User login
The authors, including Fabio Salomone of the University of Naples Federico II, department of clinical medicine and surgery, also observed trends toward an association between QoL improvement and PFS among patients treated with chemotherapy and immunotherapy.
The new research was presented during a poster session at European Lung Cancer Congress 2023.
“The findings of the study support the thesis that QoL and survival in patients with NSCLC are linked. Although this is documented in the literature, this study sums up the evidence of a large number of RCTs, and provides detail in the QoL/survival relationship by treatment type. The subgroup analysis by treatment type is a key strength of the study showing that the QoL/survival link is stronger and more reliable in target(ed) therapies,” George Kypriotakis, PhD, who was not involved with the study, said in an interview.
Combining efficacy and quality of life improvement is an important consideration in clinical practice. “It is important that clinicians provide therapies that are also palliative and improve QoL,” said Dr. Kypriotakis, assistant professor of behavioral sciences at University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston. He noted that the finding of a PFS benefit is a good indicator of overall benefit, which is important since OS outcomes require a larger number of patients and longer follow-up to determine.
“PFS can still be a valid surrogate for OS, especially when it is positively associated with QoL,” noted Dr. Kypriotakis.
The study included 81 trials. Sixteen of the studies investigated immunotherapy, 50 investigated targeted therapy, and 17 investigated chemotherapy regimens. Thirty-seven percent of the trials found an improvement in QoL in the treatment arm compared with the control arm, 59.3% found no difference between arms, and 3.7% found a worse QoL in the treatment arm. There was no statistically significant association between an improvement in OS and QoL among the trials (P = .368).
Improved QoL tied to improved PFS
The researchers found an association between improved QoL and improved PFS. Among 60 trials that showed improved PFS, 43.3% found a superior QoL in the treatment arm, 53.3% showed no difference, and 3.3% showed reduced QoL. Among 20 trials that found no improvement in PFS, 20% demonstrated an improved QoL, 75% found no change, and 5% showed worse QoL (P = .0473).
A subanalysis of 48 targeted therapy trials found a correlation between PFS and QoL improvement (P = .0196). Among 25 trials involving patients receiving epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) inhibitors showing an improved PFS, 60% showed improved QoL, 36% showed no difference, and 4% showed worsening (P = .0077). Seven of these trials showed no PFS benefit and no change in QoL.
Industry sponsorship may affect QOL results
The researchers found potential evidence that industry sponsorship may lead to a spin on QoL outcomes. Among 51 trials that showed no QoL benefit associated with treatment, the description of the QoL outcome in 37 industry-sponsored was judged to be neutral and coherent with the study findings in 26 cases, but unjustifiably favorable in 11 cases. Among 14 with nonprofit support, descriptions of QoL results were found to be neutral in all cases (P = .0232).
“Obviously, industry may be motivated to overemphasize treatment benefits, especially in measures that also have a qualitative/subjective dimension such as QoL. Assuming that the authors used a reliable criterion to evaluate “inappropriateness,” industry may be more likely to emphasize QoL improvements as a surrogate for OS, especially when seeking drug approval,” Dr. Kypriotakis said.
The study is retrospective and cannot prove causation.
Dr. Salomone and Dr. Kypriotakis have no relevant financial disclosures.
The authors, including Fabio Salomone of the University of Naples Federico II, department of clinical medicine and surgery, also observed trends toward an association between QoL improvement and PFS among patients treated with chemotherapy and immunotherapy.
The new research was presented during a poster session at European Lung Cancer Congress 2023.
“The findings of the study support the thesis that QoL and survival in patients with NSCLC are linked. Although this is documented in the literature, this study sums up the evidence of a large number of RCTs, and provides detail in the QoL/survival relationship by treatment type. The subgroup analysis by treatment type is a key strength of the study showing that the QoL/survival link is stronger and more reliable in target(ed) therapies,” George Kypriotakis, PhD, who was not involved with the study, said in an interview.
Combining efficacy and quality of life improvement is an important consideration in clinical practice. “It is important that clinicians provide therapies that are also palliative and improve QoL,” said Dr. Kypriotakis, assistant professor of behavioral sciences at University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston. He noted that the finding of a PFS benefit is a good indicator of overall benefit, which is important since OS outcomes require a larger number of patients and longer follow-up to determine.
“PFS can still be a valid surrogate for OS, especially when it is positively associated with QoL,” noted Dr. Kypriotakis.
The study included 81 trials. Sixteen of the studies investigated immunotherapy, 50 investigated targeted therapy, and 17 investigated chemotherapy regimens. Thirty-seven percent of the trials found an improvement in QoL in the treatment arm compared with the control arm, 59.3% found no difference between arms, and 3.7% found a worse QoL in the treatment arm. There was no statistically significant association between an improvement in OS and QoL among the trials (P = .368).
