Commentary

How to Cure Hedonic Eating?


 

Logan is a 62-year-old woman who has reached the pinnacle of professional success. She started a $50 million consumer products company and, after selling it, managed to develop another successful brand. She is healthy and happily married, with four adult children. And yet, despite all her achievements and stable family life, Logan was always bothered by her inability to lose weight.

Despite peddling in beauty, she felt perpetually overweight and, frankly, unattractive. She has no family history of obesity, drinks minimal alcohol, and follows an (allegedly) healthy diet. Logan had tried “everything” to lose weight — human growth hormone injections (not prescribed by me), Ozempic-like medications, Belviq, etc. — all to no avail.

Here’s the catch: After she finished with her busy days of meetings and spreadsheets, Logan sat down to read through countless emails and rewarded herself with all her favorite foods. Without realizing it, she often doubled her daily caloric intake in one sitting. She wasn’t hungry in these moments, rather just a little worn out and perhaps a little careless. She then proceeded to email her doctor (me) to report on this endless cycle of unwanted behavior.

In January 2024, a novel study from Turkey examined the relationship between hedonic eating, self-condemnation, and self-esteem. Surprising to no one, the study determined that higher hedonic hunger scores were associated with lower self-esteem and an increased propensity to self-stigmatize.

Oprah could have handily predicted this conclusion. Many years ago, she described food as a fake friend: Perhaps you’ve had a long and difficult day. While you’re busy eating your feelings, the heaping plate of pasta feels like your best buddy in the world. However, the moment the plate is empty, you realize that you feel worse than before. Not only do you have to unbutton your new jeans, but you also realize that you have just lost your ability to self-regulate.

While the positive association between hedonic eating and low self-esteem may seem self-evident, the solution is less obvious. Mindfulness is one possible approach to this issue. Mindfulness has been described as “paying attention in a particular way: on purpose, in the present moment, and nonjudgmentally” and has existed for thousands of years. Mindful eating, in particular, involves paying close attention to our food choices and how they affect our emotions, and typically includes some combination of:

  • Slowing down eating/chewing thoroughly
  • Eliminating distractions such as TV, computers, and phones — perhaps even eating in silence
  • Eating only until physically satiated
  • Distinguishing between true hunger and cravings
  • Noticing the texture, flavors, and smell of food
  • Paying attention to the effect of food on your mood
  • Appreciating food

In our society, where processed food is so readily available and stress is so ubiquitous, eating can become a hedonic and fast-paced activity. Our brains don’t have time to process our bodies’ signals of fullness and, as a result, we often ingest many more calories than we need for a healthy lifestyle.

If mindless eating is part of the problem, mindful eating is part of the solution. Indeed, a meta-review of 10 scientific studies showed that mindful eating is as effective as conventional weight loss programs in regard to body mass index and waist circumference. On the basis of these studies — as well as some good old-fashioned common sense — intuitive eating is an important component of sustainable weight reduction.

Eventually, I convinced Logan to meet up with the psychologist in our group who specializes in emotional eating. Through weekly cognitive-behavioral therapy sessions, Logan was able to understand the impetus behind her self-defeating behavior and has finally been able to reverse some of her lifelong habits. Once she started practicing mindful eating, I was able to introduce Ozempic, and now Logan is happily shedding several pounds a week.

Dr. Messer has disclosed no relevant financial relationships.

Dr. Messer is clinical assistant professor, Mount Sinai School of Medicine and associate professor, Hofstra School of Medicine, both in New York City.

A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.

Recommended Reading

Eating disorders in children is a global public health emergency
MDedge Family Medicine
Eating disorder apps fall short when it comes to privacy
MDedge Family Medicine
APA launches online eating disorder assessment tool
MDedge Family Medicine
What’s best for patients who are dying of anorexia?
MDedge Family Medicine
Tips for addressing uptick in mental health visits: Primary care providers collaborate, innovate
MDedge Family Medicine
Psilocybin shows early promise for anorexia nervosa
MDedge Family Medicine
Screen bipolar patients for eating disorders
MDedge Family Medicine
Can a decrease in dopamine lead to binge eating?
MDedge Family Medicine
What Happens to Surgery Candidates with BHDs and Cancer?
MDedge Family Medicine
Remote CBT as Effective as In-Person Therapy for Mental Illness
MDedge Family Medicine