Q&A

HPV testing may replace Pap smears for primary screening

Author and Disclosure Information

  • CLINICAL QUESTION: Can human papillomavirus testing replace Papanicolaou tests as the primary means of screening for cervical cancer?
  • STUDY DESIGN: Randomized controlled trial (nonblinded)
  • SETTING: Outpatient (primary care)
  • SYNOPSIS: In this multicenter screening study, 11,085 women aged 30 to 60 years were recruited from 161 family practices in the United Kingdom. To be eligible, the women could not have had an abnormal Pap result in the preceding 3 years and could never have been treated for cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). Women had a standard Pap test using an extended-tip Ayre’s spatula and a sample was placed into transport medium. Women with mild dyskaryosis or worse were referred for colposcopy.


 

BOTTOM LINE

Using human papillomavirus (HPV) testing is likely to replace Papanicolaou (Pap) testing for primary screening for cervical cancer for a variety of reasons—detection of the etiologic factor should predate the development of disease; urine testing for HPV may remove patient barriers to screening; and reduced interpretation error. This study can’t really provide the kind of data to support this, however. It is even more likely that vaccination against HPV may render both these technologies obsolete. (LOE=2b)

Recommended Reading

Should we screen for ovarian cancer?
MDedge Family Medicine
What is the best approach for patients with ASCUS detected on Pap smear?
MDedge Family Medicine
Water versus gel lubricant for cervical cytology specimens
MDedge Family Medicine
Clindamycin for vaginosis reduces prematurity and late miscarriage
MDedge Family Medicine
3-year interval between Pap smears adequate for women with prior negative results
MDedge Family Medicine
First-trimester tests for trisomies 21 and 18 as sensitive as triple screen
MDedge Family Medicine
Estrogen plus progestin may increase incidence of dementia
MDedge Family Medicine
Which cytology results predict cervical intraepithelial neoplasia?
MDedge Family Medicine
Routine induction reduces cesarean rate
MDedge Family Medicine
Aspirin prevents preeclampsia and complications
MDedge Family Medicine