SAN FRANCISCO – The Mediterranean diet may be superior to the low-fat diet for decreasing hepatic fat and increasing insulin sensitivity in patients with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease, based on a small randomized crossover study conducted in Australia.
After just 6 weeks on the Mediterranean diet, the 12 patients studied had significant improvements in a range of metabolic measures, such as a greater than one-third decrease in hepatic triglyceride content. In contrast, they had no such improvements after 6 weeks on the low-fat diet.
“The Mediterranean diet treats the underlying pathophysiology of NAFLD; this diet shows promise as a dietary recommendation for NAFLD,” lead author Dr. Marno C. Ryan said at the meeting.
“However, this is a small, highly controlled study, and larger, longer-term studies are needed to confirm these findings,” she said.
Importantly, the Mediterranean diet was also well received. “All of our patients enjoyed it, a lot more than the low-fat diet. Our dietitian actually was personally involved in preparing a lot of the meals,” she explained, noting that a larger trial would require more patient training in food preparation.
Also, cost might be a barrier for some patients in following the Mediterranean diet, said Dr. Ryan, of St. Vincent's Hospital in Melbourne. “Olive oil was a concern, and fish was as well. We did provide patients with money, approximately $80 a week, for that.”
The investigators are now planning a similar but larger, less well-controlled study in which patients will be followed for 2 years and will have liver biopsy at the beginning and end, she said.
Dr. T. Jake Liang, president of the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases and chief of the liver diseases branch at the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases pointed out thatro%-3% of the U.S. populationhass NAFLD. That number is likely to increase, he said, given that two-thirds of the populationis are now overweight.
These new findings are “interesting; further long-term study is warranted,” he said in a press conference. “Obviously, if we can prevent and treat a disease with a diet, that's probably better than any drugs we can develop.”
Insulin resistance is implicated in the pathogenesis of NAFLD as well as the other components of metabolic syndrome, such as abdominal obesity and dyslipidemia, Dr. Ryan said, giving some background for the study. “Therefore, any therapeutic strategies directed toward NAFLD should also encompass potential benefits for these associated features.”
To be eligible for the study, patients needed to be nondiabetic, with biopsy-proven NAFLD with fibrosis classified as less than F3 in extent, and to consume fewer than two servings of alcohol daily.
The cohort had an equal sex distribution, a mean body mass index of 32 kg/m
The patients were randomized to start the study with either the Mediterranean diet or the low-fat, high-carbohydrate diet currently recommended for patients with NAFLD. They ate one diet for 6 weeks, returned to their own diet for 6 weeks as a washout, and then went on the alternative diet for 6 weeks. The aim was to change diet without inducing weight loss, since that can be a confounding factor, Dr. Ryan noted.
All patients received dietary instructions, weekly rotating menus, and approximately 70% of the meals needed for the study diets. They underwent testing – lab assays of fasting blood samples, a 3-hour euglycemic clamp study, and liver imaging and spectroscopy – before and at the end of each 6-week study period.
Patients lost only small amounts of weight on the two diets, an average of 1 kg on the Mediterranean diet and 2.4 kg on the low-fat diet, a nonsignificant difference, Dr. Ryan reported.
The main results showed that the Mediterranean diet was associated with a 39% reduction from baseline in hepatic triglyceride content. This was determined via magnetic resonance spectroscopy after adjustment for weight loss (P = .001).
There was a similar reduction in hepatic fat fraction measured by volumetric magnetic resonance imaging (P = .006).
The Mediterranean diet was also associated with improvements in insulin sensitivity as determined from reductions in homeostasis model assessment–insulin resistance, or HOMA-IR (P = .008) and fasting insulin levels (P = .003), and an increase in the glucose infusion rate on the euglycemic clamp study (P = .09).
In contrast, the low-fat diet was not associated with significant changes from baseline in any of these measures. “Interestingly, the serum insulin concentration actually increased across the 6-week period of the low-fat diet, presumably in response to the higher carbohydrate intake,” she noted.