Diana Swift

Intervening with physical activity appears to mitigate depressive symptoms in children and adolescents, a systematic review and meta-analysis of almost 2,500 participants found. Greater reductions were observed for children older than 13 years and those having a diagnosis of mental illness and/or depression versus other conditions, according to Hong Kong researchers reporting in JAMA Pediatrics.

“There is an urgent need to explore novel treatment approaches that can be safely, feasibly, and widely implemented in the daily routine of depressed children and adolescents,” said study coauthor Parco M. Siu, PhD, exercise physiologist and associate professor in the school of public health at the University of Hong Kong, in an interview. “Given the observed association with significant reductions in symptoms, clinical practice guidelines should consider the role of physical activity for improving the mental health of young populations.”

Dr. Siu further noted that while current guidelines suggest psychotherapy and/or pharmacotherapy for children with this common mood disorder, adherence to these can be problematic, and surveys show that nearly 80% do not receive appropriate disorder-specific medical care.

The analysis

Dr. Siu’s team drew on 21 international studies, including 17 randomized controlled trials, published from 1987 to 2021 and comprising 2,444 young participants, mean age 14, 53% girls. Eligible studies compared the effect of exercise on depression versus a control condition.

In 12 studies, participants had a somatic or psychiatric disorder such as obesity, diabetes, depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. The mean duration of the prescribed physical activity program was 22 weeks (6-144 weeks), while the frequency of weekly sessions ranged from 2 to 5 days, with 3 days per week most common and mean duration of 50 minutes (30-120 minutes). Regimens ranged from aerobic exercise on fitness equipment such as treadmills, stationary bikes, and ellipticals, to running, swimming, dancing, sports, and exercise games.

In meta-analysis of postintervention differences, physical activity was associated with a significant reduction in the pooled estimate of depressive symptoms compared with the control condition (Hedges g statistic [effect size] = −0.29; 95% confidence interval, −0.47 to −0.10; P = .004). This was driven by moderate to large effect sizes in adolescents (g = −0.44) and children with diagnosed depression (g = −0.75).The differences, however, were not detectable after a mean follow-up of 21 weeks, possibly owing to the limited number of studies with follow-up outcomes, the authors conceded.

Despite the strong association, the mechanisms underlying the antidepressant properties of physical activity remain uncertain. “Potential pathways include the activation of the endocannabinoid system to stimulate the release of endorphins, an increase in the bioavailability of brain neurotransmitters such as serotonin, dopamine, and noradrenaline, which are reduced in depression, as well as long-term changes in brain plasticity,” Dr. Siu said.

In addition, psychosocial and behavioral hypotheses suggest that physical activity can lead to improvements in self-perception, social interactions, and self-confidence. However, he added, depressive phenomenology is multifaceted and individual, so isolating the effects that physical activity have on specific symptoms may not be possible.

Physical activity appears to enhance the treatment of cognitive and affective symptoms in depression, Dr. Siu continued, and a combination of physical activity and pharmacotherapy may also reduce relapse risk, improve adherence to antidepressants, and promote better management of adverse effects, compared with pharmacotherapy alone. “More research is warranted to explain if and how these mechanisms moderate the effect of physical activity, and whether these changes are also present in younger populations,” he said.

Still unanswered is the question of how vigorous activity has to be in order to have an effect, Dr. Siu said. “Future studies should investigate the influence of parameters such as frequency, duration, and supervision of exercise sessions to determine the optimal dose and mode of delivery of the intervention for depressive symptom management.”

But would group activity likely have broader benefits than solitary exercise? “It is still unclear whether there’s a difference between the effect of solitary activities and team sports,” Dr. Siu said.

In an accompanying editorial on the meta-analysis, Eduardo E. Bustamante, PhD, an exercise psychologist in the department of kinesiology and nutrition at the University of Illinois at Chicago, and colleagues called the meta-analysis “part of a potential watershed moment” in the field of exercise as therapy for psychological disorders. “The work is timely, aligning with the rise of mental health disorders in adolescents, and the methods are rigorous (e.g., random-effects models, risk-of-bias assessment, sensitivity analyses).”

Dr. Bustamante said the literature on physical activity in children has lagged behind that for adults, so this meta-analysis provides a welcome “critical mass” of evidence of benefit in children, in an interview. “Though the benefit is relatively small, it’s exciting to see the results come in positive specifically to depression.” In his view, the effect of exercise is likely to be less pronounced in children than in adults, especially older ones, as they have fewer inflammatory and other systemic health problems that might improve with exercise. “And we tend to see bigger effects in children with a diagnosis like ADHD or clinical depression.”

But the bottom line is clear: “The evidence that physical activity is effective medicine for mental health is robust; now we need to find ways to get people to take it.”

This work was supported by the Health and Medical Research Fund of the Food and Health Bureau, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government, and the Seed Fund for Basic Research of the University of Hong Kong. The authors and editorial commentators disclosed no conflicts of interest.

Intervening with physical activity appears to mitigate depressive symptoms in children and adolescents, a systematic review and meta-analysis of almost 2,500 participants found. Greater reductions were observed for children older than 13 years and those having a diagnosis of mental illness and/or depression versus other conditions, according to Hong Kong researchers reporting in JAMA Pediatrics.

“There is an urgent need to explore novel treatment approaches that can be safely, feasibly, and widely implemented in the daily routine of depressed children and adolescents,” said study coauthor Parco M. Siu, PhD, exercise physiologist and associate professor in the school of public health at the University of Hong Kong, in an interview. “Given the observed association with significant reductions in symptoms, clinical practice guidelines should consider the role of physical activity for improving the mental health of young populations.”

Dr. Siu further noted that while current guidelines suggest psychotherapy and/or pharmacotherapy for children with this common mood disorder, adherence to these can be problematic, and surveys show that nearly 80% do not receive appropriate disorder-specific medical care.

The analysis

Dr. Siu’s team drew on 21 international studies, including 17 randomized controlled trials, published from 1987 to 2021 and comprising 2,444 young participants, mean age 14, 53% girls. Eligible studies compared the effect of exercise on depression versus a control condition.

In 12 studies, participants had a somatic or psychiatric disorder such as obesity, diabetes, depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. The mean duration of the prescribed physical activity program was 22 weeks (6-144 weeks), while the frequency of weekly sessions ranged from 2 to 5 days, with 3 days per week most common and mean duration of 50 minutes (30-120 minutes). Regimens ranged from aerobic exercise on fitness equipment such as treadmills, stationary bikes, and ellipticals, to running, swimming, dancing, sports, and exercise games.

In meta-analysis of postintervention differences, physical activity was associated with a significant reduction in the pooled estimate of depressive symptoms compared with the control condition (Hedges g statistic [effect size] = −0.29; 95% confidence interval, −0.47 to −0.10; P = .004). This was driven by moderate to large effect sizes in adolescents (g = −0.44) and children with diagnosed depression (g = −0.75).The differences, however, were not detectable after a mean follow-up of 21 weeks, possibly owing to the limited number of studies with follow-up outcomes, the authors conceded.

Despite the strong association, the mechanisms underlying the antidepressant properties of physical activity remain uncertain. “Potential pathways include the activation of the endocannabinoid system to stimulate the release of endorphins, an increase in the bioavailability of brain neurotransmitters such as serotonin, dopamine, and noradrenaline, which are reduced in depression, as well as long-term changes in brain plasticity,” Dr. Siu said.

In addition, psychosocial and behavioral hypotheses suggest that physical activity can lead to improvements in self-perception, social interactions, and self-confidence. However, he added, depressive phenomenology is multifaceted and individual, so isolating the effects that physical activity have on specific symptoms may not be possible.

Physical activity appears to enhance the treatment of cognitive and affective symptoms in depression, Dr. Siu continued, and a combination of physical activity and pharmacotherapy may also reduce relapse risk, improve adherence to antidepressants, and promote better management of adverse effects, compared with pharmacotherapy alone. “More research is warranted to explain if and how these mechanisms moderate the effect of physical activity, and whether these changes are also present in younger populations,” he said.

Still unanswered is the question of how vigorous activity has to be in order to have an effect, Dr. Siu said. “Future studies should investigate the influence of parameters such as frequency, duration, and supervision of exercise sessions to determine the optimal dose and mode of delivery of the intervention for depressive symptom management.”

But would group activity likely have broader benefits than solitary exercise? “It is still unclear whether there’s a difference between the effect of solitary activities and team sports,” Dr. Siu said.

In an accompanying editorial on the meta-analysis, Eduardo E. Bustamante, PhD, an exercise psychologist in the department of kinesiology and nutrition at the University of Illinois at Chicago, and colleagues called the meta-analysis “part of a potential watershed moment” in the field of exercise as therapy for psychological disorders. “The work is timely, aligning with the rise of mental health disorders in adolescents, and the methods are rigorous (e.g., random-effects models, risk-of-bias assessment, sensitivity analyses).”

Dr. Bustamante said the literature on physical activity in children has lagged behind that for adults, so this meta-analysis provides a welcome “critical mass” of evidence of benefit in children, in an interview. “Though the benefit is relatively small, it’s exciting to see the results come in positive specifically to depression.” In his view, the effect of exercise is likely to be less pronounced in children than in adults, especially older ones, as they have fewer inflammatory and other systemic health problems that might improve with exercise. “And we tend to see bigger effects in children with a diagnosis like ADHD or clinical depression.”

But the bottom line is clear: “The evidence that physical activity is effective medicine for mental health is robust; now we need to find ways to get people to take it.”

This work was supported by the Health and Medical Research Fund of the Food and Health Bureau, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government, and the Seed Fund for Basic Research of the University of Hong Kong. The authors and editorial commentators disclosed no conflicts of interest.

Intervening with physical activity appears to mitigate depressive symptoms in children and adolescents, a systematic review and meta-analysis of almost 2,500 participants found. Greater reductions were observed for children older than 13 years and those having a diagnosis of mental illness and/or depression versus other conditions, according to Hong Kong researchers reporting in JAMA Pediatrics.

“There is an urgent need to explore novel treatment approaches that can be safely, feasibly, and widely implemented in the daily routine of depressed children and adolescents,” said study coauthor Parco M. Siu, PhD, exercise physiologist and associate professor in the school of public health at the University of Hong Kong, in an interview. “Given the observed association with significant reductions in symptoms, clinical practice guidelines should consider the role of physical activity for improving the mental health of young populations.”

Dr. Siu further noted that while current guidelines suggest psychotherapy and/or pharmacotherapy for children with this common mood disorder, adherence to these can be problematic, and surveys show that nearly 80% do not receive appropriate disorder-specific medical care.

The analysis

Dr. Siu’s team drew on 21 international studies, including 17 randomized controlled trials, published from 1987 to 2021 and comprising 2,444 young participants, mean age 14, 53% girls. Eligible studies compared the effect of exercise on depression versus a control condition.

In 12 studies, participants had a somatic or psychiatric disorder such as obesity, diabetes, depression, and attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. The mean duration of the prescribed physical activity program was 22 weeks (6-144 weeks), while the frequency of weekly sessions ranged from 2 to 5 days, with 3 days per week most common and mean duration of 50 minutes (30-120 minutes). Regimens ranged from aerobic exercise on fitness equipment such as treadmills, stationary bikes, and ellipticals, to running, swimming, dancing, sports, and exercise games.

In meta-analysis of postintervention differences, physical activity was associated with a significant reduction in the pooled estimate of depressive symptoms compared with the control condition (Hedges g statistic [effect size] = −0.29; 95% confidence interval, −0.47 to −0.10; P = .004). This was driven by moderate to large effect sizes in adolescents (g = −0.44) and children with diagnosed depression (g = −0.75).The differences, however, were not detectable after a mean follow-up of 21 weeks, possibly owing to the limited number of studies with follow-up outcomes, the authors conceded.

Despite the strong association, the mechanisms underlying the antidepressant properties of physical activity remain uncertain. “Potential pathways include the activation of the endocannabinoid system to stimulate the release of endorphins, an increase in the bioavailability of brain neurotransmitters such as serotonin, dopamine, and noradrenaline, which are reduced in depression, as well as long-term changes in brain plasticity,” Dr. Siu said.

In addition, psychosocial and behavioral hypotheses suggest that physical activity can lead to improvements in self-perception, social interactions, and self-confidence. However, he added, depressive phenomenology is multifaceted and individual, so isolating the effects that physical activity have on specific symptoms may not be possible.

Physical activity appears to enhance the treatment of cognitive and affective symptoms in depression, Dr. Siu continued, and a combination of physical activity and pharmacotherapy may also reduce relapse risk, improve adherence to antidepressants, and promote better management of adverse effects, compared with pharmacotherapy alone. “More research is warranted to explain if and how these mechanisms moderate the effect of physical activity, and whether these changes are also present in younger populations,” he said.

Still unanswered is the question of how vigorous activity has to be in order to have an effect, Dr. Siu said. “Future studies should investigate the influence of parameters such as frequency, duration, and supervision of exercise sessions to determine the optimal dose and mode of delivery of the intervention for depressive symptom management.”

But would group activity likely have broader benefits than solitary exercise? “It is still unclear whether there’s a difference between the effect of solitary activities and team sports,” Dr. Siu said.

In an accompanying editorial on the meta-analysis, Eduardo E. Bustamante, PhD, an exercise psychologist in the department of kinesiology and nutrition at the University of Illinois at Chicago, and colleagues called the meta-analysis “part of a potential watershed moment” in the field of exercise as therapy for psychological disorders. “The work is timely, aligning with the rise of mental health disorders in adolescents, and the methods are rigorous (e.g., random-effects models, risk-of-bias assessment, sensitivity analyses).”

Dr. Bustamante said the literature on physical activity in children has lagged behind that for adults, so this meta-analysis provides a welcome “critical mass” of evidence of benefit in children, in an interview. “Though the benefit is relatively small, it’s exciting to see the results come in positive specifically to depression.” In his view, the effect of exercise is likely to be less pronounced in children than in adults, especially older ones, as they have fewer inflammatory and other systemic health problems that might improve with exercise. “And we tend to see bigger effects in children with a diagnosis like ADHD or clinical depression.”

But the bottom line is clear: “The evidence that physical activity is effective medicine for mental health is robust; now we need to find ways to get people to take it.”

This work was supported by the Health and Medical Research Fund of the Food and Health Bureau, Hong Kong Special Administrative Region Government, and the Seed Fund for Basic Research of the University of Hong Kong. The authors and editorial commentators disclosed no conflicts of interest.

By August 2022, two-and-a-half years into the COVID-19 pandemic, most children as well as most adults under age 60 years had evidence of SARS-CoV-2 vaccination and/or infection, a Canadian seroprevalence study of almost 14,000 people over the first seven waves of the pandemic reports.

However, fewer than 50% people older than age 60, the age group most vulnerable to severe outcomes, showed evidence of immunity from infection or vaccination. The authors noted that older adults – who have the lowest infection rates but highest risk of severe outcomes – continue to warrant prioritized vaccination, writing online in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

The study

Conducted in British Columbia’s Greater Vancouver and Fraser Valley, the analysis found that in the first year of the pandemic, when extraordinary measures were in place to curtail transmission, virtually everyone remained immunologically naive. Thereafter, however, age-based vaccine rollouts dramatically changed the immuno-epidemiological landscape so that by September 2021, more than 80% of the study population had antibody evidence of immunological priming, while more than 85% remained uninfected.

By August 2022, after the Omicron-variant waves, overall vaccine- and infection-induced seroprevalence exceeded 95%, with 60% having been actually infected, including at least three-quarters of children. Fewer than 50% of older adults, however, showed immunological evidence of exposure.

