Ollier disease, or multiple enchondromatosis, is a rare nonfamilial condition characterized by multiple cartilaginous tumors often beginning in early childhood. There is significant variation in disease distribution, location, size, number of lesions, and behavior, but the tumors are often located unilaterally.1 Enchondromas are most commonly found in the metacarpals, metatarsals, and phalanges, and develop from metaphyseal bone in close proximity to the physis. They frequently present as painless masses or are incidentally noted during the evaluation of another musculoskeletal condition. Radiographically, enchondromas of the hands and feet appear as oval radiolucencies with thinned, sclerotic rims. The lesions have varying degrees of mineralization and endosteal scalloping, and may expand the bone.2 Enchondromas usually enlarge until skeletal maturity and have been observed to ossify spontaneously.1,3 The clinical course of Ollier disease is variable, and a number of cases of significant hand deformity and malignant transformation have been reported.4-6
In this case report, we present a mild form of Ollier disease isolated to the patient’s left hand, which we followed for 8 years, demonstrating part of the natural history of these lesions. We discuss the patient’s clinical features, radiologic findings, diagnosis, treatment, prognosis, and follow-up, as well as review the literature. The patient and the patient’s family provided written informed consent for print and electronic publication of this case report.
Case Report
A 10-year-old, right-handed girl was referred to our department for the evaluation of left-hand masses. At age 3 years, the patient underwent a chondroma excision from the middle phalanx of her middle finger on her left hand. No operative or pathology report was available from this surgery, and the patient tolerated the procedure well without any complications. At the time of presentation, the masses did not cause any pain, motor or sensory dysfunction, or any systemic symptoms. No history of recent or distant trauma was elicited. The patient’s medical and family history was unremarkable.
On physical examination, there was a firm, immobile, nontender palpable mass over the dorsal aspect of the distal second metacarpal bone of the left hand. The mass extended medially between the second and third metacarpals. A second small, firm, nontender left-hand mass was palpated over the volar aspect of her proximal phalanx on her index finger. She was neurovascularly intact with full active range of motion of the metacarpophalangeal and proximal and distal interphalangeal joints. There was no angular deformity of the digits. Plain radiographs taken at the time of initial presentation showed a 2.3×1.7-cm radiolucent lesion located in the metaphysis and diaphysis of the second metacarpal of the left hand (Figures 1A-1C). The lesion had varying degrees of mineralization with cortical thinning and expansion in the volar, dorsal, radial, and ulnar directions, consistent with a chondroid lesion. The second and third lesions were oval radiolucencies with sclerotic rims located at the metaphyseal-diaphyseal junction of the proximal phalanx of the index finger and middle phalanx of the middle finger, respectively. No fractures were identified in the radiographs, and the physes were open at this time. The patient was diagnosed with multiple enchondromatosis, or Ollier disease.
Our case showed 1 episode of pain and tenderness to palpation at the second proximal phalanx approximately 6 months after initial presentation. We attributed the pain and tenderness to a small pathologic fracture but did not see radiographic evidence of this. We elected to provide a trial of supportive measures, such as splinting and buddy taping, and to monitor the pain with a tentative plan of open biopsy with curettage and bone grafting if the pain persisted or evidence of fracture was seen on radiographs. The pain and tenderness to palpation resolved at a follow-up visit, and the surgery was deferred.
The patient was treated nonoperatively at initial presentation given the lack of significant cosmetic deformity or functional compromise and was advised close follow-up at 3 and 6 months. Given the absence of disease progression, annual checks (ie, clinical examination and radiographs) in a skeletally immature patient were decided on after consultation with the patient and parent. The family was educated about the possibility of pathologic fracture from minimal trauma to the hand versus the small risk of iatrogenic physeal injury with surgical curettage and bone grafting. No protective splinting was offered. A favorable prognosis and reassurance was provided to the patient and family, given the absence of symptoms, low suspicion and risk of malignant transformation, and stability of the lesion. Serial radiographs showed gradual increases in the lesions’ sizes but were consistent with the stable growth of the metacarpal and phalanges. With the patient nearing skeletal maturity, no pathologic fractures were identified on radiography during follow-up, and the risks of surgery lessened with growth; however, the continued absence of symptoms led to the mutual decision to continue observation.