Jill D. Pivovarov

Because of significant reduction in delivery of recommended childhood immunization during the pandemic, there is a risk for resurgence of vaccine preventable infections, including measles, pertussis, and polio, which can result in significant morbidity and mortality in children, reported Amy G. Feldman, MD, of Children’s Hospital Colorado, Aurora, and associates.

Yangna/Thinkstock

Will loss of herd immunity lead to vaccine deserts?

When asked to comment, pediatric infectious disease specialist Christopher J. Harrison, MD, said, “My concern is that we may see expansion of what I call ‘vaccine deserts.’ Vaccine deserts occur in underserved communities, areas with pockets of vaccine-hesitant families or among selected groups with difficult access to health care. These vaccine deserts have held a higher density of vulnerables due to low vaccine uptake, often giving rise to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases, e.g., measles, mumps, pertussis. They are usually due to an index case arriving from another vaccine desert (a developing country or a developed country, U.S. or foreign) where the disease is still endemic or pockets of vaccine hesitancy/refusal exist. When detected, local outbreaks result in rapid responses from public/private health collaborations that limit the outbreak. But what if vaccine deserts became more generalized in the U.S. because of loss of vaccine-induced herd immunity in many more or larger areas of our communities because of pandemic-driven lack of vaccinations? That pandemic-driven indirect damage would further stress the health care system and the economy. And it may first show up in the older children whose vaccines were deferred in the first 4-6 months of the pandemic.”

Dr. Feldman and associates cited findings from a collaborative survey conducted by UNICEF, the World Health Organization, Gavi the Vaccine Alliance, the CDC, the Sabin Vaccine Institute, and the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, which found that immunization programs experienced moderate to severe disruptions or terminations in at least 68 of 129 low and middle-income countries surveyed. According to the WHO, CDC, Red Cross, and GAVI, 94 million people presently are estimated to be at risk as a consequence of not receiving their measles vaccines following the suspensions.

“These national and international declines in routine immunizations have placed the global community at significant risk for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable infections (VPIs) including measles, polio, and pertussis, diseases which are more deadly, more contagious and have a higher reproductive factor (R0) amongst children than COVID-19,” the authors observed.

Dr. Feldman and associates outlined the horrible devastation that these VPI can cause in children, including significantly higher morbidity and mortality than adults, especially among those with immunodeficiencies. Neurologic deficits, paralysis, intellectual disabilities, and vision and hearing loss are just some of the permanent effects conveyed. “It is concerning to imagine how measles could spread across the United States when social distancing restriction[s] are relaxed and unvaccinated children return to school and usual community engagement,” they noted.
 

Collaborative engagement key to course correction

The authors found that primary care providers and public health communities are working not only to restore vaccine administration but also to restore confidence that vaccine delivery is safe in spite of COVID. In addition to recommending specific risk mitigation strategies for clinicians, they also suggested individual practitioners use electronic health records to identify patients with COVID-related lapses in vaccination, employ electronic health record–based parent notification of overdue immunizations, and offer distance-friendly vaccination options that include parking lot or drive-up window vaccine delivery.

Additionally, Dr. Feldman and colleagues recommended that local, state, regional, and national health systems use public service announcements via television and digital as well as social media platforms to convey important messages about the considerable health risks associated with vaccine avoidance and the availability of free or reduced-cost vaccination programs through the federally funded Vaccines For Children program for parents out of work or without insurance. Equally important is messaging around encouraging vaccine opportunities during all health care visits, whether they be subspecialty, urgent care, emergency room, or inpatient visits. In areas where access to clinics is limited, they urged the use of mobile clinics as well as additional focus on providing medical homes to children with poor access to care.

“A partial but expanding safety net may be developing spontaneously, i.e., practices and clinics based on a patient-centered medical home (PCMH) model,” noted Dr. Harrison, professor of pediatrics, University of Missouri-Kansas City, in an interview. “When lagging vaccinations were reported in mid-2020, we checked with a local hospital–based urban clinic and two suburban private practices modeled on PCMH. Each had noted a drastic drop in well checks in the first months of the pandemic. But with ill visits nearly nonexistent, they doubled down on maintaining health maintenance visits. Even though staff and provider work hours were limited, and families were less enthusiastic about well checks, momentum appears to have grown so that, by later in 2020, vaccine uptake rates were again comparable to 2019. So, some already seem to have answered the call, but practices/clinics remain hampered by months of reduced revenue needed to support staff, providers, PPE supplies, and added infection control needs,” he said.The study was funded by the Agency for Healthcare Research Quality. Dr. Isakov disclosed relationships with various pharmaceutical companies outside the submitted work. The other authors had no relevant disclosures. Dr. Harrison’s institution receives grant funding from GSK, Merck, and Pfizer for pediatric vaccine trials and pneumococcal seroprevalence studies on which he is an investigator.

pdnews@mdedge.com

Because of significant reduction in delivery of recommended childhood immunization during the pandemic, there is a risk for resurgence of vaccine preventable infections, including measles, pertussis, and polio, which can result in significant morbidity and mortality in children, reported Amy G. Feldman, MD, of Children’s Hospital Colorado, Aurora, and associates.

Yangna/Thinkstock

Will loss of herd immunity lead to vaccine deserts?

When asked to comment, pediatric infectious disease specialist Christopher J. Harrison, MD, said, “My concern is that we may see expansion of what I call ‘vaccine deserts.’ Vaccine deserts occur in underserved communities, areas with pockets of vaccine-hesitant families or among selected groups with difficult access to health care. These vaccine deserts have held a higher density of vulnerables due to low vaccine uptake, often giving rise to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases, e.g., measles, mumps, pertussis. They are usually due to an index case arriving from another vaccine desert (a developing country or a developed country, U.S. or foreign) where the disease is still endemic or pockets of vaccine hesitancy/refusal exist. When detected, local outbreaks result in rapid responses from public/private health collaborations that limit the outbreak. But what if vaccine deserts became more generalized in the U.S. because of loss of vaccine-induced herd immunity in many more or larger areas of our communities because of pandemic-driven lack of vaccinations? That pandemic-driven indirect damage would further stress the health care system and the economy. And it may first show up in the older children whose vaccines were deferred in the first 4-6 months of the pandemic.”

Dr. Feldman and associates cited findings from a collaborative survey conducted by UNICEF, the World Health Organization, Gavi the Vaccine Alliance, the CDC, the Sabin Vaccine Institute, and the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, which found that immunization programs experienced moderate to severe disruptions or terminations in at least 68 of 129 low and middle-income countries surveyed. According to the WHO, CDC, Red Cross, and GAVI, 94 million people presently are estimated to be at risk as a consequence of not receiving their measles vaccines following the suspensions.

“These national and international declines in routine immunizations have placed the global community at significant risk for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable infections (VPIs) including measles, polio, and pertussis, diseases which are more deadly, more contagious and have a higher reproductive factor (R0) amongst children than COVID-19,” the authors observed.

Dr. Feldman and associates outlined the horrible devastation that these VPI can cause in children, including significantly higher morbidity and mortality than adults, especially among those with immunodeficiencies. Neurologic deficits, paralysis, intellectual disabilities, and vision and hearing loss are just some of the permanent effects conveyed. “It is concerning to imagine how measles could spread across the United States when social distancing restriction[s] are relaxed and unvaccinated children return to school and usual community engagement,” they noted.
 

Collaborative engagement key to course correction

The authors found that primary care providers and public health communities are working not only to restore vaccine administration but also to restore confidence that vaccine delivery is safe in spite of COVID. In addition to recommending specific risk mitigation strategies for clinicians, they also suggested individual practitioners use electronic health records to identify patients with COVID-related lapses in vaccination, employ electronic health record–based parent notification of overdue immunizations, and offer distance-friendly vaccination options that include parking lot or drive-up window vaccine delivery.

Additionally, Dr. Feldman and colleagues recommended that local, state, regional, and national health systems use public service announcements via television and digital as well as social media platforms to convey important messages about the considerable health risks associated with vaccine avoidance and the availability of free or reduced-cost vaccination programs through the federally funded Vaccines For Children program for parents out of work or without insurance. Equally important is messaging around encouraging vaccine opportunities during all health care visits, whether they be subspecialty, urgent care, emergency room, or inpatient visits. In areas where access to clinics is limited, they urged the use of mobile clinics as well as additional focus on providing medical homes to children with poor access to care.

“A partial but expanding safety net may be developing spontaneously, i.e., practices and clinics based on a patient-centered medical home (PCMH) model,” noted Dr. Harrison, professor of pediatrics, University of Missouri-Kansas City, in an interview. “When lagging vaccinations were reported in mid-2020, we checked with a local hospital–based urban clinic and two suburban private practices modeled on PCMH. Each had noted a drastic drop in well checks in the first months of the pandemic. But with ill visits nearly nonexistent, they doubled down on maintaining health maintenance visits. Even though staff and provider work hours were limited, and families were less enthusiastic about well checks, momentum appears to have grown so that, by later in 2020, vaccine uptake rates were again comparable to 2019. So, some already seem to have answered the call, but practices/clinics remain hampered by months of reduced revenue needed to support staff, providers, PPE supplies, and added infection control needs,” he said.The study was funded by the Agency for Healthcare Research Quality. Dr. Isakov disclosed relationships with various pharmaceutical companies outside the submitted work. The other authors had no relevant disclosures. Dr. Harrison’s institution receives grant funding from GSK, Merck, and Pfizer for pediatric vaccine trials and pneumococcal seroprevalence studies on which he is an investigator.

pdnews@mdedge.com

Because of significant reduction in delivery of recommended childhood immunization during the pandemic, there is a risk for resurgence of vaccine preventable infections, including measles, pertussis, and polio, which can result in significant morbidity and mortality in children, reported Amy G. Feldman, MD, of Children’s Hospital Colorado, Aurora, and associates.

Yangna/Thinkstock

Will loss of herd immunity lead to vaccine deserts?

When asked to comment, pediatric infectious disease specialist Christopher J. Harrison, MD, said, “My concern is that we may see expansion of what I call ‘vaccine deserts.’ Vaccine deserts occur in underserved communities, areas with pockets of vaccine-hesitant families or among selected groups with difficult access to health care. These vaccine deserts have held a higher density of vulnerables due to low vaccine uptake, often giving rise to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases, e.g., measles, mumps, pertussis. They are usually due to an index case arriving from another vaccine desert (a developing country or a developed country, U.S. or foreign) where the disease is still endemic or pockets of vaccine hesitancy/refusal exist. When detected, local outbreaks result in rapid responses from public/private health collaborations that limit the outbreak. But what if vaccine deserts became more generalized in the U.S. because of loss of vaccine-induced herd immunity in many more or larger areas of our communities because of pandemic-driven lack of vaccinations? That pandemic-driven indirect damage would further stress the health care system and the economy. And it may first show up in the older children whose vaccines were deferred in the first 4-6 months of the pandemic.”

Dr. Feldman and associates cited findings from a collaborative survey conducted by UNICEF, the World Health Organization, Gavi the Vaccine Alliance, the CDC, the Sabin Vaccine Institute, and the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health, which found that immunization programs experienced moderate to severe disruptions or terminations in at least 68 of 129 low and middle-income countries surveyed. According to the WHO, CDC, Red Cross, and GAVI, 94 million people presently are estimated to be at risk as a consequence of not receiving their measles vaccines following the suspensions.

“These national and international declines in routine immunizations have placed the global community at significant risk for outbreaks of vaccine-preventable infections (VPIs) including measles, polio, and pertussis, diseases which are more deadly, more contagious and have a higher reproductive factor (R0) amongst children than COVID-19,” the authors observed.

Dr. Feldman and associates outlined the horrible devastation that these VPI can cause in children, including significantly higher morbidity and mortality than adults, especially among those with immunodeficiencies. Neurologic deficits, paralysis, intellectual disabilities, and vision and hearing loss are just some of the permanent effects conveyed. “It is concerning to imagine how measles could spread across the United States when social distancing restriction[s] are relaxed and unvaccinated children return to school and usual community engagement,” they noted.
 

Collaborative engagement key to course correction

The authors found that primary care providers and public health communities are working not only to restore vaccine administration but also to restore confidence that vaccine delivery is safe in spite of COVID. In addition to recommending specific risk mitigation strategies for clinicians, they also suggested individual practitioners use electronic health records to identify patients with COVID-related lapses in vaccination, employ electronic health record–based parent notification of overdue immunizations, and offer distance-friendly vaccination options that include parking lot or drive-up window vaccine delivery.

Additionally, Dr. Feldman and colleagues recommended that local, state, regional, and national health systems use public service announcements via television and digital as well as social media platforms to convey important messages about the considerable health risks associated with vaccine avoidance and the availability of free or reduced-cost vaccination programs through the federally funded Vaccines For Children program for parents out of work or without insurance. Equally important is messaging around encouraging vaccine opportunities during all health care visits, whether they be subspecialty, urgent care, emergency room, or inpatient visits. In areas where access to clinics is limited, they urged the use of mobile clinics as well as additional focus on providing medical homes to children with poor access to care.

“A partial but expanding safety net may be developing spontaneously, i.e., practices and clinics based on a patient-centered medical home (PCMH) model,” noted Dr. Harrison, professor of pediatrics, University of Missouri-Kansas City, in an interview. “When lagging vaccinations were reported in mid-2020, we checked with a local hospital–based urban clinic and two suburban private practices modeled on PCMH. Each had noted a drastic drop in well checks in the first months of the pandemic. But with ill visits nearly nonexistent, they doubled down on maintaining health maintenance visits. Even though staff and provider work hours were limited, and families were less enthusiastic about well checks, momentum appears to have grown so that, by later in 2020, vaccine uptake rates were again comparable to 2019. So, some already seem to have answered the call, but practices/clinics remain hampered by months of reduced revenue needed to support staff, providers, PPE supplies, and added infection control needs,” he said.The study was funded by the Agency for Healthcare Research Quality. Dr. Isakov disclosed relationships with various pharmaceutical companies outside the submitted work. The other authors had no relevant disclosures. Dr. Harrison’s institution receives grant funding from GSK, Merck, and Pfizer for pediatric vaccine trials and pneumococcal seroprevalence studies on which he is an investigator.

pdnews@mdedge.com

The majority of women in the United States remain unaware of the benefits breastfeeding offers in reducing the risk of breast cancer, reported Adrienne Hoyt-Austin, DO, and colleagues at University of California, Davis.

oksun70/ThinkStock

Using nationally representative data collected from the 2015-2017 National Survey of Family Growth, Dr. Hoyt-Austin and colleagues analyzed responses to the question: “Do you think that breastfeeding decreases a woman’s chances of getting breast cancer a lot, a little, or not at all, no opinion, or don’t know?” A total of 5,554 female respondents aged 15-49 years participated. The response rate was 66.7%.
 

Multiparous status and education play a role in decreased awareness

Those who had given birth more than once, who had no more than a high school education, or who were U.S.-born Hispanic had the lowest level of awareness, believing that breastfeeding offers only “a little” protection. Of those who were aware of the link, 44% reported that breastfeeding provides “a lot” of protection, and foreign-born participants as well as those who breastfed for more than a year were more likely to conclude that breastfeeding offers “a lot” of protection. The researchers found that neither mammogram or personal family history of breast cancer had any bearing on awareness.

Although multiple studies have found breastfeeding to confer a lower rate of cancer risk, morbidity and mortality, with a 26% lower lifetime risk for those mothers who breastfeed for 12 months or longer, only 36% of women in the United States actually breastfeed.
 

Limited data indicate whether respondents were breastfed themselves

“Public health initiatives must consider the complex roots of disparities in breastfeeding,” noted Dr. Hoyt-Austin and colleagues. They acknowledged the subjectivity of perceptions of “a lot” versus “a little” and noted that the study was limited by a lack of data on whether participants were breastfed themselves.

Clinicians have an opportunity to play a key role in better educating families concerning the benefits of breastfeeding, both for mother and child, they advised. According to one recent study, just 5 minutes of counseling on the benefits of breastfeeding “significantly strengthened women’s intentions to breastfeed.

In a separate interview, Amy E. Cyr, MD, FACS, section of surgical oncology at Washington University, St. Louis, noted that “many breast cancer risk factors – age, sex, family history, and age of menopause – are nonmodifiable.” And while other risk factors, including alcohol use, diet, and exercise are controllable, “pregnancies and breastfeeding don’t always go as planned,” Dr. Cyr added.

“Although Dr. Hoyt-Austin et al. observed that many women aren’t aware that breastfeeding decreases breast cancer risk – or to what extent (they cite a 26% cancer risk reduction after 12 or more months of breastfeeding) – most studies haven’t shown that large a drop in breast cancer risk,“ she pointed out, adding that “I think it’s an overstatement to suggest that breastfeeding reduces cancer risk by ‘a lot,’ as one of the survey choices offered in the study suggests.”

