Will the standard change?
At present, the PERSEPHONE findings are not sufficient to change the existing standard of care of 12 months of adjuvant trastuzumab, according to Dr. Earl. “We need to be very careful and cautious about coming out at this point and saying, ‘Yes, 6 months is enough,’ ” she maintained. “At the moment, I do think we need to wait for longer follow-up and we need to take a real close look at the data. Changing from an established treatment that works is always going to be a very complex and very challenging thing to do.”
“Personally, I find the results quite compelling, and I think that it is likely that they will signal a shift even in the U.S. oncology community toward shorter duration of Herceptin adjuvant therapy,” commented Richard L. Schilsky, MD, FACP, FASCO, chief medical officer of ASCO and press briefing moderator. However, “we don’t have data yet on overall survival. Survival in this study is still relatively short for a breast cancer population, although patients with HER2+ disease oftentimes have a somewhat more aggressive course,” he noted. In addition, the ongoing translational studies will be critical to any decisions about changing the standard of care because some subgroups of patients will probably not fare as well with the shorter-duration therapy.