Q&A

Are ionized wrist bracelets better than placebo for musculoskeletal pain?

J Fam Pract. 2003 March;52(3):183-200
By
Kodavayour S. Nirmal, MD
Kendra Schwartz, MD, MSPH
Author and Disclosure Information

  • BACKGROUND: Currently, there are advertisements claiming that this ionized bracelet relieves musculoskeletal pain. This study compared the efficacy of ionized wrist bracelets and identical placebo wrist bracelets in treating musculoskeletal pain.
  • POPULATION STUDIED: The researchers studied a group of 610 adults (recruited from advertisements posted at the Jacksonville, Florida Mayo Clinic) with pain in at least 1 of 12 locations: neck, shoulders, elbows, wrists, hands, upper back, mid back, lower back, hips, knees, ankles, or feet. The mean age of the participants was 48 years; most were female (74.2%) and white (87.8%). Similar numbers of participants in both treatment groups had previously used ionized bracelets (4.5%), and about 80% believed the ionized bracelet would work.
  • STUDY DESIGN AND VALIDITY: The study was a randomized, placebo-controlled trial. Patients, researchers, and the bracelet manufacturer were blinded to the identity of the bracelets. Allocation was concealed during enrollment. The patients were randomly assigned to wear the ionized wrist bracelet or an identical placebo bracelet for 4 weeks. Patients wore the bracelets according to manufacturer’s instructions. All 610 patients completed the study.
  • OUTCOMES MEASURED: The authors measured 2 primary endpoints. The first was the change in pain score on a 10-point scale at 4-week follow-up at the location where baseline pain was most severe. The second endpoint was change in the sum total of pain scores for all locations after 4 weeks of bracelet use.
  • RESULTS: There was no significant difference between the 2 groups for either endpoint. The baseline pain score for all body locations for both groups was between 4.2 and 5.8 out of a possible 10; at 4-week follow-up the scores had decreased 1.3 to 2.6 points. Most (77%) individuals in both groups reported improvement in their maximum pain score and a similar percentage had an improved sum of pain scores.
PDF Download

 

PRACTICE RECOMMENDATIONS

As a result of a profound placebo effect, this study showed that Q-Ray ionized wrist bracelets were not superior to placebo bracelets in self-reported pain improvement among patients with musculoskeletal pain.

Like many other studies involving the treatment of pain, the perception that the treatment would work profoundly improved its effectiveness. While the bracelet did not work better than placebo, many patients may experience less pain if they purchase and use it.

Recommended Reading

Which is most effective for osteoarthritis of the knee: rofecoxib, celecoxib, or acetaminophen?
MDedge Family Medicine
Losartan more effective than atenolol in hypertension with left ventricular hypertrophy
MDedge Family Medicine
Arthroscopic surgery ineffective for osteoarthritis of the knee
MDedge Family Medicine
Bell’s palsy
MDedge Family Medicine
Which patients with blunt trauma do not require cervical spine x-rays?
MDedge Family Medicine
What is the optimal treatment for lateral ankle ligament ruptures?
MDedge Family Medicine
How accurate is the Canadian C-spine rule for the detection of clinically significant cervical spine injuries?
MDedge Family Medicine
Does intra-articular hyaluronate decrease symptoms of osteoarthritis of the knee?
MDedge Family Medicine
Does raloxifene affect risk of cardiovascular events in osteoporotic postmenopausal women?
MDedge Family Medicine
Managing musculoskeletal complaints with rehabilitation therapy: Summary of the Philadelphia Panel evidence-based clinical practice guidelines on musculoskeletal rehabilitation interventions
MDedge Family Medicine