Medicolegal Issues

More strategies to avoid malpractice hazards on labor and delivery

Author and Disclosure Information

 

References

Management options may vary from institution to institution, however, because of limited availability of certain services—such as the expertise required for a trial of external cephalic version, the availability of on-site cesarean delivery capabilities, and patient and clinician preferences.

Uniformity of care, based on best practices, can therefore simplify the care process and decrease the risk that may be associated with individual experience-based management. Adhering to a uniform practice augments the clinician’s knowledge and allows for enhanced nursing and therapeutic efficiency.

The greatest benefit of using an evidence-based, widely accepted approach, however, is the potential to diminish poor practice and consequent malpractice exposure for both clinicians and the hospital.

Note: Although your adherence to clinical guidelines, best practices, and uniformity of care ought to be consistent with established standards of care, don’t automatically consider any deviation a lapse or failing because it’s understood and accepted that some local variability exists in practice.

Prelude to birth: triage and admission Triage. Most women in labor arrive at the hospital or birthing center to an area set aside for labor and delivery triage. There, 1) recording of the chief complaint and vital signs and 2) completion of a brief history and physical generate a call to the clinician.

The record produced in triage should be scrutinized carefully for accuracy. Clarify, in as timely a manner as possible, any errors in:

  • timing (possibly because of different clocks set to different times)
  • the precise capture of the chief complaint
  • reporting difficulty or ease in reaching the responsible clinician.

Whether these records are electronic or paper, an addendum marked with the time is always acceptable. Never attempt to correct a record! Always utilize a late entry or addendum.

Admission. After the patient is admitted, she generally undergoes an admission protocol, specific to the hospital, regarding her situation. This includes:

  • the history
  • special requests
  • any previously agreed-on plan of care
  • any problems that have developed since her last prenatal visit.

This protocol is generally completed by a nurse, resident, nurse practitioner, or physician assistant.

Hospitals generally request input from the attending physician on the specifics of the admission, based on those hospital protocols. There may be some room to individualize the admission process to labor and delivery.

4 pillars of care during labor

In general, labor is defined as progressive dilation of the cervix. Several parameters serve as guidelines regarding adequate progress through the various stages of labor.

Fetal monitoring. Continuous evaluation of the fetus during labor is a routine part of intrapartum care. Recording and observing the FHR tracing is an accepted—and expected—practice. Documentation of the FHR in the medical record is specifically required, and should include both the physician’s and nursing notes.

Anesthesia care. The patient’s preference and the availability of options allows for several accepted practices regarding anesthesia and analgesia during L & D. Does she want epidural anesthesia during labor, for example? Intravenous narcotics? Her choice is an important facet of your provision of care.

However, such choice requires the patient to give consent and to understand the risk-benefit equation. Documentation by nursing of the patient’s consent and understanding should be complete, including discussion and administration. Anesthesia staff should be clear, complete, and legible in making a record.

Neonatal care. If logistics permit, a member of the pediatrics service should be routinely available to see the newborn at delivery. The patient should view the pediatrician and obstetrician as partners working as a team for the benefit of the mother and her family. This can enhance the patient’s understanding and confidence about the well being of her baby.

Documentation. Although deficient documentation does not, itself, lead to a finding of malpractice, appropriate documentation plays an important role in demonstrating that clinical practices have addressed issues about both allegation and causation of potential adverse outcomes.

We cannot overemphasize that nursing documentation should complement and be consistent with notes made by the physician. That said, nursing notes are not a substitute for the physician’s notes. Practices that integrate the written comments of nursing and physician into a single set of progress notes facilitate this complementary interaction.

3 more clinical scenarios

CASE 2: Admitted at term with contractions

The initial exam determines that this 21-year-old gravida 1 is 2/80/-1. Re-examination in 3 hours finds her at 3-4/80/0.

She requests pain relief and states that she wants epidural anesthesia.

Evaluation 2 hours later suggests secondary arrest of dilation. Oxytocin is begun.

Soon after, late decelerations are observed on the FHR monitor.


Use of exogenous oxytocin in L & D is a double-edged sword: The drug can enhance the safety and efficacy of labor and delivery for mother and fetus, but using it in an unregulated manner (in terms of its indication and administration) can subject both to increased risk.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Web Tool Helps New Moms Shed Pounds
MDedge ObGyn
Maternal Flu Vaccine Cuts Infants' Infection Risk
MDedge ObGyn
Risks of Delayed-Interval Delivery Can Be High
MDedge ObGyn
Induced Abortions Linked to Preterm Delivery
MDedge ObGyn
PPIs Might Raise Risk of Cardiac Birth Defects
MDedge ObGyn
OTC Painkillers Tied To Undescended Testes
MDedge ObGyn
Maternal DTaP Vaccine Protected Newborns
MDedge ObGyn
Paternal Postpartum Depression High
MDedge ObGyn
Managing Rheumatologic Diseases in Pregnancy
MDedge ObGyn
Sound strategies to avoid malpractice hazards on labor and delivery
MDedge ObGyn