Whether or not a woman breastfeeds depends not only on desire but on social and economic support and biology; for some, breastfeeding simply isn’t an option. “I agree that we should educate women about the benefits of breastfeeding so they can make an informed decision for themselves and their infants, but we also need to acknowledge the complexity of this issue,” she cautioned.

One coauthor reported a travel stipend by the Human Milk Banking Association of North America; Dr. Hoyt-Austin and the other authors had no conflicts of interest to report. Dr. Cyr had no conflicts of interest to report.

SOURCE: Hoyt-Austin A et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020 Dec. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000004162.

The majority of women in the United States remain unaware of the benefits breastfeeding offers in reducing the risk of breast cancer, reported Adrienne Hoyt-Austin, DO, and colleagues at University of California, Davis.

oksun70/ThinkStock

Using nationally representative data collected from the 2015-2017 National Survey of Family Growth, Dr. Hoyt-Austin and colleagues analyzed responses to the question: “Do you think that breastfeeding decreases a woman’s chances of getting breast cancer a lot, a little, or not at all, no opinion, or don’t know?” A total of 5,554 female respondents aged 15-49 years participated. The response rate was 66.7%.
 

Multiparous status and education play a role in decreased awareness

Those who had given birth more than once, who had no more than a high school education, or who were U.S.-born Hispanic had the lowest level of awareness, believing that breastfeeding offers only “a little” protection. Of those who were aware of the link, 44% reported that breastfeeding provides “a lot” of protection, and foreign-born participants as well as those who breastfed for more than a year were more likely to conclude that breastfeeding offers “a lot” of protection. The researchers found that neither mammogram or personal family history of breast cancer had any bearing on awareness.

Although multiple studies have found breastfeeding to confer a lower rate of cancer risk, morbidity and mortality, with a 26% lower lifetime risk for those mothers who breastfeed for 12 months or longer, only 36% of women in the United States actually breastfeed.
 

Limited data indicate whether respondents were breastfed themselves

“Public health initiatives must consider the complex roots of disparities in breastfeeding,” noted Dr. Hoyt-Austin and colleagues. They acknowledged the subjectivity of perceptions of “a lot” versus “a little” and noted that the study was limited by a lack of data on whether participants were breastfed themselves.

Clinicians have an opportunity to play a key role in better educating families concerning the benefits of breastfeeding, both for mother and child, they advised. According to one recent study, just 5 minutes of counseling on the benefits of breastfeeding “significantly strengthened women’s intentions to breastfeed.

In a separate interview, Amy E. Cyr, MD, FACS, section of surgical oncology at Washington University, St. Louis, noted that “many breast cancer risk factors – age, sex, family history, and age of menopause – are nonmodifiable.” And while other risk factors, including alcohol use, diet, and exercise are controllable, “pregnancies and breastfeeding don’t always go as planned,” Dr. Cyr added.

“Although Dr. Hoyt-Austin et al. observed that many women aren’t aware that breastfeeding decreases breast cancer risk – or to what extent (they cite a 26% cancer risk reduction after 12 or more months of breastfeeding) – most studies haven’t shown that large a drop in breast cancer risk,“ she pointed out, adding that “I think it’s an overstatement to suggest that breastfeeding reduces cancer risk by ‘a lot,’ as one of the survey choices offered in the study suggests.”

Whether or not a woman breastfeeds depends not only on desire but on social and economic support and biology; for some, breastfeeding simply isn’t an option. “I agree that we should educate women about the benefits of breastfeeding so they can make an informed decision for themselves and their infants, but we also need to acknowledge the complexity of this issue,” she cautioned.

One coauthor reported a travel stipend by the Human Milk Banking Association of North America; Dr. Hoyt-Austin and the other authors had no conflicts of interest to report. Dr. Cyr had no conflicts of interest to report.

SOURCE: Hoyt-Austin A et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020 Dec. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000004162.

The majority of women in the United States remain unaware of the benefits breastfeeding offers in reducing the risk of breast cancer, reported Adrienne Hoyt-Austin, DO, and colleagues at University of California, Davis.

oksun70/ThinkStock

Using nationally representative data collected from the 2015-2017 National Survey of Family Growth, Dr. Hoyt-Austin and colleagues analyzed responses to the question: “Do you think that breastfeeding decreases a woman’s chances of getting breast cancer a lot, a little, or not at all, no opinion, or don’t know?” A total of 5,554 female respondents aged 15-49 years participated. The response rate was 66.7%.
 

Multiparous status and education play a role in decreased awareness

Those who had given birth more than once, who had no more than a high school education, or who were U.S.-born Hispanic had the lowest level of awareness, believing that breastfeeding offers only “a little” protection. Of those who were aware of the link, 44% reported that breastfeeding provides “a lot” of protection, and foreign-born participants as well as those who breastfed for more than a year were more likely to conclude that breastfeeding offers “a lot” of protection. The researchers found that neither mammogram or personal family history of breast cancer had any bearing on awareness.

Although multiple studies have found breastfeeding to confer a lower rate of cancer risk, morbidity and mortality, with a 26% lower lifetime risk for those mothers who breastfeed for 12 months or longer, only 36% of women in the United States actually breastfeed.
 

Limited data indicate whether respondents were breastfed themselves

“Public health initiatives must consider the complex roots of disparities in breastfeeding,” noted Dr. Hoyt-Austin and colleagues. They acknowledged the subjectivity of perceptions of “a lot” versus “a little” and noted that the study was limited by a lack of data on whether participants were breastfed themselves.

Clinicians have an opportunity to play a key role in better educating families concerning the benefits of breastfeeding, both for mother and child, they advised. According to one recent study, just 5 minutes of counseling on the benefits of breastfeeding “significantly strengthened women’s intentions to breastfeed.

In a separate interview, Amy E. Cyr, MD, FACS, section of surgical oncology at Washington University, St. Louis, noted that “many breast cancer risk factors – age, sex, family history, and age of menopause – are nonmodifiable.” And while other risk factors, including alcohol use, diet, and exercise are controllable, “pregnancies and breastfeeding don’t always go as planned,” Dr. Cyr added.

“Although Dr. Hoyt-Austin et al. observed that many women aren’t aware that breastfeeding decreases breast cancer risk – or to what extent (they cite a 26% cancer risk reduction after 12 or more months of breastfeeding) – most studies haven’t shown that large a drop in breast cancer risk,“ she pointed out, adding that “I think it’s an overstatement to suggest that breastfeeding reduces cancer risk by ‘a lot,’ as one of the survey choices offered in the study suggests.”

Whether or not a woman breastfeeds depends not only on desire but on social and economic support and biology; for some, breastfeeding simply isn’t an option. “I agree that we should educate women about the benefits of breastfeeding so they can make an informed decision for themselves and their infants, but we also need to acknowledge the complexity of this issue,” she cautioned.

One coauthor reported a travel stipend by the Human Milk Banking Association of North America; Dr. Hoyt-Austin and the other authors had no conflicts of interest to report. Dr. Cyr had no conflicts of interest to report.

SOURCE: Hoyt-Austin A et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020 Dec. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000004162.

Puberty suppression (PS) not only successfully reduces the physical development of sex characteristics, giving transgender youth the opportunity to qualify “for different gender-affirming surgical techniques, it also gives adolescents the time needed to explore their gender identity prior to beginning irreversible cross-sex hormone (CSH) treatment,” Tim C. van de Grift, MD, PhD, of the Vrije Universiteit Medical Center, Amsterdam, and colleagues reported in a retrospective single-center cohort study published in Pediatrics.

Dr. van de Grift and his colleagues evaluated the development of sex characteristics in 184 (61%) transgender men and 116 (39%) transgender women aged an average of 23 years at follow-up; a total of 50 men and 50 women served as controls within the total patient pool. The patients, identified from local registries, were adolescents at the time who had applied for gender-affirming medical interventions between 2006 and 2013.

In order to be included in the analysis, patients were required to 1) have a confirmed gender dysphoria diagnosis, 2) be at least 18 years of age at the point of data collection, 3) be less than 18 years of age when PS was initiated, 4) have initiated and continued PS treatment, and 5) not be lost to follow-up.

Clinical controls were identified by random sample using hospital records. Unlike patients in the PS cohort, the controls received CSH instead of PS, but they otherwise applied for gender-affirming surgery during the same years and met all other non-PS inclusion criteria.
 

PS offers more favorable, less invasive outcomes for transgender men than women

The researchers found no statistically significant impact of PS on height, weight, and body mass index preoperatively in either transgender men or women.

In transgender men, breast development differed the most, with the least development in the Tanner 2/3 puberty scale group, intermediate development in Tanner 4/5 patients, and the most development in controls who did not have PS. As a result, fewer mastectomies were required after PS, and those that were performed were less invasive, compared with controls. Dr. van de Grift and colleagues noted that these findings were in line with surgical guidelines that advise which mastectomy technique is appropriate based on breast size, elasticity, and ptosis grade. They cautioned that, while PS improves the odds of not needing a mastectomy, it is not a guaranteed outcome.

In transgender women, PS had a significant effect on penile development, which was less in Tanner 2/3 patients, compared with the other groups and less in Tanner 4/5 patients, compared with controls. As the researchers explained, penile length is key to vaginoplasty surgery since the penile skin is what is used to create the vaginal lining. For patients lacking sufficient skin, an alternative vaginoplasty technique using intestinal tissue or full-thickness graft is necessary. In this group, surgical options depended upon the onset of PS. In the control group, standard penile-inversion vaginoplasty was more probable, but it was less so in the Tanner 4/5 patients and only infrequently probable in Tanner 2/3 patients. Most transgender women who started PS in Tanner 2/3 underwent intestinal vaginoplasty.
 

Before PS is initiated much dialog and planning is warranted

“Clinicians should counsel transgender youth and their parents in making informed decisions when starting PS. Counseling consists of informing about the possible surgical consequences when puberty is suppressed and that these techniques may not be available in general transgender care facilities,” advised Dr. van de Grift and his colleagues. Specifically, when pediatricians prescribe PS, they need to be cognizant of the consequences down the line regarding the demand for “technically complex gender-affirming surgery,” performed by, for example, plastic surgeons, who will need to be “skilled in minimally invasive mastectomy techniques and more extensive vaginoplasty approaches.” Therefore, it is key for referring physicians to be sensitive to the need for early referral to specialized care in order to maximize positive outcomes, they added.

The study was limited by the sample size of some subgroups. Only two-thirds of eligible candidates were included in the sample size because follow-up data were not available for the remaining patients. Future studies should include multicenter standardized prospective data collection that provides patient-reported outcomes to enhance the perspective of the clinical findings, the researchers observed.

In a separate interview with Pediatric News, M. Brett Cooper, MD, of the department of pediatrics at University of Texas, Dallas, and an adolescent medicine physician at Children’s Medical Center in Dallas, noted that “Initiation of puberty suppression can be lifesaving for many gender-diverse youth, preventing the development of secondary sex characteristics. However, this can have effects later if these youth choose to pursue gender-affirming surgeries. This study is important for helping to frame the conversation for youth and their parents when doing consent to start puberty-blocking medications, as well as around optimal timing for each individual.”

Dr. Cooper is a paid MDedge consultant for the LGBTQ Youth Consult in Pediatric News. He had no other disclosures to report.

SOURCE: van de Grift T et al. Pediatrics. 2020;146(5):e20193653.

Puberty suppression (PS) not only successfully reduces the physical development of sex characteristics, giving transgender youth the opportunity to qualify “for different gender-affirming surgical techniques, it also gives adolescents the time needed to explore their gender identity prior to beginning irreversible cross-sex hormone (CSH) treatment,” Tim C. van de Grift, MD, PhD, of the Vrije Universiteit Medical Center, Amsterdam, and colleagues reported in a retrospective single-center cohort study published in Pediatrics.

Dr. van de Grift and his colleagues evaluated the development of sex characteristics in 184 (61%) transgender men and 116 (39%) transgender women aged an average of 23 years at follow-up; a total of 50 men and 50 women served as controls within the total patient pool. The patients, identified from local registries, were adolescents at the time who had applied for gender-affirming medical interventions between 2006 and 2013.

In order to be included in the analysis, patients were required to 1) have a confirmed gender dysphoria diagnosis, 2) be at least 18 years of age at the point of data collection, 3) be less than 18 years of age when PS was initiated, 4) have initiated and continued PS treatment, and 5) not be lost to follow-up.

Clinical controls were identified by random sample using hospital records. Unlike patients in the PS cohort, the controls received CSH instead of PS, but they otherwise applied for gender-affirming surgery during the same years and met all other non-PS inclusion criteria.
 

PS offers more favorable, less invasive outcomes for transgender men than women

The researchers found no statistically significant impact of PS on height, weight, and body mass index preoperatively in either transgender men or women.

In transgender men, breast development differed the most, with the least development in the Tanner 2/3 puberty scale group, intermediate development in Tanner 4/5 patients, and the most development in controls who did not have PS. As a result, fewer mastectomies were required after PS, and those that were performed were less invasive, compared with controls. Dr. van de Grift and colleagues noted that these findings were in line with surgical guidelines that advise which mastectomy technique is appropriate based on breast size, elasticity, and ptosis grade. They cautioned that, while PS improves the odds of not needing a mastectomy, it is not a guaranteed outcome.

In transgender women, PS had a significant effect on penile development, which was less in Tanner 2/3 patients, compared with the other groups and less in Tanner 4/5 patients, compared with controls. As the researchers explained, penile length is key to vaginoplasty surgery since the penile skin is what is used to create the vaginal lining. For patients lacking sufficient skin, an alternative vaginoplasty technique using intestinal tissue or full-thickness graft is necessary. In this group, surgical options depended upon the onset of PS. In the control group, standard penile-inversion vaginoplasty was more probable, but it was less so in the Tanner 4/5 patients and only infrequently probable in Tanner 2/3 patients. Most transgender women who started PS in Tanner 2/3 underwent intestinal vaginoplasty.
 

Before PS is initiated much dialog and planning is warranted

“Clinicians should counsel transgender youth and their parents in making informed decisions when starting PS. Counseling consists of informing about the possible surgical consequences when puberty is suppressed and that these techniques may not be available in general transgender care facilities,” advised Dr. van de Grift and his colleagues. Specifically, when pediatricians prescribe PS, they need to be cognizant of the consequences down the line regarding the demand for “technically complex gender-affirming surgery,” performed by, for example, plastic surgeons, who will need to be “skilled in minimally invasive mastectomy techniques and more extensive vaginoplasty approaches.” Therefore, it is key for referring physicians to be sensitive to the need for early referral to specialized care in order to maximize positive outcomes, they added.

The study was limited by the sample size of some subgroups. Only two-thirds of eligible candidates were included in the sample size because follow-up data were not available for the remaining patients. Future studies should include multicenter standardized prospective data collection that provides patient-reported outcomes to enhance the perspective of the clinical findings, the researchers observed.

In a separate interview with Pediatric News, M. Brett Cooper, MD, of the department of pediatrics at University of Texas, Dallas, and an adolescent medicine physician at Children’s Medical Center in Dallas, noted that “Initiation of puberty suppression can be lifesaving for many gender-diverse youth, preventing the development of secondary sex characteristics. However, this can have effects later if these youth choose to pursue gender-affirming surgeries. This study is important for helping to frame the conversation for youth and their parents when doing consent to start puberty-blocking medications, as well as around optimal timing for each individual.”

Dr. Cooper is a paid MDedge consultant for the LGBTQ Youth Consult in Pediatric News. He had no other disclosures to report.

SOURCE: van de Grift T et al. Pediatrics. 2020;146(5):e20193653.

Puberty suppression (PS) not only successfully reduces the physical development of sex characteristics, giving transgender youth the opportunity to qualify “for different gender-affirming surgical techniques, it also gives adolescents the time needed to explore their gender identity prior to beginning irreversible cross-sex hormone (CSH) treatment,” Tim C. van de Grift, MD, PhD, of the Vrije Universiteit Medical Center, Amsterdam, and colleagues reported in a retrospective single-center cohort study published in Pediatrics.

Dr. van de Grift and his colleagues evaluated the development of sex characteristics in 184 (61%) transgender men and 116 (39%) transgender women aged an average of 23 years at follow-up; a total of 50 men and 50 women served as controls within the total patient pool. The patients, identified from local registries, were adolescents at the time who had applied for gender-affirming medical interventions between 2006 and 2013.

In order to be included in the analysis, patients were required to 1) have a confirmed gender dysphoria diagnosis, 2) be at least 18 years of age at the point of data collection, 3) be less than 18 years of age when PS was initiated, 4) have initiated and continued PS treatment, and 5) not be lost to follow-up.