The study results were based on anonymized residual sera from children and adults in an outpatient laboratory network. At least three immunoassays per serosurvey were used to detect antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 spike (from vaccine) and to nucleocapsid antibodies (from infection).

The researchers assessed any seroprevalence – vaccine-, infection-induced, or both – as defined by positivity on any two assays. Infection-induced seroprevalence was also defined by dual-assay positivity but required both antinucleocapsid and antispike detection. Their estimates of infection-induced seroprevalence indicated considerable under-ascertainment of infections by standard surveillance case reports.
 

Results

During the first year of the pandemic, fewer than 1% manifested seroprevalence during the first three snapshots and fewer than 5% by January 2021. With vaccine rollout, however, seroprevalence increased dramatically during the first half of 2021 to 56% by May/June 2021 and to 83% by September/October 2021.

In addition, infection-induced seroprevalence was low at less than 15% in September/October 2021 until the arrival of the Omicron waves, after which it rose to 42% by March 2022 and 61% by July/August 2022. Combined seroprevalence for vaccination or infection was more than 95% by the summer, with most children but less than half of adults older than 60 years showing evidence of having been infected.

“We found the highest infection rates among children, closely followed by young adults, which may reflect their greater interconnectedness, including between siblings and parents in the household, as well as with peers in schools and the community,” the authors wrote, adding that the low cumulative infection rates among older adults may reflect their higher vaccination rates and greater social isolation.

U.S. data show similar age-related infection rates, but data among children from other Canadian provinces are limited, the authors said.

Commenting on the survey but not involved in it, infectious diseases expert Marc Germain, MD, PhD, a vice president at Héma-Québec in Quebec City, believes the pattern observed in British Columbia is fairly representative of what happened across Canada and the United States, including the sweeping effect of the Omicron variant and the differential impact according to age.

“But regional differences might very well exist – for example, due to differential vaccine uptake – and are also probably related in part to the different testing platforms being used,” Dr. Germain told this news organization.

Caroline Quach-Tanh, MD, PhD, a pediatrician and epidemiologist/infectologist at the University of Montreal, pointed out that Quebec seroprevalence surveys using residual blood samples from children and adults visiting emergency departments for any reason showed higher rates of prior infection than did the BC surveys. “But Dr. Skowronski’s findings are likely applicable to settings where some nonpharmacological interventions were put in place, but without strict confinement – and thus are likely applicable to most settings in the U.S. and Canada.”

Dr. Quach-Tanh added that there is always a risk of bias with the use of residual blood samples, “but the fact that the study method was stable should have captured a similar population from time to time. It would be unlikely to result in a major overestimation in the proportion of individuals positive for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.”

A recent global meta-analysis found that while global seroprevalence has risen considerably, albeit variably by region, more than a third of the world’s population is still seronegative to the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

Dr. Skowronski reported institutional grants from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the British Columbia Centre for Disease Control Foundation for Public Health for other SARSCoV-2 work. Coauthor Romina C. Reyes, MD, chairs the BC Diagnostic Accreditation Program committee. Coauthor Mel Krajden, MD, reported institutional grants from Roche, Hologic, and Siemens. Dr. Germain and Dr. Quach-Tanh disclosed no competing interests relevant to their comments.

By August 2022, two-and-a-half years into the COVID-19 pandemic, most children as well as most adults under age 60 years had evidence of SARS-CoV-2 vaccination and/or infection, a Canadian seroprevalence study of almost 14,000 people over the first seven waves of the pandemic reports.

However, fewer than 50% people older than age 60, the age group most vulnerable to severe outcomes, showed evidence of immunity from infection or vaccination. The authors noted that older adults – who have the lowest infection rates but highest risk of severe outcomes – continue to warrant prioritized vaccination, writing online in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

The study

Conducted in British Columbia’s Greater Vancouver and Fraser Valley, the analysis found that in the first year of the pandemic, when extraordinary measures were in place to curtail transmission, virtually everyone remained immunologically naive. Thereafter, however, age-based vaccine rollouts dramatically changed the immuno-epidemiological landscape so that by September 2021, more than 80% of the study population had antibody evidence of immunological priming, while more than 85% remained uninfected.

By August 2022, after the Omicron-variant waves, overall vaccine- and infection-induced seroprevalence exceeded 95%, with 60% having been actually infected, including at least three-quarters of children. Fewer than 50% of older adults, however, showed immunological evidence of exposure.

The study results were based on anonymized residual sera from children and adults in an outpatient laboratory network. At least three immunoassays per serosurvey were used to detect antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 spike (from vaccine) and to nucleocapsid antibodies (from infection).

The researchers assessed any seroprevalence – vaccine-, infection-induced, or both – as defined by positivity on any two assays. Infection-induced seroprevalence was also defined by dual-assay positivity but required both antinucleocapsid and antispike detection. Their estimates of infection-induced seroprevalence indicated considerable under-ascertainment of infections by standard surveillance case reports.
 

Results

During the first year of the pandemic, fewer than 1% manifested seroprevalence during the first three snapshots and fewer than 5% by January 2021. With vaccine rollout, however, seroprevalence increased dramatically during the first half of 2021 to 56% by May/June 2021 and to 83% by September/October 2021.

In addition, infection-induced seroprevalence was low at less than 15% in September/October 2021 until the arrival of the Omicron waves, after which it rose to 42% by March 2022 and 61% by July/August 2022. Combined seroprevalence for vaccination or infection was more than 95% by the summer, with most children but less than half of adults older than 60 years showing evidence of having been infected.

“We found the highest infection rates among children, closely followed by young adults, which may reflect their greater interconnectedness, including between siblings and parents in the household, as well as with peers in schools and the community,” the authors wrote, adding that the low cumulative infection rates among older adults may reflect their higher vaccination rates and greater social isolation.

U.S. data show similar age-related infection rates, but data among children from other Canadian provinces are limited, the authors said.

Commenting on the survey but not involved in it, infectious diseases expert Marc Germain, MD, PhD, a vice president at Héma-Québec in Quebec City, believes the pattern observed in British Columbia is fairly representative of what happened across Canada and the United States, including the sweeping effect of the Omicron variant and the differential impact according to age.

“But regional differences might very well exist – for example, due to differential vaccine uptake – and are also probably related in part to the different testing platforms being used,” Dr. Germain told this news organization.

Caroline Quach-Tanh, MD, PhD, a pediatrician and epidemiologist/infectologist at the University of Montreal, pointed out that Quebec seroprevalence surveys using residual blood samples from children and adults visiting emergency departments for any reason showed higher rates of prior infection than did the BC surveys. “But Dr. Skowronski’s findings are likely applicable to settings where some nonpharmacological interventions were put in place, but without strict confinement – and thus are likely applicable to most settings in the U.S. and Canada.”

Dr. Quach-Tanh added that there is always a risk of bias with the use of residual blood samples, “but the fact that the study method was stable should have captured a similar population from time to time. It would be unlikely to result in a major overestimation in the proportion of individuals positive for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.”

A recent global meta-analysis found that while global seroprevalence has risen considerably, albeit variably by region, more than a third of the world’s population is still seronegative to the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

Dr. Skowronski reported institutional grants from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the British Columbia Centre for Disease Control Foundation for Public Health for other SARSCoV-2 work. Coauthor Romina C. Reyes, MD, chairs the BC Diagnostic Accreditation Program committee. Coauthor Mel Krajden, MD, reported institutional grants from Roche, Hologic, and Siemens. Dr. Germain and Dr. Quach-Tanh disclosed no competing interests relevant to their comments.

By August 2022, two-and-a-half years into the COVID-19 pandemic, most children as well as most adults under age 60 years had evidence of SARS-CoV-2 vaccination and/or infection, a Canadian seroprevalence study of almost 14,000 people over the first seven waves of the pandemic reports.

However, fewer than 50% people older than age 60, the age group most vulnerable to severe outcomes, showed evidence of immunity from infection or vaccination. The authors noted that older adults – who have the lowest infection rates but highest risk of severe outcomes – continue to warrant prioritized vaccination, writing online in the Canadian Medical Association Journal.

The study

Conducted in British Columbia’s Greater Vancouver and Fraser Valley, the analysis found that in the first year of the pandemic, when extraordinary measures were in place to curtail transmission, virtually everyone remained immunologically naive. Thereafter, however, age-based vaccine rollouts dramatically changed the immuno-epidemiological landscape so that by September 2021, more than 80% of the study population had antibody evidence of immunological priming, while more than 85% remained uninfected.

By August 2022, after the Omicron-variant waves, overall vaccine- and infection-induced seroprevalence exceeded 95%, with 60% having been actually infected, including at least three-quarters of children. Fewer than 50% of older adults, however, showed immunological evidence of exposure.

The study results were based on anonymized residual sera from children and adults in an outpatient laboratory network. At least three immunoassays per serosurvey were used to detect antibodies to SARS-CoV-2 spike (from vaccine) and to nucleocapsid antibodies (from infection).

The researchers assessed any seroprevalence – vaccine-, infection-induced, or both – as defined by positivity on any two assays. Infection-induced seroprevalence was also defined by dual-assay positivity but required both antinucleocapsid and antispike detection. Their estimates of infection-induced seroprevalence indicated considerable under-ascertainment of infections by standard surveillance case reports.
 

Results

During the first year of the pandemic, fewer than 1% manifested seroprevalence during the first three snapshots and fewer than 5% by January 2021. With vaccine rollout, however, seroprevalence increased dramatically during the first half of 2021 to 56% by May/June 2021 and to 83% by September/October 2021.

In addition, infection-induced seroprevalence was low at less than 15% in September/October 2021 until the arrival of the Omicron waves, after which it rose to 42% by March 2022 and 61% by July/August 2022. Combined seroprevalence for vaccination or infection was more than 95% by the summer, with most children but less than half of adults older than 60 years showing evidence of having been infected.

“We found the highest infection rates among children, closely followed by young adults, which may reflect their greater interconnectedness, including between siblings and parents in the household, as well as with peers in schools and the community,” the authors wrote, adding that the low cumulative infection rates among older adults may reflect their higher vaccination rates and greater social isolation.

U.S. data show similar age-related infection rates, but data among children from other Canadian provinces are limited, the authors said.

Commenting on the survey but not involved in it, infectious diseases expert Marc Germain, MD, PhD, a vice president at Héma-Québec in Quebec City, believes the pattern observed in British Columbia is fairly representative of what happened across Canada and the United States, including the sweeping effect of the Omicron variant and the differential impact according to age.

“But regional differences might very well exist – for example, due to differential vaccine uptake – and are also probably related in part to the different testing platforms being used,” Dr. Germain told this news organization.

Caroline Quach-Tanh, MD, PhD, a pediatrician and epidemiologist/infectologist at the University of Montreal, pointed out that Quebec seroprevalence surveys using residual blood samples from children and adults visiting emergency departments for any reason showed higher rates of prior infection than did the BC surveys. “But Dr. Skowronski’s findings are likely applicable to settings where some nonpharmacological interventions were put in place, but without strict confinement – and thus are likely applicable to most settings in the U.S. and Canada.”

Dr. Quach-Tanh added that there is always a risk of bias with the use of residual blood samples, “but the fact that the study method was stable should have captured a similar population from time to time. It would be unlikely to result in a major overestimation in the proportion of individuals positive for SARS-CoV-2 antibodies.”

A recent global meta-analysis found that while global seroprevalence has risen considerably, albeit variably by region, more than a third of the world’s population is still seronegative to the SARS-CoV-2 virus.

Dr. Skowronski reported institutional grants from the Canadian Institutes of Health Research and the British Columbia Centre for Disease Control Foundation for Public Health for other SARSCoV-2 work. Coauthor Romina C. Reyes, MD, chairs the BC Diagnostic Accreditation Program committee. Coauthor Mel Krajden, MD, reported institutional grants from Roche, Hologic, and Siemens. Dr. Germain and Dr. Quach-Tanh disclosed no competing interests relevant to their comments.

Obesity is not a universal phenotype in children with type 2 diabetes (T2D), a global systematic review and meta-analysis reported. In fact, the study found, as many as one in four children with T2D do not have obesity and some have normal reference-range body mass measurements. Further studies should consider other mechanisms beyond obesity in the genesis of pediatric diabetes, the authors of the international analysis concluded, writing for JAMA Network Open.

“We were aware that some children and adolescents with T2D did not have obesity, but we didn’t know the scale of obesity in T2D, or what variables may impact the occurrence of diabetes in this group,” endocrinologist M. Constantine Samaan, MD, MSc, associate professor of pediatrics at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ont., told this news organization. “So, the analysis did help us understand the body mass distribution of this group in more detail.”

Obesity is not a universal phenotype in children with type 2 diabetes (T2D), a global systematic review and meta-analysis reported. In fact, the study found, as many as one in four children with T2D do not have obesity and some have normal reference-range body mass measurements. Further studies should consider other mechanisms beyond obesity in the genesis of pediatric diabetes, the authors of the international analysis concluded, writing for JAMA Network Open.

“We were aware that some children and adolescents with T2D did not have obesity, but we didn’t know the scale of obesity in T2D, or what variables may impact the occurrence of diabetes in this group,” endocrinologist M. Constantine Samaan, MD, MSc, associate professor of pediatrics at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ont., told this news organization. “So, the analysis did help us understand the body mass distribution of this group in more detail.”

Obesity is not a universal phenotype in children with type 2 diabetes (T2D), a global systematic review and meta-analysis reported. In fact, the study found, as many as one in four children with T2D do not have obesity and some have normal reference-range body mass measurements. Further studies should consider other mechanisms beyond obesity in the genesis of pediatric diabetes, the authors of the international analysis concluded, writing for JAMA Network Open.

“We were aware that some children and adolescents with T2D did not have obesity, but we didn’t know the scale of obesity in T2D, or what variables may impact the occurrence of diabetes in this group,” endocrinologist M. Constantine Samaan, MD, MSc, associate professor of pediatrics at McMaster University in Hamilton, Ont., told this news organization. “So, the analysis did help us understand the body mass distribution of this group in more detail.”

Adolescents later diagnosed with anorexia nervosa (AN) likely embark on the trajectory to AN with undisclosed dieting for weight loss at about age 14, a study of teens and parents found.

In the interview-based study, both adolescents and their parents described a similar prediagnosis sequence of behavioral changes occurring over roughly 1 year to 18 months, but parents lagged some 6 months behind in noticing their children’s disordered eating.

The findings suggest that even teens of normal weight should be asked about their eating habits and monitored more closely for contact with those who endorse these potentially harmful eating behaviors, according to Lisa M. Ranzenhofer, PhD, assistant professor of clinical psychology in psychiatry at Columbia University Medical Center in New York, and colleagues. Their report is in the Journal of Adolescent Health.

“We know that adolescents often have eating disorder behaviors long before they’re diagnosed, so we developed this interview as a tool to figure out how long a maladaptive behavior has been present,” Dr. Ranzenhofer said in an interview. “Most studies that report illness duration do so based on diagnosis, so this interview provides a more fine-grained assessment of the duration of problematic behavior, which may help improve understanding of the impact of duration on outcome, and hopefully facilitate better methods for early detection.” Since healthy adolescents are often seen once per year at an annual pediatrician visit, she added, teens engaging in significant dieting might benefit from more frequent monitoring since this behavior can evolve into an eating disorder over a relatively short time frame.

AN is associated with significant medical and psychiatric comorbidity and has a mortality rate among the highest of any psychiatric illness, the authors noted.
 

The study

The study cohort consisted of 71 girls ages 12-18 years participating in research from 2017 to 2021 at the Eating Disorders Research Unit of New York (N.Y.) State Psychiatric Institute. Patients had either the restricting or binge-eating/purging subtype of AN as diagnosed by the Eating Disorder Assessment–5 questionnaire. A semistructured 15-minute interview with the girls and their parents explored food restriction, dieting, loss of control/binge eating, purging, excessive/compulsive exercise, weight history, and amenorrhea.

