Delayed diagnosis renders dominant hand and wrist useless
A WOMAN HOSPITALIZED WITH RESPIRATORY SYMPTOMS was treated and released 4 days later. She returned by ambulance the next day and was readmitted for chronic obstructive pulmonary disease and respiratory failure. She had a history of tobacco use. It turned out she had suffered a myocardial infarction. After a cardiac consultation, she was started on 3 anticoagulants, including enoxaparin.
When her condition failed to improve after 4 days, she was transferred to another hospital. Before the transfer, bruising and slight swelling were observed on the patient’s left side and chest, and a physician reportedly ordered that the enoxaparin be discontinued. The plaintiff received another dose of enoxaparin just after she arrived at the second hospital and 3 more doses before the drug was discontinued 2 days later. On the day after admission, the patient’s right forearm, her dominant arm, was noted to be swollen, firm, and painful; her torso was bruised. No immediate evaluation was performed.
An orthopedic consultation the following day led to a diagnosis of compartment syndrome. Emergency surgery resulted in loss of muscle and nerves in the arm and chronic pain. The patient also developed anemia, hypovolemic shock, and retroperitoneal hemorrhage requiring a number of blood transfusions. The patient lost almost all function in her right wrist and hand.
PLAINTIFF’S CLAIM The defendants were negligent in failing to promptly diagnose compartment syndrome and subsequent hemorrhaging.
THE DEFENSE No negligence occurred.
VERDICT $1.525 million Ohio verdict.
COMMENT Subtle and nonspecific findings make compartment syndrome a challenging diagnosis. The combination of extremity pain, swelling, and bruising in the context of anticoagulation should trigger consideration of this condition.
Failure to suspect endocarditis ends in heart surgery and memory deficit
GENERAL ACHES, FATIGUE, AND OCCASIONAL FEVER of 102.5°F led a 43-year-old woman to seek treatment at a local clinic. The nurse practitioner who examined her suspected influenza. Six days later the patient returned, complaining that her symptoms were making it difficult to care for her 4 children. She didn’t have a fever at the time. The nurse practitioner suggested that the woman might want to go to the local hospital for an examination; she also said she could prescribe oral antibiotics to see if they helped. The patient chose the antibiotics.
Her symptoms improved over the next week but then reappeared, prompting her to return to the clinic with complaints of headache, muscle aches, fatigue, chest tightening, an unproductive cough, and night sweats so severe she had to wrap herself in a towel to avoid soaking her bed. Although she was still having regular periods, a physician told her she was probably premenopausal. He also told her that overweight people often sweat at night and attributed her fatigue to her 4 children. He prescribed rizatriptan on the theory that the headaches might be migraines. Because the woman didn’t have a fever at the time of the visit and had just finished a course of antibiotics, the physician said he was sure that she didn’t have an infection.
After 6 days with no improvement, the patient went to a hospital emergency department (ED) for a complete checkup because she was planning to drive to Arizona with her family and wanted to make sure she was all right before leaving. The ED physician ordered scans, a spinal tap, and blood tests; he diagnosed a viral infection.
Three days later, the patient went to the clinic, accompanied by her entire family, to find out the results of the blood tests. She still had symptoms and had developed a swollen, tender sternum. The nurse practitioner noted a positive culture result for Streptococcus veridans on the test report; she allegedly told the patient, in the presence of her 10-year-old son, that it must be a skin contaminant. She advised the patient to go on vacation and have additional blood work if she didn’t feel better.
The nurse practitioner gave the patient another pack of oral antibiotics in case she had a lingering low-grade infection. The patient also received another prescription for rizatriptan and an acetaminophen and oxycodone prescription for pain.