Early education crucial
How are health care institutions dealing with this problem? “Very poorly. Sexual violence perpetrated by physicians and other health care professionals is a taboo subject that people are still afraid to talk about,” Dr. Cohen observed. “Regrettably, sexual violence happens all too often. Before, maybe we weren’t talking about it much because, from our viewpoint, health care professionals, such as physicians and nurses, weren’t likely to commit acts of violence while performing their duties,” noted Dr. Drezett.
Dr. Drezett also spoke about schools and what role they can play. “Of course, schools should discuss violence against women, especially in the field of health care. This has been done for a long time now, though it’s not in every curriculum in every medical school or nursing school, nor in every school of social work or of psychology,” said Dr. Drezett. For example, in the bioethics classes taken in the third and fourth years of the University of São Paolo’s medical degree program, Dr. Cohen asks students to reflect on the significance of being in a position where you ask a patient you’ve never met to undress so you can perform an exam, and the patient promptly and readily complies. “This is not about the physician, it’s about the power of the institution,” the professor pointed out. Sexual violence is a problem on the university campus as well. Another front in the battle has formed across various schools, where groups of students have created feminist collectives to have sexual violence and other issues related to gender-based violence added to the agenda.
Dr. Drezett said it’s very unlikely that efforts made during a degree program are going to succeed in preventing students who are prone to commit sexual violence from engaging in such behavior. “We’re talking about gender-specific lessons, where discussions about gender-based violence should be started much, much earlier – parents talking to their children, teachers talking to their pupils.” He also doesn’t believe that the molesters are dissuaded by the fact that these accusations get publicized in the media. “If they were, the Roger Abdelmassih case would have done away with the problem.”
On the other hand, Dr. Drezett suggested, publicizing these stories can help to bring very positive issues out into the open. What the Bezerra case made clear was that laws were not followed and rights were not protected. An environment was thus created in which the sexual crime could be perpetrated, with nurses coming to suspect acts of obstetric violence, such as use of sedation, which prevented the woman from having skin-to-skin contact with the newborn and from breastfeeding within the first few hours of birth – two clinical practices that are recommended the world over.
“Health care professionals who act properly, in accordance with best practices for interacting with others and performing daily duties, at all times, in public or private practice – they remove themselves from situations like those described in the Bezerra case; they don’t practice medicine in a reckless manner,” said Dr. Drezett.
Another negative aspect of all this, he said, is that the suspicion and wariness that patients feel may spread far and wide. “Among my colleagues are anesthetists and anesthesiologists with impeccable ethical and professional records. They are very upset that people are now regarding them with doubt and uncertainty. We need to make it clear that those horrifying cases are the exceptions, not the rule,” he said. There is also a need to correct the misconception that such abuse is always in some way associated with obstetrics and gynecology.
“This is not true. These incidents can happen in any doctor’s office. It all depends on the physician – whether he or she has designs on committing a criminal act,” Dr. Drezett noted. He did point out that there are few sexual molesters among health care professionals, though there are numerous cases. Yet this in no way diminishes the seriousness of the incidents. “Of course, we’re speaking again about the exceptions, but in my experience of treating victims, I’ve seen, for example, more cases where it’s been a police officer, not a physician, committing an act of sexual violence against a woman,” he stated.
The nurses and nurse technicians at São João do Meriti Hospital who reported the abuser acted very assertively. If they hadn’t gathered the evidence to back up their accusations, it’s possible that the physician wouldn’t have been caught in the act and that the case would have taken a different course – including pressure being put on them and their becoming the target of retaliation.
A version of this article first appeared on Medscape.com. This article was translated from the Medscape Portuguese edition.