Both parents and children were asked whether and when the children had been underweight or overweight, and whether and when primary amenorrhea (no menarche) or secondary amenorrhea (periods missed for 3 months) became evident. Dieting was defined as “deliberately changing eating patterns in any way to influence your shape or weight,” and restriction as “deliberately cutting down on the amount of food that you are eating, in order to change your shape or weight.” Loss-of-control eating was defined as “feeling unable to stop eating or control what or how much you are eating.”

In other characterizations, purging was defined as making yourself vomit on purpose, taking diuretics, or feeling driven to engage in these behaviors. Questions on exercise explored whether children might feel anxious when they do not exercise or inclined to exercise even if sick or injured, with excessive exercise defined as “Feeling like you must exercise, might continue exercising, sometimes in secret, if parents or doctors have told you to stop.”

Other questions focused on use of diuretics or laxatives and other strategies to compensate for calories consumed.

Responses revealed that restriction, underweight, dieting, and excessive exercise were present in most of the sample, while purging, loss-of-control eating, and overweight were reported by fewer than a third. With dieting typically emerging first around age 14, the other behaviors tended to manifest from age 14 to 14 and a half. The average age of formal diagnosis was just over 15 years. Parent-child dyads showed good agreement on the presence and timing of all behaviors except for dieting, for which children reported onset about 6 months earlier or longer duration compared with parents.

Although older age at the time of interview was associated with a lower body mass index percentile and higher eating disorder score, neither age of onset nor duration of disordered eating was associated with severity when researchers controlled for current age.
 

Telltale signs for parents

“For teens starting at a healthy weight, significant and intentional weight loss of more than 5-10 pounds can be a cause for concern,” Dr. Ranzenhofer said. Missed periods, refusing meals, skipping meals, fighting or arguing about eating, and withdrawal from normal activities and relationships are other signs of disordered eating. For overweight or obese teens, rapid weight loss and weight loss above and beyond that recommended are also concerning.

As for compulsive exercise, she said, “Altered exercise behavior might look like exercise that interferes with other activities, for example, being late to school or not doing homework in order to exercise.” Other red flags would be physical activity that varies considerably from that of peers, for instance, going running after a 2-hour sports practice and an inflexible routine that precludes being able to skip a day.

“All adolescents, male and female, should be screened regardless of weight trends – underweight, overweight, obese, or normal weight – regarding their body image and thoughts of dieting,” said Margaret E. Thew, DNP, FNP-BC, of the Medical College of Wisconsin, and medical director of the department of adolescent medicine at Children’s Wisconsin in Milwaukee, commenting on the study but not involved in it. “Most adolescents make decisions to lose weight after trying to ‘eat healthy’ but may take an aggressive approach when they don’t see the weight loss they hope to see.”

According to Ms. Thew, the study findings support the benefit of giving medical caregivers and parents training on the red flags regarding eating disorders to foster early detection. “These include starting a new fad diet, eliminating foods, ‘healthy eating,’ over-exercising, skipping meals, or no longer eating foods they previously loved.”

She added that times of transition are key junctures to watch: The transition from grade school to middle school, middle to high school, and high school to college. “These tend to provoke eating disorder onset or relapse of eating disorder thoughts and behaviors after diagnosis,” Ms. Thew said. “It would benefit the patient to screen for concerns about disordered eating and provide resources, including consultation with a dietitian, as appropriate.”

This study was supported by grants from the National Institute of Mental Health and the Hilda and Preston Davis Foundation. Coauthor Joanna E. Steinglass, MD, disclosed receiving royalties from UpToDate. Ms. Thew disclosed no competing interests with regard to her comments.

Adolescents later diagnosed with anorexia nervosa (AN) likely embark on the trajectory to AN with undisclosed dieting for weight loss at about age 14, a study of teens and parents found.

In the interview-based study, both adolescents and their parents described a similar prediagnosis sequence of behavioral changes occurring over roughly 1 year to 18 months, but parents lagged some 6 months behind in noticing their children’s disordered eating.

The findings suggest that even teens of normal weight should be asked about their eating habits and monitored more closely for contact with those who endorse these potentially harmful eating behaviors, according to Lisa M. Ranzenhofer, PhD, assistant professor of clinical psychology in psychiatry at Columbia University Medical Center in New York, and colleagues. Their report is in the Journal of Adolescent Health.

“We know that adolescents often have eating disorder behaviors long before they’re diagnosed, so we developed this interview as a tool to figure out how long a maladaptive behavior has been present,” Dr. Ranzenhofer said in an interview. “Most studies that report illness duration do so based on diagnosis, so this interview provides a more fine-grained assessment of the duration of problematic behavior, which may help improve understanding of the impact of duration on outcome, and hopefully facilitate better methods for early detection.” Since healthy adolescents are often seen once per year at an annual pediatrician visit, she added, teens engaging in significant dieting might benefit from more frequent monitoring since this behavior can evolve into an eating disorder over a relatively short time frame.

AN is associated with significant medical and psychiatric comorbidity and has a mortality rate among the highest of any psychiatric illness, the authors noted.
 

The study

The study cohort consisted of 71 girls ages 12-18 years participating in research from 2017 to 2021 at the Eating Disorders Research Unit of New York (N.Y.) State Psychiatric Institute. Patients had either the restricting or binge-eating/purging subtype of AN as diagnosed by the Eating Disorder Assessment–5 questionnaire. A semistructured 15-minute interview with the girls and their parents explored food restriction, dieting, loss of control/binge eating, purging, excessive/compulsive exercise, weight history, and amenorrhea.

Both parents and children were asked whether and when the children had been underweight or overweight, and whether and when primary amenorrhea (no menarche) or secondary amenorrhea (periods missed for 3 months) became evident. Dieting was defined as “deliberately changing eating patterns in any way to influence your shape or weight,” and restriction as “deliberately cutting down on the amount of food that you are eating, in order to change your shape or weight.” Loss-of-control eating was defined as “feeling unable to stop eating or control what or how much you are eating.”

In other characterizations, purging was defined as making yourself vomit on purpose, taking diuretics, or feeling driven to engage in these behaviors. Questions on exercise explored whether children might feel anxious when they do not exercise or inclined to exercise even if sick or injured, with excessive exercise defined as “Feeling like you must exercise, might continue exercising, sometimes in secret, if parents or doctors have told you to stop.”

Other questions focused on use of diuretics or laxatives and other strategies to compensate for calories consumed.

Responses revealed that restriction, underweight, dieting, and excessive exercise were present in most of the sample, while purging, loss-of-control eating, and overweight were reported by fewer than a third. With dieting typically emerging first around age 14, the other behaviors tended to manifest from age 14 to 14 and a half. The average age of formal diagnosis was just over 15 years. Parent-child dyads showed good agreement on the presence and timing of all behaviors except for dieting, for which children reported onset about 6 months earlier or longer duration compared with parents.

Although older age at the time of interview was associated with a lower body mass index percentile and higher eating disorder score, neither age of onset nor duration of disordered eating was associated with severity when researchers controlled for current age.
 

Telltale signs for parents

“For teens starting at a healthy weight, significant and intentional weight loss of more than 5-10 pounds can be a cause for concern,” Dr. Ranzenhofer said. Missed periods, refusing meals, skipping meals, fighting or arguing about eating, and withdrawal from normal activities and relationships are other signs of disordered eating. For overweight or obese teens, rapid weight loss and weight loss above and beyond that recommended are also concerning.

As for compulsive exercise, she said, “Altered exercise behavior might look like exercise that interferes with other activities, for example, being late to school or not doing homework in order to exercise.” Other red flags would be physical activity that varies considerably from that of peers, for instance, going running after a 2-hour sports practice and an inflexible routine that precludes being able to skip a day.

“All adolescents, male and female, should be screened regardless of weight trends – underweight, overweight, obese, or normal weight – regarding their body image and thoughts of dieting,” said Margaret E. Thew, DNP, FNP-BC, of the Medical College of Wisconsin, and medical director of the department of adolescent medicine at Children’s Wisconsin in Milwaukee, commenting on the study but not involved in it. “Most adolescents make decisions to lose weight after trying to ‘eat healthy’ but may take an aggressive approach when they don’t see the weight loss they hope to see.”

According to Ms. Thew, the study findings support the benefit of giving medical caregivers and parents training on the red flags regarding eating disorders to foster early detection. “These include starting a new fad diet, eliminating foods, ‘healthy eating,’ over-exercising, skipping meals, or no longer eating foods they previously loved.”

She added that times of transition are key junctures to watch: The transition from grade school to middle school, middle to high school, and high school to college. “These tend to provoke eating disorder onset or relapse of eating disorder thoughts and behaviors after diagnosis,” Ms. Thew said. “It would benefit the patient to screen for concerns about disordered eating and provide resources, including consultation with a dietitian, as appropriate.”

This study was supported by grants from the National Institute of Mental Health and the Hilda and Preston Davis Foundation. Coauthor Joanna E. Steinglass, MD, disclosed receiving royalties from UpToDate. Ms. Thew disclosed no competing interests with regard to her comments.

Adolescents later diagnosed with anorexia nervosa (AN) likely embark on the trajectory to AN with undisclosed dieting for weight loss at about age 14, a study of teens and parents found.

In the interview-based study, both adolescents and their parents described a similar prediagnosis sequence of behavioral changes occurring over roughly 1 year to 18 months, but parents lagged some 6 months behind in noticing their children’s disordered eating.

The findings suggest that even teens of normal weight should be asked about their eating habits and monitored more closely for contact with those who endorse these potentially harmful eating behaviors, according to Lisa M. Ranzenhofer, PhD, assistant professor of clinical psychology in psychiatry at Columbia University Medical Center in New York, and colleagues. Their report is in the Journal of Adolescent Health.

“We know that adolescents often have eating disorder behaviors long before they’re diagnosed, so we developed this interview as a tool to figure out how long a maladaptive behavior has been present,” Dr. Ranzenhofer said in an interview. “Most studies that report illness duration do so based on diagnosis, so this interview provides a more fine-grained assessment of the duration of problematic behavior, which may help improve understanding of the impact of duration on outcome, and hopefully facilitate better methods for early detection.” Since healthy adolescents are often seen once per year at an annual pediatrician visit, she added, teens engaging in significant dieting might benefit from more frequent monitoring since this behavior can evolve into an eating disorder over a relatively short time frame.

AN is associated with significant medical and psychiatric comorbidity and has a mortality rate among the highest of any psychiatric illness, the authors noted.
 

The study

The study cohort consisted of 71 girls ages 12-18 years participating in research from 2017 to 2021 at the Eating Disorders Research Unit of New York (N.Y.) State Psychiatric Institute. Patients had either the restricting or binge-eating/purging subtype of AN as diagnosed by the Eating Disorder Assessment–5 questionnaire. A semistructured 15-minute interview with the girls and their parents explored food restriction, dieting, loss of control/binge eating, purging, excessive/compulsive exercise, weight history, and amenorrhea.

Both parents and children were asked whether and when the children had been underweight or overweight, and whether and when primary amenorrhea (no menarche) or secondary amenorrhea (periods missed for 3 months) became evident. Dieting was defined as “deliberately changing eating patterns in any way to influence your shape or weight,” and restriction as “deliberately cutting down on the amount of food that you are eating, in order to change your shape or weight.” Loss-of-control eating was defined as “feeling unable to stop eating or control what or how much you are eating.”

In other characterizations, purging was defined as making yourself vomit on purpose, taking diuretics, or feeling driven to engage in these behaviors. Questions on exercise explored whether children might feel anxious when they do not exercise or inclined to exercise even if sick or injured, with excessive exercise defined as “Feeling like you must exercise, might continue exercising, sometimes in secret, if parents or doctors have told you to stop.”

Other questions focused on use of diuretics or laxatives and other strategies to compensate for calories consumed.

Responses revealed that restriction, underweight, dieting, and excessive exercise were present in most of the sample, while purging, loss-of-control eating, and overweight were reported by fewer than a third. With dieting typically emerging first around age 14, the other behaviors tended to manifest from age 14 to 14 and a half. The average age of formal diagnosis was just over 15 years. Parent-child dyads showed good agreement on the presence and timing of all behaviors except for dieting, for which children reported onset about 6 months earlier or longer duration compared with parents.

Although older age at the time of interview was associated with a lower body mass index percentile and higher eating disorder score, neither age of onset nor duration of disordered eating was associated with severity when researchers controlled for current age.
 

Telltale signs for parents

“For teens starting at a healthy weight, significant and intentional weight loss of more than 5-10 pounds can be a cause for concern,” Dr. Ranzenhofer said. Missed periods, refusing meals, skipping meals, fighting or arguing about eating, and withdrawal from normal activities and relationships are other signs of disordered eating. For overweight or obese teens, rapid weight loss and weight loss above and beyond that recommended are also concerning.

As for compulsive exercise, she said, “Altered exercise behavior might look like exercise that interferes with other activities, for example, being late to school or not doing homework in order to exercise.” Other red flags would be physical activity that varies considerably from that of peers, for instance, going running after a 2-hour sports practice and an inflexible routine that precludes being able to skip a day.

“All adolescents, male and female, should be screened regardless of weight trends – underweight, overweight, obese, or normal weight – regarding their body image and thoughts of dieting,” said Margaret E. Thew, DNP, FNP-BC, of the Medical College of Wisconsin, and medical director of the department of adolescent medicine at Children’s Wisconsin in Milwaukee, commenting on the study but not involved in it. “Most adolescents make decisions to lose weight after trying to ‘eat healthy’ but may take an aggressive approach when they don’t see the weight loss they hope to see.”

According to Ms. Thew, the study findings support the benefit of giving medical caregivers and parents training on the red flags regarding eating disorders to foster early detection. “These include starting a new fad diet, eliminating foods, ‘healthy eating,’ over-exercising, skipping meals, or no longer eating foods they previously loved.”

She added that times of transition are key junctures to watch: The transition from grade school to middle school, middle to high school, and high school to college. “These tend to provoke eating disorder onset or relapse of eating disorder thoughts and behaviors after diagnosis,” Ms. Thew said. “It would benefit the patient to screen for concerns about disordered eating and provide resources, including consultation with a dietitian, as appropriate.”

This study was supported by grants from the National Institute of Mental Health and the Hilda and Preston Davis Foundation. Coauthor Joanna E. Steinglass, MD, disclosed receiving royalties from UpToDate. Ms. Thew disclosed no competing interests with regard to her comments.

The offspring of mothers who sustain unintentional injuries during pregnancy appear to have a modest 33% increased risk of developing cerebral palsy (CP) – higher when injuries are more severe, multiple, or lead to delivery soon afterward, a Canadian birth cohort study found.

Such children may benefit from long-term monitoring for neurodevelpmental issues, wrote a group led by Asma Ahmed, MD, PhD, MPH, a pediatric epidemiologist at the Hospital for Sick Children Research Institute in Toronto in JAMA Pediatrics.

“We need to provide better support for babies whose mothers have been injured in pregnancy, especially after severe injuries,” Dr. Ahmed said in a press release. “As well, these findings suggest the need for early monitoring of babies’ development, regular check-ups, and longer-term neurodevelopmental assessments.” Future studies should directly measure injury severity and its possible link to CP.

Current guidelines, however, focus on monitoring fetal condition immediately after injury with little attention to its long-term effects.

