Feature

Justices appear skeptical of California’s abortion speech law


 


“I am confident that at least some members of the Supreme Court understood what was at stake here and understand that there is a layer of deception behind the actions of the anti-abortion centers,” she said in an interview.

Paul Sherman, a senior attorney for the Institute for Justice in Arlington, Va., said that based on the oral arguments, it appears likely California’s law will be struck down. Mr. Sherman coauthored the Institute for Justice’s amicus brief in support of NIFLA.

Paul Sherman, a senior attorney for the Institute for Justice in Arlington, Va.

Paul Sherman

“Even some of the more liberal members of the court seemed to think that California’s law went too far,” he said in an interview. “The real question now seems to be whether the court will rule broadly that there are significant limitations on the government’s ability to regulate speech by crisis pregnancy centers, or whether it will rule more narrowly that this particular law subjected crisis pregnancy centers to unreasonable burdens that other speakers offering pregnancy counseling were not subject to.”

A number of physician associations have weighed in on NIFLA v. Becerra. The American Medical Association issued a court brief in support of California and the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists and the American Academy of Pediatrics joined several other medical associations in a similar brief. The American Association of Pro-Life Obstetrician and Gynecologists joined the Christian Medical Association and others to submit a brief in support of NIFLA.

The Supreme Court is expected to rule on the case by this summer.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Incidence of adenomyosis in hysterectomy patients higher than previously reported
MDedge Internal Medicine
E-visits less likely to generate antibiotic prescriptions for common ailments
MDedge Internal Medicine
Sleep improved with urinary incontinence treatment
MDedge Internal Medicine
PCOS may influence the diversity of the gut microbiome
MDedge Internal Medicine
Menopause accelerates RA functional decline
MDedge Internal Medicine
nPEP for HIV: Updated CDC guidelines available for primary care physicians
MDedge Internal Medicine
Laparoscopic hysterectomy safest even for markedly enlarged uteri
MDedge Internal Medicine
High MIH case volume may up risk for adverse events in women with large uteri
MDedge Internal Medicine
VIDEO: Fezolinetant drops testosterone levels in PCOS
MDedge Internal Medicine
MDedge Daily News: Stem cells may reverse premature menopause
MDedge Internal Medicine