I drive a 10-year-old pickup truck. The air conditioner no longer works – not a real problem here in Maine. It has hand-operated roll down windows ... a real plus should I back too far down the boat ramp and find myself in the cold waters of the Atlantic. If I ever decide to lock it, I will need to use a real key. But the pile of mismatched work gloves and rusty garden tools stashed behind the front seat hasn’t seemed to attract any burglars. Its dented body sits on a new frame, thanks to a generous recall from the manufacturer.
It’s a four-wheel drive, handy in the winter. But what I really like about it is that my old truck has a standard manual transmission. I still have that boyish enthusiasm for shifting gears. I can imagine myself driving a low-slung sports car or operating some gargantuan piece of heavy machinery.
Dr. William G. Wilkoff
Driving a stick shift vehicle demands a level of engagement and concentration several levels above that of simply aiming a car equipped with an automatic transmission. While I am sure some have tried, shifting gears is a serious deterrent to texting at the wheel.
The fact that our three children learned to drive on a standard shift station wagon is a tribute to their parents’ ability to tolerate repeated whiplash injuries. But it also may be one of the reasons that they survived those deadly middle teenage years. Nichole Morris, a researcher at the Human FIRST Laboratory of the University of Minnesota has said, “If you are going to have an early, untimely death, the most dangerous 2 years of your life are between 16 and 17, and the reason for that is driving” (“Teenage Drivers? Be Very Afraid,” by Bruce Feiler, New York Times, March 19, 2016). Six teenagers a day die from motor vehicle accident–related injuries, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. There are more deaths from motor vehicle accidents in this age group than from suicides, cancer, and other accidents.
©Thinkstock.com
An unfortunate combination of perceived invincibility and inexperience in an environment richly decorated with distractions makes those first years behind the wheel so dangerous. Charlie Klauer, a researcher at Virginia Tech’s Transportation Institute, believes that one in four teenagers will be involved in a motor vehicle crash in his or her first 6 months of driving. My personal experience supports her observation. Luckily, my daughter’s first accident was a low speed rear-ender into a giant pickup truck that sustained no obvious damage.
Given these frightening statistics, it is surprising that any parents would ever allow their teenage children to start on the path toward a driver’s license. As physicians committed to the health and safety of children, why haven’t pediatricians done more to prevent this tragic loss of life? The honest answer is simply that the motor vehicle is too tightly woven into our culture. We have tried, but we could probably do more.
Technological advances such as self-braking cars that are spinning off from the development of autonomous vehicles may save a few teenage drivers. But, watching your 17-year-old child take the wheel for the first time will continue to be an anxiety-provoking experience for the foreseeable future. We can help by reminding parents that the driving is a privilege that can easily be revoked. We must continue to urge parents to create and enforce rules about the use of cell phones behind the wheel. Many states have enacted laws that restrict teenage drivers from driving with other teens in the car, a well-known and often fatal distraction. But parents must be reminded that they are the first line of enforcement.
Enduring those neck-snapping sessions that are unavoidable when your child is learning to drive a standard shift vehicle was a sacrifice my wife and I made gladly. Manual transmissions aren’t coming back. But there are still plenty of sacrifices for today’s parents to make if they want their children to survive those deadly midteen years.
Dr. Wilkoff practiced primary care pediatrics in Brunswick, Maine, for nearly 40 years. He has authored several books on behavioral pediatrics including “How to Say No to Your Toddler.”