After 1945
Behavior before 1945 is not the only source of shame. Crimes committed by doctors were never really confronted until the late 1970s, Jörg-Dietrich Hoppe, MD, former president of the German Medical Association, explained to ZEIT, a German newspaper, in 2011.
The psychoanalyst Alexander Mitscherlich, MD, and Fred Mielke were official observers from the German Commission of Physicians at the Nuremberg Doctors’ Trial who were made painfully aware that National Socialism was by no means over when the regime came to an end. They were both reviled as traitors to their country and for fouling their own nest, and, according to Mitscherlich, the behavior of the “authorities” bordered on character assassination.
As late as 1973, a renowned internist threatened that German internists would leave the room locked at the upcoming DGIM Congress if — as had been planned by congress chair Herbert Begemann — Mitscherlich gave a talk on this subject, journalist and doctor Renate Jäckle reported in her book on doctors and politics.
Even toward the end of the 1980s, Karsten Vilmar, MD, then president of the German Medical Association, reacted in an insensitive and defensive manner — during an interview — to an article in the Lancet, written by the Mainz pediatrician Hartmut M. Hanauske-Abel, MD, on the role of the German medical profession in the Third Reich and the suppression that followed after 1945.
A group of 400 doctors, at most, were culpable, and coming to terms with the past should not defame doctors collectively, Dr. Vilmar said in a statement chillingly reminiscent of declarations made by the Wehrmacht, which described itself as mainly “clean.”
Of course, the end of the Nazi regime was not the end of all barbarity, not even in Europe. “Violence will be something we have to confront in our future lives, too. Belief in the healing powers of civilization is nothing but a fairytale,” Berlin historian Jörg Barberowski wrote in a 2012 essay.
Nevertheless, as Michael Hallek, MD, from the University Hospital of Cologne, said, it is important to keep memory alive.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com.