Clinical controls were identified by random sample using hospital records. Unlike patients in the PS cohort, the controls received CSH instead of PS, but they otherwise applied for gender-affirming surgery during the same years and met all other non-PS inclusion criteria.
 

PS offers more favorable, less invasive outcomes for transgender men than women

The researchers found no statistically significant impact of PS on height, weight, and body mass index preoperatively in either transgender men or women.

In transgender men, breast development differed the most, with the least development in the Tanner 2/3 puberty scale group, intermediate development in Tanner 4/5 patients, and the most development in controls who did not have PS. As a result, fewer mastectomies were required after PS, and those that were performed were less invasive, compared with controls. Dr. van de Grift and colleagues noted that these findings were in line with surgical guidelines that advise which mastectomy technique is appropriate based on breast size, elasticity, and ptosis grade. They cautioned that, while PS improves the odds of not needing a mastectomy, it is not a guaranteed outcome.

In transgender women, PS had a significant effect on penile development, which was less in Tanner 2/3 patients, compared with the other groups and less in Tanner 4/5 patients, compared with controls. As the researchers explained, penile length is key to vaginoplasty surgery since the penile skin is what is used to create the vaginal lining. For patients lacking sufficient skin, an alternative vaginoplasty technique using intestinal tissue or full-thickness graft is necessary. In this group, surgical options depended upon the onset of PS. In the control group, standard penile-inversion vaginoplasty was more probable, but it was less so in the Tanner 4/5 patients and only infrequently probable in Tanner 2/3 patients. Most transgender women who started PS in Tanner 2/3 underwent intestinal vaginoplasty.
 

Before PS is initiated much dialog and planning is warranted

“Clinicians should counsel transgender youth and their parents in making informed decisions when starting PS. Counseling consists of informing about the possible surgical consequences when puberty is suppressed and that these techniques may not be available in general transgender care facilities,” advised Dr. van de Grift and his colleagues. Specifically, when pediatricians prescribe PS, they need to be cognizant of the consequences down the line regarding the demand for “technically complex gender-affirming surgery,” performed by, for example, plastic surgeons, who will need to be “skilled in minimally invasive mastectomy techniques and more extensive vaginoplasty approaches.” Therefore, it is key for referring physicians to be sensitive to the need for early referral to specialized care in order to maximize positive outcomes, they added.

The study was limited by the sample size of some subgroups. Only two-thirds of eligible candidates were included in the sample size because follow-up data were not available for the remaining patients. Future studies should include multicenter standardized prospective data collection that provides patient-reported outcomes to enhance the perspective of the clinical findings, the researchers observed.

In a separate interview with Pediatric News, M. Brett Cooper, MD, of the department of pediatrics at University of Texas, Dallas, and an adolescent medicine physician at Children’s Medical Center in Dallas, noted that “Initiation of puberty suppression can be lifesaving for many gender-diverse youth, preventing the development of secondary sex characteristics. However, this can have effects later if these youth choose to pursue gender-affirming surgeries. This study is important for helping to frame the conversation for youth and their parents when doing consent to start puberty-blocking medications, as well as around optimal timing for each individual.”

Dr. Cooper is a paid MDedge consultant for the LGBTQ Youth Consult in Pediatric News. He had no other disclosures to report.

SOURCE: van de Grift T et al. Pediatrics. 2020;146(5):e20193653.

Additional blood cultures are not needed after two negative follow-up blood culture results in well-appearing patients with Staphylococcus aureus bacteremia, reported Caitlin Cardenas-Comfort, MD, of the section of pediatric infectious diseases at Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, and colleagues.

CDC/Janice Haney Carr

In a retrospective cohort study of 122 pediatric patients with documented Staphylococcus aureus bacteremia (SAB) that were hospitalized at one of three hospitals in the Texas Children’s Hospital network in Houston, Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues sought to determine whether specific recommendations can be made on the number of follow-up blood cultures (FUBC) needed to document clearance of SAB. Patients included in the study were under 18 years of age and had confirmed diagnosis of SAB between Jan. 1, and Dec. 31, 2018.
 

Most cases of bacteremia resolve in under 48 hours

In the majority of cases, patients had bacteremia for less than 48 hours and few to no complications. Only 16% of patients experienced bacteremia lasting 3 or more days, and they had either central line-associated bloodstream infection, endocarditis, or osteomyelitis. In such cases, “patients with endovascular and closed-space infections are at an increased risk of persistent bacteremia,” warranting more conservative monitoring and follow-up, cautioned the researchers.

Although Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues did note an association between the duration of bacteremia and a diagnosis of infectious disease, increased risk for persistent SAB did not appear to be tied to an underlying medical condition, including immunosuppression.

Fewer than 5% of patients with SAB had intermittent positive cultures and fewer than 1% had repeat positive cultures following two negative FUBC results. For those patients with intermittent positive cultures, the risk of being diagnosed with endocarditis or osteomyelitis is more than double. The authors suggested that “source control could be a critical variable” increasing the risk for intermittent positive cultures, noting that surgical debridement occurred more than 24 hours following initial blood draw for every patient in the osteomyelitis group. In contrast, of those who had consistently negative FUBC results, only 2 of 33 (6%) had debridement in the same period, and only 6 of 33 (18%) required more than one debridement.
 

Children are less likely to have intermittent positive cultures

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues also observed that intermittent positive cultures may appear less frequently in children than adults, consistent with a recent study of adults in which intermittent cultures were found in 13% of 1.071 SAB cases. In just 4% of the cases in that study, more than 2 days of negative blood cultures preceded a repeat positive culture.

The researchers noted several study limitations in their own research. Because more than half (61%) of patients had two or less FUBCs collected, and 21% one or less, they acknowledged that their conclusions are based on the presumption that the 61% of patients would not have any further positive cultures if they had been drawn. Relying on provider documentation also suggested that cases of bacteremia without an identified source also likely were overrepresented. The retrospective nature of the study only allowed for limited collection of standardized follow-up metrics with the limited patient sample available. Patient characteristics also may have affected the quality of study results because a large number of patients had underlying medical conditions or were premature infants.
 

Look for ongoing hemodynamic instability before third FUBC

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues only recommend a third FUBC in cases where patients demonstrate ongoing hemodynamic instability. Applying this to their study population, in retrospect, the authors noted that unnecessary FUBCs could have been prevented in 26% of patients included in the study. They further recommend a thorough clinical evaluation for any patients with SAB lasting 3 or more days with an unidentified infection source. Further research could be beneficial in evaluating cost savings that come from eliminating unnecessary cultures. Additionally, performing a powered analysis would help to determine the probability of an increase in complications based on implementation of these recommendations.

In a separate interview, Tina Q. Tan, MD, infectious disease specialist at Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago noted: “This study provides some importance evidence-based guidance on deciding how many blood cultures are needed to demonstrate clearance of S. aureus bacteremia, even in children who have intermittent positive cultures after having negative FUBCs. The recommendation that additional blood cultures to document sterility are not needed after 2 FUBC results are negative in well-appearing children is one that has the potential to decrease cost and unnecessary discomfort in patients. The recommendation currently is for well-appearing children; children who are ill appearing may require further blood cultures to document sterility. Even though this is a single-center study with a relatively small number of patients (n = 122), the information provided is a very useful guide to all clinicians who deal with this issue. Further studies are needed to determine the impact on cost reduction by the elimination of unnecessary blood cultures and whether the rate of complications would increase as a result of not obtaining further cultures in well-appearing children who have two negative follow up blood cultures.”

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues as well as Dr. Tan had no conflicts of interest and no relevant financial disclosures. There was no external funding for the study.

SOURCE: Cardenas-Comfort C et al. Pediatrics. 2020. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-1821.

Additional blood cultures are not needed after two negative follow-up blood culture results in well-appearing patients with Staphylococcus aureus bacteremia, reported Caitlin Cardenas-Comfort, MD, of the section of pediatric infectious diseases at Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, and colleagues.

CDC/Janice Haney Carr

In a retrospective cohort study of 122 pediatric patients with documented Staphylococcus aureus bacteremia (SAB) that were hospitalized at one of three hospitals in the Texas Children’s Hospital network in Houston, Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues sought to determine whether specific recommendations can be made on the number of follow-up blood cultures (FUBC) needed to document clearance of SAB. Patients included in the study were under 18 years of age and had confirmed diagnosis of SAB between Jan. 1, and Dec. 31, 2018.
 

Most cases of bacteremia resolve in under 48 hours

In the majority of cases, patients had bacteremia for less than 48 hours and few to no complications. Only 16% of patients experienced bacteremia lasting 3 or more days, and they had either central line-associated bloodstream infection, endocarditis, or osteomyelitis. In such cases, “patients with endovascular and closed-space infections are at an increased risk of persistent bacteremia,” warranting more conservative monitoring and follow-up, cautioned the researchers.

Although Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues did note an association between the duration of bacteremia and a diagnosis of infectious disease, increased risk for persistent SAB did not appear to be tied to an underlying medical condition, including immunosuppression.

Fewer than 5% of patients with SAB had intermittent positive cultures and fewer than 1% had repeat positive cultures following two negative FUBC results. For those patients with intermittent positive cultures, the risk of being diagnosed with endocarditis or osteomyelitis is more than double. The authors suggested that “source control could be a critical variable” increasing the risk for intermittent positive cultures, noting that surgical debridement occurred more than 24 hours following initial blood draw for every patient in the osteomyelitis group. In contrast, of those who had consistently negative FUBC results, only 2 of 33 (6%) had debridement in the same period, and only 6 of 33 (18%) required more than one debridement.
 

Children are less likely to have intermittent positive cultures

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues also observed that intermittent positive cultures may appear less frequently in children than adults, consistent with a recent study of adults in which intermittent cultures were found in 13% of 1.071 SAB cases. In just 4% of the cases in that study, more than 2 days of negative blood cultures preceded a repeat positive culture.

The researchers noted several study limitations in their own research. Because more than half (61%) of patients had two or less FUBCs collected, and 21% one or less, they acknowledged that their conclusions are based on the presumption that the 61% of patients would not have any further positive cultures if they had been drawn. Relying on provider documentation also suggested that cases of bacteremia without an identified source also likely were overrepresented. The retrospective nature of the study only allowed for limited collection of standardized follow-up metrics with the limited patient sample available. Patient characteristics also may have affected the quality of study results because a large number of patients had underlying medical conditions or were premature infants.
 

Look for ongoing hemodynamic instability before third FUBC

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues only recommend a third FUBC in cases where patients demonstrate ongoing hemodynamic instability. Applying this to their study population, in retrospect, the authors noted that unnecessary FUBCs could have been prevented in 26% of patients included in the study. They further recommend a thorough clinical evaluation for any patients with SAB lasting 3 or more days with an unidentified infection source. Further research could be beneficial in evaluating cost savings that come from eliminating unnecessary cultures. Additionally, performing a powered analysis would help to determine the probability of an increase in complications based on implementation of these recommendations.

In a separate interview, Tina Q. Tan, MD, infectious disease specialist at Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago noted: “This study provides some importance evidence-based guidance on deciding how many blood cultures are needed to demonstrate clearance of S. aureus bacteremia, even in children who have intermittent positive cultures after having negative FUBCs. The recommendation that additional blood cultures to document sterility are not needed after 2 FUBC results are negative in well-appearing children is one that has the potential to decrease cost and unnecessary discomfort in patients. The recommendation currently is for well-appearing children; children who are ill appearing may require further blood cultures to document sterility. Even though this is a single-center study with a relatively small number of patients (n = 122), the information provided is a very useful guide to all clinicians who deal with this issue. Further studies are needed to determine the impact on cost reduction by the elimination of unnecessary blood cultures and whether the rate of complications would increase as a result of not obtaining further cultures in well-appearing children who have two negative follow up blood cultures.”

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues as well as Dr. Tan had no conflicts of interest and no relevant financial disclosures. There was no external funding for the study.

SOURCE: Cardenas-Comfort C et al. Pediatrics. 2020. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-1821.

Additional blood cultures are not needed after two negative follow-up blood culture results in well-appearing patients with Staphylococcus aureus bacteremia, reported Caitlin Cardenas-Comfort, MD, of the section of pediatric infectious diseases at Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, and colleagues.

CDC/Janice Haney Carr

In a retrospective cohort study of 122 pediatric patients with documented Staphylococcus aureus bacteremia (SAB) that were hospitalized at one of three hospitals in the Texas Children’s Hospital network in Houston, Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues sought to determine whether specific recommendations can be made on the number of follow-up blood cultures (FUBC) needed to document clearance of SAB. Patients included in the study were under 18 years of age and had confirmed diagnosis of SAB between Jan. 1, and Dec. 31, 2018.
 

Most cases of bacteremia resolve in under 48 hours

In the majority of cases, patients had bacteremia for less than 48 hours and few to no complications. Only 16% of patients experienced bacteremia lasting 3 or more days, and they had either central line-associated bloodstream infection, endocarditis, or osteomyelitis. In such cases, “patients with endovascular and closed-space infections are at an increased risk of persistent bacteremia,” warranting more conservative monitoring and follow-up, cautioned the researchers.

Although Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues did note an association between the duration of bacteremia and a diagnosis of infectious disease, increased risk for persistent SAB did not appear to be tied to an underlying medical condition, including immunosuppression.

Fewer than 5% of patients with SAB had intermittent positive cultures and fewer than 1% had repeat positive cultures following two negative FUBC results. For those patients with intermittent positive cultures, the risk of being diagnosed with endocarditis or osteomyelitis is more than double. The authors suggested that “source control could be a critical variable” increasing the risk for intermittent positive cultures, noting that surgical debridement occurred more than 24 hours following initial blood draw for every patient in the osteomyelitis group. In contrast, of those who had consistently negative FUBC results, only 2 of 33 (6%) had debridement in the same period, and only 6 of 33 (18%) required more than one debridement.
 

Children are less likely to have intermittent positive cultures

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues also observed that intermittent positive cultures may appear less frequently in children than adults, consistent with a recent study of adults in which intermittent cultures were found in 13% of 1.071 SAB cases. In just 4% of the cases in that study, more than 2 days of negative blood cultures preceded a repeat positive culture.

The researchers noted several study limitations in their own research. Because more than half (61%) of patients had two or less FUBCs collected, and 21% one or less, they acknowledged that their conclusions are based on the presumption that the 61% of patients would not have any further positive cultures if they had been drawn. Relying on provider documentation also suggested that cases of bacteremia without an identified source also likely were overrepresented. The retrospective nature of the study only allowed for limited collection of standardized follow-up metrics with the limited patient sample available. Patient characteristics also may have affected the quality of study results because a large number of patients had underlying medical conditions or were premature infants.
 

Look for ongoing hemodynamic instability before third FUBC

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues only recommend a third FUBC in cases where patients demonstrate ongoing hemodynamic instability. Applying this to their study population, in retrospect, the authors noted that unnecessary FUBCs could have been prevented in 26% of patients included in the study. They further recommend a thorough clinical evaluation for any patients with SAB lasting 3 or more days with an unidentified infection source. Further research could be beneficial in evaluating cost savings that come from eliminating unnecessary cultures. Additionally, performing a powered analysis would help to determine the probability of an increase in complications based on implementation of these recommendations.

In a separate interview, Tina Q. Tan, MD, infectious disease specialist at Ann & Robert H. Lurie Children’s Hospital of Chicago noted: “This study provides some importance evidence-based guidance on deciding how many blood cultures are needed to demonstrate clearance of S. aureus bacteremia, even in children who have intermittent positive cultures after having negative FUBCs. The recommendation that additional blood cultures to document sterility are not needed after 2 FUBC results are negative in well-appearing children is one that has the potential to decrease cost and unnecessary discomfort in patients. The recommendation currently is for well-appearing children; children who are ill appearing may require further blood cultures to document sterility. Even though this is a single-center study with a relatively small number of patients (n = 122), the information provided is a very useful guide to all clinicians who deal with this issue. Further studies are needed to determine the impact on cost reduction by the elimination of unnecessary blood cultures and whether the rate of complications would increase as a result of not obtaining further cultures in well-appearing children who have two negative follow up blood cultures.”

Dr. Cardenas-Comfort and colleagues as well as Dr. Tan had no conflicts of interest and no relevant financial disclosures. There was no external funding for the study.

SOURCE: Cardenas-Comfort C et al. Pediatrics. 2020. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-1821.

Clinical encounters with female patients presenting with a STI offer a key opportunity for health care professionals to identify and prevent HIV through testing and prophylactic treatment, reported Kirk D. Henny, PhD, and colleagues of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

In an effort to quantify HIV testing rates as well as the rate of pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) among women with gonorrhea or syphilis, Dr. Henny and his colleagues performed a multivariate logistic regression analysis of 13,074 female patients aged 15-64 diagnosed with a STI in the absence of HIV. Data was pulled in 2017 from the IBM MarketScan commercial and Medicaid insurance databases, and the research was published in Obstetrics & Gynecology.
 

