape French edition.

Essure implants arrived on the market in 2002 as permanent contraception for women older than age 45 years with children. They were recalled in 2017. Presented as an alternative to laparoscopic tubal ligation, this medical device resulted in rare side effects affecting thousands of women, most notably the nervous system, cardiovascular system, endocrine system, and musculoskeletal system.

Implant analysis protocol

A team from Lyon, France, studied the wear debris from these medical devices and their possible toxic health effects. They discovered that tin could be the cause of the implant’s toxicity. “My research focuses on a variety of medical devices, mostly joint replacements, and more specifically, hip replacements. I look at how these materials behave in humans and how the wear debris affects the body,” explained Ana Maria Trunfio-Sfarghiu, bioengineering expert and research associate with the French National Center for Scientific Research at the Lyon National Institute of Applied Sciences’ Contact and Structure Mechanics Laboratory.

“The problems with Essure implants started with a woman who had been using one for about 10 years and was experiencing side effects such as trouble concentrating and focusing, significant vaginal bleeding, extreme tiredness, hair loss, etc. She had the implant removed, and we retrieved it from her gynecologist and analyzed it alongside other implants,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

“Together with the hospital, we set up an implant analysis protocol. We visited hospital teams to demonstrate how to prepare the biopsies, embedded in paraffin blocks, before sending them to us for analysis. We gave the same specimen preparation instructions for all subjects,” Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu explained.

After a year of clinical analysis, the Journal of Trace Elements in Medicine and Biology published an article about 18 cases.
 

Implant weld corrosion

The Essure implant measures a few centimeters long and resembles a small spring. Once it is released inside the fallopian tube, its goal is to create inflammation and block the tube. It triggers fibrosis, which prevents the sperm from reaching the egg. Premarketing tests had shown that the fibrosis surrounding the implant would keep it from moving. However, the pharmaceutical company hadn’t assessed the mechanical integrity of the spring weld, which was made of silver-tin.

During their analysis in collaboration with the Minapath laboratory, Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu’s team found that the weld had corroded and that tin particles had been released into the subjects’ bodies. “The study included about 40 women, and we found tin in all of them,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

This weld corrosion has several possible consequences. “When the implant degrades, it can travel anywhere in the pelvis, like a needle moving through the body with no apparent destination. The surgeons who operate to remove it describe similar surgeries in military medicine when the patient has been hit by a bullet!”
 

Organotin toxicity

Although tin is not especially toxic for the body when ingested, it can bind to organic compounds if it passes through to the blood. “When tin binds to a carbon atom, it becomes organotin, a neurotoxin,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

She said that this organotin can travel to the brain and trigger symptoms like those found in patients with Essure implants. “For the time being, there is insufficient data to assert that we found organotin in all subjects. Another more in-depth study would be needed to assess migration to the brain. For the past 2 years, we have tried to obtain academic funding to continue our research, so far without success. Academic and political authorities seem to be a bit scared of what we’ve found,” said Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu.

For her, “it’s how the implant was marketed that is problematic. The implant was designed to create local inflammation, inflammation in itself being difficult to control. Some women need to have their entire uterus and ovaries removed to resolve problems caused by the implant.”
 

Harm in the United States

Ms. Trunfio-Sfarghiu’s research has helped American victims obtain acknowledgment of their suffering in the United States. “But the harm caused to women by defective implants has yet to be acknowledged in France,” she added.

She explained that Essure was recalled in 2017 because sales were poor, not because it was deemed dangerous. Her conclusion? “No implant that creates inflammation should be authorized, especially if there is a surgical alternative, which there is here: tubal ligation.”

A version of this article appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape French edition.