In their findings from the population-based linkage study of 2,110,177 children born in Ontario’s public health system during 2002-2017 and followed to 2018 with a median follow-up of 8 years:

• A total of 81,281 fetuses were exposed in utero to unintentional maternal injury.
• Overall, 0.3% children were diagnosed with CP, and the mean CP incidence rates were 4.36 per 10,000 child-years for the exposed versus 2.93 for the unexposed.
• In those exposed, the hazard ratio was 1.33 (95% confidence interval, 1.18-1.50) after adjusting for maternal sociodemographic and clinical characteristics.
• Injuries resulting in hospitalization or delivery within 1 week were linked to higher adjusted hazard ratios of 2.18 (95% CI, 1.29-3.68) and 3.40 (95% CI, 1.93-6.00), respectively.
• Injuries most frequently resulted from transportation mishaps, falls, and being struck by a person or object. They were most commonly associated with age younger than 20 years, substance use disorder, residence in rural and under-resourced areas, and lower socioeconomic status.

The authors noted that complications after maternal injuries – which affect 6%-8% of pregnant women – include uterine rupture, preterm delivery, and placental abruption and are linked to fetal complications such as asphyxia. The association with an offspring’s neurodevelopment has been rarely investigated. One U.K. population study, however, suggested a link between vehicular crashes and higher CP risk in preterm infants.

A related editorial on the study noted that while CP affects about two to four children per 1,000 live births each year in high-income countries, the etiological causes of most cases remain unknown. “This large population-based cohort study ... should inspire more research into preventing and mitigating factors for maternal injuries and offspring CP development,” wrote Zeyan Liew, PhD, MPH, and Haoran Zhuo, MPH, of Yale University School of Public Health in New Haven, Conn.

This study was supported by Santé-Québec and ICES, a research institute funded by the Ontario Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Long-Term Care.

Dr. Ahmed and coauthor Seungmi Yang, PhD, reported research funding from Santé-Québec during the conduct of the study.

The offspring of mothers who sustain unintentional injuries during pregnancy appear to have a modest 33% increased risk of developing cerebral palsy (CP) – higher when injuries are more severe, multiple, or lead to delivery soon afterward, a Canadian birth cohort study found.

Such children may benefit from long-term monitoring for neurodevelpmental issues, wrote a group led by Asma Ahmed, MD, PhD, MPH, a pediatric epidemiologist at the Hospital for Sick Children Research Institute in Toronto in JAMA Pediatrics.

“We need to provide better support for babies whose mothers have been injured in pregnancy, especially after severe injuries,” Dr. Ahmed said in a press release. “As well, these findings suggest the need for early monitoring of babies’ development, regular check-ups, and longer-term neurodevelopmental assessments.” Future studies should directly measure injury severity and its possible link to CP.

Current guidelines, however, focus on monitoring fetal condition immediately after injury with little attention to its long-term effects.

In their findings from the population-based linkage study of 2,110,177 children born in Ontario’s public health system during 2002-2017 and followed to 2018 with a median follow-up of 8 years:

• A total of 81,281 fetuses were exposed in utero to unintentional maternal injury.
• Overall, 0.3% children were diagnosed with CP, and the mean CP incidence rates were 4.36 per 10,000 child-years for the exposed versus 2.93 for the unexposed.
• In those exposed, the hazard ratio was 1.33 (95% confidence interval, 1.18-1.50) after adjusting for maternal sociodemographic and clinical characteristics.
• Injuries resulting in hospitalization or delivery within 1 week were linked to higher adjusted hazard ratios of 2.18 (95% CI, 1.29-3.68) and 3.40 (95% CI, 1.93-6.00), respectively.
• Injuries most frequently resulted from transportation mishaps, falls, and being struck by a person or object. They were most commonly associated with age younger than 20 years, substance use disorder, residence in rural and under-resourced areas, and lower socioeconomic status.

The authors noted that complications after maternal injuries – which affect 6%-8% of pregnant women – include uterine rupture, preterm delivery, and placental abruption and are linked to fetal complications such as asphyxia. The association with an offspring’s neurodevelopment has been rarely investigated. One U.K. population study, however, suggested a link between vehicular crashes and higher CP risk in preterm infants.

A related editorial on the study noted that while CP affects about two to four children per 1,000 live births each year in high-income countries, the etiological causes of most cases remain unknown. “This large population-based cohort study ... should inspire more research into preventing and mitigating factors for maternal injuries and offspring CP development,” wrote Zeyan Liew, PhD, MPH, and Haoran Zhuo, MPH, of Yale University School of Public Health in New Haven, Conn.

This study was supported by Santé-Québec and ICES, a research institute funded by the Ontario Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Long-Term Care.

Dr. Ahmed and coauthor Seungmi Yang, PhD, reported research funding from Santé-Québec during the conduct of the study.

The offspring of mothers who sustain unintentional injuries during pregnancy appear to have a modest 33% increased risk of developing cerebral palsy (CP) – higher when injuries are more severe, multiple, or lead to delivery soon afterward, a Canadian birth cohort study found.

Such children may benefit from long-term monitoring for neurodevelpmental issues, wrote a group led by Asma Ahmed, MD, PhD, MPH, a pediatric epidemiologist at the Hospital for Sick Children Research Institute in Toronto in JAMA Pediatrics.

“We need to provide better support for babies whose mothers have been injured in pregnancy, especially after severe injuries,” Dr. Ahmed said in a press release. “As well, these findings suggest the need for early monitoring of babies’ development, regular check-ups, and longer-term neurodevelopmental assessments.” Future studies should directly measure injury severity and its possible link to CP.

Current guidelines, however, focus on monitoring fetal condition immediately after injury with little attention to its long-term effects.

In their findings from the population-based linkage study of 2,110,177 children born in Ontario’s public health system during 2002-2017 and followed to 2018 with a median follow-up of 8 years:

• A total of 81,281 fetuses were exposed in utero to unintentional maternal injury.
• Overall, 0.3% children were diagnosed with CP, and the mean CP incidence rates were 4.36 per 10,000 child-years for the exposed versus 2.93 for the unexposed.
• In those exposed, the hazard ratio was 1.33 (95% confidence interval, 1.18-1.50) after adjusting for maternal sociodemographic and clinical characteristics.
• Injuries resulting in hospitalization or delivery within 1 week were linked to higher adjusted hazard ratios of 2.18 (95% CI, 1.29-3.68) and 3.40 (95% CI, 1.93-6.00), respectively.
• Injuries most frequently resulted from transportation mishaps, falls, and being struck by a person or object. They were most commonly associated with age younger than 20 years, substance use disorder, residence in rural and under-resourced areas, and lower socioeconomic status.

The authors noted that complications after maternal injuries – which affect 6%-8% of pregnant women – include uterine rupture, preterm delivery, and placental abruption and are linked to fetal complications such as asphyxia. The association with an offspring’s neurodevelopment has been rarely investigated. One U.K. population study, however, suggested a link between vehicular crashes and higher CP risk in preterm infants.

A related editorial on the study noted that while CP affects about two to four children per 1,000 live births each year in high-income countries, the etiological causes of most cases remain unknown. “This large population-based cohort study ... should inspire more research into preventing and mitigating factors for maternal injuries and offspring CP development,” wrote Zeyan Liew, PhD, MPH, and Haoran Zhuo, MPH, of Yale University School of Public Health in New Haven, Conn.

This study was supported by Santé-Québec and ICES, a research institute funded by the Ontario Ministry of Health and the Ministry of Long-Term Care.

Dr. Ahmed and coauthor Seungmi Yang, PhD, reported research funding from Santé-Québec during the conduct of the study.

For devout Muslims, praying multiple times a day is a lifelong observance and a core aspect of their faith. But osteoarthritis of the knee (KOA) can make kneeling and prostration challenging. To address this problem in an aging U.S. Muslim population, a multicenter team developed literature-based guidelines published online in Arthritis & Rheumatology.

In an interview, corresponding author Mahfujul Z. Haque, a medical student at Michigan State University, Grand Rapids, discussed the guide, which he assembled with Marina N. Magrey, MD, the Ronald Moskowitz Professor of Rheumatology at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, and orthopedic surgeon Karl C. Roberts, MD, president of West Michigan Orthopaedics in Grand Rapids, among others.

Could you detail the clinical and cultural context for these recommendations?

Mr. Haque: Muslims currently make up 1.1% of the U.S. population, or 3.45 million people. This guidance provides advice to Muslim patients with KOA in a culturally sensitive manner that can supplement standard care. Prayer, or Salah, is a religious obligation typically performed in 17-48 daily repetitions of squatting, floor sitting, full-knee flexion, and kneeling. For patients with KOA, prayer can be painful, and a few studies have found a link between these repeated movements and KOA progression.

Carlina Teteris/Moment/Getty Images

Yet recommending stopping or limiting prayer is insensitive, so our group did a thorough literature search to identify easily implemented and culturally appropriate ways to ease praying.

Is there a traditional preference for praying on a hard surface?

Mr. Haque: Prayer can be performed on any surface that is clean and free from impurities. Cushioned and carpeted surfaces are permissible if the surface is somewhat firm and supportive for when worshippers prostrate themselves and put their faces on the ground. For example, compacted snow that wouldn’t allow the face to sink into it is permissible, but snow that is soft and would allow the face to sink in is not.

Have an increasing number of older patients raised the issue of knee pain during prayers?

Mr. Haque: We found no research on this in the literature. Anecdotally, however, two of our authors lead prayer in large Muslim communities in Detroit, and people often share with them that they feel discomfort during prayer and ask if there is anything they can do to limit this.

It is important to dispel the common myth that after total knee replacement one cannot kneel. About 20% of patients have some anterior knee discomfort after total knee arthroplasty, which can be exacerbated by kneeling, but kneeling causes no harm and can be done safely.

Could you outline the main recommendations?

Mr. Haque: These fall under three main categories: prayer surface, mechanics, and lifestyle modifications. The surface recommendations essentially advise using prayer rugs that provide cushioning or using cushioned kneepads.

The mechanics recommendations involve bracing with the palms down, standing up using the hands and knees, and guiding prayer motions with the hands. Chairs may be used as well.

Lifestyle recommendations outline home-exercise programs tailored to KOA and suggest the use of ice and compression during acute exacerbations.

Could these recommendations benefit other arthritic joints such as the wrists?

Mr. Haque: Anecdotally, our authors do not hear about pain in joints except for the knee and spine. To a limited extent, some of these recommendations may help patients with spinal arthritis as well.

What do you see as the greatest obstacle to implementation?

Mr. Haque: These recommendations, although permissible in the Muslim faith, are not part of traditional ritual and thus patients may simply forget to implement them. We advise physicians to ask patients which recommendations they are most likely to follow and to monitor how these have worked for them.

What is your best overall advice for broaching this issue with patients?

Mr. Haque: Holistic, functional, and culturally sensitive recommendations will be highly appreciated. Physicians are therefore encouraged to share this guidance with Muslim patients while using terms such as Salah, pronounced saa-laah, and Sajdah, pronounced sajduh and meaning prostration, and engage in a healthy dialogue.

These guidelines received no funding. The authors disclosed no competing interests relevant to their recommendations, but Dr. Magrey reported consulting and research relationships with private-sector companies outside of this work.

For devout Muslims, praying multiple times a day is a lifelong observance and a core aspect of their faith. But osteoarthritis of the knee (KOA) can make kneeling and prostration challenging. To address this problem in an aging U.S. Muslim population, a multicenter team developed literature-based guidelines published online in Arthritis & Rheumatology.

In an interview, corresponding author Mahfujul Z. Haque, a medical student at Michigan State University, Grand Rapids, discussed the guide, which he assembled with Marina N. Magrey, MD, the Ronald Moskowitz Professor of Rheumatology at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, and orthopedic surgeon Karl C. Roberts, MD, president of West Michigan Orthopaedics in Grand Rapids, among others.

Could you detail the clinical and cultural context for these recommendations?

Mr. Haque: Muslims currently make up 1.1% of the U.S. population, or 3.45 million people. This guidance provides advice to Muslim patients with KOA in a culturally sensitive manner that can supplement standard care. Prayer, or Salah, is a religious obligation typically performed in 17-48 daily repetitions of squatting, floor sitting, full-knee flexion, and kneeling. For patients with KOA, prayer can be painful, and a few studies have found a link between these repeated movements and KOA progression.

Carlina Teteris/Moment/Getty Images

Yet recommending stopping or limiting prayer is insensitive, so our group did a thorough literature search to identify easily implemented and culturally appropriate ways to ease praying.

Is there a traditional preference for praying on a hard surface?

Mr. Haque: Prayer can be performed on any surface that is clean and free from impurities. Cushioned and carpeted surfaces are permissible if the surface is somewhat firm and supportive for when worshippers prostrate themselves and put their faces on the ground. For example, compacted snow that wouldn’t allow the face to sink into it is permissible, but snow that is soft and would allow the face to sink in is not.

Have an increasing number of older patients raised the issue of knee pain during prayers?

Mr. Haque: We found no research on this in the literature. Anecdotally, however, two of our authors lead prayer in large Muslim communities in Detroit, and people often share with them that they feel discomfort during prayer and ask if there is anything they can do to limit this.

It is important to dispel the common myth that after total knee replacement one cannot kneel. About 20% of patients have some anterior knee discomfort after total knee arthroplasty, which can be exacerbated by kneeling, but kneeling causes no harm and can be done safely.

Could you outline the main recommendations?

Mr. Haque: These fall under three main categories: prayer surface, mechanics, and lifestyle modifications. The surface recommendations essentially advise using prayer rugs that provide cushioning or using cushioned kneepads.

The mechanics recommendations involve bracing with the palms down, standing up using the hands and knees, and guiding prayer motions with the hands. Chairs may be used as well.

Lifestyle recommendations outline home-exercise programs tailored to KOA and suggest the use of ice and compression during acute exacerbations.

Could these recommendations benefit other arthritic joints such as the wrists?

Mr. Haque: Anecdotally, our authors do not hear about pain in joints except for the knee and spine. To a limited extent, some of these recommendations may help patients with spinal arthritis as well.

What do you see as the greatest obstacle to implementation?

Mr. Haque: These recommendations, although permissible in the Muslim faith, are not part of traditional ritual and thus patients may simply forget to implement them. We advise physicians to ask patients which recommendations they are most likely to follow and to monitor how these have worked for them.

What is your best overall advice for broaching this issue with patients?

Mr. Haque: Holistic, functional, and culturally sensitive recommendations will be highly appreciated. Physicians are therefore encouraged to share this guidance with Muslim patients while using terms such as Salah, pronounced saa-laah, and Sajdah, pronounced sajduh and meaning prostration, and engage in a healthy dialogue.

These guidelines received no funding. The authors disclosed no competing interests relevant to their recommendations, but Dr. Magrey reported consulting and research relationships with private-sector companies outside of this work.

For devout Muslims, praying multiple times a day is a lifelong observance and a core aspect of their faith. But osteoarthritis of the knee (KOA) can make kneeling and prostration challenging. To address this problem in an aging U.S. Muslim population, a multicenter team developed literature-based guidelines published online in Arthritis & Rheumatology.

In an interview, corresponding author Mahfujul Z. Haque, a medical student at Michigan State University, Grand Rapids, discussed the guide, which he assembled with Marina N. Magrey, MD, the Ronald Moskowitz Professor of Rheumatology at Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, and orthopedic surgeon Karl C. Roberts, MD, president of West Michigan Orthopaedics in Grand Rapids, among others.

Could you detail the clinical and cultural context for these recommendations?

Mr. Haque: Muslims currently make up 1.1% of the U.S. population, or 3.45 million people. This guidance provides advice to Muslim patients with KOA in a culturally sensitive manner that can supplement standard care. Prayer, or Salah, is a religious obligation typically performed in 17-48 daily repetitions of squatting, floor sitting, full-knee flexion, and kneeling. For patients with KOA, prayer can be painful, and a few studies have found a link between these repeated movements and KOA progression.

