From the Journals

Clinical course of depression is worse in older people

View on the News

Poorer depression outcomes in the elderly

While major depression appears to follow a worse clinical course in older people, this study is important in providing robust evidence of poorer prognostic outcomes and addresses some major methodological limitations of previous studies.

One limitation, acknowledged by the authors, is the absence of a sufficient measure of cognitive function. Cognitive impairment is associated with major depression, slows recovery from depression, and reduces treatment effectiveness. The study did exclude people with dementia or with Mini-Mental State Examination scores of 18 or lower, but this may not have excluded other variations in cognitive impairment that could have contributed to the age-related differences in outcomes.

Tze Pin Ng, MD, is with the department of psychological medicine at the National University of Singapore. These comments are taken from an accompanying editorial (Lancet Psychiatry. 2018 Jun 7. doi: 10.1016/S2215-0366[18]30186-X). No conflicts of interest were declared.


 

FROM THE LANCET PSYCHIATRY

Older people are much more likely than younger people to experience a poorer clinical course of major depression, even after accounting for differences in social, clinical, and other health factors, new research suggests.

A longitudinal cohort study, published in the Lancet Psychiatry, examined baseline and 2-year follow-up data from 1,042 participants who had a recent diagnosis of a depressive or anxiety disorder in two previous cohort studies.

depression elderly giocalde/Thinkstock
More than half (51%) of people aged 70 years or older still had a depression diagnosis 2 years after the initial diagnosis, compared with 36% of people aged 18-29 years. Those over age 70 years also showed less of a decline in depression severity, compared with those aged 18-29 years, and the time to remission was longest for older individuals.

The authors adjusted initially for the number of major depressive disorder (MDD) episodes, comorbid anxiety, and antidepressant use but still found that older age was significantly associated with increased risk of a depressive diagnosis, a chronic symptom course, reduced likelihood of achieving remission, and a smaller decrease in depression severity.

They also adjusted for other factors common in old age, such as loneliness, social support, pain, other chronic disease, and higher body mass index, and again found that this only led to small reductions in the association with older age. However, the adjustment for loneliness did have the effect of dissipating the association between older age and the presence of any depression diagnosis.

The more unfavorable course of MDD towards old age was only explained to a small extent by clinical, social, and health factors that are common in old age and that are thought to worsen the course of the disease,” wrote Roxanne Schaakxs, PhD, of the Amsterdam Public Health Research Institute at VU University Medical Center, and her coauthors.

Researchers also looked for an effect of antidepressant use, in case the age differences might be related to differences in treatment response. “However, adjustment for antidepressant use at baseline did not substantially change our findings, and stratified analysis for participants who did and did not use antidepressants revealed consistent age–MDD course associations for both subsamples,” they wrote.

Pages

Recommended Reading

Two more and counting: Suicide in medical trainees
MDedge Psychiatry
Heart rate variability may be risk factor for depression, not a consequence
MDedge Psychiatry
Simple postural exercises may reduce depressive symptoms
MDedge Psychiatry
Palliative care may reduce suicide among lung cancer patients
MDedge Psychiatry
Antidepressant use linked to increased weight gain
MDedge Psychiatry
Americans back from captivity need decompression period
MDedge Psychiatry
Esketamine nasal spray prevails in two phase 3 trials
MDedge Psychiatry
First antidepressant use not tied to first abortion
MDedge Psychiatry
Antidepressant therapy after MI, stroke cut CVD events
MDedge Psychiatry
Suicides up 30%; risk factors go beyond diagnosed disorders
MDedge Psychiatry