The invited discussant, Dr. Matthew M. Hutter, of Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, described the size of the overall study cohort as remarkable. "What I find most interesting about this study is that it shows that sleeve gastrectomy – a brand-new, very complex procedure – can be introduced safely and effectively when performed under the standards of a bariatric accreditation program," Dr. Hutter said. "Other surgical procedures such as laparoscopic cholecystectomy or laparoscopic colectomy had very high morbidity and conversion rates when they were first implemented. However, this new complex procedure has been safe and effective from the get-go, and that is really quite impressive. The other remarkable finding is how consistent this is with all of the other major [bariatric surgery] data collection programs."
Dr. Morton acknowledged certain limitations of the study, including the fact that 1-year follow-up was available in only 60% of patients, while 30-day follow-up was available in 98% of the cohort. "Potentially, patients could have been admitted to other hospitals," he added. "These are research-consented patients, so about 70% consented. Some of this is surgeon-directed reporting."
Dr. Morton said that he had no relevant financial conflicts to disclose.