Carlina Teteris/Moment/Getty Images

Yet recommending stopping or limiting prayer is insensitive, so our group did a thorough literature search to identify easily implemented and culturally appropriate ways to ease praying.

Is there a traditional preference for praying on a hard surface?

Mr. Haque: Prayer can be performed on any surface that is clean and free from impurities. Cushioned and carpeted surfaces are permissible if the surface is somewhat firm and supportive for when worshippers prostrate themselves and put their faces on the ground. For example, compacted snow that wouldn’t allow the face to sink into it is permissible, but snow that is soft and would allow the face to sink in is not.

Have an increasing number of older patients raised the issue of knee pain during prayers?

Mr. Haque: We found no research on this in the literature. Anecdotally, however, two of our authors lead prayer in large Muslim communities in Detroit, and people often share with them that they feel discomfort during prayer and ask if there is anything they can do to limit this.

It is important to dispel the common myth that after total knee replacement one cannot kneel. About 20% of patients have some anterior knee discomfort after total knee arthroplasty, which can be exacerbated by kneeling, but kneeling causes no harm and can be done safely.

Could you outline the main recommendations?

Mr. Haque: These fall under three main categories: prayer surface, mechanics, and lifestyle modifications. The surface recommendations essentially advise using prayer rugs that provide cushioning or using cushioned kneepads.

The mechanics recommendations involve bracing with the palms down, standing up using the hands and knees, and guiding prayer motions with the hands. Chairs may be used as well.

Lifestyle recommendations outline home-exercise programs tailored to KOA and suggest the use of ice and compression during acute exacerbations.

Could these recommendations benefit other arthritic joints such as the wrists?

Mr. Haque: Anecdotally, our authors do not hear about pain in joints except for the knee and spine. To a limited extent, some of these recommendations may help patients with spinal arthritis as well.

What do you see as the greatest obstacle to implementation?

Mr. Haque: These recommendations, although permissible in the Muslim faith, are not part of traditional ritual and thus patients may simply forget to implement them. We advise physicians to ask patients which recommendations they are most likely to follow and to monitor how these have worked for them.

What is your best overall advice for broaching this issue with patients?

Mr. Haque: Holistic, functional, and culturally sensitive recommendations will be highly appreciated. Physicians are therefore encouraged to share this guidance with Muslim patients while using terms such as Salah, pronounced saa-laah, and Sajdah, pronounced sajduh and meaning prostration, and engage in a healthy dialogue.

These guidelines received no funding. The authors disclosed no competing interests relevant to their recommendations, but Dr. Magrey reported consulting and research relationships with private-sector companies outside of this work.

Adolescents and young adults who undergo “top surgery” for gender dysphoria overwhelmingly report being satisfied with the procedure in the near-term, new research shows.

The results of the prospective cohort study, reported recently in JAMA Pediatrics, suggest that the surgery can help facilitate gender congruence and comfort with body image for transmasculine and nonbinary youth. The authors, from Northwestern University, Chicago, said the findings may “help dispel misconceptions that gender-affirming treatment is experimental and support evidence-based practices of top surgery.”

Sumanas Jordan, MD, PhD, assistant professor of plastic surgery at Northwestern University, Chicago, and a coauthor of the study, said the study was the first prospective, matched cohort analysis showing that chest surgery improves outcomes in this age group.

“We focused our study on chest dysphoria, the distress due to the presence of breasts, and gender congruence, the feeling of alignment between identity and physical characteristics,” Dr. Jordan said. “We will continue to study the effect of surgery in other areas of health, such as physical functioning and quality of life, and follow our patients longer term.”

As many as 9% of adolescents and young adults identify as transgender or nonbinary - a group underrepresented in the pediatric literature, Dr. Jordan’s group said. Chest dysphoria often is associated with psychosocial issues such as depression and anxiety.

“Dysphoria can lead to a range of negative physical and emotional consequences, such as avoidance of exercise and sports, harmful chest-binding practices, functional limitations, and suicidal ideation, said M. Brett Cooper, MD, MEd, assistant professor of pediatrics, and adolescent and young adult medicine, at UT Southwestern Medical Center/Children’s Health, Dallas. “These young people often bind for several hours a day to reduce the presence of their chest.”

The study

The Northwestern team recruited 81 patients with a mean age of 18.6 years whose sex at birth was assigned female. Patients were overwhelmingly White (89%), and the majority (59%) were transgender male, the remaining patients nonbinary.

The population sample included patients aged 13-24 who underwent top surgery from December 2019 to April 2021 and a matched control group of those who did not have surgery.

Outcomes measures were assessed preoperatively and 3 months after surgery.

Thirty-six surgical patients and 34 of those in the control arm completed the outcomes measures. Surgical complications were minimal. Propensity analyses suggested an association between surgery and substantial improvements in scores on the following study endpoints:

• Chest dysphoria measure (–25.58 points, 95% confidence interval [CI], –29.18 to –21.98).
• Transgender congruence scale (7.78 points, 95%: CI, 6.06-9.50)
• Body image scale (–7.20 points, 95% CI, –11.68 to –2.72).

The patients who underwent top surgery reported significant improvements in scores of chest dysphoria, transgender congruence, and body image. The results for patients younger than age 18 paralleled those for older participants in the study.

While the results corroborate other studies showing that gender-affirming therapy improves mental health and quality of life among these young people, the researchers cautioned that some insurers require testosterone therapy for 1 year before their plans will cover the costs of gender-affirming surgery.

This may negatively affect those nonbinary patients who do not undergo hormone therapy,” the researchers wrote. They are currently collecting 1-year follow-up data to determine the long-term effects of top surgery on chest dysphoria, gender congruence, and body image.

As surgical patients progress through adult life, does the risk of regret increase? “We did not address regret in this short-term study,” Dr. Jordan said. “However, previous studies have shown very low levels of regret.”

An accompanying editorial concurred that top surgery is effective and medically necessary in this population of young people.

Calling the study “an important milestone in gender affirmation research,” Kishan M. Thadikonda, MD, and Katherine M. Gast, MD, MS, of the school of medicine and public health at the University of Wisconsin in Madison, said it will be important to follow this young cohort to prove these benefits will endure as patients age.

They cautioned, however, that nonbinary patients represented just 13% of the patient total and only 8% of the surgical cohort. Nonbinary patients are not well understood as a patient population when it comes to gender-affirmation surgery and are often included in studies with transgender patients despite clear differences, they noted.
 

Current setbacks

According to Dr. Cooper, politics is already affecting care in Texas. “Due to the sociopolitical climate in my state in regard to gender-affirming care, I have also seen a few young people have their surgeries either canceled or postponed by their parents,” he said. “This has led to a worsening of mental health in these patients.”

Dr. Cooper stressed the need for more research on the perspective of non-White and socioeconomically disadvantaged youth.

“This study also highlights the disparity between patients who have commercial insurance versus those who are on Medicaid,” he said. “Medicaid plans often do not cover this, so those patients usually have to continue to suffer or pay for this surgery out of their own pocket.”

This study was supported by the Northwestern University Clinical and Translational Sciences Institute, funded in part by the National Institutes of Health. Funding also came from the Plastic Surgery Foundation and American Association of Pediatric Plastic Surgery. Dr. Jordan received grants from the Plastic Surgery Foundation during the study. One coauthor reported consultant fees from CVS Caremark for consulting outside the submitted work, and another reported grants from the National Institutes of Health outside the submitted work. Dr. Cooper disclosed no competing interests relevant to his comments. The editorial commentators disclosed no conflicts of interest.

Adolescents and young adults who undergo “top surgery” for gender dysphoria overwhelmingly report being satisfied with the procedure in the near-term, new research shows.

The results of the prospective cohort study, reported recently in JAMA Pediatrics, suggest that the surgery can help facilitate gender congruence and comfort with body image for transmasculine and nonbinary youth. The authors, from Northwestern University, Chicago, said the findings may “help dispel misconceptions that gender-affirming treatment is experimental and support evidence-based practices of top surgery.”

Sumanas Jordan, MD, PhD, assistant professor of plastic surgery at Northwestern University, Chicago, and a coauthor of the study, said the study was the first prospective, matched cohort analysis showing that chest surgery improves outcomes in this age group.

“We focused our study on chest dysphoria, the distress due to the presence of breasts, and gender congruence, the feeling of alignment between identity and physical characteristics,” Dr. Jordan said. “We will continue to study the effect of surgery in other areas of health, such as physical functioning and quality of life, and follow our patients longer term.”

As many as 9% of adolescents and young adults identify as transgender or nonbinary - a group underrepresented in the pediatric literature, Dr. Jordan’s group said. Chest dysphoria often is associated with psychosocial issues such as depression and anxiety.

“Dysphoria can lead to a range of negative physical and emotional consequences, such as avoidance of exercise and sports, harmful chest-binding practices, functional limitations, and suicidal ideation, said M. Brett Cooper, MD, MEd, assistant professor of pediatrics, and adolescent and young adult medicine, at UT Southwestern Medical Center/Children’s Health, Dallas. “These young people often bind for several hours a day to reduce the presence of their chest.”

The study

The Northwestern team recruited 81 patients with a mean age of 18.6 years whose sex at birth was assigned female. Patients were overwhelmingly White (89%), and the majority (59%) were transgender male, the remaining patients nonbinary.

The population sample included patients aged 13-24 who underwent top surgery from December 2019 to April 2021 and a matched control group of those who did not have surgery.

Outcomes measures were assessed preoperatively and 3 months after surgery.

Thirty-six surgical patients and 34 of those in the control arm completed the outcomes measures. Surgical complications were minimal. Propensity analyses suggested an association between surgery and substantial improvements in scores on the following study endpoints:

• Chest dysphoria measure (–25.58 points, 95% confidence interval [CI], –29.18 to –21.98).
• Transgender congruence scale (7.78 points, 95%: CI, 6.06-9.50)
• Body image scale (–7.20 points, 95% CI, –11.68 to –2.72).

The patients who underwent top surgery reported significant improvements in scores of chest dysphoria, transgender congruence, and body image. The results for patients younger than age 18 paralleled those for older participants in the study.

While the results corroborate other studies showing that gender-affirming therapy improves mental health and quality of life among these young people, the researchers cautioned that some insurers require testosterone therapy for 1 year before their plans will cover the costs of gender-affirming surgery.

This may negatively affect those nonbinary patients who do not undergo hormone therapy,” the researchers wrote. They are currently collecting 1-year follow-up data to determine the long-term effects of top surgery on chest dysphoria, gender congruence, and body image.

As surgical patients progress through adult life, does the risk of regret increase? “We did not address regret in this short-term study,” Dr. Jordan said. “However, previous studies have shown very low levels of regret.”

An accompanying editorial concurred that top surgery is effective and medically necessary in this population of young people.

Calling the study “an important milestone in gender affirmation research,” Kishan M. Thadikonda, MD, and Katherine M. Gast, MD, MS, of the school of medicine and public health at the University of Wisconsin in Madison, said it will be important to follow this young cohort to prove these benefits will endure as patients age.

They cautioned, however, that nonbinary patients represented just 13% of the patient total and only 8% of the surgical cohort. Nonbinary patients are not well understood as a patient population when it comes to gender-affirmation surgery and are often included in studies with transgender patients despite clear differences, they noted.
 

Current setbacks

According to Dr. Cooper, politics is already affecting care in Texas. “Due to the sociopolitical climate in my state in regard to gender-affirming care, I have also seen a few young people have their surgeries either canceled or postponed by their parents,” he said. “This has led to a worsening of mental health in these patients.”

Dr. Cooper stressed the need for more research on the perspective of non-White and socioeconomically disadvantaged youth.

“This study also highlights the disparity between patients who have commercial insurance versus those who are on Medicaid,” he said. “Medicaid plans often do not cover this, so those patients usually have to continue to suffer or pay for this surgery out of their own pocket.”

This study was supported by the Northwestern University Clinical and Translational Sciences Institute, funded in part by the National Institutes of Health. Funding also came from the Plastic Surgery Foundation and American Association of Pediatric Plastic Surgery. Dr. Jordan received grants from the Plastic Surgery Foundation during the study. One coauthor reported consultant fees from CVS Caremark for consulting outside the submitted work, and another reported grants from the National Institutes of Health outside the submitted work. Dr. Cooper disclosed no competing interests relevant to his comments. The editorial commentators disclosed no conflicts of interest.

Adolescents and young adults who undergo “top surgery” for gender dysphoria overwhelmingly report being satisfied with the procedure in the near-term, new research shows.

The results of the prospective cohort study, reported recently in JAMA Pediatrics, suggest that the surgery can help facilitate gender congruence and comfort with body image for transmasculine and nonbinary youth. The authors, from Northwestern University, Chicago, said the findings may “help dispel misconceptions that gender-affirming treatment is experimental and support evidence-based practices of top surgery.”

Sumanas Jordan, MD, PhD, assistant professor of plastic surgery at Northwestern University, Chicago, and a coauthor of the study, said the study was the first prospective, matched cohort analysis showing that chest surgery improves outcomes in this age group.

“We focused our study on chest dysphoria, the distress due to the presence of breasts, and gender congruence, the feeling of alignment between identity and physical characteristics,” Dr. Jordan said. “We will continue to study the effect of surgery in other areas of health, such as physical functioning and quality of life, and follow our patients longer term.”

As many as 9% of adolescents and young adults identify as transgender or nonbinary - a group underrepresented in the pediatric literature, Dr. Jordan’s group said. Chest dysphoria often is associated with psychosocial issues such as depression and anxiety.

“Dysphoria can lead to a range of negative physical and emotional consequences, such as avoidance of exercise and sports, harmful chest-binding practices, functional limitations, and suicidal ideation, said M. Brett Cooper, MD, MEd, assistant professor of pediatrics, and adolescent and young adult medicine, at UT Southwestern Medical Center/Children’s Health, Dallas. “These young people often bind for several hours a day to reduce the presence of their chest.”

The study

The Northwestern team recruited 81 patients with a mean age of 18.6 years whose sex at birth was assigned female. Patients were overwhelmingly White (89%), and the majority (59%) were transgender male, the remaining patients nonbinary.

The population sample included patients aged 13-24 who underwent top surgery from December 2019 to April 2021 and a matched control group of those who did not have surgery.

Outcomes measures were assessed preoperatively and 3 months after surgery.

Thirty-six surgical patients and 34 of those in the control arm completed the outcomes measures. Surgical complications were minimal. Propensity analyses suggested an association between surgery and substantial improvements in scores on the following study endpoints:

• Chest dysphoria measure (–25.58 points, 95% confidence interval [CI], –29.18 to –21.98).
• Transgender congruence scale (7.78 points, 95%: CI, 6.06-9.50)
• Body image scale (–7.20 points, 95% CI, –11.68 to –2.72).

The patients who underwent top surgery reported significant improvements in scores of chest dysphoria, transgender congruence, and body image. The results for patients younger than age 18 paralleled those for older participants in the study.

While the results corroborate other studies showing that gender-affirming therapy improves mental health and quality of life among these young people, the researchers cautioned that some insurers require testosterone therapy for 1 year before their plans will cover the costs of gender-affirming surgery.

This may negatively affect those nonbinary patients who do not undergo hormone therapy,” the researchers wrote. They are currently collecting 1-year follow-up data to determine the long-term effects of top surgery on chest dysphoria, gender congruence, and body image.

As surgical patients progress through adult life, does the risk of regret increase? “We did not address regret in this short-term study,” Dr. Jordan said. “However, previous studies have shown very low levels of regret.”

