Benzodiazepines Improve Dyspnea in Palliative Care Patients

DENVER – Low-dose adjunctive benzodiazepines are effective in combination with opioids for dyspnea in palliative care patients who don’t respond to opioids alone, according to Dr. Patama Gomutbutra.

When opioids alone aren’t bringing significant improvement, adding a benzodiazepine is worthwhile, she said. The question of whether benzodiazepines alone are effective in the management of dyspnea must await answers from randomized clinical trials.

Dr. Gomutbutra conducted a retrospective chart review of 303 inpatients with dyspnea evaluated by members of the University of California, San Francisco, palliative care program. These were seriously ill patients: Twenty-three percent had primary lung cancer, 32% had cancer outside the lung, 12% had heart failure, and 7% had chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Of these patients, 47% died in the hospital and 25% were discharged to hospice.

At baseline, physicians rated dyspnea as severe in 19% of patients, moderate in 28%, and mild in 53%. At baseline, 49% of patients were already on opioids at a median dose of 52 mg/day; 87% of these patients remained on opioids at 24 hours, with a bump up in dose to a median of 60 mg/day. Of the patients not initially taking an opioid, 41% were placed on the medication at a median dose of 22 mg/day.

"Our results should not dissuade people from using opioids as the first-line treatment."

At baseline, 17% of patients were on a benzodiazepine at a median dose of 1 mg/day of oral lorazepam or its equivalent. At 24 hours, 24% of patients were on a benzodiazepine, again at a median daily dose of 1 mg.

At follow-up 24 hours after adjustment of dosages or addition of an opioid or a benzodiazepine, the population with severe dyspnea had fallen from 19% to 4%. Dyspnea was rated moderate in 18% and mild in 44%, and was absent in 34%.

Overall, 57% of patients had a clinically meaningful improvement in dyspnea of one severity grade or more, 37% remained the same, and the rest became worse, according to Dr. Gomutbutra of Chiang Mai (Thailand) University.

Taking an opioid and a benzodiazepine at follow-up was independently associated with a 2.1-fold increased likelihood of significant improvement in dyspnea. Having moderate or severe dyspnea at baseline was associated with 4.1- and 4.5-fold increased likelihoods of improvement, respectively.

Surprisingly, being on an opioid at baseline wasn’t associated with significant improvement at follow-up, even though opioids are guideline-recommended therapy for dyspnea.

Dr. Gomutbutra cautioned against overinterpretation of this finding, given that her study was retrospective and thus vulnerable to confounding. For example, she noted, the respiratory rate typically slows near death, so affected patients may not have received continued or increased doses of opioids.

"Our results should not dissuade people from using opioids as the first-line treatment," Dr. Gomutbutra emphasized.

Dr. Gomutbutra carried out this study after observing big differences in how dyspnea is managed in palliative care settings in the United States, compared with Thailand. While the median daily dose of opioids at baseline in the San Francisco study was 52 mg/day, a typical dose in Thailand would be 6 mg/day. And benzodiazepines are far more widely used in treating dyspnea there, she added.

She reported having no financial conflicts.

DENVER – Low-dose adjunctive benzodiazepines are effective in combination with opioids for dyspnea in palliative care patients who don’t respond to opioids alone, according to Dr. Patama Gomutbutra.

When opioids alone aren’t bringing significant improvement, adding a benzodiazepine is worthwhile, she said. The question of whether benzodiazepines alone are effective in the management of dyspnea must await answers from randomized clinical trials.

Dr. Gomutbutra conducted a retrospective chart review of 303 inpatients with dyspnea evaluated by members of the University of California, San Francisco, palliative care program. These were seriously ill patients: Twenty-three percent had primary lung cancer, 32% had cancer outside the lung, 12% had heart failure, and 7% had chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Of these patients, 47% died in the hospital and 25% were discharged to hospice.

At baseline, physicians rated dyspnea as severe in 19% of patients, moderate in 28%, and mild in 53%. At baseline, 49% of patients were already on opioids at a median dose of 52 mg/day; 87% of these patients remained on opioids at 24 hours, with a bump up in dose to a median of 60 mg/day. Of the patients not initially taking an opioid, 41% were placed on the medication at a median dose of 22 mg/day.

"Our results should not dissuade people from using opioids as the first-line treatment."

At baseline, 17% of patients were on a benzodiazepine at a median dose of 1 mg/day of oral lorazepam or its equivalent. At 24 hours, 24% of patients were on a benzodiazepine, again at a median daily dose of 1 mg.