Medicaid patients were more likely to be tested for HIV

A total of 3,709 patients with commercial insurance were diagnosed with gonorrhea and 1,696 with syphilis. Among those with Medicaid, 6,172 were diagnosed with gonorrhea and 1,497 with syphilis. Medicaid patients diagnosed with either STI were more likely to be tested for HIV than the commercially insured patients. With an adjusted prevalence ratio, patients commercially insured with had either STI were more likely to be tested for HIV than patients who had no STI. Prophylactic treatment rates were similar in both insurance groups: 0.15% in the commercial insurance group and 0.26% in the Medicaid group. No patient from either group who was diagnosed with gonorrhea or syphilis and subsequently tested for HIV received pre-exposure prophylactic (PrEP) treatment.

STI diagnosis is a significant indicator of future HIV

Female patients diagnosed with either STI are more likely to contract HIV, the researchers noted. They cautioned that their findings of low HIV testing rates and the absence of prophylactic treatment means that “these missed opportunities for health care professionals to intervene with female patients diagnosed with gonorrhea or syphilis might have contributed to HIV infections that could have been averted.”

The researchers also pointed out that, in a recent analysis of pharmacy data, prophylactic prescribing for female patients with clinical indications for PrEP was 6.6%, less than one-third the coverage provided to male patients.

Future research should target understanding “individual and contextual factors associated with low HIV testing” and PrEP treatment in female patients, especially those with STIs, Dr. Henny and his colleagues advised.

In a separate interview, Constance Bohon, MD FACOG, observed: “The authors present data to document the low incidence of pre-exposure prophylaxis in women who are at substantial risk of acquiring HIV and possible causes for the low utilization of this treatment.” It is important to identify barriers to diagnosis, counseling, and treatment, she advised.

“Multicenter studies to determine the best methodologies to improve the identification, management, and treatment of these at-risk women need to be done, and the conclusions disseminated to health care providers caring for women,” Dr. Bohon said.
 

PrEP is an important, simple strategy for reducing HIV transmission

“Pre-exposure prophylaxis has been demonstrated to decrease HIV acquisition in those at risk by up to 90% when taken appropriately,” and yet prescribing rates are extremely low (2%-6%) in at-risk women and especially women of color. These disparities have only grown over time, with prophylactic prescriptions for women at 5% between 2012 and 2017, compared with 68% for men, Catherine S. Eppes, MD, MPH, and Jennifer McKinney, MD, MPH, said in a related editorial commenting on the Research Letter by Dr. Henny and colleagues in Obstetrics & Gynecology (2020 Dec;136[6]:1080-2).

Given the abundant research demonstrating the importance and ease of prescribing PrEP, the question remains: “why does preexposure prophylaxis uptake remain so low, especially for women and women of color? There are three important issues about preexposure prophylaxis raised by this study: the research gap, the implementation gap, and the effect of systemic racism and bias,” noted Dr. Eppes and Dr. McKinney.

Women constitute a significant portion of the population that would benefit from HIV-prevention strategies, yet they continue to be excluded from research, they noted. “Much focus on research into barriers and implementation interventions for preexposure prophylaxis have focused on men who have sex with men and transgender women,” the authors of the editorial wrote.

Most women eligible for treatment would be willing to consider it if they were aware of the option, but numerous studies have cited a lack of awareness, especially among high-risk women of color in the United States, Dr. Eppes and Dr. McKinney noted.

Clinicians also need to add it to their growing checklist of mandatory appointment discussion topics, the editorialists said. “We propose standardized inclusion of preexposure prophylaxis counseling during reproductive healthcare visits. This could be aided through an electronic medical record-based best practice advisory alert. … Standardized order sets with the medication and laboratory studies necessary for safe monitoring could facilitate ease of incorporating into routine visits,” they suggested.

“Preexposure prophylaxis is extremely effective in preventing HIV, is safe, and is the only prevention method that leaves control entirely in the hands of the female partner. As a specialty, we have a responsibility to make sure our patients know about this option,” the editorialists concluded.

The authors had no financial disclosures to report. Dr. Bohon had no conflicts of interest to report.
 

SOURCE: Henny KD et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020 Dec;136(6):1083-5.

Clinical encounters with female patients presenting with a STI offer a key opportunity for health care professionals to identify and prevent HIV through testing and prophylactic treatment, reported Kirk D. Henny, PhD, and colleagues of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

In an effort to quantify HIV testing rates as well as the rate of pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) among women with gonorrhea or syphilis, Dr. Henny and his colleagues performed a multivariate logistic regression analysis of 13,074 female patients aged 15-64 diagnosed with a STI in the absence of HIV. Data was pulled in 2017 from the IBM MarketScan commercial and Medicaid insurance databases, and the research was published in Obstetrics & Gynecology.
 

Medicaid patients were more likely to be tested for HIV

A total of 3,709 patients with commercial insurance were diagnosed with gonorrhea and 1,696 with syphilis. Among those with Medicaid, 6,172 were diagnosed with gonorrhea and 1,497 with syphilis. Medicaid patients diagnosed with either STI were more likely to be tested for HIV than the commercially insured patients. With an adjusted prevalence ratio, patients commercially insured with had either STI were more likely to be tested for HIV than patients who had no STI. Prophylactic treatment rates were similar in both insurance groups: 0.15% in the commercial insurance group and 0.26% in the Medicaid group. No patient from either group who was diagnosed with gonorrhea or syphilis and subsequently tested for HIV received pre-exposure prophylactic (PrEP) treatment.

STI diagnosis is a significant indicator of future HIV

Female patients diagnosed with either STI are more likely to contract HIV, the researchers noted. They cautioned that their findings of low HIV testing rates and the absence of prophylactic treatment means that “these missed opportunities for health care professionals to intervene with female patients diagnosed with gonorrhea or syphilis might have contributed to HIV infections that could have been averted.”

The researchers also pointed out that, in a recent analysis of pharmacy data, prophylactic prescribing for female patients with clinical indications for PrEP was 6.6%, less than one-third the coverage provided to male patients.

Future research should target understanding “individual and contextual factors associated with low HIV testing” and PrEP treatment in female patients, especially those with STIs, Dr. Henny and his colleagues advised.

In a separate interview, Constance Bohon, MD FACOG, observed: “The authors present data to document the low incidence of pre-exposure prophylaxis in women who are at substantial risk of acquiring HIV and possible causes for the low utilization of this treatment.” It is important to identify barriers to diagnosis, counseling, and treatment, she advised.

“Multicenter studies to determine the best methodologies to improve the identification, management, and treatment of these at-risk women need to be done, and the conclusions disseminated to health care providers caring for women,” Dr. Bohon said.
 

PrEP is an important, simple strategy for reducing HIV transmission

“Pre-exposure prophylaxis has been demonstrated to decrease HIV acquisition in those at risk by up to 90% when taken appropriately,” and yet prescribing rates are extremely low (2%-6%) in at-risk women and especially women of color. These disparities have only grown over time, with prophylactic prescriptions for women at 5% between 2012 and 2017, compared with 68% for men, Catherine S. Eppes, MD, MPH, and Jennifer McKinney, MD, MPH, said in a related editorial commenting on the Research Letter by Dr. Henny and colleagues in Obstetrics & Gynecology (2020 Dec;136[6]:1080-2).

Given the abundant research demonstrating the importance and ease of prescribing PrEP, the question remains: “why does preexposure prophylaxis uptake remain so low, especially for women and women of color? There are three important issues about preexposure prophylaxis raised by this study: the research gap, the implementation gap, and the effect of systemic racism and bias,” noted Dr. Eppes and Dr. McKinney.

Women constitute a significant portion of the population that would benefit from HIV-prevention strategies, yet they continue to be excluded from research, they noted. “Much focus on research into barriers and implementation interventions for preexposure prophylaxis have focused on men who have sex with men and transgender women,” the authors of the editorial wrote.

Most women eligible for treatment would be willing to consider it if they were aware of the option, but numerous studies have cited a lack of awareness, especially among high-risk women of color in the United States, Dr. Eppes and Dr. McKinney noted.

Clinicians also need to add it to their growing checklist of mandatory appointment discussion topics, the editorialists said. “We propose standardized inclusion of preexposure prophylaxis counseling during reproductive healthcare visits. This could be aided through an electronic medical record-based best practice advisory alert. … Standardized order sets with the medication and laboratory studies necessary for safe monitoring could facilitate ease of incorporating into routine visits,” they suggested.

“Preexposure prophylaxis is extremely effective in preventing HIV, is safe, and is the only prevention method that leaves control entirely in the hands of the female partner. As a specialty, we have a responsibility to make sure our patients know about this option,” the editorialists concluded.

The authors had no financial disclosures to report. Dr. Bohon had no conflicts of interest to report.
 

SOURCE: Henny KD et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020 Dec;136(6):1083-5.

Clinical encounters with female patients presenting with a STI offer a key opportunity for health care professionals to identify and prevent HIV through testing and prophylactic treatment, reported Kirk D. Henny, PhD, and colleagues of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

In an effort to quantify HIV testing rates as well as the rate of pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) among women with gonorrhea or syphilis, Dr. Henny and his colleagues performed a multivariate logistic regression analysis of 13,074 female patients aged 15-64 diagnosed with a STI in the absence of HIV. Data was pulled in 2017 from the IBM MarketScan commercial and Medicaid insurance databases, and the research was published in Obstetrics & Gynecology.
 

Medicaid patients were more likely to be tested for HIV

A total of 3,709 patients with commercial insurance were diagnosed with gonorrhea and 1,696 with syphilis. Among those with Medicaid, 6,172 were diagnosed with gonorrhea and 1,497 with syphilis. Medicaid patients diagnosed with either STI were more likely to be tested for HIV than the commercially insured patients. With an adjusted prevalence ratio, patients commercially insured with had either STI were more likely to be tested for HIV than patients who had no STI. Prophylactic treatment rates were similar in both insurance groups: 0.15% in the commercial insurance group and 0.26% in the Medicaid group. No patient from either group who was diagnosed with gonorrhea or syphilis and subsequently tested for HIV received pre-exposure prophylactic (PrEP) treatment.

STI diagnosis is a significant indicator of future HIV

Female patients diagnosed with either STI are more likely to contract HIV, the researchers noted. They cautioned that their findings of low HIV testing rates and the absence of prophylactic treatment means that “these missed opportunities for health care professionals to intervene with female patients diagnosed with gonorrhea or syphilis might have contributed to HIV infections that could have been averted.”

The researchers also pointed out that, in a recent analysis of pharmacy data, prophylactic prescribing for female patients with clinical indications for PrEP was 6.6%, less than one-third the coverage provided to male patients.

Future research should target understanding “individual and contextual factors associated with low HIV testing” and PrEP treatment in female patients, especially those with STIs, Dr. Henny and his colleagues advised.

In a separate interview, Constance Bohon, MD FACOG, observed: “The authors present data to document the low incidence of pre-exposure prophylaxis in women who are at substantial risk of acquiring HIV and possible causes for the low utilization of this treatment.” It is important to identify barriers to diagnosis, counseling, and treatment, she advised.

“Multicenter studies to determine the best methodologies to improve the identification, management, and treatment of these at-risk women need to be done, and the conclusions disseminated to health care providers caring for women,” Dr. Bohon said.
 

PrEP is an important, simple strategy for reducing HIV transmission

“Pre-exposure prophylaxis has been demonstrated to decrease HIV acquisition in those at risk by up to 90% when taken appropriately,” and yet prescribing rates are extremely low (2%-6%) in at-risk women and especially women of color. These disparities have only grown over time, with prophylactic prescriptions for women at 5% between 2012 and 2017, compared with 68% for men, Catherine S. Eppes, MD, MPH, and Jennifer McKinney, MD, MPH, said in a related editorial commenting on the Research Letter by Dr. Henny and colleagues in Obstetrics & Gynecology (2020 Dec;136[6]:1080-2).

Given the abundant research demonstrating the importance and ease of prescribing PrEP, the question remains: “why does preexposure prophylaxis uptake remain so low, especially for women and women of color? There are three important issues about preexposure prophylaxis raised by this study: the research gap, the implementation gap, and the effect of systemic racism and bias,” noted Dr. Eppes and Dr. McKinney.

Women constitute a significant portion of the population that would benefit from HIV-prevention strategies, yet they continue to be excluded from research, they noted. “Much focus on research into barriers and implementation interventions for preexposure prophylaxis have focused on men who have sex with men and transgender women,” the authors of the editorial wrote.

Most women eligible for treatment would be willing to consider it if they were aware of the option, but numerous studies have cited a lack of awareness, especially among high-risk women of color in the United States, Dr. Eppes and Dr. McKinney noted.

Clinicians also need to add it to their growing checklist of mandatory appointment discussion topics, the editorialists said. “We propose standardized inclusion of preexposure prophylaxis counseling during reproductive healthcare visits. This could be aided through an electronic medical record-based best practice advisory alert. … Standardized order sets with the medication and laboratory studies necessary for safe monitoring could facilitate ease of incorporating into routine visits,” they suggested.

“Preexposure prophylaxis is extremely effective in preventing HIV, is safe, and is the only prevention method that leaves control entirely in the hands of the female partner. As a specialty, we have a responsibility to make sure our patients know about this option,” the editorialists concluded.

The authors had no financial disclosures to report. Dr. Bohon had no conflicts of interest to report.
 

SOURCE: Henny KD et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020 Dec;136(6):1083-5.

Women who experience irregular and long menstrual cycles in adolescence and adulthood are more likely to die before the age of 70 years than women with regular or short cycles, reported Yi-Xin Wang, PhD, of Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, Boston, and associates. This is particularly true in the presence of cardiovascular disease and a history of smoking.

In a peer-reviewed observational study of 79,505 premenopausal women enrolled in the Nurses’ Health Study II, the researchers sought to determine whether a life-long history of irregular or long menstrual cycles was associated with premature death. Patients averaged a mean age of 37.7 years and had no history of cardiovascular disease, cancer, or diabetes at enrollment.

Although irregular and long menstrual cycles are common and frequently linked with an increased risk of major chronic diseases – such as ovarian cancer, coronary heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and mental health problems – in women of reproductive age, actual evidence linking irregular or long menstrual cycles with mortality is scant, the researchers noted in the BMJ.

During the study, participants checked in at ages 14-17 years, 18-22 years, and 29-46 years to report the usual length and regularity of their menstrual cycles. Over 24 years of follow-up, a total of 1,975 premature deaths were noted, including 894 from cancer and 172 from cardiovascular disease.
 

Irregular cycles appear to bring risks

After considering other possible factors of influence, including age, weight, lifestyle, and family medical history, Dr. Wang and associates noted higher rates of mortality among those consistently reporting irregular cycles than women in the same age ranges with very regular cycles. Specifically, women aged 18-22 years and 29-46 years with cycles of 40 days or more were at greater risk of dying prematurely than were those in the same age ranges with cycles of 26-31 days.

Cardiovascular disease was a stronger predictor of death than cancer or other causes. Also included in the higher-risk group were those who currently smoked.

Among women reporting very regular cycles and women reporting always irregular cycles, mortality rates per 1,000 person-years were 1.05 and 1.23 at ages 14-17 years, 1.00 and 1.37 at ages 18-22 years, and 1.00 and 1.68 at ages 29-46 years, respectively.

The study also found that women reporting irregular cycles or no periods had a higher body mass indexes (28.2 vs. 25.0 kg/m²); were more likely to have conditions including hypertension (13.2% vs. 6.2%), high blood cholesterol levels (23.9% vs. 14.9%), hirsutism (8.4%

vs. 1.8%), or endometriosis (5.9% vs. 4.5%); and uterine fibroids (10.0% vs. 7.8%); and a higher prevalence of family history of diabetes (19.4% vs. 15.8%).

Dr. Wang and associates also observed – using multivariable Cox models – a greater risk of premature death across all categories and all age ranges in women with decreasing menstrual cycle regularity. In models that were fully adjusted, cycle lengths that were 40 days or more or too irregular to estimate from ages 18-22 and 29-46 expressed hazard ratios for premature death at the time of follow-up of 1.34 and 1.40, compared with women in the same age ranges reporting cycle lengths of 26-31 days.

Of note, Dr. Wang and colleagues unexpectedly discovered an increased risk of premature death in women who had used contraceptives between 14-17 years. They suggested that a greater number of women self-reporting contraceptive use in adolescence may have been using contraceptives to manage symptoms of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and other conditions such as endometriosis.

Relying on the potential inaccuracy inherent in patient recall of their menstrual cycle characteristics, and the likelihood for other unmeasured factors, may have affected study results. Study strengths included the significant number of participants who had a high follow-up rate over many years, and the availability of menstrual cycle data at three different points across the reproductive lifespan.