An accompanying editorial concurred that top surgery is effective and medically necessary in this population of young people.

Calling the study “an important milestone in gender affirmation research,” Kishan M. Thadikonda, MD, and Katherine M. Gast, MD, MS, of the school of medicine and public health at the University of Wisconsin in Madison, said it will be important to follow this young cohort to prove these benefits will endure as patients age.

They cautioned, however, that nonbinary patients represented just 13% of the patient total and only 8% of the surgical cohort. Nonbinary patients are not well understood as a patient population when it comes to gender-affirmation surgery and are often included in studies with transgender patients despite clear differences, they noted.
 

Current setbacks

According to Dr. Cooper, politics is already affecting care in Texas. “Due to the sociopolitical climate in my state in regard to gender-affirming care, I have also seen a few young people have their surgeries either canceled or postponed by their parents,” he said. “This has led to a worsening of mental health in these patients.”

Dr. Cooper stressed the need for more research on the perspective of non-White and socioeconomically disadvantaged youth.

“This study also highlights the disparity between patients who have commercial insurance versus those who are on Medicaid,” he said. “Medicaid plans often do not cover this, so those patients usually have to continue to suffer or pay for this surgery out of their own pocket.”

This study was supported by the Northwestern University Clinical and Translational Sciences Institute, funded in part by the National Institutes of Health. Funding also came from the Plastic Surgery Foundation and American Association of Pediatric Plastic Surgery. Dr. Jordan received grants from the Plastic Surgery Foundation during the study. One coauthor reported consultant fees from CVS Caremark for consulting outside the submitted work, and another reported grants from the National Institutes of Health outside the submitted work. Dr. Cooper disclosed no competing interests relevant to his comments. The editorial commentators disclosed no conflicts of interest.

The commonly used but sometimes debated Ages and Stages Questionnaire (ASQ), has modest utility for identifying developmental delays in young children, an Australian review and meta-analysis found.

On this easily administered parent-completed screening tool, scores of more than 2 standard deviations below the mean in more than one of five domains had moderate sensitivity and specificity to predict any delay, severe delay, motor delay, and cognitive delay, according to neonatologist Shripada Rao, PhD, a clinical associate professor in the neonatal intensive care unit at Perth Hospital and the University of Western Australia, also in Perth, and colleagues.

If a child of 12-60 months passes all ASQ domains, there is a moderate probability that child does not have severe developmental delay, the researchers concluded. If a child in that age range fails the motor or cognitive domain, there is a moderate probability that some motor or cognitive delay is present. The authors say the tool may work best as a screening test to identify children in need of more formal assessment.

“Our meta-analysis found that ASQ was somewhat more predictive in older children (older than 24 months), compared with younger age groups of 12-24 months,” Dr. Rao said in an interview. “However, the sample size for these comparisons was too small to reach definite conclusions, and we have called for future studies to evaluate ASQ separately for different age groups.”

Early identification of developmental delay in children is essential to enable timely intervention,” Dr. Rao and associates wrote in JAMA Pediatrics.

While formal assessments such as the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development are the gold standard, they are time-consuming and expensive, need the physical attendance of both the child and caregivers, and “thus may not be feasible in resource-limited settings or in pandemic conditions.”

According to Barbara J. Howard, MD, commenting on a recent update to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention’s developmental milestones guide, Learn the Signs. Act Early, fewer than 25% of children with delays or disabilities receive intervention before age 3 and most with emotional, behavioral, and developmental condition, other than autism spectrum disorder receive no intervention before age 5.
 

The ASQ

As an accessible alternative, the ASQ consists of questions on communication (language), gross-motor, fine-motor, problem-solving (cognitive), and personal-adaptive skills. The survey requires only 10-15 minutes, is relatively inexpensive, and also establishes a sense of parental involvement, the authors noted.

“Based on the generally accepted interpretation of LR [likelihood ratio] values, if a child passes ASQ-2SD, there is a moderate probability that the child does not have severe delay,” the investigators concluded.
 

The analysis

The final meta-analysis reviewed 36 eligible ASQ studies published from 1997 to 2022. Looking at the four indicators of pooled sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative likelihood ratios, the following respective predictive values emerged for scores of more than 2 SDs below the mean across several domains: sensitivity of 0.77 (95% confidence interval, 0.64-0.86), specificity of 0.81 (95% CI 0.75-0.86), positive likelihood ratio of 4.10 (95% CI 3.17-5.30), and a negative likelihood ratio of 0.28 (95% CI, 0.18-0.44)

They cautioned, however, that the certainty of evidence from the reviewed studies was low or very low and given the small sample sizes for comparing domains, clinicians should be circumspect in interpreting the results.
 

An initial step

Commenting on the paper but not involved in it, David G. Fagan, MD, vice chairman of pediatric ambulatory administration in the department of pediatrics at Cohen Children’s Medical Center, New York, agreed that screening tools such as the ASQ have a place in clinical practice. “However, the purpose of a screening tool is not to make the diagnosis but to identify children at risk for developmental delays,” he said in an interview. “The meta-analysis highlights the fact that no screening is 100% accurate and that results need to be interpreted in context.

“Before screening tools were widely used, pediatricians trusted their gut,” Dr. Fagan continued. “‘I know it when I see it,’ which obviously resulted in tremendous variability based on experience.”

He added that, even if a child passes this validated questionnaire, any concern on the part of a parent or pediatrician about developmental delay should be addressed with further assessment.
 

The future

According to Dr. Rao, clinicians should continue to screen for developmental delays in young children using the ASQ. “Given the long wait times to see a developmental pediatrician or a clinical psychologist, a screening tool such as ASQ will enable appropriate triaging.”

Going forward, however, studies should evaluate this questionnaire separately for different age groups such as less than 12 months, 12-23 months, and at least 24 months. They should also be prospective in design and entail a low risk of bias, as well as report raw numbers for true and false positives and negatives. “Even if they use their own cutoff ASQ scores, they should also give results for the conventional cutoff scores to enable comparison with other studies,” the authors wrote.

The authors disclosed no specific funding for this study and no competing interests. Dr. Fagan disclosed no competing interests with regard to his comments.

The commonly used but sometimes debated Ages and Stages Questionnaire (ASQ), has modest utility for identifying developmental delays in young children, an Australian review and meta-analysis found.

On this easily administered parent-completed screening tool, scores of more than 2 standard deviations below the mean in more than one of five domains had moderate sensitivity and specificity to predict any delay, severe delay, motor delay, and cognitive delay, according to neonatologist Shripada Rao, PhD, a clinical associate professor in the neonatal intensive care unit at Perth Hospital and the University of Western Australia, also in Perth, and colleagues.

If a child of 12-60 months passes all ASQ domains, there is a moderate probability that child does not have severe developmental delay, the researchers concluded. If a child in that age range fails the motor or cognitive domain, there is a moderate probability that some motor or cognitive delay is present. The authors say the tool may work best as a screening test to identify children in need of more formal assessment.

“Our meta-analysis found that ASQ was somewhat more predictive in older children (older than 24 months), compared with younger age groups of 12-24 months,” Dr. Rao said in an interview. “However, the sample size for these comparisons was too small to reach definite conclusions, and we have called for future studies to evaluate ASQ separately for different age groups.”

Early identification of developmental delay in children is essential to enable timely intervention,” Dr. Rao and associates wrote in JAMA Pediatrics.

While formal assessments such as the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development are the gold standard, they are time-consuming and expensive, need the physical attendance of both the child and caregivers, and “thus may not be feasible in resource-limited settings or in pandemic conditions.”

According to Barbara J. Howard, MD, commenting on a recent update to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention’s developmental milestones guide, Learn the Signs. Act Early, fewer than 25% of children with delays or disabilities receive intervention before age 3 and most with emotional, behavioral, and developmental condition, other than autism spectrum disorder receive no intervention before age 5.
 

The ASQ

As an accessible alternative, the ASQ consists of questions on communication (language), gross-motor, fine-motor, problem-solving (cognitive), and personal-adaptive skills. The survey requires only 10-15 minutes, is relatively inexpensive, and also establishes a sense of parental involvement, the authors noted.

“Based on the generally accepted interpretation of LR [likelihood ratio] values, if a child passes ASQ-2SD, there is a moderate probability that the child does not have severe delay,” the investigators concluded.
 

The analysis

The final meta-analysis reviewed 36 eligible ASQ studies published from 1997 to 2022. Looking at the four indicators of pooled sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative likelihood ratios, the following respective predictive values emerged for scores of more than 2 SDs below the mean across several domains: sensitivity of 0.77 (95% confidence interval, 0.64-0.86), specificity of 0.81 (95% CI 0.75-0.86), positive likelihood ratio of 4.10 (95% CI 3.17-5.30), and a negative likelihood ratio of 0.28 (95% CI, 0.18-0.44)

They cautioned, however, that the certainty of evidence from the reviewed studies was low or very low and given the small sample sizes for comparing domains, clinicians should be circumspect in interpreting the results.
 

An initial step

Commenting on the paper but not involved in it, David G. Fagan, MD, vice chairman of pediatric ambulatory administration in the department of pediatrics at Cohen Children’s Medical Center, New York, agreed that screening tools such as the ASQ have a place in clinical practice. “However, the purpose of a screening tool is not to make the diagnosis but to identify children at risk for developmental delays,” he said in an interview. “The meta-analysis highlights the fact that no screening is 100% accurate and that results need to be interpreted in context.

“Before screening tools were widely used, pediatricians trusted their gut,” Dr. Fagan continued. “‘I know it when I see it,’ which obviously resulted in tremendous variability based on experience.”

He added that, even if a child passes this validated questionnaire, any concern on the part of a parent or pediatrician about developmental delay should be addressed with further assessment.
 

The future

According to Dr. Rao, clinicians should continue to screen for developmental delays in young children using the ASQ. “Given the long wait times to see a developmental pediatrician or a clinical psychologist, a screening tool such as ASQ will enable appropriate triaging.”

Going forward, however, studies should evaluate this questionnaire separately for different age groups such as less than 12 months, 12-23 months, and at least 24 months. They should also be prospective in design and entail a low risk of bias, as well as report raw numbers for true and false positives and negatives. “Even if they use their own cutoff ASQ scores, they should also give results for the conventional cutoff scores to enable comparison with other studies,” the authors wrote.

The authors disclosed no specific funding for this study and no competing interests. Dr. Fagan disclosed no competing interests with regard to his comments.

The commonly used but sometimes debated Ages and Stages Questionnaire (ASQ), has modest utility for identifying developmental delays in young children, an Australian review and meta-analysis found.

On this easily administered parent-completed screening tool, scores of more than 2 standard deviations below the mean in more than one of five domains had moderate sensitivity and specificity to predict any delay, severe delay, motor delay, and cognitive delay, according to neonatologist Shripada Rao, PhD, a clinical associate professor in the neonatal intensive care unit at Perth Hospital and the University of Western Australia, also in Perth, and colleagues.

If a child of 12-60 months passes all ASQ domains, there is a moderate probability that child does not have severe developmental delay, the researchers concluded. If a child in that age range fails the motor or cognitive domain, there is a moderate probability that some motor or cognitive delay is present. The authors say the tool may work best as a screening test to identify children in need of more formal assessment.

“Our meta-analysis found that ASQ was somewhat more predictive in older children (older than 24 months), compared with younger age groups of 12-24 months,” Dr. Rao said in an interview. “However, the sample size for these comparisons was too small to reach definite conclusions, and we have called for future studies to evaluate ASQ separately for different age groups.”

Early identification of developmental delay in children is essential to enable timely intervention,” Dr. Rao and associates wrote in JAMA Pediatrics.

While formal assessments such as the Bayley Scales of Infant and Toddler Development are the gold standard, they are time-consuming and expensive, need the physical attendance of both the child and caregivers, and “thus may not be feasible in resource-limited settings or in pandemic conditions.”

According to Barbara J. Howard, MD, commenting on a recent update to the Center for Disease Control and Prevention’s developmental milestones guide, Learn the Signs. Act Early, fewer than 25% of children with delays or disabilities receive intervention before age 3 and most with emotional, behavioral, and developmental condition, other than autism spectrum disorder receive no intervention before age 5.
 

The ASQ

As an accessible alternative, the ASQ consists of questions on communication (language), gross-motor, fine-motor, problem-solving (cognitive), and personal-adaptive skills. The survey requires only 10-15 minutes, is relatively inexpensive, and also establishes a sense of parental involvement, the authors noted.

“Based on the generally accepted interpretation of LR [likelihood ratio] values, if a child passes ASQ-2SD, there is a moderate probability that the child does not have severe delay,” the investigators concluded.
 

The analysis

The final meta-analysis reviewed 36 eligible ASQ studies published from 1997 to 2022. Looking at the four indicators of pooled sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative likelihood ratios, the following respective predictive values emerged for scores of more than 2 SDs below the mean across several domains: sensitivity of 0.77 (95% confidence interval, 0.64-0.86), specificity of 0.81 (95% CI 0.75-0.86), positive likelihood ratio of 4.10 (95% CI 3.17-5.30), and a negative likelihood ratio of 0.28 (95% CI, 0.18-0.44)

They cautioned, however, that the certainty of evidence from the reviewed studies was low or very low and given the small sample sizes for comparing domains, clinicians should be circumspect in interpreting the results.
 

An initial step

Commenting on the paper but not involved in it, David G. Fagan, MD, vice chairman of pediatric ambulatory administration in the department of pediatrics at Cohen Children’s Medical Center, New York, agreed that screening tools such as the ASQ have a place in clinical practice. “However, the purpose of a screening tool is not to make the diagnosis but to identify children at risk for developmental delays,” he said in an interview. “The meta-analysis highlights the fact that no screening is 100% accurate and that results need to be interpreted in context.

“Before screening tools were widely used, pediatricians trusted their gut,” Dr. Fagan continued. “‘I know it when I see it,’ which obviously resulted in tremendous variability based on experience.”

He added that, even if a child passes this validated questionnaire, any concern on the part of a parent or pediatrician about developmental delay should be addressed with further assessment.
 

The future

According to Dr. Rao, clinicians should continue to screen for developmental delays in young children using the ASQ. “Given the long wait times to see a developmental pediatrician or a clinical psychologist, a screening tool such as ASQ will enable appropriate triaging.”

Going forward, however, studies should evaluate this questionnaire separately for different age groups such as less than 12 months, 12-23 months, and at least 24 months. They should also be prospective in design and entail a low risk of bias, as well as report raw numbers for true and false positives and negatives. “Even if they use their own cutoff ASQ scores, they should also give results for the conventional cutoff scores to enable comparison with other studies,” the authors wrote.

The authors disclosed no specific funding for this study and no competing interests. Dr. Fagan disclosed no competing interests with regard to his comments.

The use of laparoscopic power morcellators for minimally invasive hysterectomy has significantly decreased, and while the use of containment bags increased after the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s 2014 safety warning about power morcellators, most procedures employing them are still performed without bags, according to a large database study in Obstetrics & Gynecology.

Containment bags are thought to limit the dissemination of potentially pathologic tissue, including unsuspected cancerous cells.

Rates of uterine cancer in women having morcellation were similar before and after the 2014 FDA guidance, and containment bags were used in only a small proportion of women with uterine cancer, according to findings from a research group led by Jason D. Wright, MD, of the division of gynecologic oncology at Columbia University, New York.

“Despite warnings from professional societies and regulatory agencies, as well as intense public scrutiny after the FDA warnings, the majority of morcellated uterine cancers occurred with uncontained laparoscopic power morcellation,” Dr. Wright and associates wrote, adding that the findings have important policy implications. First, efforts are needed to ensure morcellation is avoided in women with pathologic abnormalities. Second, despite regulatory approval, the safety and efficacy of containment bags remain uncertain, and the use and outcomes of these devices should be monitored closely.

