A baby is born limp and blue without a cry. Her hypotonia raises a concern for encephalopathy, and she is whisked off to the neonatal intensive care unit for 72 hours of therapeutic hypothermia. Stunned, the parents begin to wonder, “Will our baby be O.K.?” and “What went wrong?”
When neonatologists recommend therapeutic hypothermia for the newborn with presumptive encephalopathy, they may explain the situation to the parents with words such as brain injury, encephalopathy, hypoxia, and ischemia. Intrapartum events such as a Category II or III fetal heart rate tracing, operative vaginal delivery, or maternal sepsis or abruption might be mentioned as contributing factors. A consulting neurologist may mention injury of the cerebral cortex, subcortical white matter, or lateral thalami. The neonatologists and neurologists might not mention that less than 50% of cases of newborn encephalopathy are thought to be due to the management of labor.2
The obstetrician, as stunned by the events as the parents, may be at a loss about how to communicate effectively with their patient about the newborn’s encephalopathy. Obstetricians can help assure the parents of their continued involvement in the care and reinforce that the hospital’s neonatologists are superb clinicians who will do their best for the baby.
Challenges exist to effective communication. It is often difficult to optimally coordinate and align the communications of the neonatologists, neurologist, nurses, and obstetrician with the family. Communication with the family can be uncoordinated because interactions occur between the family and multiple specialists with unique perspectives and vocabularies. These conversations occur in sequence, separated in time and place. The communication between family and neonatologists typically occurs in the neonatal intensive care unit. Interactions between obstetrician and mother typically occur in the postpartum unit. The neonatologists and obstetricians are assigned to the hospital in rotating coverage shifts, increasing the number of hand-offs and physicians involved in the hospital care of the mother and newborn dyad.
A joint family meeting with the neonatologists, obstetrician, and family early in the course of newborn care might be an optimal approach to coordinating communication with the parents. Conflicting obligations certainly may make a joint meeting difficult to arrange, however.
Reducing the risk of permanent injury to the central and peripheral nervous system of the newborn is the goal of all obstetricians and neonatologists. Many authorities believe that therapeutic hypothermia can reduce the risk of death and major neurodevelopmental disorders in newborns with encephalopathy. Initial data are promising. If long-term follow-up studies prove that this therapy reduces neurologic disability, the treatment represents a major advance in maternal-child care. As we learn more about this novel, and potentially effective therapy, it should be on the minds of those involved with newborn care to involve the ObGyn in coordinated communication with the family and other medical staff.
Share your thoughts! Send your Letter to the Editor to rbarbieri@frontlinemedcom.com. Please include your name and the city and state in which you practice.