Because the mechanisms underlying these associations are likely related to the disrupted hormonal environment, the study results “emphasize the need for primary care providers to include menstrual cycle characteristics throughout the reproductive life span as additional vital signs in assessing women’s general health status,” Dr. Wang and colleagues cautioned.
 

Expert suggests a probable underlying link

“Irregular menstrual cycles in women have long been known to be associated with significant morbidities, including the leading causes of mortality worldwide such as cardiovascular disease and cancer,” Reshef Tal, MD, PhD, assistant professor of obstetrics, gynecology & reproductive sciences at Yale University, New Haven, Conn., said in an interview. “The findings of this large study that irregular menstrual cycles are associated with premature death, most strongly from cardiovascular causes, are therefore not surprising.”

Dr. Tal acknowledged that one probable underlying link is PCOS, which is recognized as the most common hormonal disorder affecting women of reproductive age. The irregular periods that characterize PCOS are tied to a number of metabolic risk factors, including obesity, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and hypertension, which increase the long-term risk of cardiovascular disease and cancer of the uterus.

“The study did not have information on patients’ pelvic ultrasound findings and male hormone levels, which would have helped to establish PCOS diagnosis. However, women in this study who had irregular cycles tended to have more hirsutism, high cholesterol, hypertension as well as higher BMI, suggesting that PCOS is at least partly responsible for the observed association with cardiovascular disease. Interestingly, the association between irregular cycles and early mortality was independent of BMI, indicating that mechanisms other than metabolic factors may also play a role,” observed Dr. Tal, who was asked to comment on the study.

“Irregular periods are a symptom and not a disease, so it is important to identify underlying metabolic risk factors. Furthermore, physicians are advised to counsel patients experiencing menstrual irregularity, [to advise them to] maintain a healthy lifestyle and be alert to health changes,” Dr. Tal suggested.

The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health. The investigators had no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Tal said he had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Chavarro J et al. BMJ. 2020. doi: 10.1136/bmj.m3464.

Women who experience irregular and long menstrual cycles in adolescence and adulthood are more likely to die before the age of 70 years than women with regular or short cycles, reported Yi-Xin Wang, PhD, of Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, Boston, and associates. This is particularly true in the presence of cardiovascular disease and a history of smoking.

In a peer-reviewed observational study of 79,505 premenopausal women enrolled in the Nurses’ Health Study II, the researchers sought to determine whether a life-long history of irregular or long menstrual cycles was associated with premature death. Patients averaged a mean age of 37.7 years and had no history of cardiovascular disease, cancer, or diabetes at enrollment.

Although irregular and long menstrual cycles are common and frequently linked with an increased risk of major chronic diseases – such as ovarian cancer, coronary heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and mental health problems – in women of reproductive age, actual evidence linking irregular or long menstrual cycles with mortality is scant, the researchers noted in the BMJ.

During the study, participants checked in at ages 14-17 years, 18-22 years, and 29-46 years to report the usual length and regularity of their menstrual cycles. Over 24 years of follow-up, a total of 1,975 premature deaths were noted, including 894 from cancer and 172 from cardiovascular disease.
 

Irregular cycles appear to bring risks

After considering other possible factors of influence, including age, weight, lifestyle, and family medical history, Dr. Wang and associates noted higher rates of mortality among those consistently reporting irregular cycles than women in the same age ranges with very regular cycles. Specifically, women aged 18-22 years and 29-46 years with cycles of 40 days or more were at greater risk of dying prematurely than were those in the same age ranges with cycles of 26-31 days.

Cardiovascular disease was a stronger predictor of death than cancer or other causes. Also included in the higher-risk group were those who currently smoked.

Among women reporting very regular cycles and women reporting always irregular cycles, mortality rates per 1,000 person-years were 1.05 and 1.23 at ages 14-17 years, 1.00 and 1.37 at ages 18-22 years, and 1.00 and 1.68 at ages 29-46 years, respectively.

The study also found that women reporting irregular cycles or no periods had a higher body mass indexes (28.2 vs. 25.0 kg/m²); were more likely to have conditions including hypertension (13.2% vs. 6.2%), high blood cholesterol levels (23.9% vs. 14.9%), hirsutism (8.4%

vs. 1.8%), or endometriosis (5.9% vs. 4.5%); and uterine fibroids (10.0% vs. 7.8%); and a higher prevalence of family history of diabetes (19.4% vs. 15.8%).

Dr. Wang and associates also observed – using multivariable Cox models – a greater risk of premature death across all categories and all age ranges in women with decreasing menstrual cycle regularity. In models that were fully adjusted, cycle lengths that were 40 days or more or too irregular to estimate from ages 18-22 and 29-46 expressed hazard ratios for premature death at the time of follow-up of 1.34 and 1.40, compared with women in the same age ranges reporting cycle lengths of 26-31 days.

Of note, Dr. Wang and colleagues unexpectedly discovered an increased risk of premature death in women who had used contraceptives between 14-17 years. They suggested that a greater number of women self-reporting contraceptive use in adolescence may have been using contraceptives to manage symptoms of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and other conditions such as endometriosis.

Relying on the potential inaccuracy inherent in patient recall of their menstrual cycle characteristics, and the likelihood for other unmeasured factors, may have affected study results. Study strengths included the significant number of participants who had a high follow-up rate over many years, and the availability of menstrual cycle data at three different points across the reproductive lifespan.

Because the mechanisms underlying these associations are likely related to the disrupted hormonal environment, the study results “emphasize the need for primary care providers to include menstrual cycle characteristics throughout the reproductive life span as additional vital signs in assessing women’s general health status,” Dr. Wang and colleagues cautioned.
 

Expert suggests a probable underlying link

“Irregular menstrual cycles in women have long been known to be associated with significant morbidities, including the leading causes of mortality worldwide such as cardiovascular disease and cancer,” Reshef Tal, MD, PhD, assistant professor of obstetrics, gynecology & reproductive sciences at Yale University, New Haven, Conn., said in an interview. “The findings of this large study that irregular menstrual cycles are associated with premature death, most strongly from cardiovascular causes, are therefore not surprising.”

Dr. Tal acknowledged that one probable underlying link is PCOS, which is recognized as the most common hormonal disorder affecting women of reproductive age. The irregular periods that characterize PCOS are tied to a number of metabolic risk factors, including obesity, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and hypertension, which increase the long-term risk of cardiovascular disease and cancer of the uterus.

“The study did not have information on patients’ pelvic ultrasound findings and male hormone levels, which would have helped to establish PCOS diagnosis. However, women in this study who had irregular cycles tended to have more hirsutism, high cholesterol, hypertension as well as higher BMI, suggesting that PCOS is at least partly responsible for the observed association with cardiovascular disease. Interestingly, the association between irregular cycles and early mortality was independent of BMI, indicating that mechanisms other than metabolic factors may also play a role,” observed Dr. Tal, who was asked to comment on the study.

“Irregular periods are a symptom and not a disease, so it is important to identify underlying metabolic risk factors. Furthermore, physicians are advised to counsel patients experiencing menstrual irregularity, [to advise them to] maintain a healthy lifestyle and be alert to health changes,” Dr. Tal suggested.

The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health. The investigators had no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Tal said he had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Chavarro J et al. BMJ. 2020. doi: 10.1136/bmj.m3464.

Women who experience irregular and long menstrual cycles in adolescence and adulthood are more likely to die before the age of 70 years than women with regular or short cycles, reported Yi-Xin Wang, PhD, of Harvard TH Chan School of Public Health, Boston, and associates. This is particularly true in the presence of cardiovascular disease and a history of smoking.

In a peer-reviewed observational study of 79,505 premenopausal women enrolled in the Nurses’ Health Study II, the researchers sought to determine whether a life-long history of irregular or long menstrual cycles was associated with premature death. Patients averaged a mean age of 37.7 years and had no history of cardiovascular disease, cancer, or diabetes at enrollment.

Although irregular and long menstrual cycles are common and frequently linked with an increased risk of major chronic diseases – such as ovarian cancer, coronary heart disease, type 2 diabetes, and mental health problems – in women of reproductive age, actual evidence linking irregular or long menstrual cycles with mortality is scant, the researchers noted in the BMJ.

During the study, participants checked in at ages 14-17 years, 18-22 years, and 29-46 years to report the usual length and regularity of their menstrual cycles. Over 24 years of follow-up, a total of 1,975 premature deaths were noted, including 894 from cancer and 172 from cardiovascular disease.
 

Irregular cycles appear to bring risks

After considering other possible factors of influence, including age, weight, lifestyle, and family medical history, Dr. Wang and associates noted higher rates of mortality among those consistently reporting irregular cycles than women in the same age ranges with very regular cycles. Specifically, women aged 18-22 years and 29-46 years with cycles of 40 days or more were at greater risk of dying prematurely than were those in the same age ranges with cycles of 26-31 days.

Cardiovascular disease was a stronger predictor of death than cancer or other causes. Also included in the higher-risk group were those who currently smoked.

Among women reporting very regular cycles and women reporting always irregular cycles, mortality rates per 1,000 person-years were 1.05 and 1.23 at ages 14-17 years, 1.00 and 1.37 at ages 18-22 years, and 1.00 and 1.68 at ages 29-46 years, respectively.

The study also found that women reporting irregular cycles or no periods had a higher body mass indexes (28.2 vs. 25.0 kg/m²); were more likely to have conditions including hypertension (13.2% vs. 6.2%), high blood cholesterol levels (23.9% vs. 14.9%), hirsutism (8.4%

vs. 1.8%), or endometriosis (5.9% vs. 4.5%); and uterine fibroids (10.0% vs. 7.8%); and a higher prevalence of family history of diabetes (19.4% vs. 15.8%).

Dr. Wang and associates also observed – using multivariable Cox models – a greater risk of premature death across all categories and all age ranges in women with decreasing menstrual cycle regularity. In models that were fully adjusted, cycle lengths that were 40 days or more or too irregular to estimate from ages 18-22 and 29-46 expressed hazard ratios for premature death at the time of follow-up of 1.34 and 1.40, compared with women in the same age ranges reporting cycle lengths of 26-31 days.

Of note, Dr. Wang and colleagues unexpectedly discovered an increased risk of premature death in women who had used contraceptives between 14-17 years. They suggested that a greater number of women self-reporting contraceptive use in adolescence may have been using contraceptives to manage symptoms of polycystic ovary syndrome (PCOS) and other conditions such as endometriosis.

Relying on the potential inaccuracy inherent in patient recall of their menstrual cycle characteristics, and the likelihood for other unmeasured factors, may have affected study results. Study strengths included the significant number of participants who had a high follow-up rate over many years, and the availability of menstrual cycle data at three different points across the reproductive lifespan.

Because the mechanisms underlying these associations are likely related to the disrupted hormonal environment, the study results “emphasize the need for primary care providers to include menstrual cycle characteristics throughout the reproductive life span as additional vital signs in assessing women’s general health status,” Dr. Wang and colleagues cautioned.
 

Expert suggests a probable underlying link

“Irregular menstrual cycles in women have long been known to be associated with significant morbidities, including the leading causes of mortality worldwide such as cardiovascular disease and cancer,” Reshef Tal, MD, PhD, assistant professor of obstetrics, gynecology & reproductive sciences at Yale University, New Haven, Conn., said in an interview. “The findings of this large study that irregular menstrual cycles are associated with premature death, most strongly from cardiovascular causes, are therefore not surprising.”

Dr. Tal acknowledged that one probable underlying link is PCOS, which is recognized as the most common hormonal disorder affecting women of reproductive age. The irregular periods that characterize PCOS are tied to a number of metabolic risk factors, including obesity, insulin resistance, dyslipidemia, and hypertension, which increase the long-term risk of cardiovascular disease and cancer of the uterus.

“The study did not have information on patients’ pelvic ultrasound findings and male hormone levels, which would have helped to establish PCOS diagnosis. However, women in this study who had irregular cycles tended to have more hirsutism, high cholesterol, hypertension as well as higher BMI, suggesting that PCOS is at least partly responsible for the observed association with cardiovascular disease. Interestingly, the association between irregular cycles and early mortality was independent of BMI, indicating that mechanisms other than metabolic factors may also play a role,” observed Dr. Tal, who was asked to comment on the study.

“Irregular periods are a symptom and not a disease, so it is important to identify underlying metabolic risk factors. Furthermore, physicians are advised to counsel patients experiencing menstrual irregularity, [to advise them to] maintain a healthy lifestyle and be alert to health changes,” Dr. Tal suggested.

The study was funded by the National Institutes of Health. The investigators had no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Tal said he had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Chavarro J et al. BMJ. 2020. doi: 10.1136/bmj.m3464.

Sexual activity and function improve or at least are maintained following pelvic organ prolapse surgery, Danielle D. Antosh, MD, of the Houston Methodist Hospital and colleagues reported in a systematic review of prospective comparative studies on pelvic organ prolapse surgery, which was published in Obstetrics & Gynecology.

In a preliminary search of 3,124 citations, Dr. Antosh and her colleagues, who are members of the Society of Gynecologic Surgeons Systematic Review Group responsible for the study, identified and accepted 74 articles representing 67 original studies. Ten of these were ancillary studies with different reported outcomes or follow-up times, and 44 were randomized control trials. They compared the pre- and postoperative effects of pelvic organ prolapse (POP) surgery on sexual function for changes in sexual activity and function across eight different prolapse surgery categories: mixed native tissue repairs, anterior repair, posterior repair, uterosacral ligament suspension, sacrospinous ligament suspension, transvaginal mesh, biologic grafts, and sacrocolpopexy. In only three categories – posterior repair, transvaginal mesh, and biological grafts – postoperative changes in sexual function scores were similar or remained unchanged. In all other categories, total sexual function scores improved. Dyspareunia was lower after surgery for all prolapse surgery types.

“Although sexual function improves in the majority of women, it is important to note that a small proportion of women can develop de novo (new onset) dyspareunia after surgery. The rate of this ranges from 0%-9% for prolapse surgeries. However, there is limited data on posterior repairs,” Dr. Antosh said in a later interview.* 
 

POP surgeries positively impact sexual function, dyspareunia outcomes

The researchers determined that there is “moderate to high quality data” supporting the influence of POP on sexual activity and function. They also observed a lower prevalence of dyspareunia postoperatively across all surgery types, compared with baseline. Additionally, no decrease in sexual function was reported across surgical categories; in fact, sexual activity and function improved or stayed the same after POP surgery in this review.

Across most POP surgery groups, Dr. Antosh and colleagues found that with the exception of the sacrospinous ligament suspension, transvaginal mesh, and sacrocolpopexy groups, the rate of postoperative sexual activity was modestly higher. Several studies attributed this finding to a lack of partner or partner-related issues. Another 16 studies (7.7%) cited pain as the primary factor for postoperative sexual inactivity.

Few studies included in the review “reported both preoperative and postoperative rates of sexual activity and dyspareunia, and no study reported patient-level changes in sexual activity or dyspareunia (except occasionally, for de novo activity or dyspareunia),” Dr. Antosh and associates clarified. As a result, they concluded that their findings are based primarily on qualitative comparisons of events reported pre- and postoperatively from different but overlapping sets of studies.

The finding that the prevalence of dyspareunia decreased following all types of POP surgery is consistent with previous reviews. Because the studies did not account for minimally important differences in sexual function scores, it is important to consider this when interpreting results of the review. Dr. Antosh and colleagues also noted that some studies did not define dyspareunia, and those that did frequently used measures that were not validated. They also were unable to identify the persistence of dyspareunia following surgery as this was not recorded in the literature.
 

Menopausal status and other considerations

Also worth noting, the mean age of women in the studies were postmenopausal, yet the “studies did not stratify sexual function outcomes based on premenopause compared with postmenopause status.”

The researchers advised that future studies using validated definitions of sexual activity, function, and dyspareunia, as well as reporting both their preoperative and postoperative measures would do much to improve the quality of research reported.

It is widely recognized that women with pelvic floor disorders experience a high rate of sexual dysfunction, so the need to achieve optimum outcomes that at least maintain if not improve sexual function postoperatively should be of key concern when planning POP surgery for patients, they cautioned. Previous studies have observed that women experiencing POP rated the need for improved sexual function second only to resolved bulge symptoms and improvement in overall function. The women also classified sexual dysfunction in the same category of adversity as having chronic pain or having to be admitted to an intensive care unit.
 

Study provides preoperative counseling help

David M. Jaspan, DO, chairman of the department of obstetrics and gynecology and Natasha Abdullah, MD, obstetrics and gynecology resident, both of Einstein Medical Center, Philadelphia, collaboratively commented on the study findings: “This review provides physicians with data to add to the preoperative counseling for patients undergoing pelvic organ prolapse surgery.”