The authors noted that laparoscopic power morcellation with a containment bag actually carries a small but significant increase in the risk of complications, compared with uncontained morcellation.

The study

Drawing on the Premier Healthcare Database, the researchers looked at deidentified patients aged 18 years or older who underwent laparoscopic supracervical hysterectomy from 2010 to 2018. The largest age group having the procedure consisted of women aged 40-49.

Patients were stratified based on use of laparoscopic power morcellators.

The cohort was further stratified as either pre–FDA guidance (2010 quarter 1 to 2014 quarter 1) or post–FDA guidance (2014 quarter 2 to 2018 quarter 2).

In the final cohort of 67,115 patients, laparoscopic power morcellator use decreased from 66.7% in 2013 quarter 4 to 13.3% by 2018 quarter 2. The likelihood of using this device decreased by 9.5% for each quarter elapsed in the post–FDA warning period (risk ratio, 0.91; 95% confidence interval, 0.90-0.91).

In other findings, containment bag use rose from 5.2% in 2013 quarter 4 to 15.2% by 2018 quarter 2. The likelihood of containment bag use rose by 3% for each quarter elapsed in the post–FDA warning period (RR, 1.03; 95% CI, 1.02-1.05).

Among women who underwent surgery with laparoscopic power morcellator use, uterine cancers or sarcomas were identified in 54 (0.17%) before the FDA guidance, compared with 7 (0.12%) after the guidance (P = .45).

Containment bags were used in 11.1% of women with uterine cancers or sarcomas before the FDA guidance, compared with 14.3% after the guidance (P = .12). The perioperative complication rate was 3.3% among women who had laparoscopic power morcellator use without a containment bag, compared with 4.5% (P = .001) in those with a containment bag (adjusted RR, 1.35; 95% CI, 1.12-1.64).

A related editorial argued that the backlash against power morcellation was unwarranted and an example of “reactionary medicine.”

Ben A. Abdu, MD, and Cameron Lowry, MD, of the department of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center in Memphis, noted that with the known advantages of laparoscopy over laparotomy – decreased blood loss, decreased pain, and fewer wound complications and infections – it is of paramount importance to continue to offer minimally invasive surgery whenever possible. After the FDA raised safety concerns, there was a rise in the rate of open abdominal hysterectomy, which was accompanied by an increase in surgical morbidity. “Perhaps for now we should avoid throwing the baby out with the bath water,” they wrote.

The editorialists pointed out that any surgery may entail unintended complications. “It is also important to remember that there is a risk of dissemination of malignant tissue whether or not power morcellation is used, and it has even been observed in laparotomy,” they stated, noting that bag rupture and tissue spillage can occur even when the containment bag remains intact.

The downward trend in the use of power morcellators observed by Dr. Wright’s group is of serious concern, the commentators added, especially because the FDA communication was made in response to a rare occurrence and possibly resting on an overestimation of risk. “Based on their review of the medical literature at the time, the FDA cited prevalence estimates of 1 in 352 for any uterine sarcoma and 1 in 498 for leiomyosarcoma,” they wrote. “Many authors have expressed concern that the FDA data review was overestimated.” For example, they cite a meta-analysis using prospective data in which the prevalence of occult leiomyosarcoma was estimated at 1 in 8,300. Despite this extremely low prevalence, there has been an almost total nationwide hospital moratorium on the use of power morcellation, which will likely continue. Some manufacturers have ceased or limited production, distribution, and sales of these devices, they noted.

According to Dr. Michael L. Nimaroff, MD, however, chief of minimally invasive gynecologic surgery at Northwell Health in New Hyde Park, N.Y., the general post–FDA-guidance backlash did not have much effect on expert practitioners in this surgical field. “Those of us who specialize in minimally invasive gynecologic surgery, which has many benefits for the patients, never pivoted,” he told this news organization. “We continued to perform it but more conscientiously and with more concern for safety.”

As for morcellator use, added Dr. Nimaroff, specialists were so accustomed to doing these surgeries before the containment systems were made available that they don’t miss the power morcellator. “We actually retrieve tissue manually, and most of our morcellations, if they’re not contained manually, are retrieved vaginally or through a slightly bigger incision. So patients still benefit from minimally invasive surgery, and in some cases these techniques actually shorten the operation.”

This study received no external funding. Dr. Wright is editor in chief of Obstetrics & Gynecology. He reported royalties from UpToDate and has received research support from Merck. Coauthor Dr. Hou has served as a consultant for Foundation Medicine and Natera. Dr. Abdu and Dr. Lowry disclosed no competing interests, as did Dr. Nimaroff.

The use of laparoscopic power morcellators for minimally invasive hysterectomy has significantly decreased, and while the use of containment bags increased after the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s 2014 safety warning about power morcellators, most procedures employing them are still performed without bags, according to a large database study in Obstetrics & Gynecology.

Containment bags are thought to limit the dissemination of potentially pathologic tissue, including unsuspected cancerous cells.

Rates of uterine cancer in women having morcellation were similar before and after the 2014 FDA guidance, and containment bags were used in only a small proportion of women with uterine cancer, according to findings from a research group led by Jason D. Wright, MD, of the division of gynecologic oncology at Columbia University, New York.

“Despite warnings from professional societies and regulatory agencies, as well as intense public scrutiny after the FDA warnings, the majority of morcellated uterine cancers occurred with uncontained laparoscopic power morcellation,” Dr. Wright and associates wrote, adding that the findings have important policy implications. First, efforts are needed to ensure morcellation is avoided in women with pathologic abnormalities. Second, despite regulatory approval, the safety and efficacy of containment bags remain uncertain, and the use and outcomes of these devices should be monitored closely.

The authors noted that laparoscopic power morcellation with a containment bag actually carries a small but significant increase in the risk of complications, compared with uncontained morcellation.

The study

Drawing on the Premier Healthcare Database, the researchers looked at deidentified patients aged 18 years or older who underwent laparoscopic supracervical hysterectomy from 2010 to 2018. The largest age group having the procedure consisted of women aged 40-49.

Patients were stratified based on use of laparoscopic power morcellators.

The cohort was further stratified as either pre–FDA guidance (2010 quarter 1 to 2014 quarter 1) or post–FDA guidance (2014 quarter 2 to 2018 quarter 2).

In the final cohort of 67,115 patients, laparoscopic power morcellator use decreased from 66.7% in 2013 quarter 4 to 13.3% by 2018 quarter 2. The likelihood of using this device decreased by 9.5% for each quarter elapsed in the post–FDA warning period (risk ratio, 0.91; 95% confidence interval, 0.90-0.91).

In other findings, containment bag use rose from 5.2% in 2013 quarter 4 to 15.2% by 2018 quarter 2. The likelihood of containment bag use rose by 3% for each quarter elapsed in the post–FDA warning period (RR, 1.03; 95% CI, 1.02-1.05).

Among women who underwent surgery with laparoscopic power morcellator use, uterine cancers or sarcomas were identified in 54 (0.17%) before the FDA guidance, compared with 7 (0.12%) after the guidance (P = .45).

Containment bags were used in 11.1% of women with uterine cancers or sarcomas before the FDA guidance, compared with 14.3% after the guidance (P = .12). The perioperative complication rate was 3.3% among women who had laparoscopic power morcellator use without a containment bag, compared with 4.5% (P = .001) in those with a containment bag (adjusted RR, 1.35; 95% CI, 1.12-1.64).

A related editorial argued that the backlash against power morcellation was unwarranted and an example of “reactionary medicine.”

Ben A. Abdu, MD, and Cameron Lowry, MD, of the department of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center in Memphis, noted that with the known advantages of laparoscopy over laparotomy – decreased blood loss, decreased pain, and fewer wound complications and infections – it is of paramount importance to continue to offer minimally invasive surgery whenever possible. After the FDA raised safety concerns, there was a rise in the rate of open abdominal hysterectomy, which was accompanied by an increase in surgical morbidity. “Perhaps for now we should avoid throwing the baby out with the bath water,” they wrote.

The editorialists pointed out that any surgery may entail unintended complications. “It is also important to remember that there is a risk of dissemination of malignant tissue whether or not power morcellation is used, and it has even been observed in laparotomy,” they stated, noting that bag rupture and tissue spillage can occur even when the containment bag remains intact.

The downward trend in the use of power morcellators observed by Dr. Wright’s group is of serious concern, the commentators added, especially because the FDA communication was made in response to a rare occurrence and possibly resting on an overestimation of risk. “Based on their review of the medical literature at the time, the FDA cited prevalence estimates of 1 in 352 for any uterine sarcoma and 1 in 498 for leiomyosarcoma,” they wrote. “Many authors have expressed concern that the FDA data review was overestimated.” For example, they cite a meta-analysis using prospective data in which the prevalence of occult leiomyosarcoma was estimated at 1 in 8,300. Despite this extremely low prevalence, there has been an almost total nationwide hospital moratorium on the use of power morcellation, which will likely continue. Some manufacturers have ceased or limited production, distribution, and sales of these devices, they noted.

According to Dr. Michael L. Nimaroff, MD, however, chief of minimally invasive gynecologic surgery at Northwell Health in New Hyde Park, N.Y., the general post–FDA-guidance backlash did not have much effect on expert practitioners in this surgical field. “Those of us who specialize in minimally invasive gynecologic surgery, which has many benefits for the patients, never pivoted,” he told this news organization. “We continued to perform it but more conscientiously and with more concern for safety.”

As for morcellator use, added Dr. Nimaroff, specialists were so accustomed to doing these surgeries before the containment systems were made available that they don’t miss the power morcellator. “We actually retrieve tissue manually, and most of our morcellations, if they’re not contained manually, are retrieved vaginally or through a slightly bigger incision. So patients still benefit from minimally invasive surgery, and in some cases these techniques actually shorten the operation.”

This study received no external funding. Dr. Wright is editor in chief of Obstetrics & Gynecology. He reported royalties from UpToDate and has received research support from Merck. Coauthor Dr. Hou has served as a consultant for Foundation Medicine and Natera. Dr. Abdu and Dr. Lowry disclosed no competing interests, as did Dr. Nimaroff.

The use of laparoscopic power morcellators for minimally invasive hysterectomy has significantly decreased, and while the use of containment bags increased after the U.S. Food and Drug Administration’s 2014 safety warning about power morcellators, most procedures employing them are still performed without bags, according to a large database study in Obstetrics & Gynecology.

Containment bags are thought to limit the dissemination of potentially pathologic tissue, including unsuspected cancerous cells.

Rates of uterine cancer in women having morcellation were similar before and after the 2014 FDA guidance, and containment bags were used in only a small proportion of women with uterine cancer, according to findings from a research group led by Jason D. Wright, MD, of the division of gynecologic oncology at Columbia University, New York.

“Despite warnings from professional societies and regulatory agencies, as well as intense public scrutiny after the FDA warnings, the majority of morcellated uterine cancers occurred with uncontained laparoscopic power morcellation,” Dr. Wright and associates wrote, adding that the findings have important policy implications. First, efforts are needed to ensure morcellation is avoided in women with pathologic abnormalities. Second, despite regulatory approval, the safety and efficacy of containment bags remain uncertain, and the use and outcomes of these devices should be monitored closely.

The authors noted that laparoscopic power morcellation with a containment bag actually carries a small but significant increase in the risk of complications, compared with uncontained morcellation.

The study

Drawing on the Premier Healthcare Database, the researchers looked at deidentified patients aged 18 years or older who underwent laparoscopic supracervical hysterectomy from 2010 to 2018. The largest age group having the procedure consisted of women aged 40-49.

Patients were stratified based on use of laparoscopic power morcellators.

The cohort was further stratified as either pre–FDA guidance (2010 quarter 1 to 2014 quarter 1) or post–FDA guidance (2014 quarter 2 to 2018 quarter 2).

In the final cohort of 67,115 patients, laparoscopic power morcellator use decreased from 66.7% in 2013 quarter 4 to 13.3% by 2018 quarter 2. The likelihood of using this device decreased by 9.5% for each quarter elapsed in the post–FDA warning period (risk ratio, 0.91; 95% confidence interval, 0.90-0.91).

In other findings, containment bag use rose from 5.2% in 2013 quarter 4 to 15.2% by 2018 quarter 2. The likelihood of containment bag use rose by 3% for each quarter elapsed in the post–FDA warning period (RR, 1.03; 95% CI, 1.02-1.05).

Among women who underwent surgery with laparoscopic power morcellator use, uterine cancers or sarcomas were identified in 54 (0.17%) before the FDA guidance, compared with 7 (0.12%) after the guidance (P = .45).

Containment bags were used in 11.1% of women with uterine cancers or sarcomas before the FDA guidance, compared with 14.3% after the guidance (P = .12). The perioperative complication rate was 3.3% among women who had laparoscopic power morcellator use without a containment bag, compared with 4.5% (P = .001) in those with a containment bag (adjusted RR, 1.35; 95% CI, 1.12-1.64).

A related editorial argued that the backlash against power morcellation was unwarranted and an example of “reactionary medicine.”

Ben A. Abdu, MD, and Cameron Lowry, MD, of the department of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Tennessee Health Science Center in Memphis, noted that with the known advantages of laparoscopy over laparotomy – decreased blood loss, decreased pain, and fewer wound complications and infections – it is of paramount importance to continue to offer minimally invasive surgery whenever possible. After the FDA raised safety concerns, there was a rise in the rate of open abdominal hysterectomy, which was accompanied by an increase in surgical morbidity. “Perhaps for now we should avoid throwing the baby out with the bath water,” they wrote.

The editorialists pointed out that any surgery may entail unintended complications. “It is also important to remember that there is a risk of dissemination of malignant tissue whether or not power morcellation is used, and it has even been observed in laparotomy,” they stated, noting that bag rupture and tissue spillage can occur even when the containment bag remains intact.

The downward trend in the use of power morcellators observed by Dr. Wright’s group is of serious concern, the commentators added, especially because the FDA communication was made in response to a rare occurrence and possibly resting on an overestimation of risk. “Based on their review of the medical literature at the time, the FDA cited prevalence estimates of 1 in 352 for any uterine sarcoma and 1 in 498 for leiomyosarcoma,” they wrote. “Many authors have expressed concern that the FDA data review was overestimated.” For example, they cite a meta-analysis using prospective data in which the prevalence of occult leiomyosarcoma was estimated at 1 in 8,300. Despite this extremely low prevalence, there has been an almost total nationwide hospital moratorium on the use of power morcellation, which will likely continue. Some manufacturers have ceased or limited production, distribution, and sales of these devices, they noted.

According to Dr. Michael L. Nimaroff, MD, however, chief of minimally invasive gynecologic surgery at Northwell Health in New Hyde Park, N.Y., the general post–FDA-guidance backlash did not have much effect on expert practitioners in this surgical field. “Those of us who specialize in minimally invasive gynecologic surgery, which has many benefits for the patients, never pivoted,” he told this news organization. “We continued to perform it but more conscientiously and with more concern for safety.”

As for morcellator use, added Dr. Nimaroff, specialists were so accustomed to doing these surgeries before the containment systems were made available that they don’t miss the power morcellator. “We actually retrieve tissue manually, and most of our morcellations, if they’re not contained manually, are retrieved vaginally or through a slightly bigger incision. So patients still benefit from minimally invasive surgery, and in some cases these techniques actually shorten the operation.”

This study received no external funding. Dr. Wright is editor in chief of Obstetrics & Gynecology. He reported royalties from UpToDate and has received research support from Merck. Coauthor Dr. Hou has served as a consultant for Foundation Medicine and Natera. Dr. Abdu and Dr. Lowry disclosed no competing interests, as did Dr. Nimaroff.

