Postmarket outcomes with the first commercially available U.S. transcatheter aortic valve replacement device are comparable with randomized trial and international registry experience, national registry results suggest.
The Edwards LifeSciences Sapien XT valve was successfully implanted in 92% of 7,710 TAVR patients, two-thirds with a transfemoral approach.
The primary outcomes of in-hospital all-cause mortality and stroke were 5.5% and 2%, respectively, Dr. Michael J. Mack reported at the American Heart Association scientific sessions.
Conversion to open-heart surgery was needed in only 1% of patients, but associated with a 49% incidence of in-hospital mortality.
Major bleeding and vascular complications were relatively low, at 3.5% and 6.4%, respectively, despite the overall lack of experience and use of larger sheath delivery systems. Acute renal insufficiency occurred in 5.5% of patients.
The 30-day death and stroke rates were 7.6% and 2.8% among 3,113 patients with sufficient follow-up. Most deaths were due to noncardiovascular causes, he noted.
This is the first public report from the national Society of Thoracic Surgeons/American College of Cardiology Transcatheter Valve Therapy (TVT) Registry, and comes amid calls for increased postmarket surveillance of high-risk medical devices.
The results also help address whether outcomes after a controlled commercial rollout of the first-generation valve hold up to those from clinical trials and the global TAVR experience, now based on second- and third-generation devices, according to Dr. Mack, past STS president and director of cardiovascular research and medicine at the Heart Hospital Baylor Plano in Plano, Texas.
The Food and Drug Administration initially approved the Edwards valve for severe, symptomatic aortic stenosis in inoperable patients in 2011 and expanded its label in September 2012 to include operable, high-risk patients using either a transfemoral or transapical approach.
The TVT analysis comprised 1,559 inoperable and 6,151 high-risk, operable patients who underwent TAVR at 224 participating registry hospitals from November 2011 to May 2013. Their median STS predicted risk of operative mortality (PROM) was 7%, but varied widely from 1.2% to 17.4%. Their median age was 84 years.
The risk profile of patients was generally lower in the registry than in randomized trials and European reports, and may have contributed to the good outcomes, Dr. Mack acknowledged. The mean PROM was 11.2% among inoperable patients and 11.8% among high-risk, operable patients in the pivotal PARTNER trial, which was used for the device’s approval.
Although incomplete data may have been entered into the risk calculator, the other plausible explanation is "risk creep," or that patients with lower surgical risk are being treated with the less-invasive procedure, leading to better outcomes, he noted.
Other possible contributors to the registry outcomes include a shorter U.S. learning curve due to international collaboration, inclusion of at least 35 highly experienced PARTNER study centers in the registry, and mandated training by the manufacturer including a company employed clinical specialist during all procedures.
Still, the results stack up well. Germany, which has led the TAVR revolution, had an in-hospital mortality of 5.1% with a transfemoral approach and 7.7% with a transapical approach in 2011 in the German Aortic Valve Registry.
In the PARTNER trial, 30-day mortality was 5% among inoperable patients, 3.7% among high-risk, operable patients by a transfemoral approach, and 8.7% among high-risk, operable patients by a transapical approach.
This compares with 30-day mortality rates of 6.1%, 4.6%, and 9.8%, respectively, in the TVT registry, Dr. Mack reported.
The TVT registry captured an estimated 88% of TAVR procedures performed between May 2012, when the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services issued its national coverage determination, and the end of the study. Notably, 30-day outcomes were reported from only 114 hospitals or 51% of the 244 hospitals in the registry. The results were published simultaneously with Dr. Mack’s presentation (JAMA 2013;310:2069-77. doi:10.1001/jama/2013.282043).
More complete long-term outcomes at 30 days and 1 year are needed to have a more comprehensive assessment of TAVR outcomes in the United States, Dr. Mack cautioned. Patient health status and quality of life outcomes will also be addressed in subsequent reports.
So far, it’s known that most (63%) patients were discharged home, 6% experienced new-onset atrial fibrillation, and 6.6% needed a new permanent pacemaker or implantable cardioverter-defibrillator.
The study was funded by the American College of Cardiology Foundation and the Society of Thoracic Surgeons. Dr. Mack reported no other disclosures; a co-author reported travel support from the STS and a second reported consulting for Janssen, Boehringer Ingelheim, and Sanofi.