Taking issue with some of the arguments
Both Dr. Polsky and Dr. Stein took issue with several of the arguments put forward by Dr. Welch and colleagues.
For instance, Dr. Welch and colleagues cited research suggesting that UV light is a weak risk factor for melanoma, but Dr. Polsky disagreed. “There are many lines of evidence ranging from epidemiological, clinical, and biological studies that prove the causative association between ultraviolet light and melanoma, while acknowledging that other factors, such as genetic predisposition, play an important role,” he said. “Since ultraviolet light in the form of outdoor sunburns or indoor tanning exposure are modifiable risk factors, it is important that we continue with our current public messaging on their causal role in the development of melanoma.”
Furthermore, the 2012 study that the authors cited to support their argument that pathologists today are more likely to diagnose melanoma than in years past is flawed, according to Dr. Stein. The study was very small and included just nine contemporary pathologists. Unlike in real life, pathologists in the study could not diagnose lesions as “atypical,” and may have erred on the side of caution by calling them malignant.
“There were multiple limitations to this study that were acknowledged by its authors, who stated that it was a hypothesis-generating study and may not be generalizable,” Dr. Stein said.
In addition, Dr. Polsky took issue with the suggestion that awareness about melanoma among the general public is overly heightened.
“Reducing melanoma awareness would not be wise,” he said. “Studies have shown that awareness of melanoma is associated with the diagnosis of earlier-stage lesions that can be cured by simple skin surgery, without the need for more costly interventions utilized for more advanced melanomas.”
Dr. Mazer reported receiving travel compensation from Hillcrest Healthcare Systems, and is a commentator for this new organization. Dr. Welch has written three books on the subjects of overdiagnosis and testing for cancer. Dr. Adamson disclosed no relevant financial relationships.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.