Clinical Review

Cutting the legal risks of hypertension in pregnancy

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

HELLP syndrome. Hemolysis (H), elevated liver proteins (EL), and low platelets (LP)—or a combination of these (HELLP)—are well-recognized complications of preeclampsia-eclampsia. Several of the signs, symptoms, and laboratory abnormalities that constitute HELLP syndrome may be confused with similar findings that are usually present in a number of distinct medical and surgical disorders (TABLE 9). This is particularly true when they manifest remote from term. Diagnosis often is delayed, and management frequently is complicated by inappropriate medical and surgical treatments that may be dangerous to both mother and fetus. Not surprisingly, complications related to this syndrome are a major cause of litigation claiming failure to diagnose preeclampsia or failure to diagnose syndromes that can mimic preeclampsia.

The typical HELLP patient is white and complains of epigastric or RUQ pain at less than 36 weeks’ gestation. Some women experience nausea and vomiting (40% to 50%) or diarrhea (5% to 10%), and others have nonspecific viral syndrome-like symptoms. Most patients report a history of malaise for the few hours or days leading up to presentation. Some of these women may complain of flank or shoulder pain, hematuria, bleeding from the gums, or jaundice. Hypertension or proteinuria may be slight or absent. Physical examination will show RUQ tenderness, significant weight gain (ascites, generalized edema), petechiae, or purpura.

Patients with preeclampsia are at increased risk for convulsions during labor and for the first 12 to 24 hours postpartum.

Some patients may have a variety of signs and symptoms, none of which are diagnostic of classic preeclampsia. For this reason, all gravidas beyond 20 weeks’ gestation having any of these symptoms should undergo a platelet count and liver enzyme determinations, regardless of maternal BP. Since 30% of HELLP syndrome cases develop postpartum, similar evaluation should be performed in all women having these complaints within 2 weeks of delivery.

TABLE 4

Clinical factors to be considered in management

  • Diagnosis of the condition
  • Severity of the disease process
  • Fetal gestational age
  • Fetal growth and well-being
  • Maternal condition
    • - Results of blood tests
    • - Presence of symptoms
  • Presence of labor
  • Bishop cervical score

TABLE 5

Indications for delivery in mild preeclampsia

  • Gestational age ≥37 weeks with ripe cervix
  • Onset of labor and/or membrane rupture ≥34 weeks
  • Onset of persistent headaches or visual symptoms
  • Epigastric or RUQ pain
  • Abdominal tenderness or vaginal bleeding
  • Thromobocytopenia (platelets <100 x 103/mm3)
  • Severe oligohydramnios or IUGR by ultrasound
  • Abnormal FHR testing*
FHR=fetal heart rate; IUGR=intrauterine growth restriction; RUQ=right upper quadrant
* Nonreactive nonstress test confirmed by biophysical profile or contraction test.

TABLE 6

Characteristics of patients eligible for outpatient management of mild preeclampsia

  • Systolic pressure ≤150 mm Hg or diastolic pressure ≤100 mm Hg
  • Proteinuria ≤1,000 mg/24 hr or ≤2+ on dipstick
  • No labor
  • Highly reliable
  • Absent cerebral signs and symptoms
  • Absent epigastric or upper quadrant pain
  • Absent fetal growth retardation by ultrasound
  • Normal antepartum fetal testing
  • Normal liver enzymes and platelet count

TABLE 7

Antepartum management of mild preeclampsia

  • Relative bed rest (hospital or home)
  • Blood pressure measurement (daily)
  • Dipstick for urine protein (daily)
  • Evaluation of symptoms (daily)
  • Platelet count and liver enzymes (2x/week)
  • Fetal movement counts (daily)
  • Antepartum fetal testing (2x/week)
  • Ultrasound for fetal growth (every 3 weeks)

TABLE 8

Indications for delivery during expectant management of severe preeclampsia

  • Fetal indications:
    • - 34 weeks’ gestation
    • - 33-34 weeks with documented lung maturity or after steroid use
    • - Estimated fetal weight below the fifth percentile by ultrasound
    • - Evidence of severe oligohydramnios
    • - Abnormal fetal testing
    • - Rupture of membranes
  • Maternal indications:
    • - Preterm labor or vaginal bleeding
    • - Eclampsia or encephalopathy
    • - Pulmonary edema or renal failure
    • - Persistent oliguria despite therapy
    • - Persistent thrombocytopenia
    • - Severe epigastric pain or cerebral symptoms
    • - Maternal desire
    • - Severe hypertension unresponsive to maximum drug therapy

TABLE 9

Imitators of HELLP syndrome

  • Acute fatty liver of pregnancy
  • Thrombotic thrombocytopenia purpura
  • Hemolytic uremic syndrome
  • Exacerbation of lupus nephritis
  • Thrombophilias
  • Disseminated herpes simplex
  • Acute glomerulonephritis
  • Immune thrombocytopenia
  • Septic shock
  • Gall bladder disease/pancreatitis
  • Hypertensive encephalopathy
  • Intracerebral hemorrhage
HELLP=hemolysis, elevated liver proteins, and low platelets

Intrapartum management

Some of the medicolegal claims involving intrapartum management of hypertensive disorders concern the failure to give magnesium sulfate to prevent convulsions, the failure to distinguish bleeding of a “bloody show” from abruptio placentae, the failure to use antihypertensive drugs to treat a certain BP level, the mode of delivery, and the association of abnormal fetal-heart-rate (FHR) tracings with neonatal outcome.

In some women, hypertension first develops in labor. These patients should undergo urine protein and blood tests to confirm the presence or absence of preeclampsia and should then be managed accordingly.

Preventing convulsions. Patients with preeclampsia are at increased risk for convulsions during labor and for the first 12 to 24 hours postpartum. The risks are slight in those with mild disease (1%), but may reach 3% to 10% in women with severe disease at less than 32 weeks’ gestation and in patients with HELLP syndrome.9 Therefore, all patients with diagnosed preeclampsia should receive parenteral magnesium sulfate during labor and for at least 12 hours postpartum; in patients with severe preeclampsia or HELLP syndrome, magnesium sulfate should be continued for at least 24 hours postpartum. A typical regimen is a loading dose of 6 g given over 20 minutes, followed by a maintenance dose of 2 g per hour as a continuous intravenous (IV) solution (5% dextrose in lactated Ringer’s solution).

Pages

Recommended Reading

Patient follow-up after urodynamic testing
MDedge ObGyn
Update on hysterectomy codes
MDedge ObGyn
Assessing fetal scalp pH levels
MDedge ObGyn
HRT and cancer: quantifying the risk
MDedge ObGyn
Transdermal contraception: update on clinical management
MDedge ObGyn
Solving the medical liability riddle
MDedge ObGyn
Duloxetine for stress incontinence
MDedge ObGyn
Fetus discovered during hysterectomy
MDedge ObGyn
Scarring develops after cauterization of condylomata
MDedge ObGyn
Did incomplete ovary removal lead to residual pain?
MDedge ObGyn