Evolution of Femoroacetabular Impingement Treatment: The ANCHOR Experience

Take-Home Points

• Our understanding of FAI has evolved from cam-type and pincer-type impingement to much more complex disease patterns.
• Most surgeons are performing less aggressive acetabular rim trimming.
• Inadequate osseous correction is still the most common cause of the failed hip arthroscopy.
• Labral preservation is important to maintaining suction seal effect.
• Open surgical techniques have a role for more severe and complex FAI deformities.

Femoroacetabular impingement (FAI) was described by Ganz and colleagues¹ in 2003 as a refinement of concepts introduced decades earlier. This description advanced our understanding of FAI as a mechanism for prearthritic hip pain and secondary hip osteoarthritis¹ (OA) and allowed for treatment of FAI. The concept of proximal femoral and acetabular/pelvic deformity contributing to OA had been previously speculated by Smith-Petersen,² Murray,³ Solomon,⁴ and Stulberg.⁵ Early cases of overcorrection of dysplasia using the periacetabular osteotomy created iatrogenic FAI, which further stimulated early development of the FAI concept.⁶ Improved anatomical characterization of the proximal femoral blood supply (medial femoral circumflex artery) allowed for development of the open surgical hip dislocation.⁷ Through open surgical hip dislocation, an improved understanding of hip pathomechanics by direct visualization helped pave the way for a better understanding of FAI. Open surgical hip dislocation allows for global treatment of labrochondral pathology and deformity of the proximal femoral head–neck junction and/or acetabular rim in FAI.

Hip arthroscopy has further developed and improved our understanding of FAI. Early hip arthroscopy was generally limited to débridement of labral and chondral pathology, and management of the soft-tissue structures. Advances in the understanding of FAI through open techniques allowed for application of similar techniques to hip arthroscopy. Improvements in arthroscopic instrumentation and techniques have allowed for treatment of labrochondral and acetabular-sided rim deformity in the central compartment and cam morphologies in the peripheral compartment through arthroscopic surgery. Appropriate bony correction by arthroscopic techniques has always been a concern, but improved techniques, dynamic assessment, and accurate use of intraoperative imaging have made this feasible and more predictable. Treatment of cam deformities extending adjacent and proximal to the retinacular vessels is possible but more technically demanding. Inadequate bony correction of FAI by arthroscopic means remains one of the most common causes of failure.^8-10In 2013, the Academic Network of Conservational Hip Outcome Research (ANCHOR) Study Group reported the characteristics of a FAI cohort of 1130 hips (1076 patients) that underwent surgical treatment of FAI across 8 institutions and 12 surgeons.¹¹ At that time, most ANCHOR surgeons (or surgeon groups) performed both open and arthroscopic surgeries and had significant referral volumes of complex cases that may have overrepresented the proportion of complex FAI cases in the cohort. During the 2008 to 2011 study period, FAI was treated with arthroscopy in 56% of these cases, open surgical hip dislocation in 34%, and reverse periacetabular osteotomy in 9%. FAI was characterized as isolated cam-type in 48%, combined cam–pincer type in 45%, and isolated pincer-type in 8%. Fifty-five percent of the patients were female. Patient-reported outcome studies in this cohort of patients are ongoing.

The FAI Concept

In 2003, after treating more than 600 open surgical hip dislocations over the previous decade, Ganz and colleagues¹ coined the term femoroacetabular impingement to describe a “mechanism for the development of early osteoarthritis for most nondysplastic hips.” They reported surgical treatment focused on “improving the clearance for hip motion and alleviation of femoral abutment against the acetabular rim” with the goal of improving pain and possibly of halting progression of the degenerative process. FAI was defined as “abnormal contact between the proximal femur and acetabular rim that occurs during terminal motion of the hip” leading to “lesions of the acetabular labrum and/or the adjacent acetabular cartilage.” Subtle, previously overlooked deformities of the proximal femur and acetabulum were recognized as the cause of FAI, “including the presence of a bony prominence usually in the anterolateral head and neck junction that is seen best on the lateral radiographs, reduced offset of the femoral neck and head junction, and changes on the acetabular rim such as os acetabuli or a double line that is seen with rim ossification.” Ganz and colleagues¹ recognized that “normal or near normal” hips could also experience FAI in the setting of excessive or supraphysiologic range of motion. Cam-type and pincer-type FAI deformities were introduced as 2 distinct mechanisms of FAI. By 2003, arthroscopic hip surgery was increasingly being used as a treatment for labral tears but not bony abnormalities. These FAI concepts seemed to explain the prevalence of labral tears at the anterosuperior rim, which had been noted during hip arthroscopy, and paved the way for major changes in arthroscopic hip surgery during the next decade. The ANCHOR group reported the descriptive epidemiology of a cohort of more than 1000 patients with FAI.¹¹