ILLUSTRATIVE CASE
John M, a 50-year-old patient, recently had a routine colonoscopy and was diagnosed with diverticulosis. Concerned because a friend has had multiple bouts of diverticulitis and a partial colectomy, John schedules an appointment to discuss management of diverticulosis. His friend has told John he’ll have to follow a strict diet and avoid nuts, corn, and popcorn altogether. Anxious to avoid the complications his friend has experienced, John turns to you for dietary advice. Would you know what dietary advice is best?
Diverticulosis affects one-third of the US population by age 60; by the age of 85, two-thirds are affected.2,3 This common digestive disorder has been associated with a diet high in refined carbohydrates, and is less prevalent among people who follow a vegetarian diet.4-6 Up to 35% of patients with diverticulosis develop complications, including diverticulitis and diverticular bleeding, that frequently require hospitalization and invasive procedures.7,8
Nuts or no nuts? In search of evidence
Biological mechanisms responsible for the development of diverticular complications are poorly understood.1,4 But luminal trauma has been suggested as a contributory factor and nuts, corn, popcorn, and seeds have long been viewed as likely culprits.8 Thus, physicians have historically advised patients with diverticular disease to avoid these foods.8-12
That recommendation, however, had little evidence to support it. Until the study by Strate et al that we report on here, no studies had assessed the consumption of nuts, corn, popcorn, or seeds as a risk factor for diverticulitis or diverticular complications.1,13 Conversely, there was a growing body of evidence that a diet rich in nuts may provide protection against many common disorders, including coronary heart disease, diabetes, colon and prostate cancers, and gall bladder disease.14-19 The research by Strate et al settles the matter, but it also provides an interesting twist.
STUDY SUMMARY: Nuts and popcorn linked to lower risk
The Strate trial is part of the Health Professionals Follow-up Study, a prospective cohort study that followed male health professionals in the United States from 1986 to 2004.20 A counterpart to the all-female Nurses’ Health Study, this long-running study allowed investigators to evaluate the relationship between nutritional factors and the incidence of serious illnesses such as cancer, heart disease, and other vascular diseases. The study population was comprised of 47,228 men between the ages of 40 and 75 years who completed periodic self-administered medical and dietary questionnaires.
At baseline, all the men were free of diverticulosis or related complications, as well as cancer and inflammatory bowel disease. During the 18 years of follow-up, 801 incident cases of diverticulitis and 383 cases of diverticular bleeding occurred. After analyzing the data, the researchers reported that, not only was the consumption of nuts and/or popcorn not associated with an increased risk of diverticulitis, it had a protective effect. The hazard ratios for men with the highest intake of nuts and/or popcorn (at least twice a week) compared with men with the lowest intake (less than once a month) were 0.80 (95% confidence interval [CI], 0.63-1.01) for nuts and 0.72 (95% CI, 0.56-0.92) for popcorn. The researchers found no association, positive or negative, between corn consumption and diverticulitis, nor between nut, corn, or popcorn consumption and diverticular bleeding or the development of uncomplicated diverticulosis.1
FIGURE
Colonoscopy reveals diverticular disease
This colonoscopic image shows the presence of a diverticulum.
WHAT’S NEW?: A long-standing belief gets debunked
This study—the first to examine the relationship between a diet rich in nuts, corn, or popcorn and diverticular disease—showed that these foods did not increase the risk of developing diverticulosis, diverticulitis, or diverticular bleeding. Moreover, it found an association between a diet rich in nuts or popcorn and a decreased risk of diverticulitis. Although we can’t characterize this as a cause-and-effect relationship based on this study, the evidence convinces us that, at the least, nuts, corn, and popcorn do not increase the risk of diverticular disease. We think we can confidently tell patients to enjoy these foods.
CAVEATS: Protective effect of nuts is tough to explain
As with all cohort studies, there is a possibility of unmeasured confounding variables which, in this case, could account for the protective effect of nuts and popcorn suggested by the decreased risk of diverticulitis. Although this was a large and carefully conducted prospective cohort study involving health professionals, we are not aware of any proven pathophysiologic mechanism by which nuts, corn, and popcorn may either increase or decrease the risk of diverticular disease or its complications.