In particular, they noted that, while the article “is a review of previous literature, Table 1 provides an opportunity for physicians to share with their patients the important answers to their concerns surrounding postoperative sexual activity, dyspareunia, and total changes in sexual function scores based on the Pelvic Organ Prolapse/Incontinence Sexual Questionnaire 12 (PISQ-12).” 

Noting the clinical usefulness of the questionnaire, they added: “The PISQ-12 is a validated and reliable short form that evaluates sexual function in women with urinary incontinence and/or pelvic organ prolapse and predicts PISQ-31 scores. It was developed from the data of 99 of 182 women surveyed to create the long form (PISQ-31); 46 patients were recruited for further validation. Test-retest reliability was checked with a subset of 20 patients. All subsets regression analysis with R greater than 0.92 identified 12 items that predicted PISQ-31 scores. The PISQ-12 covers three domains of function: Behavioral/Emotive, Physical, and Partner-Related.”

Because ob.gyns. are trained to recognize the “multifactorial reasons (age, partner relationship, other health conditions etc.) that surround sexual activity,” Dr. Jaspan and Dr. Abdullah cautioned against prematurely concluding that the lower sexual activity score is directly related to POP surgery. 

“Because sexual function is such an important postsurgical outcome for patients, this article provides significant preoperative counseling data for patients on all POP repair options,” they observed. “No surgical option worsens sexual function. The article concludes that individually validated definitions of sexual activity, function, and dyspareunia in a measuring instrument would improve the quality of data for future studies.”

The study authors reported no relevant financial disclosures. Although no direct funding was provided by the Society of Gynecologic Surgeons, they did provide meeting space, oversight, stipends for expert and statistical support, and aid in disseminating findings. Dr. Abdullah and Dr. Jaspan had no relevant financial disclosures.
 

SOURCE: Antosh DD et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000004125.

*This article was updated on 10/28.

Sexual activity and function improve or at least are maintained following pelvic organ prolapse surgery, Danielle D. Antosh, MD, of the Houston Methodist Hospital and colleagues reported in a systematic review of prospective comparative studies on pelvic organ prolapse surgery, which was published in Obstetrics & Gynecology.

In a preliminary search of 3,124 citations, Dr. Antosh and her colleagues, who are members of the Society of Gynecologic Surgeons Systematic Review Group responsible for the study, identified and accepted 74 articles representing 67 original studies. Ten of these were ancillary studies with different reported outcomes or follow-up times, and 44 were randomized control trials. They compared the pre- and postoperative effects of pelvic organ prolapse (POP) surgery on sexual function for changes in sexual activity and function across eight different prolapse surgery categories: mixed native tissue repairs, anterior repair, posterior repair, uterosacral ligament suspension, sacrospinous ligament suspension, transvaginal mesh, biologic grafts, and sacrocolpopexy. In only three categories – posterior repair, transvaginal mesh, and biological grafts – postoperative changes in sexual function scores were similar or remained unchanged. In all other categories, total sexual function scores improved. Dyspareunia was lower after surgery for all prolapse surgery types.

“Although sexual function improves in the majority of women, it is important to note that a small proportion of women can develop de novo (new onset) dyspareunia after surgery. The rate of this ranges from 0%-9% for prolapse surgeries. However, there is limited data on posterior repairs,” Dr. Antosh said in a later interview.* 
 

POP surgeries positively impact sexual function, dyspareunia outcomes

The researchers determined that there is “moderate to high quality data” supporting the influence of POP on sexual activity and function. They also observed a lower prevalence of dyspareunia postoperatively across all surgery types, compared with baseline. Additionally, no decrease in sexual function was reported across surgical categories; in fact, sexual activity and function improved or stayed the same after POP surgery in this review.

Across most POP surgery groups, Dr. Antosh and colleagues found that with the exception of the sacrospinous ligament suspension, transvaginal mesh, and sacrocolpopexy groups, the rate of postoperative sexual activity was modestly higher. Several studies attributed this finding to a lack of partner or partner-related issues. Another 16 studies (7.7%) cited pain as the primary factor for postoperative sexual inactivity.

Few studies included in the review “reported both preoperative and postoperative rates of sexual activity and dyspareunia, and no study reported patient-level changes in sexual activity or dyspareunia (except occasionally, for de novo activity or dyspareunia),” Dr. Antosh and associates clarified. As a result, they concluded that their findings are based primarily on qualitative comparisons of events reported pre- and postoperatively from different but overlapping sets of studies.

The finding that the prevalence of dyspareunia decreased following all types of POP surgery is consistent with previous reviews. Because the studies did not account for minimally important differences in sexual function scores, it is important to consider this when interpreting results of the review. Dr. Antosh and colleagues also noted that some studies did not define dyspareunia, and those that did frequently used measures that were not validated. They also were unable to identify the persistence of dyspareunia following surgery as this was not recorded in the literature.
 

Menopausal status and other considerations

Also worth noting, the mean age of women in the studies were postmenopausal, yet the “studies did not stratify sexual function outcomes based on premenopause compared with postmenopause status.”

The researchers advised that future studies using validated definitions of sexual activity, function, and dyspareunia, as well as reporting both their preoperative and postoperative measures would do much to improve the quality of research reported.

It is widely recognized that women with pelvic floor disorders experience a high rate of sexual dysfunction, so the need to achieve optimum outcomes that at least maintain if not improve sexual function postoperatively should be of key concern when planning POP surgery for patients, they cautioned. Previous studies have observed that women experiencing POP rated the need for improved sexual function second only to resolved bulge symptoms and improvement in overall function. The women also classified sexual dysfunction in the same category of adversity as having chronic pain or having to be admitted to an intensive care unit.
 

Study provides preoperative counseling help

David M. Jaspan, DO, chairman of the department of obstetrics and gynecology and Natasha Abdullah, MD, obstetrics and gynecology resident, both of Einstein Medical Center, Philadelphia, collaboratively commented on the study findings: “This review provides physicians with data to add to the preoperative counseling for patients undergoing pelvic organ prolapse surgery.”

In particular, they noted that, while the article “is a review of previous literature, Table 1 provides an opportunity for physicians to share with their patients the important answers to their concerns surrounding postoperative sexual activity, dyspareunia, and total changes in sexual function scores based on the Pelvic Organ Prolapse/Incontinence Sexual Questionnaire 12 (PISQ-12).” 

Noting the clinical usefulness of the questionnaire, they added: “The PISQ-12 is a validated and reliable short form that evaluates sexual function in women with urinary incontinence and/or pelvic organ prolapse and predicts PISQ-31 scores. It was developed from the data of 99 of 182 women surveyed to create the long form (PISQ-31); 46 patients were recruited for further validation. Test-retest reliability was checked with a subset of 20 patients. All subsets regression analysis with R greater than 0.92 identified 12 items that predicted PISQ-31 scores. The PISQ-12 covers three domains of function: Behavioral/Emotive, Physical, and Partner-Related.”

Because ob.gyns. are trained to recognize the “multifactorial reasons (age, partner relationship, other health conditions etc.) that surround sexual activity,” Dr. Jaspan and Dr. Abdullah cautioned against prematurely concluding that the lower sexual activity score is directly related to POP surgery. 

“Because sexual function is such an important postsurgical outcome for patients, this article provides significant preoperative counseling data for patients on all POP repair options,” they observed. “No surgical option worsens sexual function. The article concludes that individually validated definitions of sexual activity, function, and dyspareunia in a measuring instrument would improve the quality of data for future studies.”

The study authors reported no relevant financial disclosures. Although no direct funding was provided by the Society of Gynecologic Surgeons, they did provide meeting space, oversight, stipends for expert and statistical support, and aid in disseminating findings. Dr. Abdullah and Dr. Jaspan had no relevant financial disclosures.
 

SOURCE: Antosh DD et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000004125.

*This article was updated on 10/28.

Sexual activity and function improve or at least are maintained following pelvic organ prolapse surgery, Danielle D. Antosh, MD, of the Houston Methodist Hospital and colleagues reported in a systematic review of prospective comparative studies on pelvic organ prolapse surgery, which was published in Obstetrics & Gynecology.

In a preliminary search of 3,124 citations, Dr. Antosh and her colleagues, who are members of the Society of Gynecologic Surgeons Systematic Review Group responsible for the study, identified and accepted 74 articles representing 67 original studies. Ten of these were ancillary studies with different reported outcomes or follow-up times, and 44 were randomized control trials. They compared the pre- and postoperative effects of pelvic organ prolapse (POP) surgery on sexual function for changes in sexual activity and function across eight different prolapse surgery categories: mixed native tissue repairs, anterior repair, posterior repair, uterosacral ligament suspension, sacrospinous ligament suspension, transvaginal mesh, biologic grafts, and sacrocolpopexy. In only three categories – posterior repair, transvaginal mesh, and biological grafts – postoperative changes in sexual function scores were similar or remained unchanged. In all other categories, total sexual function scores improved. Dyspareunia was lower after surgery for all prolapse surgery types.

“Although sexual function improves in the majority of women, it is important to note that a small proportion of women can develop de novo (new onset) dyspareunia after surgery. The rate of this ranges from 0%-9% for prolapse surgeries. However, there is limited data on posterior repairs,” Dr. Antosh said in a later interview.* 
 

POP surgeries positively impact sexual function, dyspareunia outcomes

The researchers determined that there is “moderate to high quality data” supporting the influence of POP on sexual activity and function. They also observed a lower prevalence of dyspareunia postoperatively across all surgery types, compared with baseline. Additionally, no decrease in sexual function was reported across surgical categories; in fact, sexual activity and function improved or stayed the same after POP surgery in this review.

Across most POP surgery groups, Dr. Antosh and colleagues found that with the exception of the sacrospinous ligament suspension, transvaginal mesh, and sacrocolpopexy groups, the rate of postoperative sexual activity was modestly higher. Several studies attributed this finding to a lack of partner or partner-related issues. Another 16 studies (7.7%) cited pain as the primary factor for postoperative sexual inactivity.

Few studies included in the review “reported both preoperative and postoperative rates of sexual activity and dyspareunia, and no study reported patient-level changes in sexual activity or dyspareunia (except occasionally, for de novo activity or dyspareunia),” Dr. Antosh and associates clarified. As a result, they concluded that their findings are based primarily on qualitative comparisons of events reported pre- and postoperatively from different but overlapping sets of studies.

The finding that the prevalence of dyspareunia decreased following all types of POP surgery is consistent with previous reviews. Because the studies did not account for minimally important differences in sexual function scores, it is important to consider this when interpreting results of the review. Dr. Antosh and colleagues also noted that some studies did not define dyspareunia, and those that did frequently used measures that were not validated. They also were unable to identify the persistence of dyspareunia following surgery as this was not recorded in the literature.
 

Menopausal status and other considerations

Also worth noting, the mean age of women in the studies were postmenopausal, yet the “studies did not stratify sexual function outcomes based on premenopause compared with postmenopause status.”

The researchers advised that future studies using validated definitions of sexual activity, function, and dyspareunia, as well as reporting both their preoperative and postoperative measures would do much to improve the quality of research reported.

It is widely recognized that women with pelvic floor disorders experience a high rate of sexual dysfunction, so the need to achieve optimum outcomes that at least maintain if not improve sexual function postoperatively should be of key concern when planning POP surgery for patients, they cautioned. Previous studies have observed that women experiencing POP rated the need for improved sexual function second only to resolved bulge symptoms and improvement in overall function. The women also classified sexual dysfunction in the same category of adversity as having chronic pain or having to be admitted to an intensive care unit.
 

Study provides preoperative counseling help

David M. Jaspan, DO, chairman of the department of obstetrics and gynecology and Natasha Abdullah, MD, obstetrics and gynecology resident, both of Einstein Medical Center, Philadelphia, collaboratively commented on the study findings: “This review provides physicians with data to add to the preoperative counseling for patients undergoing pelvic organ prolapse surgery.”

In particular, they noted that, while the article “is a review of previous literature, Table 1 provides an opportunity for physicians to share with their patients the important answers to their concerns surrounding postoperative sexual activity, dyspareunia, and total changes in sexual function scores based on the Pelvic Organ Prolapse/Incontinence Sexual Questionnaire 12 (PISQ-12).” 

Noting the clinical usefulness of the questionnaire, they added: “The PISQ-12 is a validated and reliable short form that evaluates sexual function in women with urinary incontinence and/or pelvic organ prolapse and predicts PISQ-31 scores. It was developed from the data of 99 of 182 women surveyed to create the long form (PISQ-31); 46 patients were recruited for further validation. Test-retest reliability was checked with a subset of 20 patients. All subsets regression analysis with R greater than 0.92 identified 12 items that predicted PISQ-31 scores. The PISQ-12 covers three domains of function: Behavioral/Emotive, Physical, and Partner-Related.”

Because ob.gyns. are trained to recognize the “multifactorial reasons (age, partner relationship, other health conditions etc.) that surround sexual activity,” Dr. Jaspan and Dr. Abdullah cautioned against prematurely concluding that the lower sexual activity score is directly related to POP surgery. 

“Because sexual function is such an important postsurgical outcome for patients, this article provides significant preoperative counseling data for patients on all POP repair options,” they observed. “No surgical option worsens sexual function. The article concludes that individually validated definitions of sexual activity, function, and dyspareunia in a measuring instrument would improve the quality of data for future studies.”

The study authors reported no relevant financial disclosures. Although no direct funding was provided by the Society of Gynecologic Surgeons, they did provide meeting space, oversight, stipends for expert and statistical support, and aid in disseminating findings. Dr. Abdullah and Dr. Jaspan had no relevant financial disclosures.
 

SOURCE: Antosh DD et al. Obstet Gynecol. 2020. doi: 10.1097/AOG.0000000000004125.

*This article was updated on 10/28.

Starting early intervention (EI) enrollment before age 6 months in children who are deaf or hard of hearing may have a lasting influence on ensuring kindergarten readiness, Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPH of Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center and colleagues reported in Pediatrics.

The researchers created a comprehensive, longitudinal, population-based database, which linked hearing screening and diagnostic data to that of early intervention data and educational records for 1,746 infants identified with permanent hearing loss who were born between Jan. 1, 2008 and Dec. 31, 2014 The database was established in partnership with the Ohio Departments of Health, Developmental Disabilities and Education, and with the support of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities.

Of those, 784 children ranging from preschool to fourth grade were evaluated based on education data available for the 2017 and 2018 school year that had been linked by way of an identifier that flagged students enrolled in EI.

All together, 417 students had kindergarten assessment records, and of those, 385 had Kindergarten Readiness Assessments (KRAs) between 2014 and 2018; 222 (58%) had been enrolled in EI before the age of 6 months. Of those who were enrolled early, the median age of EI enrollment was 3.4 months (2.4-4.3 months) and in those enrolled later, the median age was 9.2 months (7.5-15.4 months).
 

The importance of EI prior to 6 months

A total of 109 children (28%) receiving services as part of Ohio’s early intervention programs demonstrated kindergarten readiness on their overall KRA scores. The scores revealed that children receiving EI early (34%, n = 75) were more likely to be ready for kindergarten than were those who entered later (21%, n = 34; P = .005). They also were more likely to have on track language and literacy scores (60% vs. 42%, respectively; P = .0006).

Dr. Meinzen-Derr and colleagues noted that factors identified with “an increased odds of being on track included having private insurance and some college education for the mother.” Conversely, factors identified with a decreased likelihood included having a diagnosed disability and bilateral hearing loss.

The researchers cautioned that children transitioned from EI to academic settings will face challenges that may go underrecognized because a school’s focus often is largely on social and academic performance. Thus, working with linked data systems can provide the data to track outcomes that might otherwise be missed, the researchers noted.

Furthermore, they cautioned that even though kindergarten readiness offers some glimpse into future academic success, these measures alone may not be sufficient predictors for children who are deaf or hard of hearing. Risk for communication, social, and academic delays persist throughout school so it is important to employ alternative methods of reading instruction in order to “achieve more complex skills (e.g., complex syntax and advanced vocabulary) necessary for reading proficiency,” the researchers said.

Collecting data from public health and education systems posed limitations for the study. In addition, the absence of kindergarten language assessments prevented Dr. Meinzen-Derr and colleagues from better elucidating reasons for kindergarten readiness. Also beyond the scope of the study was the ability to evaluate the effect service types may have had on outcomes.

The next step in the research process is to evaluate the link between outcomes and specific EI parameters, they said. “Our study demonstrates that an integrated data system can address relevant and important topics regarding early academic outcomes (kindergarten readiness and reading levels) among children who received EI. The current findings provide a new context by evaluating later outcomes among children who are deaf or hard of hearing,” they added, noting that more research is needed to grasp how various EI services impact outcomes since enrollment age is a marker of EI exposure.
 

