Painless Mobile Nodule on the Shoulder

The Diagnosis: Cutaneous Metaplastic Synovial Cyst

Gross examination of the excised nodule revealed a 2.5×1.2×1.0-cm, intact, gray-white, thin-walled, smooth-lined nodule filled with clear mucinouslike material. Hematoxylin and eosin-stained sections demonstrated a dermal-based cystlike structure composed of a lining of connective tissue with hyalinized material and fibrin as well as spindle and epithelioid cells with a mild mixed inflammatory infiltrate (Figure). These histopathologic findings led to the diagnosis of cutaneous metaplastic synovial cyst (CMSC).

Cutaneous metaplastic synovial cyst. Dermal-based cystlike structure composed of a lining of connective tissue with hyalinized material and fibrin as well as spindle and epithelioid cells with a mild mixed inflammatory infiltrate (H&E, original magnification ×50).

Cutaneous metaplastic synovial cyst, also known as synovial metaplasia of the skin, is an uncommon benign cystic lesion that was first reported by Gonzalez et al¹ in 1987. Histologically, CMSC lacks an epithelial lining and therefore is not a true cyst but rather a pseudocyst.² Clinically, the lesion typically presents as a solitary subcutaneous nodule that may be tender or painless. In a literature review of CMSC cases performed by Fukuyama et al,³ distribution of reported cases according to body site varied; however, limbs were found to be the most commonly involved area. A PubMed search of articles indexed for MEDLINE as well as a Google Scholar search using the term cutaneous metaplastic synovial cyst revealed at least 37 cases reported in the English-language literature,^3-9 including our present case. The pathogenesis remains uncertain; however, a majority of previously reported cases of CMSC characteristically have been associated with a pre-existing lesion, with most presentations developing at surgical scar sites secondary to operation or trauma.⁵ Relative tissue fragility secondary to rheumatoid arthritis¹⁰ and Ehlers-Danlos syndrome^9,11,12 has been linked to CMSC in some documented reports, while a minority of cases report no antecedent events triggering formation of the lesion.^13-15

As evidenced by our patient, CMSC clinically mimics several other benign entities; histopathologic examination is necessary to confirm the diagnosis. Although nodular hidradenoma also may clinically present as a solitary firm intradermal nodule, microscopy reveals a dermal-based lobulated tumor containing cystic spaces and solid areas composed of basophilic polyhedral cells and round glycogen-filled clear cells.¹⁶ Epidermoid cysts are differentiated from CMSC by the presence of a cyst wall lining composed of stratified squamous epithelium and associated laminated keratin within the lumen,¹⁷ which corresponds to its pearly white appearance on gross examination. Cutaneous ciliated cysts predominantly occur on the lower extremities of young women and are lined by simple cuboidal or columnar ciliated cells that resemble müllerian epithelium.¹⁸ Similar to CMSC, ganglion cysts are pseudocysts that lack a true epithelial lining but differ in appearance due to their mucin-filled synovial-lined sac.¹⁹ Additionally, ganglion cysts most often occur on the dorsal and volar aspects of the wrist.

Excisional biopsy is indicated as the preferred treatment of CMSC, given the lesion's benign behavior and low recurrence rate.⁶ Our case highlights this rare entity and reinforces its inclusion in the differential diagnosis of subcutaneous mobile nodules, especially in the setting of prior tissue injury secondary to trauma, surgical procedures, or conditions such as rheumatoid arthritis or Ehlers-Danlos syndrome. Unlike most previously reported cases, our patient reported no preceding tissue injury associated with formation of the lesion, and she was largely asymptomatic on presentation. Considering the limited number of CMSC cases demonstrated in the literature, it is important to continue reporting new cases to better understand characteristics and presentations of this uncommon lesion.