Midlife women who are of normal weight or are overweight should routinely receive counseling aimed at limiting weight gain and preventing obesity and its associated health risks, a new clinical guideline states.

The recommendation, issued by the Women’s Preventive Services Initiative (WPSI) of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), supports regular lifestyle counseling for women aged 40-60 years with normal or overweight body mass index of 18.5-29.9 kg/m². Counseling could include individualized discussion of healthy eating and physical activity initiated by health professionals involved in preventive care.

Published online in Annals of Internal Medicine, the guideline addresses the prevalence and health burdens of obesity in U.S. women of middle age and seeks to reduce the known harms of obesity with an intervention of minimal anticipated harms. High BMI increases the risk for many chronic conditions including hypertension, dyslipidemia, type 2 diabetes, coronary artery disease, stroke, and all-cause mortality.

The best way to counsel, however, remains unclear. “Although the optimal approach could not be discerned from existing trials, a range of interventions of varying duration, frequency, and intensity showed benefit with potential clinical significance,” wrote the WPSI guideline panel, led by David P. Chelmow, MD, chair of the department of obstetrics and gynecology at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond.

The guideline rests on a systematic literature review led by family doctor Amy G. Cantor, MD, MPH, of the Pacific Northwest Evidence-based Practice Center, at Oregon Health & Science University in Portland, suggesting moderate reductions in weight could be achieved by offering advice to this age group.

The federally supported WPSI was launched by ACOG in 2016. The guideline fills a gap in current recommendations in that it targets a specific risk group and specifies individual counseling based on its effectiveness and applicability in primary care settings.

In another benefit of routine counseling, the panel stated, “Normalizing counseling about healthy diet and physical activity by providing it to all midlife women may also mitigate concerns about weight stigma resulting from only counseling women with obesity.”

The panelists noted that during 2017-2018, the prevalence of obesity (BMI ≥ 30.0 kg/m²) was 43.3% among U.S. women aged 40-59 years, while the prevalence of severe obesity (BMI ≥ 40.0 kg/m²) was highest in this age group at 11.5%. “Midlife women gain weight at an average of approximately 1.5 pounds per year, which increases their risk for transitioning from normal or overweight to obese BMI,” the panelists wrote.

The review

Dr. Cantor’s group analyzed seven randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published up to October 2021 from 12 publications involving 51,638 participants. Although the trials were largely small and heterogeneous, they suggested that counseling may result in modest differences in weight change without causing important harms.

Four RCTs showed significant favorable weight changes for counseling over no-counseling control groups, with a mean difference of 0.87 to 2.5 kg, whereas one trial of counseling and two trials of exercise showed no differences. One of two RCTs reported improved quality-of-life measures.

As for harms, while interventions did not increase measures of depression or stress in one trial, self-reported falls (37% vs. 29%, P < .001) and injuries (19% vs. 14%, P = .03) were more frequent with exercise counseling in one trial.

“More research is needed to determine optimal content, frequency, length, and number of sessions required and should include additional patient populations,” Dr. Cantor and associates wrote.

In terms of limitations, the authors acknowledged that trials of behavioral interventions in maintaining or reducing weight in midlife women demonstrate small magnitudes of effect.

Offering a nonparticipant’s perspective on the WPSI guideline for this news organization, JoAnn E. Manson, MD, DrPH, MACP, chief of the division of preventive medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, said its message is of prime importance for women of middle age and it goes beyond concern about pounds lost or gained.

“Midlife and the transition to menopause are high-risk periods for women in terms of typical changes in body composition that increase the risk of adverse cardiometabolic outcomes,” said Dr. Manson, professor of women’s health at Harvard Medical School, Boston. “Counseling women should be a priority for physicians in clinical practice. And it’s not just whether weight gain is reflected on the scales or not but whether there’s an increase in central abdominal fat, a decrease in lean muscle mass, and an increase in adverse glucose tolerance.”

It is essential for women to be vigilant at this time, she added, and their exercise regimens should include strength and resistance training to preserve lean muscle mass and boost metabolic rate. Dr. Manson’s group has issued several statements stressing how important it is for clinicians to take decisive action on the counseling front and how they can do this in very little time during routine practice.

Also in full support of the guideline is Mary L. Rosser, MD, PhD, assistant professor of women’s health in obstetrics and gynecology at Columbia University Irving Medical Center in New York. “Midlife is a wonderful opportunity to encourage patients to assess their overall health status and make changes to impact their future health. Women in middle age tend to experience weight gain due to a variety of factors including aging and lifestyle,” said Dr. Rosser, who was not involved in the writing of the review or guideline.

While aging and genetics cannot be altered, behaviors can, and in her view, favorable behaviors would also include stress reduction and adequate sleep.

“The importance of reducing obesity with early intervention and prevention must focus on all women,” Dr. Rosser said. “We must narrow the inequities gap in care especially for high-risk minority groups and underserved populations. This will reduce disease and death and provide women the gift of active living and feeling better.”

The WPSI authors have made available a summary of the review and guideline for patients.

The systematic review and clinical guideline were funded by the federal Health Resources and Services Administration through ACOG. The authors of the guideline and the review authors disclosed no relevant financial conflicts of interest. Dr. Manson and Dr. Rosser disclosed no relevant competing interests with regard to their comments.

Midlife women who are of normal weight or are overweight should routinely receive counseling aimed at limiting weight gain and preventing obesity and its associated health risks, a new clinical guideline states.

The recommendation, issued by the Women’s Preventive Services Initiative (WPSI) of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), supports regular lifestyle counseling for women aged 40-60 years with normal or overweight body mass index of 18.5-29.9 kg/m². Counseling could include individualized discussion of healthy eating and physical activity initiated by health professionals involved in preventive care.

Published online in Annals of Internal Medicine, the guideline addresses the prevalence and health burdens of obesity in U.S. women of middle age and seeks to reduce the known harms of obesity with an intervention of minimal anticipated harms. High BMI increases the risk for many chronic conditions including hypertension, dyslipidemia, type 2 diabetes, coronary artery disease, stroke, and all-cause mortality.

The best way to counsel, however, remains unclear. “Although the optimal approach could not be discerned from existing trials, a range of interventions of varying duration, frequency, and intensity showed benefit with potential clinical significance,” wrote the WPSI guideline panel, led by David P. Chelmow, MD, chair of the department of obstetrics and gynecology at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond.

The guideline rests on a systematic literature review led by family doctor Amy G. Cantor, MD, MPH, of the Pacific Northwest Evidence-based Practice Center, at Oregon Health & Science University in Portland, suggesting moderate reductions in weight could be achieved by offering advice to this age group.

The federally supported WPSI was launched by ACOG in 2016. The guideline fills a gap in current recommendations in that it targets a specific risk group and specifies individual counseling based on its effectiveness and applicability in primary care settings.

In another benefit of routine counseling, the panel stated, “Normalizing counseling about healthy diet and physical activity by providing it to all midlife women may also mitigate concerns about weight stigma resulting from only counseling women with obesity.”

The panelists noted that during 2017-2018, the prevalence of obesity (BMI ≥ 30.0 kg/m²) was 43.3% among U.S. women aged 40-59 years, while the prevalence of severe obesity (BMI ≥ 40.0 kg/m²) was highest in this age group at 11.5%. “Midlife women gain weight at an average of approximately 1.5 pounds per year, which increases their risk for transitioning from normal or overweight to obese BMI,” the panelists wrote.

The review

Dr. Cantor’s group analyzed seven randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published up to October 2021 from 12 publications involving 51,638 participants. Although the trials were largely small and heterogeneous, they suggested that counseling may result in modest differences in weight change without causing important harms.

Four RCTs showed significant favorable weight changes for counseling over no-counseling control groups, with a mean difference of 0.87 to 2.5 kg, whereas one trial of counseling and two trials of exercise showed no differences. One of two RCTs reported improved quality-of-life measures.

As for harms, while interventions did not increase measures of depression or stress in one trial, self-reported falls (37% vs. 29%, P < .001) and injuries (19% vs. 14%, P = .03) were more frequent with exercise counseling in one trial.

“More research is needed to determine optimal content, frequency, length, and number of sessions required and should include additional patient populations,” Dr. Cantor and associates wrote.

In terms of limitations, the authors acknowledged that trials of behavioral interventions in maintaining or reducing weight in midlife women demonstrate small magnitudes of effect.

Offering a nonparticipant’s perspective on the WPSI guideline for this news organization, JoAnn E. Manson, MD, DrPH, MACP, chief of the division of preventive medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, said its message is of prime importance for women of middle age and it goes beyond concern about pounds lost or gained.

“Midlife and the transition to menopause are high-risk periods for women in terms of typical changes in body composition that increase the risk of adverse cardiometabolic outcomes,” said Dr. Manson, professor of women’s health at Harvard Medical School, Boston. “Counseling women should be a priority for physicians in clinical practice. And it’s not just whether weight gain is reflected on the scales or not but whether there’s an increase in central abdominal fat, a decrease in lean muscle mass, and an increase in adverse glucose tolerance.”

It is essential for women to be vigilant at this time, she added, and their exercise regimens should include strength and resistance training to preserve lean muscle mass and boost metabolic rate. Dr. Manson’s group has issued several statements stressing how important it is for clinicians to take decisive action on the counseling front and how they can do this in very little time during routine practice.

Also in full support of the guideline is Mary L. Rosser, MD, PhD, assistant professor of women’s health in obstetrics and gynecology at Columbia University Irving Medical Center in New York. “Midlife is a wonderful opportunity to encourage patients to assess their overall health status and make changes to impact their future health. Women in middle age tend to experience weight gain due to a variety of factors including aging and lifestyle,” said Dr. Rosser, who was not involved in the writing of the review or guideline.

While aging and genetics cannot be altered, behaviors can, and in her view, favorable behaviors would also include stress reduction and adequate sleep.

“The importance of reducing obesity with early intervention and prevention must focus on all women,” Dr. Rosser said. “We must narrow the inequities gap in care especially for high-risk minority groups and underserved populations. This will reduce disease and death and provide women the gift of active living and feeling better.”

The WPSI authors have made available a summary of the review and guideline for patients.

The systematic review and clinical guideline were funded by the federal Health Resources and Services Administration through ACOG. The authors of the guideline and the review authors disclosed no relevant financial conflicts of interest. Dr. Manson and Dr. Rosser disclosed no relevant competing interests with regard to their comments.

Midlife women who are of normal weight or are overweight should routinely receive counseling aimed at limiting weight gain and preventing obesity and its associated health risks, a new clinical guideline states.

The recommendation, issued by the Women’s Preventive Services Initiative (WPSI) of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG), supports regular lifestyle counseling for women aged 40-60 years with normal or overweight body mass index of 18.5-29.9 kg/m². Counseling could include individualized discussion of healthy eating and physical activity initiated by health professionals involved in preventive care.

Published online in Annals of Internal Medicine, the guideline addresses the prevalence and health burdens of obesity in U.S. women of middle age and seeks to reduce the known harms of obesity with an intervention of minimal anticipated harms. High BMI increases the risk for many chronic conditions including hypertension, dyslipidemia, type 2 diabetes, coronary artery disease, stroke, and all-cause mortality.

The best way to counsel, however, remains unclear. “Although the optimal approach could not be discerned from existing trials, a range of interventions of varying duration, frequency, and intensity showed benefit with potential clinical significance,” wrote the WPSI guideline panel, led by David P. Chelmow, MD, chair of the department of obstetrics and gynecology at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond.

The guideline rests on a systematic literature review led by family doctor Amy G. Cantor, MD, MPH, of the Pacific Northwest Evidence-based Practice Center, at Oregon Health & Science University in Portland, suggesting moderate reductions in weight could be achieved by offering advice to this age group.

The federally supported WPSI was launched by ACOG in 2016. The guideline fills a gap in current recommendations in that it targets a specific risk group and specifies individual counseling based on its effectiveness and applicability in primary care settings.

In another benefit of routine counseling, the panel stated, “Normalizing counseling about healthy diet and physical activity by providing it to all midlife women may also mitigate concerns about weight stigma resulting from only counseling women with obesity.”

The panelists noted that during 2017-2018, the prevalence of obesity (BMI ≥ 30.0 kg/m²) was 43.3% among U.S. women aged 40-59 years, while the prevalence of severe obesity (BMI ≥ 40.0 kg/m²) was highest in this age group at 11.5%. “Midlife women gain weight at an average of approximately 1.5 pounds per year, which increases their risk for transitioning from normal or overweight to obese BMI,” the panelists wrote.

The review

Dr. Cantor’s group analyzed seven randomized controlled trials (RCTs) published up to October 2021 from 12 publications involving 51,638 participants. Although the trials were largely small and heterogeneous, they suggested that counseling may result in modest differences in weight change without causing important harms.

Four RCTs showed significant favorable weight changes for counseling over no-counseling control groups, with a mean difference of 0.87 to 2.5 kg, whereas one trial of counseling and two trials of exercise showed no differences. One of two RCTs reported improved quality-of-life measures.

As for harms, while interventions did not increase measures of depression or stress in one trial, self-reported falls (37% vs. 29%, P < .001) and injuries (19% vs. 14%, P = .03) were more frequent with exercise counseling in one trial.

“More research is needed to determine optimal content, frequency, length, and number of sessions required and should include additional patient populations,” Dr. Cantor and associates wrote.

In terms of limitations, the authors acknowledged that trials of behavioral interventions in maintaining or reducing weight in midlife women demonstrate small magnitudes of effect.

Offering a nonparticipant’s perspective on the WPSI guideline for this news organization, JoAnn E. Manson, MD, DrPH, MACP, chief of the division of preventive medicine at Brigham and Women’s Hospital in Boston, said its message is of prime importance for women of middle age and it goes beyond concern about pounds lost or gained.

“Midlife and the transition to menopause are high-risk periods for women in terms of typical changes in body composition that increase the risk of adverse cardiometabolic outcomes,” said Dr. Manson, professor of women’s health at Harvard Medical School, Boston. “Counseling women should be a priority for physicians in clinical practice. And it’s not just whether weight gain is reflected on the scales or not but whether there’s an increase in central abdominal fat, a decrease in lean muscle mass, and an increase in adverse glucose tolerance.”

It is essential for women to be vigilant at this time, she added, and their exercise regimens should include strength and resistance training to preserve lean muscle mass and boost metabolic rate. Dr. Manson’s group has issued several statements stressing how important it is for clinicians to take decisive action on the counseling front and how they can do this in very little time during routine practice.

Also in full support of the guideline is Mary L. Rosser, MD, PhD, assistant professor of women’s health in obstetrics and gynecology at Columbia University Irving Medical Center in New York. “Midlife is a wonderful opportunity to encourage patients to assess their overall health status and make changes to impact their future health. Women in middle age tend to experience weight gain due to a variety of factors including aging and lifestyle,” said Dr. Rosser, who was not involved in the writing of the review or guideline.

While aging and genetics cannot be altered, behaviors can, and in her view, favorable behaviors would also include stress reduction and adequate sleep.

“The importance of reducing obesity with early intervention and prevention must focus on all women,” Dr. Rosser said. “We must narrow the inequities gap in care especially for high-risk minority groups and underserved populations. This will reduce disease and death and provide women the gift of active living and feeling better.”

The WPSI authors have made available a summary of the review and guideline for patients.

The systematic review and clinical guideline were funded by the federal Health Resources and Services Administration through ACOG. The authors of the guideline and the review authors disclosed no relevant financial conflicts of interest. Dr. Manson and Dr. Rosser disclosed no relevant competing interests with regard to their comments.