At follow-up 24 hours after adjustment of dosages or addition of an opioid or a benzodiazepine, the population with severe dyspnea had fallen from 19% to 4%. Dyspnea was rated moderate in 18% and mild in 44%, and was absent in 34%.

Overall, 57% of patients had a clinically meaningful improvement in dyspnea of one severity grade or more, 37% remained the same, and the rest became worse, according to Dr. Gomutbutra of Chiang Mai (Thailand) University.

Taking an opioid and a benzodiazepine at follow-up was independently associated with a 2.1-fold increased likelihood of significant improvement in dyspnea. Having moderate or severe dyspnea at baseline was associated with 4.1- and 4.5-fold increased likelihoods of improvement, respectively.

Surprisingly, being on an opioid at baseline wasn’t associated with significant improvement at follow-up, even though opioids are guideline-recommended therapy for dyspnea.

Dr. Gomutbutra cautioned against overinterpretation of this finding, given that her study was retrospective and thus vulnerable to confounding. For example, she noted, the respiratory rate typically slows near death, so affected patients may not have received continued or increased doses of opioids.

"Our results should not dissuade people from using opioids as the first-line treatment," Dr. Gomutbutra emphasized.

Dr. Gomutbutra carried out this study after observing big differences in how dyspnea is managed in palliative care settings in the United States, compared with Thailand. While the median daily dose of opioids at baseline in the San Francisco study was 52 mg/day, a typical dose in Thailand would be 6 mg/day. And benzodiazepines are far more widely used in treating dyspnea there, she added.

She reported having no financial conflicts.

DENVER – Low-dose adjunctive benzodiazepines are effective in combination with opioids for dyspnea in palliative care patients who don’t respond to opioids alone, according to Dr. Patama Gomutbutra.

When opioids alone aren’t bringing significant improvement, adding a benzodiazepine is worthwhile, she said. The question of whether benzodiazepines alone are effective in the management of dyspnea must await answers from randomized clinical trials.

Dr. Gomutbutra conducted a retrospective chart review of 303 inpatients with dyspnea evaluated by members of the University of California, San Francisco, palliative care program. These were seriously ill patients: Twenty-three percent had primary lung cancer, 32% had cancer outside the lung, 12% had heart failure, and 7% had chronic obstructive pulmonary disease. Of these patients, 47% died in the hospital and 25% were discharged to hospice.

At baseline, physicians rated dyspnea as severe in 19% of patients, moderate in 28%, and mild in 53%. At baseline, 49% of patients were already on opioids at a median dose of 52 mg/day; 87% of these patients remained on opioids at 24 hours, with a bump up in dose to a median of 60 mg/day. Of the patients not initially taking an opioid, 41% were placed on the medication at a median dose of 22 mg/day.

"Our results should not dissuade people from using opioids as the first-line treatment."

At baseline, 17% of patients were on a benzodiazepine at a median dose of 1 mg/day of oral lorazepam or its equivalent. At 24 hours, 24% of patients were on a benzodiazepine, again at a median daily dose of 1 mg.

At follow-up 24 hours after adjustment of dosages or addition of an opioid or a benzodiazepine, the population with severe dyspnea had fallen from 19% to 4%. Dyspnea was rated moderate in 18% and mild in 44%, and was absent in 34%.

Overall, 57% of patients had a clinically meaningful improvement in dyspnea of one severity grade or more, 37% remained the same, and the rest became worse, according to Dr. Gomutbutra of Chiang Mai (Thailand) University.

Taking an opioid and a benzodiazepine at follow-up was independently associated with a 2.1-fold increased likelihood of significant improvement in dyspnea. Having moderate or severe dyspnea at baseline was associated with 4.1- and 4.5-fold increased likelihoods of improvement, respectively.

Surprisingly, being on an opioid at baseline wasn’t associated with significant improvement at follow-up, even though opioids are guideline-recommended therapy for dyspnea.

Dr. Gomutbutra cautioned against overinterpretation of this finding, given that her study was retrospective and thus vulnerable to confounding. For example, she noted, the respiratory rate typically slows near death, so affected patients may not have received continued or increased doses of opioids.

"Our results should not dissuade people from using opioids as the first-line treatment," Dr. Gomutbutra emphasized.

Dr. Gomutbutra carried out this study after observing big differences in how dyspnea is managed in palliative care settings in the United States, compared with Thailand. While the median daily dose of opioids at baseline in the San Francisco study was 52 mg/day, a typical dose in Thailand would be 6 mg/day. And benzodiazepines are far more widely used in treating dyspnea there, she added.

She reported having no financial conflicts.