Improved QoL tied to improved PFS
The researchers found an association between improved QoL and improved PFS. Among 60 trials that showed improved PFS, 43.3% found a superior QoL in the treatment arm, 53.3% showed no difference, and 3.3% showed reduced QoL. Among 20 trials that found no improvement in PFS, 20% demonstrated an improved QoL, 75% found no change, and 5% showed worse QoL (P = .0473).
A subanalysis of 48 targeted therapy trials found a correlation between PFS and QoL improvement (P = .0196). Among 25 trials involving patients receiving epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) inhibitors showing an improved PFS, 60% showed improved QoL, 36% showed no difference, and 4% showed worsening (P = .0077). Seven of these trials showed no PFS benefit and no change in QoL.
Industry sponsorship may affect QOL results
The researchers found potential evidence that industry sponsorship may lead to a spin on QoL outcomes. Among 51 trials that showed no QoL benefit associated with treatment, the description of the QoL outcome in 37 industry-sponsored was judged to be neutral and coherent with the study findings in 26 cases, but unjustifiably favorable in 11 cases. Among 14 with nonprofit support, descriptions of QoL results were found to be neutral in all cases (P = .0232).
“Obviously, industry may be motivated to overemphasize treatment benefits, especially in measures that also have a qualitative/subjective dimension such as QoL. Assuming that the authors used a reliable criterion to evaluate “inappropriateness,” industry may be more likely to emphasize QoL improvements as a surrogate for OS, especially when seeking drug approval,” Dr. Kypriotakis said.
The study is retrospective and cannot prove causation.
Dr. Salomone and Dr. Kypriotakis have no relevant financial disclosures.
The authors, including Fabio Salomone of the University of Naples Federico II, department of clinical medicine and surgery, also observed trends toward an association between QoL improvement and PFS among patients treated with chemotherapy and immunotherapy.
The new research was presented during a poster session at European Lung Cancer Congress 2023.
“The findings of the study support the thesis that QoL and survival in patients with NSCLC are linked. Although this is documented in the literature, this study sums up the evidence of a large number of RCTs, and provides detail in the QoL/survival relationship by treatment type. The subgroup analysis by treatment type is a key strength of the study showing that the QoL/survival link is stronger and more reliable in target(ed) therapies,” George Kypriotakis, PhD, who was not involved with the study, said in an interview.
Combining efficacy and quality of life improvement is an important consideration in clinical practice. “It is important that clinicians provide therapies that are also palliative and improve QoL,” said Dr. Kypriotakis, assistant professor of behavioral sciences at University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center, Houston. He noted that the finding of a PFS benefit is a good indicator of overall benefit, which is important since OS outcomes require a larger number of patients and longer follow-up to determine.
“PFS can still be a valid surrogate for OS, especially when it is positively associated with QoL,” noted Dr. Kypriotakis.
The study included 81 trials. Sixteen of the studies investigated immunotherapy, 50 investigated targeted therapy, and 17 investigated chemotherapy regimens. Thirty-seven percent of the trials found an improvement in QoL in the treatment arm compared with the control arm, 59.3% found no difference between arms, and 3.7% found a worse QoL in the treatment arm. There was no statistically significant association between an improvement in OS and QoL among the trials (P = .368).
Improved QoL tied to improved PFS
The researchers found an association between improved QoL and improved PFS. Among 60 trials that showed improved PFS, 43.3% found a superior QoL in the treatment arm, 53.3% showed no difference, and 3.3% showed reduced QoL. Among 20 trials that found no improvement in PFS, 20% demonstrated an improved QoL, 75% found no change, and 5% showed worse QoL (P = .0473).
A subanalysis of 48 targeted therapy trials found a correlation between PFS and QoL improvement (P = .0196). Among 25 trials involving patients receiving epidermal growth factor receptor (EGFR) and anaplastic lymphoma kinase (ALK) inhibitors showing an improved PFS, 60% showed improved QoL, 36% showed no difference, and 4% showed worsening (P = .0077). Seven of these trials showed no PFS benefit and no change in QoL.
Industry sponsorship may affect QOL results
The researchers found potential evidence that industry sponsorship may lead to a spin on QoL outcomes. Among 51 trials that showed no QoL benefit associated with treatment, the description of the QoL outcome in 37 industry-sponsored was judged to be neutral and coherent with the study findings in 26 cases, but unjustifiably favorable in 11 cases. Among 14 with nonprofit support, descriptions of QoL results were found to be neutral in all cases (P = .0232).
“Obviously, industry may be motivated to overemphasize treatment benefits, especially in measures that also have a qualitative/subjective dimension such as QoL. Assuming that the authors used a reliable criterion to evaluate “inappropriateness,” industry may be more likely to emphasize QoL improvements as a surrogate for OS, especially when seeking drug approval,” Dr. Kypriotakis said.
The study is retrospective and cannot prove causation.
Dr. Salomone and Dr. Kypriotakis have no relevant financial disclosures.
FROM ELCC 2023