BOSTON – For patients with nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD), leaner may really be meaner, according to a recent French study involving more than 100,000 individuals of the general population.
Dr. Lawrence Serfaty
NAFLD was uncommon among participants with normal bodyweight, but when NAFLD was present, lean patients had almost twice the risk of advanced fibrosis as that of overweight and obese patients, reported principal author Lawrence Serfaty, MD, chief of the department of hepatology at Strasbourg (France) University, who conducted the project with colleagues at the French public research organization, Inserm.
“Normally, NAFLD and [nonalcoholic steatohepatitis (NASH)] are part of metabolic syndrome,” Dr. Serfaty said in an interview at the annual meeting of the American Association for the Study of Liver Diseases. “But there are some patients with no metabolic risk factors who are lean and who may have NAFLD.”
To determine the prevalence and characteristics of these patients, the investigators drew data from the CONSTANCES cohort, which is composed of 118,664 members of the general public in France. After excluding those who withdrew consent, had a history of other liver diseases, or reported an excess of alcohol consumption (more than 20 g/day), the analyzed dataset included 102,344 subjects. Among these participants, NAFLD and advanced fibrosis were diagnosed with the Fatty Liver Index (FLI) and the Forns Index (FI), respectively, in which an FLI score greater than 60 indicated NAFLD and an FI score greater than 6.9 indicated advanced fibrosis.
Participants were sorted into three weight categories by body mass index: lean (BMI less than 25 kg/m2), overweight (BMI 25-30), or obese (BMI more than 30). In addition, a variety of other health measures were recorded, including presence of metabolic risk factors, such as diabetes or metabolic syndrome, and elevated alanine transaminase (ALT).
Analysis showed that the prevalence of NAFLD in the general population was 18.2%. Of those diagnosed with NAFLD, 2.6% had advanced fibrosis. As expected, Dr. Serfaty said, NAFLD was much less common among those who were of normal bodyweight, with lean patients accounting for only 1.9% of NAFLD diagnoses. However, when NAFLD was diagnosed in lean patients, it was more often severe. Among lean patients with NAFLD, 4.5% had advanced fibrosis, compared with 2.4% of overweight patients and 2.3% of obese patients.
Dr. Serfaty noted that lean patients with NAFLD tended to have fewer metabolic risk factors, but most had at least one. Lifestyle factors were likely to blame, he said, because lean patients with NAFLD were relatively heavy users of tobacco and alcohol, compared with obese or overweight patients. Cardiovascular disease was also more common among lean patients with NAFLD.
“There are probably other factors [that are different, such as] genetic factors, the microbiome, and maybe the immune system,” Dr. Serfaty said.
While drivers of NAFLD among lean patients remain to be clarified, Dr. Serfaty highlighted the importance of recognizing this unique patient population, and if encountered, not discounting the severity of disease based on a lack of other metabolic risk factors.
“It is very important to know that these patients exist because it is very difficult to identify these patients,” Dr. Serfaty said. “If you have a lean patient with NAFLD, normally you [might] say, it’s not very severe for this patient because he’s lean; but no, [that’s not correct], because maybe he has more advanced fibrosis. So you have to go through and check with other noninvasive markers to be sure that this patient does not have advanced fibrosis.”
Concerning the difficulty of identifying such patients in the first place, Dr. Serfaty suggested that elevated ALT may be the most reliable red flag because this laboratory abnormality occurred in more than half of the lean patients diagnosed with NAFLD, despite no excessive alcohol consumption or prior hepatitis. The investigators disclosed relationships with Gilead, AbbVie, Echosens, and others.
SOURCE: Serfaty L et al. The Liver Meeting 2019, Abstract 1188.