Nine days after the independent laboratory, it published another report in Environmental Health Perspectives (EHP), on March 14, also warning about BP acne products.
The bottom line was the same: The laboratory, based in New Haven, Connecticut, said its analyses raise substantial concerns about the safety of BP-containing acne products currently on the market.
The lab’s results showed that the products can form over 800 times the conditionally restricted FDA concentration limit of 2 parts per million (ppm) of benzene, with both prescription and over-the-counter products affected.
“This is a problem of degradation, not contamination,” David Light, CEO and founder of Valisure, said in a telephone interview. BP can decompose into benzene, and exposure to benzene has been linked with a higher risk for leukemia and other blood cancers, according to the American Cancer Society.
In the wake of the findings, however, debate has erupted over the method and approach used by Valisure to test these products, with critics and companies contending that more “real-world” use data are needed. And the US Pharmacopeia (USP) is asking for full transparency about the testing methods.
In a March 8 statement, USP said the petition indicated that modified USP methods were used in the study, noting that “if changes are made to a USP method, complete validation data is necessary to demonstrate that a product meets USP standards.”
However, Valisure contended that drug products need to demonstrate stability over the entire life cycle, from shipment to continued use, emphasizing that constitutes the best “real-world” approach. It also defended the methodology it used.
The reports have led to a state of uncertainty about the use of BP products.
“Right now, we have more unknowns than anything else,” John Barbieri, MD, MBA, assistant professor of dermatology at Harvard Medical School and director of the Advanced Acne Therapeutics Clinic at Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Boston, said in a video posted on X and YouTube, summarizing the findings released by Valisure on March 6 and 14. He was not involved in the Valisure research.
Brigham and Women's Hospital
Dr. John Barbieri
In a telephone interview, Dr. Barbieri said the report “needs to be taken seriously,” but he also believed the Valisure report is lacking information about testing under “real-world” conditions. He is calling for more information and more transparency about the data. What’s clear, Dr. Barbieri told this news organization, is that the findings about high benzene levels are not a manufacturing error. “It’s something to do with the molecule itself.”
Valisure’s Analyses
Valisure performed an initial analysis, using a method called gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, which is the FDA-preferred method for detecting benzene, Mr. Light said. It tested 175 acne products, 99 containing BP and 76 with other ingredients, such as salicylic acid. All the products without BP had no detectable benzene or values below 2 ppm, the FDA concentration limit for benzene.
Of the 99 BP products, 94 contained benzene without any elevated temperature incubation, according to Valisure. Using 50 °C (122 °F, the accepted pharmaceutical stability testing temperature) on 66 products, Valisure detected over 1500 ppm of benzene in two products, over 100 ppm in 17 products, and over 10 ppm in 42 products over an 18-day period.
The analysis confirmed, Valisure said in a press release and the petition, that a substantial amount of benzene can form in a BP product and leak outside the packaging into surrounding air.
The EHP paper, which includes authors from Valisure, reported that researchers took single lots of seven branded BP products, namely, Equate Beauty 2.5% BP cleansers, Neutrogena 10% BP cleanser, CVS Health 10% BP face wash, Walgreens 10% BP cream, Clean & Clear 10% cleanser, Equate Beauty 10% BP acne wash, and Proactiv 2.5% BP cleanser.
Using testing that involved gas chromatography-mass spectrometry, benzene was detected in all the BP products samples tested, and levels increased during incubation at body and shelf-life performance temperatures to more than 2 ppm. The authors concluded that the study “raises substantial concerns” about the safety of BP products currently on the market.