Commentary

Predicting Prognosis with Thin Melanoma

How long people live after a diagnosis of thin melanoma varies.


 

Dr. Christopher J. Miller

“Most patients do well at 5 years; 95% are doing fine,” Dr. Christopher J. Miller said at a summer symposium of the Alabama Dermatology Society.

This figure comes from a study (Arch. Dermatol. 2002:138:603-8) that found 95.3% of patients survive at least 5 years if they have thin (< 1 mm) melanoma, stage II/III disease, with no ulceration.

“About 10% are not doing as well,” Dr. Miller said, referring to a different group with thin melanoma (< 1 mm, stage IV/V with ulceration). In this group, study researchers found a 5-year survival rate of 90.9%.

So how do you estimate prognosis for your individual patient? Dr. Miller recommended www.melanomaprognosis.org, a fast and easy-to-use (I tried it!) instrument to estimate survival based on a few characteristics.

“This is a great tool … and a useful thing to have for your patients,” said Dr. Miller, director of dermatologic surgery at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia. Using a number of factors to calculate survival is more accurate than relying on just one measure or using survival curves, he said.

I tried the site Dr. Miller recommended for a hypothetical patient with localized melanoma. I found that a 45-year-old with a 1-mm ulcerated lesion located on an axial site would have an estimate survival rate of:

98.8% at 1 year

96.8% at 2 years

86.5% at 5 years

73% at 10 years.

The online calculator was developed using the melanoma database of the American Joint Committee on Cancer.

–Damian McNamara @MedReporter on Twitter

Recommended Reading

PET/CT Found Best for Lymph Node Scans in Merkel Cell Carcinoma
MDedge Dermatology
Tanners Risk Sunbed Use Despite Knowing the Dangers
MDedge Dermatology
Could Aquaporins Be Next Skin Cancer Target?
MDedge Dermatology
After Mohs, Cancer Recurrence Less Than 2% in New Study
MDedge Dermatology
Almost One-Third of Mohs Surgeons Employ PAs
MDedge Dermatology
Sirolimus Cuts Skin Cancer After Renal Transplant
MDedge Dermatology
Deposits in Sentinel Nodes May Predict Prognosis
MDedge Dermatology
Evidence Backs Imiquimod Tx for Melanoma in Situ
MDedge Dermatology
ASCO: Percutaneous Hepatic Perfusion Offers Mixed Results in Metastatic Melanoma
MDedge Dermatology
Sun Exposure May Offer Mortality Benefit in BCC Patients
MDedge Dermatology