Early intervention is everyone’s business

In a separate interview, Amy Hardy M.S. CCC-SLP, speech language pathologist and clinical professor at Idaho State University, emphasized the importance of early intervention, citing reports from the National Center for Hearing Assessment and Management, which credits detection and treatment of hearing loss at birth per child to saving $400,000 in special education costs by the time they graduate from high school (https://www.ncsl.org/research/health/newborn-hearing-screening-state-laws.aspx).

Earliest possible hearing detection is and should be a standard of care for infants and children, and the importance of follow up appointments also cannot be understated,” Ms. Hardy said. Perhaps the biggest challenge for professionals involved with early learning is that many children are delayed in receiving follow up appointments for hearing detection, she added. When families fail to receive a follow-up notice or opt not attend the follow-up appointment, this leaves infants that may be deaf or hard of hearing unidentified, she explained, noting that in some states, lack of consistent and stable state funding needed for effective follow-up with these children and families is a factor.

Ms. Hardy urged that anyone who knows an expectant family can tout the importance of early screenings. Even daycare workers have a responsibility to play a role in early hearing detection, she noted.

Although speech language pathologists routinely advocate for early intervention, “it is never too late to work on skills that will assist children in their everyday lives,” she advised.

The authors had no relevant financial disclosures. The study was funded in part by the Disability Research and Dissemination Center via cooperative agreements with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

SOURCE: Meinzen-Derr J et al. Pediatrics. 2020 October. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-0557.

Starting early intervention (EI) enrollment before age 6 months in children who are deaf or hard of hearing may have a lasting influence on ensuring kindergarten readiness, Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPH of Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center and colleagues reported in Pediatrics.

The researchers created a comprehensive, longitudinal, population-based database, which linked hearing screening and diagnostic data to that of early intervention data and educational records for 1,746 infants identified with permanent hearing loss who were born between Jan. 1, 2008 and Dec. 31, 2014 The database was established in partnership with the Ohio Departments of Health, Developmental Disabilities and Education, and with the support of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities.

Of those, 784 children ranging from preschool to fourth grade were evaluated based on education data available for the 2017 and 2018 school year that had been linked by way of an identifier that flagged students enrolled in EI.

All together, 417 students had kindergarten assessment records, and of those, 385 had Kindergarten Readiness Assessments (KRAs) between 2014 and 2018; 222 (58%) had been enrolled in EI before the age of 6 months. Of those who were enrolled early, the median age of EI enrollment was 3.4 months (2.4-4.3 months) and in those enrolled later, the median age was 9.2 months (7.5-15.4 months).
 

The importance of EI prior to 6 months

A total of 109 children (28%) receiving services as part of Ohio’s early intervention programs demonstrated kindergarten readiness on their overall KRA scores. The scores revealed that children receiving EI early (34%, n = 75) were more likely to be ready for kindergarten than were those who entered later (21%, n = 34; P = .005). They also were more likely to have on track language and literacy scores (60% vs. 42%, respectively; P = .0006).

Dr. Meinzen-Derr and colleagues noted that factors identified with “an increased odds of being on track included having private insurance and some college education for the mother.” Conversely, factors identified with a decreased likelihood included having a diagnosed disability and bilateral hearing loss.

The researchers cautioned that children transitioned from EI to academic settings will face challenges that may go underrecognized because a school’s focus often is largely on social and academic performance. Thus, working with linked data systems can provide the data to track outcomes that might otherwise be missed, the researchers noted.

Furthermore, they cautioned that even though kindergarten readiness offers some glimpse into future academic success, these measures alone may not be sufficient predictors for children who are deaf or hard of hearing. Risk for communication, social, and academic delays persist throughout school so it is important to employ alternative methods of reading instruction in order to “achieve more complex skills (e.g., complex syntax and advanced vocabulary) necessary for reading proficiency,” the researchers said.

Collecting data from public health and education systems posed limitations for the study. In addition, the absence of kindergarten language assessments prevented Dr. Meinzen-Derr and colleagues from better elucidating reasons for kindergarten readiness. Also beyond the scope of the study was the ability to evaluate the effect service types may have had on outcomes.

The next step in the research process is to evaluate the link between outcomes and specific EI parameters, they said. “Our study demonstrates that an integrated data system can address relevant and important topics regarding early academic outcomes (kindergarten readiness and reading levels) among children who received EI. The current findings provide a new context by evaluating later outcomes among children who are deaf or hard of hearing,” they added, noting that more research is needed to grasp how various EI services impact outcomes since enrollment age is a marker of EI exposure.
 

Early intervention is everyone’s business

In a separate interview, Amy Hardy M.S. CCC-SLP, speech language pathologist and clinical professor at Idaho State University, emphasized the importance of early intervention, citing reports from the National Center for Hearing Assessment and Management, which credits detection and treatment of hearing loss at birth per child to saving $400,000 in special education costs by the time they graduate from high school (https://www.ncsl.org/research/health/newborn-hearing-screening-state-laws.aspx).

Earliest possible hearing detection is and should be a standard of care for infants and children, and the importance of follow up appointments also cannot be understated,” Ms. Hardy said. Perhaps the biggest challenge for professionals involved with early learning is that many children are delayed in receiving follow up appointments for hearing detection, she added. When families fail to receive a follow-up notice or opt not attend the follow-up appointment, this leaves infants that may be deaf or hard of hearing unidentified, she explained, noting that in some states, lack of consistent and stable state funding needed for effective follow-up with these children and families is a factor.

Ms. Hardy urged that anyone who knows an expectant family can tout the importance of early screenings. Even daycare workers have a responsibility to play a role in early hearing detection, she noted.

Although speech language pathologists routinely advocate for early intervention, “it is never too late to work on skills that will assist children in their everyday lives,” she advised.

The authors had no relevant financial disclosures. The study was funded in part by the Disability Research and Dissemination Center via cooperative agreements with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

SOURCE: Meinzen-Derr J et al. Pediatrics. 2020 October. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-0557.

Starting early intervention (EI) enrollment before age 6 months in children who are deaf or hard of hearing may have a lasting influence on ensuring kindergarten readiness, Jareen Meinzen-Derr, PhD, MPH of Cincinnati Children’s Hospital Medical Center and colleagues reported in Pediatrics.

The researchers created a comprehensive, longitudinal, population-based database, which linked hearing screening and diagnostic data to that of early intervention data and educational records for 1,746 infants identified with permanent hearing loss who were born between Jan. 1, 2008 and Dec. 31, 2014 The database was established in partnership with the Ohio Departments of Health, Developmental Disabilities and Education, and with the support of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and the National Center on Birth Defects and Developmental Disabilities.

Of those, 784 children ranging from preschool to fourth grade were evaluated based on education data available for the 2017 and 2018 school year that had been linked by way of an identifier that flagged students enrolled in EI.

All together, 417 students had kindergarten assessment records, and of those, 385 had Kindergarten Readiness Assessments (KRAs) between 2014 and 2018; 222 (58%) had been enrolled in EI before the age of 6 months. Of those who were enrolled early, the median age of EI enrollment was 3.4 months (2.4-4.3 months) and in those enrolled later, the median age was 9.2 months (7.5-15.4 months).
 

The importance of EI prior to 6 months

A total of 109 children (28%) receiving services as part of Ohio’s early intervention programs demonstrated kindergarten readiness on their overall KRA scores. The scores revealed that children receiving EI early (34%, n = 75) were more likely to be ready for kindergarten than were those who entered later (21%, n = 34; P = .005). They also were more likely to have on track language and literacy scores (60% vs. 42%, respectively; P = .0006).

Dr. Meinzen-Derr and colleagues noted that factors identified with “an increased odds of being on track included having private insurance and some college education for the mother.” Conversely, factors identified with a decreased likelihood included having a diagnosed disability and bilateral hearing loss.

The researchers cautioned that children transitioned from EI to academic settings will face challenges that may go underrecognized because a school’s focus often is largely on social and academic performance. Thus, working with linked data systems can provide the data to track outcomes that might otherwise be missed, the researchers noted.

Furthermore, they cautioned that even though kindergarten readiness offers some glimpse into future academic success, these measures alone may not be sufficient predictors for children who are deaf or hard of hearing. Risk for communication, social, and academic delays persist throughout school so it is important to employ alternative methods of reading instruction in order to “achieve more complex skills (e.g., complex syntax and advanced vocabulary) necessary for reading proficiency,” the researchers said.

Collecting data from public health and education systems posed limitations for the study. In addition, the absence of kindergarten language assessments prevented Dr. Meinzen-Derr and colleagues from better elucidating reasons for kindergarten readiness. Also beyond the scope of the study was the ability to evaluate the effect service types may have had on outcomes.

The next step in the research process is to evaluate the link between outcomes and specific EI parameters, they said. “Our study demonstrates that an integrated data system can address relevant and important topics regarding early academic outcomes (kindergarten readiness and reading levels) among children who received EI. The current findings provide a new context by evaluating later outcomes among children who are deaf or hard of hearing,” they added, noting that more research is needed to grasp how various EI services impact outcomes since enrollment age is a marker of EI exposure.
 

Early intervention is everyone’s business

In a separate interview, Amy Hardy M.S. CCC-SLP, speech language pathologist and clinical professor at Idaho State University, emphasized the importance of early intervention, citing reports from the National Center for Hearing Assessment and Management, which credits detection and treatment of hearing loss at birth per child to saving $400,000 in special education costs by the time they graduate from high school (https://www.ncsl.org/research/health/newborn-hearing-screening-state-laws.aspx).

Earliest possible hearing detection is and should be a standard of care for infants and children, and the importance of follow up appointments also cannot be understated,” Ms. Hardy said. Perhaps the biggest challenge for professionals involved with early learning is that many children are delayed in receiving follow up appointments for hearing detection, she added. When families fail to receive a follow-up notice or opt not attend the follow-up appointment, this leaves infants that may be deaf or hard of hearing unidentified, she explained, noting that in some states, lack of consistent and stable state funding needed for effective follow-up with these children and families is a factor.

Ms. Hardy urged that anyone who knows an expectant family can tout the importance of early screenings. Even daycare workers have a responsibility to play a role in early hearing detection, she noted.

Although speech language pathologists routinely advocate for early intervention, “it is never too late to work on skills that will assist children in their everyday lives,” she advised.

The authors had no relevant financial disclosures. The study was funded in part by the Disability Research and Dissemination Center via cooperative agreements with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

SOURCE: Meinzen-Derr J et al. Pediatrics. 2020 October. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-0557.

Increasing parental awareness of noncigarette tobacco products should be part of “tobacco anticipatory guidance and prevention support,” Tsu-Suan Wu and Benjamin W. Chaffee, DDS, PhD, of the University of California, San Francisco, advised in their study in Pediatrics.

Carpe89/ThinkStock

Previous studies have shown that children who grow up in a nonsmoking household are less likely to begin smoking themselves, and active parental engagement in interventions shows promise overall in protecting children from drug, alcohol, and illicit drug use. Households with rigid rules against smoking offer a deterrent for children who might otherwise be tempted, the researchers noted.

Other studies have shown that while youth smoking is on the decline, use of noncigarette products is increasing sharply. The inconspicuous appearance and attractive scents these delivery devices afford make it easier to conceal them from parents.

In the current study, using data from the Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health (PATH) Study involving 23,170 parents and youth ages 9 and up, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee sought to assess to what extent parents had knowledge or suspicions of tobacco use and also to evaluate the association between youth initiating tobacco use and the establishment of household rules and engaging in regular conversation about tobacco.

Study results revealed in three of the four groups evaluated that youth were most likely to engage in using several different types of tobacco (polytobacco) products; in the fourth group, e-cigarette use was most common. Among polytobacco users, fully 77%-80% reported cigarette usage.
 

Parental knowledge and actions

Overall, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee “identified substantial lapses in parents’ awareness of their children’s tobacco use.” Parents were most likely to register awareness when their children smoked cigarettes; half as many parents were aware or suspected use when noncigarette products were used.

Parents who had heightened awareness about possible tobacco usage tended to be the child’s mother, had completed lower levels of education, parented children who were older, male and non-Hispanic, and lived with a tobacco user.

Noteworthy was the growing percentage of parents who report awareness or suspicions of cigarette usage – approximately 70% – compared with previous study findings – about 40%. The researchers speculated that this increase could be directly tied to growing social concern regarding youth smoking. Unfortunately, parents will continue to be challenged to keep up with constantly changing e-cigarette designs in maintaining their awareness, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee noted.

Establishing strict household rules was found to be more effective than just talking with youth about usage, which half of the youth reported their parents did. At all time points, the risk of tobacco initiation was 20%-26% lower for children who lived in a house with strict household rules forbidding any tobacco use by anyone. The researchers observed that success with the household rules method was best achieved with children at younger ages.

The study did not measure the quality or frequency of antitobacco conversations but it should not be concluded definitively that all parental communication is unhelpful, the researchers cautioned.

To their knowledge, this study is the first to analyze the effects of household antitobacco strategies on discouraging initiation the use of tobacco and other smoking products as well as assessing parental awareness surrounding tobacco usage among youth.
 

What to tell parents

In a separate interview, Kelly Curran, MD, MA, assistant professor of pediatrics at the University of Oklahoma, Oklahoma City, commented on the explosive growth of e-cigarette use in the last 7 years.

What makes e-cigs so difficult to detect is that they “can resemble common objects such as flash drives or pens, and as a result, can often be hidden or overlooked by parents,” noted Dr. Curran.

The most important message for parents from this study is that they have the potential to have a large impact in the prevention of tobacco initiation, she said. “This effort requires parents to ‘walk the walk’ instead of just ‘talking the talk.”

As the study revealed, simply talking to teens about not using tobacco products doesn’t decrease use, but “creating strict household rules around no tobacco use for all visitors and inhabitants has a significant impact in decreasing youth tobacco initiation – by nearly 25%,” she added. “When counseling patients and families about tobacco prevention, clinicians should encourage them to create a tobacco-free home.”

The study was funded by a National Institutes of Health grant and the Delta Dental Community Care Foundation. The authors have no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Curran, who is a member of the Pediatric News editorial advisory board, said she had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Wu T-S and Chaffee BW. Pediatrics 2020 October. doi: 10.1542/peds.2019-4034.

Increasing parental awareness of noncigarette tobacco products should be part of “tobacco anticipatory guidance and prevention support,” Tsu-Suan Wu and Benjamin W. Chaffee, DDS, PhD, of the University of California, San Francisco, advised in their study in Pediatrics.

Carpe89/ThinkStock

Previous studies have shown that children who grow up in a nonsmoking household are less likely to begin smoking themselves, and active parental engagement in interventions shows promise overall in protecting children from drug, alcohol, and illicit drug use. Households with rigid rules against smoking offer a deterrent for children who might otherwise be tempted, the researchers noted.

Other studies have shown that while youth smoking is on the decline, use of noncigarette products is increasing sharply. The inconspicuous appearance and attractive scents these delivery devices afford make it easier to conceal them from parents.

In the current study, using data from the Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health (PATH) Study involving 23,170 parents and youth ages 9 and up, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee sought to assess to what extent parents had knowledge or suspicions of tobacco use and also to evaluate the association between youth initiating tobacco use and the establishment of household rules and engaging in regular conversation about tobacco.

Study results revealed in three of the four groups evaluated that youth were most likely to engage in using several different types of tobacco (polytobacco) products; in the fourth group, e-cigarette use was most common. Among polytobacco users, fully 77%-80% reported cigarette usage.
 

Parental knowledge and actions

Overall, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee “identified substantial lapses in parents’ awareness of their children’s tobacco use.” Parents were most likely to register awareness when their children smoked cigarettes; half as many parents were aware or suspected use when noncigarette products were used.

Parents who had heightened awareness about possible tobacco usage tended to be the child’s mother, had completed lower levels of education, parented children who were older, male and non-Hispanic, and lived with a tobacco user.

Noteworthy was the growing percentage of parents who report awareness or suspicions of cigarette usage – approximately 70% – compared with previous study findings – about 40%. The researchers speculated that this increase could be directly tied to growing social concern regarding youth smoking. Unfortunately, parents will continue to be challenged to keep up with constantly changing e-cigarette designs in maintaining their awareness, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee noted.

Establishing strict household rules was found to be more effective than just talking with youth about usage, which half of the youth reported their parents did. At all time points, the risk of tobacco initiation was 20%-26% lower for children who lived in a house with strict household rules forbidding any tobacco use by anyone. The researchers observed that success with the household rules method was best achieved with children at younger ages.

The study did not measure the quality or frequency of antitobacco conversations but it should not be concluded definitively that all parental communication is unhelpful, the researchers cautioned.

To their knowledge, this study is the first to analyze the effects of household antitobacco strategies on discouraging initiation the use of tobacco and other smoking products as well as assessing parental awareness surrounding tobacco usage among youth.
 

