Where do we stand with HPV vaccination?
Dr. Mutch: Those are great points.
You brought up vaccination. We have a long way to go with regard to that, certainly in the United States, because of the various factions opposed to vaccination and so on. But do you think that vaccination has allowed us to decrease the incidence of cervical cancer?
Dr. Huh: Yes. There is clear evidence from the Nordic countries.7 There is emerging evidence from Australia.8 There is emerging evidence from other industrialized nations that clearly demonstrate vaccination’s positive effect in reducing the incidence of cervical cancer. None of this should be a surprise. Every population-based study that has been published with the HPV vaccine in populations that have a low frequency of vaccination have demonstrated substantial reductions in things like genital warts, abnormal Pap tests, precancer, and now evidence that there is a downward trend in terms of the incidence of cervical cancer.9
I don’t think that there is any debate anymore that vaccination is the way to go. Our challenge is about implementation and getting the vaccine to people. We still have a long way to go with that. There are parts of the world that are so affected by invasive cervical cancers; we need to get the vaccine to those parts of the world.
Dr. Mutch: What are the barriers to vaccination? How can we overcome those barriers?
Dr. Huh: There is a lot of criticism that we are not vaccinating more in the United States. However, the rates of vaccination are going up every single year. The pandemic may have blunted that rise a bit, but if you look at the vaccination curves, they are going up, not down. We need to continue to educate patients, parents, and pediatricians on the importance of vaccination.
Boys still get vaccinated less frequently than girls, so we have some work to do there. I think globally it is the issue of getting the vaccine to people, making sure that vaccine is available. The thing that I think will be the game-changer going forward is whether or not we will have evidence to indicate that 1 dose is as effective as 2 doses or 3 doses. If we can vaccinate boys and girls with just 1 dose, then in the next generation or two, we seriously might eradicate not just cervical cancer but a lot of HPV-related malignancies worldwide.
Educating patients, clinicians is key
Dr. Mutch: So it seems education, education, education, with regard to screening guidelines, with regard to the need for continued examinations, and that HPV testing is only a test, it does not supplant overall care. Finally, education regarding eradication of cervical cancer through vaccination.
Dr. Huh: That summarizes it well. We are still going to screen for cervical cancer. We are still going to vaccinate, and providers are still going to manage abnormal Pap tests. It is confusing because we are changing it up it seems every year or 2, so this conversation you and I are having is particularly important for clinicians to understand the basis of that. There has been an explosion of data that has come out in this area in the last decade.
Dr. Mutch: Thank you, Dr. Huh. I really appreciate your thoughts on this. As you all know, Dr. Huh has been President of the ASCCP and is instrumental in writing and disseminating these guidelines, so we are very grateful that he has consented to agree to come and talk with us today.
Dr. Huh: My pleasure. Thank you for inviting me. This was fun, and I have really enjoyed talking to you and participating. ●