What to tell parents

In a separate interview, Kelly Curran, MD, MA, assistant professor of pediatrics at the University of Oklahoma, Oklahoma City, commented on the explosive growth of e-cigarette use in the last 7 years.

What makes e-cigs so difficult to detect is that they “can resemble common objects such as flash drives or pens, and as a result, can often be hidden or overlooked by parents,” noted Dr. Curran.

The most important message for parents from this study is that they have the potential to have a large impact in the prevention of tobacco initiation, she said. “This effort requires parents to ‘walk the walk’ instead of just ‘talking the talk.”

As the study revealed, simply talking to teens about not using tobacco products doesn’t decrease use, but “creating strict household rules around no tobacco use for all visitors and inhabitants has a significant impact in decreasing youth tobacco initiation – by nearly 25%,” she added. “When counseling patients and families about tobacco prevention, clinicians should encourage them to create a tobacco-free home.”

The study was funded by a National Institutes of Health grant and the Delta Dental Community Care Foundation. The authors have no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Curran, who is a member of the Pediatric News editorial advisory board, said she had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Wu T-S and Chaffee BW. Pediatrics 2020 October. doi: 10.1542/peds.2019-4034.

Increasing parental awareness of noncigarette tobacco products should be part of “tobacco anticipatory guidance and prevention support,” Tsu-Suan Wu and Benjamin W. Chaffee, DDS, PhD, of the University of California, San Francisco, advised in their study in Pediatrics.

Carpe89/ThinkStock

Previous studies have shown that children who grow up in a nonsmoking household are less likely to begin smoking themselves, and active parental engagement in interventions shows promise overall in protecting children from drug, alcohol, and illicit drug use. Households with rigid rules against smoking offer a deterrent for children who might otherwise be tempted, the researchers noted.

Other studies have shown that while youth smoking is on the decline, use of noncigarette products is increasing sharply. The inconspicuous appearance and attractive scents these delivery devices afford make it easier to conceal them from parents.

In the current study, using data from the Population Assessment of Tobacco and Health (PATH) Study involving 23,170 parents and youth ages 9 and up, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee sought to assess to what extent parents had knowledge or suspicions of tobacco use and also to evaluate the association between youth initiating tobacco use and the establishment of household rules and engaging in regular conversation about tobacco.

Study results revealed in three of the four groups evaluated that youth were most likely to engage in using several different types of tobacco (polytobacco) products; in the fourth group, e-cigarette use was most common. Among polytobacco users, fully 77%-80% reported cigarette usage.
 

Parental knowledge and actions

Overall, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee “identified substantial lapses in parents’ awareness of their children’s tobacco use.” Parents were most likely to register awareness when their children smoked cigarettes; half as many parents were aware or suspected use when noncigarette products were used.

Parents who had heightened awareness about possible tobacco usage tended to be the child’s mother, had completed lower levels of education, parented children who were older, male and non-Hispanic, and lived with a tobacco user.

Noteworthy was the growing percentage of parents who report awareness or suspicions of cigarette usage – approximately 70% – compared with previous study findings – about 40%. The researchers speculated that this increase could be directly tied to growing social concern regarding youth smoking. Unfortunately, parents will continue to be challenged to keep up with constantly changing e-cigarette designs in maintaining their awareness, Mr. Wu and Dr. Chaffee noted.

Establishing strict household rules was found to be more effective than just talking with youth about usage, which half of the youth reported their parents did. At all time points, the risk of tobacco initiation was 20%-26% lower for children who lived in a house with strict household rules forbidding any tobacco use by anyone. The researchers observed that success with the household rules method was best achieved with children at younger ages.

The study did not measure the quality or frequency of antitobacco conversations but it should not be concluded definitively that all parental communication is unhelpful, the researchers cautioned.

To their knowledge, this study is the first to analyze the effects of household antitobacco strategies on discouraging initiation the use of tobacco and other smoking products as well as assessing parental awareness surrounding tobacco usage among youth.
 

What to tell parents

In a separate interview, Kelly Curran, MD, MA, assistant professor of pediatrics at the University of Oklahoma, Oklahoma City, commented on the explosive growth of e-cigarette use in the last 7 years.

What makes e-cigs so difficult to detect is that they “can resemble common objects such as flash drives or pens, and as a result, can often be hidden or overlooked by parents,” noted Dr. Curran.

The most important message for parents from this study is that they have the potential to have a large impact in the prevention of tobacco initiation, she said. “This effort requires parents to ‘walk the walk’ instead of just ‘talking the talk.”

As the study revealed, simply talking to teens about not using tobacco products doesn’t decrease use, but “creating strict household rules around no tobacco use for all visitors and inhabitants has a significant impact in decreasing youth tobacco initiation – by nearly 25%,” she added. “When counseling patients and families about tobacco prevention, clinicians should encourage them to create a tobacco-free home.”

The study was funded by a National Institutes of Health grant and the Delta Dental Community Care Foundation. The authors have no relevant financial disclosures. Dr. Curran, who is a member of the Pediatric News editorial advisory board, said she had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Wu T-S and Chaffee BW. Pediatrics 2020 October. doi: 10.1542/peds.2019-4034.

Unlike previous studies focused on vaccine effectiveness (VE) in ambulatory care office visits, Angela P. Campbell, MD, MPH, and associates have uncovered evidence of the overall benefit influenza vaccines play in reducing hospitalizations and emergency department visits in pediatric influenza patients.

Yarinca/istockphoto

“Our data provide important VE estimates against severe influenza in children,” the researchers noted in Pediatrics, adding that the findings “provide important evidence supporting the annual recommendation that all children 6 months and older should receive influenza vaccination.”

Dr. Campbell and colleagues collected ongoing surveillance data from the New Vaccine Surveillance Network (NVSN), which is a network of pediatric hospitals across seven cities, including Kansas City, Mo.; Rochester, N.Y.; Cincinnati; Pittsburgh; Nashville, Tenn.; Houston; and Seattle. The influenza season encompassed the period Nov. 7, 2018 to June 21, 2019.

A total of 2,748 hospitalized children and 2,676 children who had completed ED visits that did not lead to hospitalization were included. Once those under 6 months were excluded, 1,792 hospitalized children were included in the VE analysis; of these, 226 (13%) tested positive for influenza infection, including 211 (93%) with influenza A viruses and 15 (7%) with influenza B viruses. Fully 1,611 of the patients (90%), had verified vaccine status, while 181 (10%) had solely parental reported vaccine status. The researchers reported 88 (5%) of the patients received mechanical ventilation and 7 (<1%) died.

Most noteworthy, the researchers observed a significant reduction in laboratory-confirmed hospitalizations by 41% in children vaccinated against the flu. They further estimated a significant reduction in hospitalizations linked to A(H3N2) and A(H1N1)pdm09 viruses, even in the presence of circulating A(H3N2) viruses that differed from the A(H3N2) vaccine component.

Studies from other countries during the same time period showed that while “significant protection against influenza-associated ambulatory care visits and hospitalizations among children infected with A(H1N1)pdm09 viruses” was observed, the same could not be said for protection against A(H3N2) viruses, which varied among pediatric outpatients in the United States (24%), in England (17% outpatient; 31% inpatient), Europe (46%), and Canada (48%). They explained that such variation in vaccine protection is multifactorial, and includes virus-, host-, and environment-related factors. They also noted that regional variations in circulating viruses, host factors including age, imprinting, and previous vaccination could explain the study’s finding of vaccine protection against both A(H1N1)pdm09 and A(H3N2) viruses.

When comparing VE estimates between ED visits and hospitalizations, the researchers observed one significant difference, that “hospitalized children likely represent more medically complex patients, with 58% having underlying medical conditions and 38% reporting at lease one hospitalization in the past year, compared with 28% and 14% respectively, among ED participants.”

Strengths of the study included the prospective multisite enrollment that provided data across diverse locations and representation from pediatric hospitalizations and ED care, which were not previously strongly represented in the literature. The single-season study with small sample size was considered a limitation, as was the inability to evaluate full and partial vaccine status. Vaccine data also were limited for many of the ED patients observed.

Dr. Campbell and colleagues did caution that while they consider their test-negative design optimal for evaluating both hospitalized and ED patients, they feel their results should not be “interpreted as VE against influenza-associated ambulatory care visits or infections that are not medically attended.”

In a separate interview, Michael E. Pichichero, MD, director of the Rochester General Hospital Research Institute and a clinical professor of pediatrics at the University of Rochester (N.Y.), observed: “There are really no surprises here. A well done contemporary study confirms again the benefits of annual influenza vaccinations for children. Viral coinfections involving SARS-CoV-2 and influenza have been reported from Australia to cause heightened illnesses. That observation provides further impetus for parents to have their children receive influenza vaccinations.”

The researchers cited multiple sources of financial support for their ongoing work, including Sanofi, Quidel, Moderna, Karius, GlaxoSmithKline, Merck, AstraZeneca, and Pfizer. Funding for this study was supported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Dr. Pichichero said he had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Campbell AP et al. Pediatrics. 2020. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-1368.

Unlike previous studies focused on vaccine effectiveness (VE) in ambulatory care office visits, Angela P. Campbell, MD, MPH, and associates have uncovered evidence of the overall benefit influenza vaccines play in reducing hospitalizations and emergency department visits in pediatric influenza patients.

Yarinca/istockphoto

“Our data provide important VE estimates against severe influenza in children,” the researchers noted in Pediatrics, adding that the findings “provide important evidence supporting the annual recommendation that all children 6 months and older should receive influenza vaccination.”

Dr. Campbell and colleagues collected ongoing surveillance data from the New Vaccine Surveillance Network (NVSN), which is a network of pediatric hospitals across seven cities, including Kansas City, Mo.; Rochester, N.Y.; Cincinnati; Pittsburgh; Nashville, Tenn.; Houston; and Seattle. The influenza season encompassed the period Nov. 7, 2018 to June 21, 2019.

A total of 2,748 hospitalized children and 2,676 children who had completed ED visits that did not lead to hospitalization were included. Once those under 6 months were excluded, 1,792 hospitalized children were included in the VE analysis; of these, 226 (13%) tested positive for influenza infection, including 211 (93%) with influenza A viruses and 15 (7%) with influenza B viruses. Fully 1,611 of the patients (90%), had verified vaccine status, while 181 (10%) had solely parental reported vaccine status. The researchers reported 88 (5%) of the patients received mechanical ventilation and 7 (<1%) died.

Most noteworthy, the researchers observed a significant reduction in laboratory-confirmed hospitalizations by 41% in children vaccinated against the flu. They further estimated a significant reduction in hospitalizations linked to A(H3N2) and A(H1N1)pdm09 viruses, even in the presence of circulating A(H3N2) viruses that differed from the A(H3N2) vaccine component.

Studies from other countries during the same time period showed that while “significant protection against influenza-associated ambulatory care visits and hospitalizations among children infected with A(H1N1)pdm09 viruses” was observed, the same could not be said for protection against A(H3N2) viruses, which varied among pediatric outpatients in the United States (24%), in England (17% outpatient; 31% inpatient), Europe (46%), and Canada (48%). They explained that such variation in vaccine protection is multifactorial, and includes virus-, host-, and environment-related factors. They also noted that regional variations in circulating viruses, host factors including age, imprinting, and previous vaccination could explain the study’s finding of vaccine protection against both A(H1N1)pdm09 and A(H3N2) viruses.

When comparing VE estimates between ED visits and hospitalizations, the researchers observed one significant difference, that “hospitalized children likely represent more medically complex patients, with 58% having underlying medical conditions and 38% reporting at lease one hospitalization in the past year, compared with 28% and 14% respectively, among ED participants.”

Strengths of the study included the prospective multisite enrollment that provided data across diverse locations and representation from pediatric hospitalizations and ED care, which were not previously strongly represented in the literature. The single-season study with small sample size was considered a limitation, as was the inability to evaluate full and partial vaccine status. Vaccine data also were limited for many of the ED patients observed.

Dr. Campbell and colleagues did caution that while they consider their test-negative design optimal for evaluating both hospitalized and ED patients, they feel their results should not be “interpreted as VE against influenza-associated ambulatory care visits or infections that are not medically attended.”

In a separate interview, Michael E. Pichichero, MD, director of the Rochester General Hospital Research Institute and a clinical professor of pediatrics at the University of Rochester (N.Y.), observed: “There are really no surprises here. A well done contemporary study confirms again the benefits of annual influenza vaccinations for children. Viral coinfections involving SARS-CoV-2 and influenza have been reported from Australia to cause heightened illnesses. That observation provides further impetus for parents to have their children receive influenza vaccinations.”

The researchers cited multiple sources of financial support for their ongoing work, including Sanofi, Quidel, Moderna, Karius, GlaxoSmithKline, Merck, AstraZeneca, and Pfizer. Funding for this study was supported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Dr. Pichichero said he had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Campbell AP et al. Pediatrics. 2020. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-1368.

Unlike previous studies focused on vaccine effectiveness (VE) in ambulatory care office visits, Angela P. Campbell, MD, MPH, and associates have uncovered evidence of the overall benefit influenza vaccines play in reducing hospitalizations and emergency department visits in pediatric influenza patients.

Yarinca/istockphoto

“Our data provide important VE estimates against severe influenza in children,” the researchers noted in Pediatrics, adding that the findings “provide important evidence supporting the annual recommendation that all children 6 months and older should receive influenza vaccination.”

Dr. Campbell and colleagues collected ongoing surveillance data from the New Vaccine Surveillance Network (NVSN), which is a network of pediatric hospitals across seven cities, including Kansas City, Mo.; Rochester, N.Y.; Cincinnati; Pittsburgh; Nashville, Tenn.; Houston; and Seattle. The influenza season encompassed the period Nov. 7, 2018 to June 21, 2019.

A total of 2,748 hospitalized children and 2,676 children who had completed ED visits that did not lead to hospitalization were included. Once those under 6 months were excluded, 1,792 hospitalized children were included in the VE analysis; of these, 226 (13%) tested positive for influenza infection, including 211 (93%) with influenza A viruses and 15 (7%) with influenza B viruses. Fully 1,611 of the patients (90%), had verified vaccine status, while 181 (10%) had solely parental reported vaccine status. The researchers reported 88 (5%) of the patients received mechanical ventilation and 7 (<1%) died.

Most noteworthy, the researchers observed a significant reduction in laboratory-confirmed hospitalizations by 41% in children vaccinated against the flu. They further estimated a significant reduction in hospitalizations linked to A(H3N2) and A(H1N1)pdm09 viruses, even in the presence of circulating A(H3N2) viruses that differed from the A(H3N2) vaccine component.

Studies from other countries during the same time period showed that while “significant protection against influenza-associated ambulatory care visits and hospitalizations among children infected with A(H1N1)pdm09 viruses” was observed, the same could not be said for protection against A(H3N2) viruses, which varied among pediatric outpatients in the United States (24%), in England (17% outpatient; 31% inpatient), Europe (46%), and Canada (48%). They explained that such variation in vaccine protection is multifactorial, and includes virus-, host-, and environment-related factors. They also noted that regional variations in circulating viruses, host factors including age, imprinting, and previous vaccination could explain the study’s finding of vaccine protection against both A(H1N1)pdm09 and A(H3N2) viruses.

When comparing VE estimates between ED visits and hospitalizations, the researchers observed one significant difference, that “hospitalized children likely represent more medically complex patients, with 58% having underlying medical conditions and 38% reporting at lease one hospitalization in the past year, compared with 28% and 14% respectively, among ED participants.”

Strengths of the study included the prospective multisite enrollment that provided data across diverse locations and representation from pediatric hospitalizations and ED care, which were not previously strongly represented in the literature. The single-season study with small sample size was considered a limitation, as was the inability to evaluate full and partial vaccine status. Vaccine data also were limited for many of the ED patients observed.

Dr. Campbell and colleagues did caution that while they consider their test-negative design optimal for evaluating both hospitalized and ED patients, they feel their results should not be “interpreted as VE against influenza-associated ambulatory care visits or infections that are not medically attended.”

In a separate interview, Michael E. Pichichero, MD, director of the Rochester General Hospital Research Institute and a clinical professor of pediatrics at the University of Rochester (N.Y.), observed: “There are really no surprises here. A well done contemporary study confirms again the benefits of annual influenza vaccinations for children. Viral coinfections involving SARS-CoV-2 and influenza have been reported from Australia to cause heightened illnesses. That observation provides further impetus for parents to have their children receive influenza vaccinations.”

The researchers cited multiple sources of financial support for their ongoing work, including Sanofi, Quidel, Moderna, Karius, GlaxoSmithKline, Merck, AstraZeneca, and Pfizer. Funding for this study was supported by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Dr. Pichichero said he had no relevant financial disclosures.

SOURCE: Campbell AP et al. Pediatrics. 2020. doi: 10.1542/peds.2020-1368.